Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2007 (draft)

Wednesday 7 March 2007 Enterprise and Culture Committee Subordinate legislation 19 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I invite the minister to speak to the third and final order.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

I hope that I will not keep the committee too long. Members will recall that we last discussed changes to the renewables obligation exactly a year ago. At that time, we mentioned the vital role that the obligation had played in what most people regard as the welcome growth of new renewable generating capacity in Scotland. That is probably the most important factor in our reaching our target earlier than we planned.As everybody knows, the bulk of our renewable generating capacity has come from onshore wind farms, which reflects how the obligation has operated until now. The methodology is technology neutral, which supports technologies that are nearest to the market, such as onshore wind and landfill gas. The draft order makes a fundamental change to that approach.In the past year, we have consulted widely on the introduction of a marine supply obligation. The mechanism, which is unique to Scotland, will oblige suppliers to produce some of their renewable obligation certificates from wave or tidal generating stations that are located in Scottish waters.When suppliers cannot produce such ROCs, they will be obliged to pay a higher buy-out price than applies to the rest of their obligation. The levels have been set to reflect the higher cost of generating power from such sources and are therefore sufficient to trigger new investment in the technologies.We believe that the measures in the draft order will create a vital long-term market for wave and tidal power in Scotland—or at least for the time in which we intend to operate the obligation. We hope that the measures will play a major role in establishing this country as a global capital for marine renewables.The draft order will support diversity and security of supply, which are key priorities for the Executive. The marine supply obligation is in tune with the recommendations in the committee's report on renewable energy, which was published in 2004.I will explain briefly the further changes in the draft order that are mirrored in all three UK obligations. The changes are aimed at making it easier for very small generators to benefit from the support that is available under the obligation. From April, we propose that small generators of under 50kW should be able to amalgamate their output to make qualifying for ROCs easier—we discussed that previously when I was before the committee.We acknowledge that some small generators can be put off by the administrative requirements under the obligation. That is why we propose that small generators should be able to appoint agents to act on their behalf in such matters as accrediting their projects and claiming ROCs from the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets.One further change applies to power stations that co-fire using energy crops. At the moment, suppliers can use co-fired ROCs to meet only up to 10 per cent of their obligation. Our proposed change will mean that ROCs from stations that co-fire using energy crops alone are no longer subject to that cap. Along with an expanded and clarified definition, that change will help to support the market for purpose-grown energy crops.Our amendments to the obligation will support the continued growth of renewable generation and I hope that they will help to diversify its growth into marine and tidal power, for example. Our proposals for wave and tidal power will set the foundations for Scotland to have a leading industry.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am interested in the proposed marine supply obligation. As the minister said, it was a key recommendation of the committee's renewable energy report in 2004. It is a little disappointing that it has taken so long to get here, but we should not be too churlish; it is good that the obligation has been proposed.Will the incentive be sufficient to drive forward the development of technology in the offshore marketplace? The obligation will create an unlevel playing field and try to provide greater incentives for offshore technologies, but the concern is that it will be insufficient in itself, given the disparity in cost between onshore wind power and the new technologies. On the basis of the discussions that you have had with developers in the power sector, will you give us a flavour of how they view the new marine supply obligation and how it might encourage them to develop their ideas?

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I will take all the questions together.

Shiona Baird Green North East Scotland
link

My question is quite complicated. I hear what you say about co-firing from energy corps, but I refer you to page 11, on which article 8, "Eligible renewable sources: other fuels", says:"A generating station shall be an excluded generating station in any month during which it is fuelled wholly or partly by waste".We need your definition of waste. The draft order lists three exclusions. Depending on your definition of waste, I am particularly concerned that a generating station will be excluded unless"the generating station is a qualifying combined heat and power generating station."I would like more explanation of that paragraph, please.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That was not too technical. Even I understood it.

Shiona Baird Green North East Scotland
link

Good. I read it through several times.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

Like Murdo Fraser, I welcome the draft order, not least because my constituency has a significant interest in marine energy, technology and fabrication. I am pleased about the amalgamation of smaller suppliers' output. That is very welcome.What discussions have you had with the producers of purpose-grown energy crops about whether the proposed measures will be sufficient to guarantee not just supply for generating purposes but for biodiesel and other fuel uses?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

I will answer Murdo Fraser's questions first. The delay in lodging the order to introduce the obligation was in part a consequence of an extensive consultation process with the suppliers. It is true that differing views were expressed about altering what had been a tried and trusted mechanism for stimulating growth in the sector and there was concern that it might damage investor confidence in that process. Ultimately, there has been widespread buy-in to what we propose in Scotland, which is in advance of what will be agreed following the United Kingdom energy review and the banding of ROCs that is proposed in that review.We should provide an incentive to suppliers. Paying a higher buy-out price of £175 for wave power and £105 for tidal power is sufficient incentive to developers to invest in the new technology. However, it also imposes an obligation on those who purchase that supply, the cost of which is then passed on to the consumer. A balance has to be struck.If we create 75MW of generating capacity from wave and tidal power in phase 1 of the marine supply obligation, we expect it to add roughly 1.46 to 2.23 per cent to electricity prices for Scottish consumers. That equates roughly to £5 or £10 a year. We have to strike a balance between promoting the development of new marine and tidal technologies and the cost to the consumer.We must also consider the state of preparedness of the market. As members know, we recently announced a £13 million stimulus for capital development and research via the European Marine Energy Centre in Orkney. That got a good response from potential developers, but technologies still have to be developed at very high operational and start-up costs and the cost per unit of generation is substantial.Although the measures in the order provide an incentive, they have to be balanced with the cost to the consumer—and we have to be extremely careful about taking over the Scottish electricity consumer base.We think that providing a wider definition—and, following discussions with the industry, a clearer definition—of energy crops reduces the burden on crop growers. We have had a positive reaction from growers, but we understand that the dialogue needs to continue. We are aware that support for biofuels is being pursued under the renewable fuels obligations. It is hoped that that mechanism will stimulate that industry as the renewables obligations have stimulated suppliers.The exclusion for combined heat and power was introduced last year. CHP is an efficient way of producing heat and power, and ROCs will be awarded to biomass as a fraction of the fuel mix. We redefined the waste element last year, and we are not changing it. All we are doing now is giving an incentive for co-firing biomass, which is obviously beneficial from an environmental perspective given the fact that, in the foreseeable future—I would argue, although others here may not—we will need a diverse mix of energy supply. That mix will include fossil fuels. The greater the biomass element in the fuel mix, the better it will be for the environment. There is no attempt here to substitute waste for biomass, as might have been suggested. The waste element was redefined last year.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you. I take it that the committee is minded to support the motion.

Shiona Baird Green North East Scotland
link

I have real concerns about the paragraph I mentioned, but there is no way I can vote against an order that will have such a positive impact on marine renewables and smaller generators.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Your concerns are now on the record. I take it that you are not moving against the order.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I draw attention to the Subordinate Legislation Committee's comments about the drafting of the order. The Executive will want to look at those comments and see whether it needs to do some rectifying drafting at a later stage. I take it that, with that qualification, the committee is happy to approve the order unanimously. I ask the minister to move motion S2M-5624.

Motion moved,

That the Enterprise and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2007 be approved.—Allan Wilson.

Motion agreed to.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you very much. We will see you next Tuesday for the final meeting of the Enterprise and Culture Committee in this session.

Meeting closed at 13:28.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Culture Committee Wednesday 7 March 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.