Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Report

“Management of patients on NHS waiting lists”

Wednesday 13 March 2013 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 459 contributions · 22 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

459 contributions · showing 1–200
Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

The first substantive item is continuing consideration of the Auditor General’s report into the management of patients on national health service waiting lists. We have two panels of witnesses. I welcome the first, which is the biggest panel since I have convened the committee. Ian Crichton is chief executive and Susan Burney is director of the Information Services Division of NHS National Services Scotland; Professor Fiona Mackenzie is chief executive and Andy Rankin is head of patient access at NHS Forth Valley; Robert Calderwood is chief executive and Jane Grant is chief operating officer for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde; and Gerry Marr is chief executive and Dr Alan Cook is associate medical director at NHS Tayside. The clerks asked the witnesses whether they wanted to make opening statements. Given the size of the panel, the witnesses said that they were happy to move directly to questions from committee members.I will kick things off. Although the Auditor General was clear that, with one minor exception in NHS Tayside and of course the exception of NHS Lothian, she did not find evidence of manipulation of waiting time information, a key finding of her report was a trend that she could not explain. The trend was that the use of social unavailability codes increased significantly—in fact, it tripled—between 2008 and 2010-11. However, late in 2011, when concerns were raised about the inappropriate use of social unavailability codes in Lothian, their use suddenly dropped in most other boards.The Auditor General was clear that she had no explanation for what she considered to be a quite noticeable trend. I ask the boards that are represented today what their explanation is for the increase in the use of social unavailability codes and—perhaps even more important—for the sudden drop in their use in 2011.

Dr Alan Cook NHS Tayside
link

We have been asking ourselves that question, which is a relevant and pertinent question to focus on and start with. In relation to the rise, we must go back to the introduction of the new ways approach in 2010—it came in from 2008 to 2010. That introduced a new set of rules that had not been in place before.When that approach was introduced in Tayside, we put quite a lot of effort into training our staff. We held a number of workshops, to which more than 136 staff came. The staff’s understanding improved considerably when the new rule set came in about what the social unavailability rules were. With that training, people had a spread of knowledge about how to apply the rule set. We think that that was the main reason for the rise that occurred.Because, as the Auditor General said, the reason was uncertain, I asked some of our booking staff—the people who did the coding at the time—about it. They told me that quite a lot of education had been done—certainly locally in Tayside—and they were aware of the rule set. They were starting to apply that, which they felt accounted for the rise. That is directly from the booking staff involved.I also asked the booking staff what they thought the fall related to. In Tayside, we are now in a different scenario—a post-Lothian scenario in which all the issues have been raised and we have become sighted on things that we probably were not sighted on before. Locally, we have done a lot of training and education about the rule set, to address any misunderstandings that got built into the system before.I asked the staff why they thought that the numbers had fallen. They said that the rule set was complex. The new ways document contains about 99 pages of guidance over the different sets. Misunderstandings built up in relation to that but, as matters have been clarified through the training and education that we put in place post-Lothian, those have fallen away. That was the staff’s understanding of why the figures had fallen.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I might come back on that, but perhaps the other two boards would like to speak first.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

From NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde’s perspective, I will build on the points that Dr Cook has amplified. There was a general understanding throughout 2008 and early 2009. The true extent of the waiting list as per the new definitions was being understood and arrived at.Parts of the explanation in Glasgow will be common across the national health service in Scotland.Going into the beginning of 2011, we had a significantly bad winter and a number of operations were cancelled because people could not get to healthcare premises. In some instances, operational problems meant that theatres were out of action, so we had to relocate and refer patients to different services. However, the underlying trend in Glasgow in the first quarter of 2011 was a significant rise in the number of patients who sought to be treated in a hospital of their choice or by a surgeon of their choice. Therefore, when patients were offered early access to an appointment across the common waiting list, a significant number of them declined and agreed to wait for the hospital or surgeon of their choice. However, as Audit Scotland’s report intimates, there were no data collection systems in those days to capture the data and record the information in real time.The second part of the question was about why the use of social unavailability codes came down. That was fairly straightforward. In the early part of 2011, the board received a report from the acute operating division intimating the movement in the overall waiting list. With a combination of funding that was released by the Scottish Government and additional funds from the health board, over the period of 2011, we increased our acute elective capacity. Therefore, by the end of 2011, our ability to deal with demand had increased compared to that ability in December 2010.

Professor Fiona Mackenzie NHS Forth Valley
link

The figures for NHS Forth Valley were actually relatively steady over that period. The reduction in our figures coincided with the work towards the 12-week treatment time guarantee. We did not really start to have reductions in the use of unavailability codes until May or June and in the lead-up to October.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

One reason why the committee was interested in speaking to NHS Forth Valley was that the trend that I referred to was not as noticeable in that board. The Auditor General said that the recorded information that Audit Scotland found in NHS Forth Valley was of a better quality than that in other health boards. I wonder whether Professor Mackenzie is puzzled about why the pressures that in other boards led to a sudden drop in the use of social unavailability codes—whether that was targeting of resources or a better understanding of how it worked—did not lead to that in NHS Forth Valley? Why did the board have a steady use of social unavailability codes?

Professor Mackenzie
link

That relates to our use of unavailability codes. The internal audit report and the Auditor General’s evidence show that a number of factors affected how we used those codes. We had systems limitations, so we were not able to put clocks off and on. Therefore, people were kept on an unavailability code to keep them visible. We did not use medical unavailability to any great extent; in fact, the internal audit report brings out that there was a preference for keeping people on the list when, actually, to be technically right, we probably ought to have returned them to their general practitioners. Issues of that sort meant that, for us, unavailability was used as a proxy for managing a group of patients. Far from being not patient focused, staff were trying to be very patient focused and ensure that people were kept in the loop and communicated with, and that they knew when their treatment would be available. Staff also tried to accommodate people’s preferences—Robert Calderwood talked about that—which are usually to be treated in their local area.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

You are saying that, if the new ways system was managed properly with patients at the centre, there was no reason why the discontinuity in the use of social unavailability codes should appear.

Professor Mackenzie
link

In preparation for the 12-week treatment time guarantee, all the systems had to change, anyway. That is what I am saying drove the major change in our use of unavailability as we moved towards October. I am also saying that our local use of unavailability reflected the practical issues that we had, but people recorded that use fully and well, which was the point that was brought out in the exchange with the Auditor General.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Dr Cook, you said that the drop in the use of social unavailability in 2011 was because you were entering a “post-Lothian” period. It is hard not to take that as a suggestion that the unacceptable practices in Lothian were revealed at that point and then you in Tayside changed the way in which you were using social unavailability.09:45

Dr Cook
link

That is not a fair reflection of what was said or what was happening at the time. This is all related to the degree of scrutiny and to the training and effort that is put in at different times over a cycle. Issues were not raised with us around social unavailability in the lead-up to the Lothian position. You can see from the information that came to us from ISD that the matter was never raised with us at meetings. Social unavailability was never raised with us as an issue at meetings with the Scottish Government access support team. Social unavailability was never raised at any of the national waiting times meetings pre-Lothian, certainly to my knowledge. It is the post-Lothian position that I am referring to as a different scenario—when people became acutely aware of the issues of social unavailability. That is what I am trying to describe, rather than there being a difference around the matter. The issue became very apparent to us, in a way that it had not pre-Lothian.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I appreciate that—and, believe you me, I am trying to be fair.

Dr Cook
link

Yes—I am sure that you are.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

However, I think that you are saying that, when the unacceptable practices in Lothian were discovered, you then trained your staff not to use those practices, and that is why your use of social unavailability codes dropped, as in Lothian.

Dr Cook
link

No. That would not be a valid conclusion, because TTG legislation was coming in and more training was being offered around that time, linked to the new rule set.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

The training programme has been running since 2010. When the situation in Scotland emerged through Lothian, it would have been wrong not to focus on it more strongly in the local systems. It was the sensible thing to ask whether there were lessons to be learned in any system in Scotland from what emerged in Lothian.After the report on the situation came into the public domain, we did a lot of work with our staff. We undertook a major culture survey through our organisational development people. We engaged with all our coding staff and told them that we needed to hear what things were like, where they thought training was deficient and where the challenges lay around the complexity of the system. I commissioned a report on that, and I received it from my team. According to the report, the focus groups among our team most often said that they were proud, that they recognised that the job was tough, with some pressure, but that they unequivocally did not generally feel any pressure from managers to do anything that would be considered to be something other than within the rules.To me, that reveals a sensible and accountable approach as a response to a problem that was exposed in the Scottish health service. I am sure that all the boards satisfied themselves that there was nothing untoward from that point of view.

Dr Cook
link

The application of social unavailability codes in Tayside pre-Lothian was closer to the position at Forth Valley. The September 2011 unavailability figures were about 26 per cent across Scotland; we were running in the high teens. We did not have the rise that was mirrored across Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

The key point is that NHS Forth Valley did not have the drop that Tayside did. I appreciate your point, Mr Marr, about staff not feeling pressured, and my committee colleagues might wish to discuss some issues in that regard. However, I cannot get away from the fact that you appear to be saying that you were using social unavailability codes in one way in 2010, and that in 2011, after training and consideration of the Lothian experience, you were using them better and differently, as a result of which far fewer patients were considered to be socially unavailable. I cannot see what conclusion we can reach except that, prior to Lothian’s practices being discovered, those same practices were taking place—not as manipulation but as an inappropriate use of the codes—so more patients were on that code. I cannot see what other conclusion we can reach from your evidence.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I do not know the numbers for other boards, but Audit Scotland and the internal auditors examined 50,000 transactions over a total of 170 audit days, which is 25 per cent of the total audit days assigned to internal audit. That was a deep, forensic dive into data. In our case, the audit raised a suspicion on 63 transactions, which is 0.2 per cent. I think that it is reasonable to say that, while we were populating the system, training people to use it and developing and improving it all the time, that is a natural feature of a system that is implementing the new ways approach. We can put that against 50,000 transactions and the fact that Audit Scotland did not draw attention to NHS Tayside in its report. That is the evidence that suggests that, over 50,000 transactions, there was not an apparent problem in the use of social unavailability codes.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

No; that might be evidence that there was no manipulation. However, what Audit Scotland drew our attention to was the discontinuity—the sudden drop in the use of social unavailability codes in 2011. I am trying to get at why that happened in Tayside. Dr Cook’s evidence was that it was because we had moved into a “post-Lothian” situation—in other words, an understanding had become available of the inappropriate practices going on in Lothian. Surely the only conclusion to reach is that the misapplication of codes was also happening in Tayside but that it was corrected at that point and the use of social unavailability codes fell.

Dr Cook
link

I think that what was said about Tayside in the Audit Scotland report was that there were areas of misunderstanding of the rules. The rule set is 99 pages long and the rules are complex; staff must get their heads around what the different parts of the rules mean. I think that there was misunderstanding of what the rules were. Like you, convener, Audit Scotland said that manipulation was not identified, and I agree with that. There was a tiny little pocket in Tayside but, at a whole-system level, I think that some misunderstanding built up around the rule set. That was clarified in a series of education and training events that we put on to ensure that staff understood the rules.Early this year we had a series of talks for our waiting time staff, of whom 219 out of 250 attended. We had two-hour long workshops that all the staff were able to come to. We developed a LearnPro electronic module—it is one of the electronic teaching aids—that goes through the rule set. It is interactive so that staff can answer questions and get feedback at the end. That has been completed by 632 staff. The understanding of the rule set is much clearer now than it was before. I think that there had been some misunderstanding previously. However, like you, convener, I do not think that there was widespread manipulation of the system—that is not what we found.Just to reiterate the findings, Audit Scotland looked at the nine-month period from April to December 2011 and had no concerns about any of our data. We were not one of the boards that showed any unusual trends or one of the boards that was looked at. Audit Scotland did not come to speak to us in that regard, and it looked at 30,000-odd of our transactions.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Okay. Thanks. While we are on unusual trends, I want to ask a quick question of Mr Calderwood. Audit Scotland identifies that at one stage in a particular specialism—orthopaedics—in a particular hospital, 70 per cent of patients were deemed socially unavailable. I think that your argument in your first answer was that that was because patients were exercising a choice about where they would be treated. Why do patients in Glasgow express such a remarkably high level of choice about where they would like to be treated? It is orders of magnitude different from anywhere else in Scotland.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I could spend a long time explaining how Glasgow citizens regard access to their local hospital as critical. I am sure that Ms Baillie knows as many of those arguments as I do.The point that I made, which I want to evidence, is that in the period in question, patient choice was part of the rise in social unavailability. Let me take the specific reference to Glasgow in the Auditor General’s report. It was highlighted that in April 2011, 924 patients were on the waiting list at the Western infirmary under the term “socially unavailable”. Had Audit Scotland picked July 2011, it would have found that the number was 343. There was a very selective approach, whereby one waiting list was picked out of eight, in one month.The movement between April and July 2011 is consistent with the point that we made about the board investing additional resources and seeking to address the choice issue, which was becoming stark in the first quarter of 2011.Let me try to put the Glasgow position in the wider context of the Auditor General’s report. In 2010-11, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde added 467,000 patients to our out-patients waiting lists, and almost 146,000 in-patient day case treatments were performed. In 2011-12, out-patient attendances rose to 475,000 and actual surgical procedures rose to 148,000. I contend that that is consistent with the board recognising the growing demand and putting in additional capacity.On the point about lessons from Lothian, the Lothian experience became public knowledge in the NHS in February and March 2012. If we look at the Glasgow figures, we can see that in March 2010 social unavailability across all our waiting lists was 25.6 per cent. That rose to 36.9 per cent in March 2011, at which point we became concerned about the issue. By March 2012 social unavailability had dropped to 17.3 per cent. Therefore, long before the Lothian information became available and long before the Auditor General came to speak to us about 2011, Glasgow had identified a problem and addressed it.That is fundamentally our position. There was an issue, which we believe was driven by patient choice. We have gone out of our way to try to address it. It remains a challenge.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I am sure that members from Glasgow will want to pursue some of those points, but I want to bring in Mary Scanlon.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

First, I want to make a point about the evidence that we heard at our most recent meeting, because I would not want anyone on the panel to think that Audit Scotland carried out a minuscule study that involved one or two patients. Audit Scotland told us:“this has been the most data-rich, data-intensive exercise that we have done.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 27 February 2013; c 1226.Therefore, please do not minimise what was done. Barbara Hurst also said that the patterns looked unusual in 3 million transactions, so I have no patience with anyone who says, “Well, it just went a little bit wrong here and there.”I want to ask about how the problem was found out. As the convener said, the use of social unavailability codes rose from 11 per cent in 2008 to 30 per cent. Also, according to Audit Scotland:“23 per cent of inpatients across Scotland had an actual wait ... of over nine weeks, compared to three per cent with a reported wait of over nine weeks.”Why was not the issue picked up by internal auditors, Audit Scotland, ISD, which has a quality assurance role, health boards, the Scottish Government or non-executive directors of health boards? Why did no one pick it up? We are here today because someone was brave enough to be a whistleblower.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Who wants to start?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps ISD will start, given its quality assurance role, which, according to Audit Scotland, includes raising“any concerns about their data, such as differences from what would be expected based on previous quarters”.Why did you not issue warnings?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

I think that one needs to go back to 2008 and the beginning of new ways. That is the context. The starting point for NHS Scotland was in managing waiting times in a totally new way—hence the name, “new ways”. Prior to that, social unavailability, as you know, was not tracked and put into reports in the way that we currently track and report it.Therefore, we took the view from the start that, clearly, social unavailability would rise because it was a new thing that we were measuring. We believed that there was a logic that, over time, as board waiting times reduced, essentially the pressure on unavailability would rise. As well as the exercising of choice, which was mentioned earlier, we expected that various dynamics would come into play, so we were not surprised when we saw social unavailability rising. We were aware of the social unavailability rises through the period. We were in touch with, I think, three boards about the social unavailability increases that we saw. There was nothing in any of that that we regarded as untoward, or anything that we had as a concern.10:00

We have gone back—hindsight always makes us all very smart—and looked at our risk registers at the time. The organisation’s focus was on ensuring that the statistics were as good as they could be. The focus of the health service was on pulling off a pretty significant change in patient waits. At the time, a lot of the focus was on ensuring that the reporting systems that were being deployed to support the information were working in the way that they should.It is easy with hindsight to look back and say, “Why didn’t you make a big deal about social unavailability?” I have no evidence that we thought that social unavailability was a big deal. There is no evidence of discussions to say that there was anything wrong there. There was no reason to have any belief about impropriety.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

At the time of the change to new ways, we were told in the Parliament loudly and clearly that new ways was the end of hidden waiting lists. However, new ways found a new way of hiding waiting lists, because the use of social unavailability codes increased from 11 to 30 per cent, with 23 per cent of patients having an actual wait above the target when only 3 per cent were reported as doing so. Despite politicians in the Parliament being told that there would be no more hidden waiting lists, the social unavailability codes were being used—by everyone round this table—to further hide patients to make the figures look good. Do you agree that it was a new way of hiding waiting lists?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

No, I absolutely do not agree. The major difference was that, in the reporting and in the information that we have published, those social unavailability figures were very clear, so they were there for all to see. Our waiting list publications website gets hits from 55,000 people a year, so 55,000 people have been able to see the growth in this thing over time and the reduction in this thing over time. That has been remarkably transparent; I would say that you would be pushed to find another health system that would give you that degree of transparency.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Do you think that it is transparent that 23 per cent of patients had an actual wait of more than nine weeks but only 3 per cent were reported as doing so? Is that transparent?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

What is transparent is that the percentage of patients over time who were socially unavailable was visible as opposed to having been put somewhere else, which is what the former system did.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

No warning bells rang with you when social unavailability increased threefold. Do you think that that is transparent as well?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

Let me say two things. First, it is easier to see that looking back. The retrospective adjustment that was made as we went through the period masked the issue to some extent, so I do not think that we would have seen the issue as starkly at the time. Secondly, when we asked several boards why social unavailability was increasing, technical and operational reasons were usually given for that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Audit Scotland said that alarm bells should have rung. Given the figures that have been quoted, should alarm bells have rung in any health board? Although NHS Lothian was found guilty of falsifying and manipulating its figures, there was not sufficient evidence of that in the rest of the health boards—it is not that they were not guilty, but that there was insufficient evidence. Did alarm bells ring in any health boards or in ISD Scotland?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

I can speak only for us. In terms of alarm bells that someone was doing anything dishonest or untoward, there were none. There was no reason to believe that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Not even with NHS Lothian, which was found guilty of manipulating the figures?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

Not even with NHS Lothian. We had discussions with NHS Lothian about where it was. We were told that a lot of its issues revolved around systems.It is important to understand that every health board in Scotland, at chief executive level, had to sign off on its submission to ISD. From where we were standing, we had absolute assurance from each board that the figures that it was reporting were correct.Returning to your point about transparency, the Statistics Authority did a review of our waiting times practices. I think that that was in 2010. The review told us that we had done a decent job of reporting waiting times and making what was being done publicly clear. The Statistics Authority was keen to use us as an exemplar elsewhere in the United Kingdom. We have to be able to separate activity going on in boards, and the way in which boards govern themselves, from ISD’s role as a keeper of national statistics.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In hindsight, you are quite content with the role that you have played in quality assurance and that people can have trust in your figures. All I can say is thank God for whistleblowers.I move on to my second point. When the waiting time target moved from 18 weeks to 12 weeks, I am not aware that huge resources were given to health boards. I appreciate that you were undergoing efficiency savings, which were going back into front-line care. Was the reduction from 18 weeks to 12 weeks an impossible task that led to looking at how figures could be presented using social unavailability codes? Was the manipulation, and indeed the muddle of the waiting lists, a consequence of Government policy or should you have asked for more money to achieve the targets?

Dr Cook
link

From a health board perspective, if we look at the support that we got in NHS Tayside, we would see reducing waiting times as important. It is important for patients to be seen as quickly as they can be.

Dr Cook
link

It is one of the elements of a quality service. A quality service is person centred, safe and timely—that is waiting times. It is about equitable services, efficiency and being effective. It is a core component of a quality service. Intrinsically, we would like to have waiting times as low as they possibly can be.On resourcing, we have had support from the Scottish Government. NHS Tayside has had recurrently about £5.3 million specifically to look at waiting times and address related issues. In addition, we have allocated £3.9 million recurrently from our budget to look at waiting times. In resourcing terms, from our finance department, about £9.2 million has been allocated.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

We consider that appropriate for the reasons that Dr Cook has just demonstrated, in terms of equity in access. I would not describe the challenge as impossible. It will always be difficult. It should be difficult, because we should always strive to get waiting times down as low as we can. The figures from NHS Tayside that we quote are no doubt replicated in my colleagues’ boards as an appropriate use of resources to achieve the 12-week target.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

If I take it at a higher level, ISD’s published statistics include the target level—the performance after clock stops are deducted—versus the total patient journey, both of which were very evident to the board. In NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, 92 per cent of all patients were treated in under 12 weeks in 2010-11. That includes all clock stops. That figure is for in-patient day cases; for out-patients, it was 93 per cent of patients, irrespective of clock stops. Their total journey was less than 12 weeks.That figure of the total experience of the patient was available and was monitored. Under new ways, we are allowed to adjust that total performance to reflect our performance against the target; in other words, where patients decline the opportunity or are medically unfit to receive the treatment, they are deducted from the targets. Hence, we get to the board’s performance against the incrementally improving waiting time targets that have existed for the past 10 years.From a financial perspective, I suspect that over the past 10 years, between new, targeted Government money and reinvestment of efficiency savings, we have invested tens of millions of pounds—although the figure is probably closer to £100 million—in increasing our acute capacity so that people can get treatment quicker.I genuinely believe that during the time that we have been moving to introduce the targets, the high-level visible performance of the NHS in Scotland has improved and moved towards the targets. As I tried to explain, that is set against a backdrop of rising demand, which has had to be factored in, and inevitable service disruption, which has to be caught up on so that patients are not disadvantaged.The other point that has been highlighted but which did not come out so much from the Audit Scotland report is that a considerable number of patients who were socially unavailable when Audit Scotland was looking could, under the rules, have been returned to their GP. It was a conscious decision—certainly in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and, I believe, a number of boards across Scotland—not to disadvantage those patients in recognition of their choice but to keep them on the waiting list so that they could then be treated. However, under the technical rules, we in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde could have discharged a significant proportion of our patients who were coded socially unavailable back to their GP.

Dr Cook
link

I would like to come in on the activity change and the resourcing that Robert Calderwood said had been put in. Back in 2008, across Tayside we carried out about 25,000 in-patient procedures. By 2012, that figure had gone up to about 30,000, which is about a 20 per cent increase. The resourcing that came in was put into additional staff. Figures from our human resources department on consultant staffing in Tayside show that back in 2008 we had 352 whole-time equivalent consultants. In 2012, we were up to 411, which was an increase of 59 whole-time equivalents—about 17 per cent. That matches the sort of activity increases in day cases that we have seen from 25,000 in 2008 to about 30,000 in 2012. The resourcing was there and it has been allocated appropriately, as Gerry Marr said. We are delivering increased activity to get through additional operations.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Quite a bit is said about NHS Tayside in the case study on page 22 of the Audit Scotland report, but I will not go into that.My next question is about staff being under pressure, which is highlighted in the NHS Lothian case study on page 21 of the report. Audit Scotland refers to boards not having the“capacity to treat patients within waiting time targets ... and a management culture of not wanting to report bad news.”Paragraph 60 mentions“accusations of a ... bullying culture”.We know that that affected the staff. Where did the fear and pressure come from? Why was management unable to report bad news? Why did Audit Scotland say that staff were under pressure and that boards did not have the capacity to treat patients? Where did the bullying and fear come from and why were staff scared to report bad news, as reported by Audit Scotland?

Professor Mackenzie
link

I am happy to kick off on that. Our audit report made clear mention that the culture was open and that staff did not feel that they were under any pressure. I want to convey that staff were trying very hard. Robert Calderwood gave a good example of the way in which people were being kept on waiting lists when they might technically have been sent back to their GP. Staff were trying very hard to accommodate people and were trying to take into account people’s wishes to be treated locally, as opposed to having to travel. In our case, people generally have that preference.Staff were under pressure because they were busy, but certainly no pressure was being brought to bear on them to behave in an untoward way. In fact, people were supported to deal with any of the challenges that they had.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

To be fair, Forth Valley was mentioned time and again in the Audit Scotland report as an exemplar of good practice. We wanted you to come along so that we had an exemplar of good practice, but we also wanted to drill down to where staff were being affected by that culture, so thank you for that.I would like to hear from some of the others.10:15

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I do not recognise those issues of a bullying culture and a fear of reporting an inability to deliver a target. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde can demonstrate that waiting list information, along with all other patient quality information, is debated publicly every month at its public meetings. Those reports are provided throughout the system. I do not recognise where the Auditor General and Audit Scotland detected those issues within Greater Glasgow and Clyde. Indeed, the report does not make any specific mention of an example of such a bullying culture.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

A bullying culture is mentioned in paragraph 60 in relation to NHS Lothian:“Evidence that staff in NHS Lothian were put under pressure to falsify patients’ waiting times has resulted in accusations of a more widespread bullying culture in the NHS.”You all seem to be in denial about the Audit Scotland report. Is the report accurate?

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

On your point about a bullying culture, I will expand on what we did when the Lothian report was published. In conjunction with our employee director and our HR department, we set up a series of workshops with those of our staff who worked in the departments that were responsible for waiting times management. We did that in a way that we think was appropriate, given the number of people. There were a whole series of workshops with 340 staff in total, of which about 50 people were accompanied into the workshops.The findings from that series of workshops were the opposite of what you describe. I can quote from them. One question was, “How does it feel to be working in Tayside?” and 13 out of the 26 people in one workshop said, “Proud.” Another 13 said, “Busy.” The other information that we got from that report, which we made available to our internal auditors, was that staff appreciated the fact that the chief executive, the chief operating officer and the senior managers took the personal time to inquire about the wellbeing of the staff and to ask whether they felt pressured and whether they felt bullied to do something that was inappropriate. The answer was an unequivocal no, so I challenge that point about a bullying culture.The way in which Audit Scotland has extrapolated the Lothian experience to other boards is not for me to comment on—I have no knowledge of how it might have done that. All I can say in good faith is that we very properly conducted an exercise with our staff and our staff gave us the opposite message to the one that you raised.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

My final question to the health board chief executives is whether this is an accurate report. Has Audit Scotland recorded the information accurately within the report? Do you agree with the contents of the report?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Audit Scotland has reflected a situation that it found at a moment in time in the NHS in Scotland by looking at data retrospectively. It has tried to extrapolate that into a situation that was identified more recently in Lothian. The way in which the information has been portrayed—Audit Scotland is unable to determine whether social unavailability was properly applied, when there was no requirement in real time for boards to record that information—is one interpretation.It is clear that Audit Scotland has not identified manipulation across the NHS in Scotland. As I showed with the orthopaedics example, if the report had used the July 2011 figure, the convener would not have quoted the example of orthopaedics at the Western infirmary. Indeed, the other example in Glasgow that Audit Scotland chose to quote is ophthalmology. The report quoted the month of May 2011, saying that 40 per cent of the waiting list was socially unavailable—145 patients. If it had quoted the month of July, that number would have dropped to 42. It is not for me to determine why Audit Scotland picked particular months and did not show an extrapolation.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Mr Calderwood, I want to be clear on the fairly central issue of Audit Scotland’s inability to find out why social unavailability had been used in specific cases. You are saying that that is because you were not required to keep that information, so you saw no reason to do so. You think that that is an unreasonable—

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

At that particular time, none of the information technology systems that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde used allowed staff to capture information about the application of the code.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

That was not what I asked. You were not required to keep information about why patients had been deemed to be socially unavailable. Was that the gist of your evidence?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I said that we did not routinely capture those data in 2011, so to look for them in 2012 and expect to find them was always going to be challenging.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

But Audit Scotland’s criticism is that you did not routinely capture those data.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

That is correct, but there was no requirement for me to collect them, so why the criticism?

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

In your view, the failure is one of the Scottish Government’s management of the NHS because it did not require you to collect that information.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I have to be clear, Mr Gray. During the period in question, I do not believe that the NHS in Scotland, particularly NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, was failing to provide speedy and equitable access to services. I have sought to demonstrate the total journey times of patients as published and retrospectively audited by ISD. We were seeing in excess of 92 per cent of people within 12 weeks for in-patient, day case treatment, including the clock stops.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

The purpose of any audit is to identify system weaknesses. If you ask me about our internal audits plus those of Audit Scotland, the answer is yes—Audit Scotland identified weaknesses in the system, and that is self-evident. An action plan containing 22 actions was published, and I know mine because our audit committee and board accepted the plan and that those weaknesses existed. Those action points will be completed by the end of March. That is the purpose of any audit and what I expect to emerge from a forensic audit of any system. We welcome it, because it leads to improvements to the systems that we have in place.Whether the results of those audits should be extrapolated to cover issues such as harassment, bullying and manipulation of figures, or whether a certain level of unavailability means de facto that the unavailability code is being applied inappropriately is much more complex. I accept the veracity and accuracy of our audit and that our system had weaknesses, but I offer the evidence that I have found in our own system and say that we do not concur with what has been articulated this morning. We have sought evidence in order to come to that view.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I understand.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I seek clarification from ISD, because I want to be really clear about this. Mr Crichton, you gave evidence that the extent of your quality assurance of the waiting times figures that ISD provides regularly is that the figures that are given to ISD have been signed off by the NHS board chief executives. In this case, over the period of time that we are considering, the chief executives signed off those figures, so you are entirely content with the extent of ISD’s quality assurance of those figures.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

It is an element, but it is only one element. I will ask Susan Burney to say a bit about how we validate, verify and quality assure our figures, because that goes beyond what you describe. I said that the signing off was definitely an extra element that we asked for, and it was quite unusual.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

In response to Mrs Scanlon, you said that it was the fact that those figures were signed off by the NHS board chief executives that meant that you were content that you had checked them.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

Then I have not been clear. The point that I was trying to make is that that requirement goes above and beyond all the normal checks and balances that we have in place. We would not rely purely on the chief executive’s letter for the purposes of deciding whether, in our view, the statistics were accurate.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Mrs Scanlon was asking about what ISD did to find out that they were accurate.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

It will be better if Susan Burney takes you through the technicalities.

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

We routinely look retrospectively at the data that come to us for any unusual patterns. For example, if one board’s figures are an outlier, we will contact it and ask it not so much for an explanation, but to confirm that the data are correct. What we are really looking to do is to ensure that what we have been given is correct and there has not been a mistake somewhere in the submission of the data. We have a list of data quality things for each board, some of which are minor. Over the years, as the data have improved, the number of data quality questions has reduced.In general, our process is to look for anything unusual and go back and say, “This looks unusual to us. Can you tell us why it might be and confirm that it is okay?” If there is something unusual and there is a data quality issue, you will find that our website has a section on data quality, and for each board there is a list of things that people ought to keep in mind when using the data. Because data are never perfect, we have a duty to help people to understand it where we know that there is something that they will need to keep in mind, whatever use they might be making of it.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I think that Mrs Scanlon’s point was that Audit Scotland said that there was an identifiable unusual trend that should have rung warning bells. The question was: why did you not notice that?

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

We noticed that Lothian was unusual and we talked to it about the fact that, compared with other boards, it was different. The explanation that we were given was one of an operational nature. Around that specific issue, we had no reason to question further. The board gave us an explanation, and that was straightforward.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

But Audit Scotland specifically says about the trend in the reducing use of social unavailability in Lothian that the same pattern was demonstrated in other boards around Scotland.

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

There seemed to be a general consensus at that point that rising unavailability was due to a number of reasons, which people have rehearsed here today, around the introduction of the new ways approach and the reducing waiting times putting more pressure on patient availability, including their early availability. There was a general consensus in the health service and in Government around there being plausible reasons for that.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

It is important to look at the context. At the time, social unavailability was a small element of the overall waiting list transition that we were managing. Most of the focus was definitely around achievement of the waiting time targets, progress towards future targets and so on, and not around social unavailability, which was a small part. It was a part that we were looking at, but it did not figure on any of the risk registers as something that people were extremely worried about. The term was not in widespread use.One thing that you majored on earlier was this business of “since Lothian” and social unavailability. Since Lothian, the whole social unavailability thing has taken a much higher position than it previously had in terms of general consciousness and terminology. Again, I say to you that, as well as our not being concerned about it, more than 50,000 people go through the website every year and they can see the list of things that we have highlighted as being worthy of keeping an eye on, which Susan Burney mentioned. It was there for people to see. We did not know—

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

Sorry?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

We saw it, and—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You have just said that it was all about achieving the targets, but what we want to know is why the figures that were presented to us were not about achieving the targets. It is not just about a top-line figure. You have a responsibility and a quality assurance role in monitoring the waiting list. I think that I have said enough, but it is not only about achieving the targets. It is important to look at how they were achieved.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

I want to be clear. My organisation is not responsible for achieving the targets. There is a letter of understanding between me and the director general for health, and it is quite clear that matters of statistics are at arm’s length and we are neutral. Our role is around providing clarity on performance against targets and giving the public confidence that the numbers that people look at are solid. That is where we spend our time.If we look at the questions that were coming in from politicians and the press and at where everybody was looking, the focus was not on social unavailability but on waiting times and how the system was performing.10:30

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I call Mr Doris. Sorry—you have been waiting a long time.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I will ask some specific questions of the ISD witnesses, but I first want to ask Mr Calderwood some questions about NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. If in the period during which Audit Scotland was reporting, someone from Greater Glasgow and Clyde was deemed to be socially unavailable, did they remain on the waiting list?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Do you have any figures that you can give me on whether, irrespective of whether they were socially or medically unavailable, their 18-week waiting time guarantee was fulfilled? What percentage of all patients, including those who were socially or medically unavailable, still had their 18-week guarantee met?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

In relation to the stage-of-treatment targets that applied during 2011, if you took the absolute backstops and recorded all the clock stops—this is the point that I was trying to make in response to an earlier question—92 per cent of the 146,000 in-patients and day cases that we treated in 2010-11 were treated within the 12-week timeframe. At the time, that was the stage-of-treatment target. Irrespective of clock stops, 92 per cent of people were treated within the 12-week guarantee. Of the 467,000 out-patients, 93 per cent had their appointment within 12 weeks, which at that point was the stage-of-treatment target.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Does that include the numbers in the Audit Scotland report, which refers to 900 orthopaedic patients at the Western infirmary and 145 ophthalmology patients at the Southern general hospital?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

It does indeed. A percentage of the ophthalmology patients, who were out-patients, and a percentage of the in-patients may have fallen into the 7 per cent who were not seen within 12 weeks. However, if I were to move that data set up to the 18 weeks, which was the backstop guarantee, the position in Glasgow is that 97 per cent of all in-patients and day cases were treated in less than 18 weeks throughout 2010-11, including clock stops. For out-patients, the monthly figure is that something like 98 per cent of all patients who were referred to Glasgow were seen within the 18-week backstop.The rise or fall in social unavailability must be seen in the context of how it affected the eventual journey of the individual patients. I contend that the performance of the NHS in Scotland, when looked at in absolute terms, is to be commended. I certainly think that the work that is done in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde by the clinical and managerial staff is something that they recognise and are quite proud of.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

We will shortly come on to how you deem someone to be socially unavailable. Whether there is a good-news story or a bad-news story in Glasgow, the problem seems to be that it was not reported properly at the time, for whatever reason. We will come back to that. Were all the statistics and data that you have given me published?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Yes. Those statistics come from the validated ISD data sets.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

No, they are not hidden at all. The point that Mr Crichton was trying to make is that the data are publicly available through ISD and the website.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde definitely has to improve, but I want to look at that snapshot in time. What would have happened before the new ways system was implemented? Would patients have remained on the waiting lists, and would that have been reported publicly?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Before the introduction of the new ways system in 2008, there were what were referred to as hidden waiting lists—people were not on the active waiting lists but were on another waiting list. From 2008, the patient either has been on the waiting list—which is very publicly available—or has been returned to their general practitioner. There is now no hidden waiting list. Whether someone is medically or socially unavailable, those data are collected and published.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Okay. If I am an orthopaedic patient in Glasgow and I am offered a procedure at the Southern general hospital but I want to go to the Western infirmary, do you tell me that that is fine or that it is not fine? What do you tell me at that point?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I ask Mrs Grant to answer that.

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

At that point, the patient will generally have been seen as an out-patient by a particular person and may have been listed for surgery. If they were at the Western and there was no space within the guarantee at the Western, we would generally phone them to say, “We have a reasonable offer for you”—in essence, seven days’ notice—“at the Southern general.” The patient may then say yes or no to that offer. If the patient says no, they receive a second reasonable offer within seven days. That may be on the same site or on a different one. If they decline those two reasonable offers and say that they want to stay with the consultant they have already seen at the out-patient clinic—that is generally what happens if they have already seen the consultant—it is explained to them that we would be unable to accommodate that within the guarantee. Therefore, they have a choice: they can choose to wait, or they can choose to go elsewhere, given that, at that point there would be a slot elsewhere, because we run eight orthopaedic sites across Glasgow and Clyde where orthopaedic in-patient and day case surgery takes place. That is how we work.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Okay. That sounds like patient choice; it sounds fine. At that point, whose responsibility is it to record that information? Is it done right away or in batch form? Do you wait until there are 100 patients to put into the system at the same time, or is it an individual’s responsibility at the time to enter those data into the system, so that they can be audited? Who does that job?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

The person who makes the call to the patient would record that. There has been no uniform recording on the IT systems. As Mr Calderwood outlined, our systems did not accommodate that well. The information was usually recorded manually and those records are not as robust as they might have been—that is a fair point. As we move forward with TrakCare we will be implementing the system in Glasgow and Clyde in a more robust fashion.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

When you say that it was recorded manually, do you mean that it was written on a bit of paper and put in a file rather than on a computer system?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Generally, the waiting list co-ordinators would keep a spreadsheet. However, that was not in the IT systems and therefore available for scrutiny in the way that we are now trying to make information available.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

When was it eventually put into the IT system for that period?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

The outcome would have been input in terms of the date, but the evidence has proved that the actual manual recording of, for example, “I had a conversation with Jane Grant on 24 June,” was not in the IT systems, because they were not capable of doing that uniformly at that time.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Okay. What training would the staff who were entering that information have had on what they should have noted in the hard-copy files before looking to see what they could put into an IT system? What training was available?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Our staff certainly have been trained in new ways—the green book, as we refer to it, which was the original guidance. As Tayside has indicated, we have gone back and reinforced the training on the issues, particularly in new ways. Also, as we move forward in the process to TTG, compliance and the new circulars, we are about to start in April an electronic version of the IT training programme so that all our staff can routinely and regularly access it. We can keep that up to date as we go forward. We have put in a lot of effort to ensure that the training is there and can be evidenced and accessed more appropriately, particularly for new people and the large number of people who have to manage waiting lists. That is one of the other issues: there are a significant number of people in the system who are required to manage waiting lists. The rules are complex and lengthy and it is therefore important that we have uniformity. It is a complex scene: even the Audit Scotland reports—the current report but also the 2010 report—describe the rules as complex. They are complex, and for a large number of people who are accessing and managing waiting lists, that is a challenge.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I understand that. I ask the question because I want to know whether the person who was recording the information at the time had been trained and told, “When you write down ‘socially unavailable’, you should give a reason at that point.” Have they been trained and told to do that? Were the people recording that information also recording information before the new ways waiting times came along, when the routine culture was just to put “unavailable” as the status code? Was a culture change needed within Greater Glasgow and Clyde in how information was recorded? People were working under a system where one in three patients was deemed socially unavailable and on a hidden waiting list, and then new ways comes in and the same staff are asked to do something different. At that point, were they explicitly told that they had to give a reason, whether on a bit of paper or in an IT system? Was there a cultural or training issue? I will come on to what is happening now, but at the moment I am asking about that point in time.

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Five years ago, when the new ways system came in, there was undoubtedly a transition. People were trained on new ways but, to be perfectly honest, it would be hard to be absolutely explicit about who recorded what in 2008, which was five years ago. Undoubtedly, there was a requirement to apply periods of social unavailability, but at that point there was no requirement to describe in detail why those periods were applied—it was just recorded that somebody was socially or medically unavailable.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

My constituents in Glasgow will be asking about what will happen if they need a surgical procedure today in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. Let us assume that the same discussion takes place with someone who wants to go to the Western but who has two offers at the Southern, and it is explained to them that, although the waiting time clock will stop, they will still be seen at the Western. What happens to that information? How is it recorded today?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Today, we have the TrakCare system in parts of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, which can record that. We are implementing that system throughout the health board, and it will be available uniformly by the early summer. As required by the TTG circular, we send letters to patients to describe the situation. For example, if we agree a period of unavailability with a patient, they now get a letter that describes that. If they are unhappy with that or do not understand it, there is a process by which they can contact us. Patients now receive confirmation in writing, which did not happen previously.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Are you confident that every person in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde who has responsibility for recording such information knows that, with the TrakCare system, they have a duty to record more than just that the patient is socially unavailable? Are you confident that staff are trained and are aware of that?

Jane Grant NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

We have certainly put a big emphasis on that. I have described the current training, and we will do more in future, which will be comprehensive and will involve an e-learning package. In addition, we are reinforcing the rules. From 1 April, we have plans to implement a full audit process under which every month a number of records in the board area will be validated, independently from the directorate teams. In addition, the directorates will be asked to scrutinise and audit another cohort of patients. We will therefore have a transparent monthly audit report that describes the situation. That process shall be in place from 1 April.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

It is incredible that what could be a good-news story for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde—it has worked towards meeting waiting time targets and extending patient choice—has turned out to be presented as a negative, because of the inability to record information appropriately. Two weeks ago, the Auditor General said that one advantage of targets is that, when they are not met, rather than ring alarm bells, that should inform a health board that it needs to consider its resource allocation and direct resources towards the area where the targets are not being met.We have heard that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has done that with surgical procedures at the Western, the Southern and elsewhere. Mr Calderwood, can you give an assurance that, in future, where targets are not met, you will continue to redeploy resources properly to ensure that they are met?I have another question for you, on patient choice. For some time, everyone has been aware that the Western infirmary will close. How will you ensure that patients know what choices will be open to them once it closes and that we have an informed patient group who can make that choice?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

On the issue of resources, the board monitors its delivery of all the Government targets and seeks to deploy the available resources to meet individual patient needs and to deliver Government objectives, as set by Parliament.Over recent years, I think that we have demonstrated a balance in identifying and moving resources to meet those targets. I do not think that anyone could say that, in response to future Government decisions on resources and potential changes in demand, everything will flow automatically. There is a requirement on the board to look across the whole healthcare spectrum. Elective and emergency targets within the acute sector are indeed important, but equally the board must look at a whole raft of other community primary care and health inequalities issues. We constantly need to balance that spectrum against the available resource.10:45

At the moment, up to and including the current financial year 2012-13, I believe that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has identified demand and need and has sought to meet those by increasing the resources available. Equally, I have to say that we have not always achieved every target—there are some targets that we have struggled to deliver against more recently.The situation regarding the future changes in acute services within NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde was well trailed a number of years ago, but we will embark on a communications exercise in the second half of 2014 in relation to the impending changes that will come in 2015. To take your specific example, the in-patient base of the orthopaedic service at the Western infirmary will move to the new Southern general. The out-patient clinics at the Western infirmary, including the diagnostics and the day surgery that are currently provided there, will go to Gartnavel general. Therefore, if you live in the west or north-west of the city and you currently choose to go to the Western infirmary orthopaedic department, you will continue to access that service as an out-patient or as a day case in the west of the city at Gartnavel general. Tonight, if you were under the care of that team, you would have your in-patient surgery at Gartnavel general. Under the new model, in all probability you will have your in-patient surgery at the Southern general.Therefore, when the changes are complete, we will not have eight discrete orthopaedic teams but a lesser number. Three teams—namely, those at the Victoria infirmary, the Southern general and the Western infirmary—will move to become one team that will support the south and north-west of the city.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Could I come and see how the TrakCare system works in Glasgow to see whether it is as sensitive as you say that it will be once it rolls out across the city?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

We would be delighted to facilitate that visit.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I say to my good friend Bob Doris that I envy his position in having all that choice, including the list of consultants that Mr Calderwood described earlier. As far as I am aware, such choice is not open to people in Shetland, Orkney, the Highlands or most other parts of Scotland. I can only envy people in Glasgow. However, that is not what I want to ask about.Professor Mackenzie, can you help me with some practical details that I want to get to the bottom of? Am I right in thinking that you and your colleagues, as chief executives, meet regularly together?

Professor Mackenzie
link

Yes, we do.

Professor Mackenzie
link

Monthly.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Who do you meet with, in addition to the chief executives?

Professor Mackenzie
link

Generally, in the morning we have a meeting among ourselves and in the afternoon we have a meeting with the NHS chief executive, Derek Feeley, and his team.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Are there any standing items on that agenda as a matter of course?

Professor Mackenzie
link

We generally discuss an overview of performance and the key issues that you would expect us to talk about. We may also discuss things that are particularly topical at the time and, obviously, our forward plans.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Was the issue that we have now been discussing for a couple of hours this morning a topical issue at the time when, post the NHS Lothian example, it first became public knowledge?

Professor Mackenzie
link

Waiting times would always be something that we look at together in terms of general performance. Yes, there would usually be a very high-level discussion highlighting any particular issues that we needed to focus on. That would be the general tone of it.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

As a neutral observer—that is why I am asking you these questions—in the context of the post-NHS Lothian scenario, do you recall the issue coming up? Was the issue of unavailability codes specifically mentioned in the chief executives’ meetings?

Professor Mackenzie
link

I could not say that it was mentioned particularly. I think that the issues in NHS Lothian became clear over quite a prolonged period, from the first point at which NHS Lothian was mentioned as a matter of interest until it became clear what the issues were. I do not particularly remember unavailability being a major point of discussion at that point.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I do not want to ask you unfair questions about your recollection of meetings some time back. When the NHS Lothian issue erupted—because of a whistleblower, as we heard earlier, rather than because of anything that came from within the system—did that then become an issue that was of note and of importance to all chief executives across the country?

Professor Mackenzie
link

Obviously, everybody was aware of the issue as it became known, and everybody would have thought about their system and how things worked. Robert Calderwood’s point is important. If you do not mind me making a point, I say that in overall terms—that is often what we looked at as a group—the performance, disregarding the stops and wherever anybody was on the list, was relatively good, so we would not have been worried by the global perspective on performance.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I chair the chief executives group and I co-chair the afternoon meeting with Derek Feeley. Such issues are discussed regularly. It would have been irresponsible of the chief executives and the Scottish Government not to discuss the implications of the Lothian situation. Of course we had a discussion, but it was in the context of the NHS’s overall performance on waiting times and the Government’s appropriate decision to invite auditors to look at the issue, because the public require assurance. If we had not given the subject proper attention, that would have been irresponsible. That proper attention has been given over the past number of months.Waiting times are not exclusively about unavailability. That has become a focal point because of the issues that were raised in the Audit Scotland report. In the past 10 years, the Scottish Government has made extraordinary effort with the health service and front-line staff. As Alan Cook has demonstrated, that investment has involved a 19 per cent growth in activity and a 20 per cent increase in consulting staffing. A huge effort to do that—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

We are here to discuss a specific report, but you are giving me an overview.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I understand that, but it is important to set the discussion in the context of the NHS’s overall performance. In relation to the report, I have already said that there is no magic number for appropriate unavailability. The auditors have pointed out system weaknesses, and every board has an action plan, which is to be completed by the end of March. We have accepted the findings, and every board is implementing measures to deal with the system weaknesses, so that we can improve how unavailability is dealt with, which we are discussing this morning.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Since you have taken over and answered lots of questions that I did not ask, I ask whether the chief executives decided to initiate all that work themselves or whether Mr Feeley asked you to do so.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

There was a coming together of the executive team along with Government officials to decide the priorities.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

Yes—of course we were.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I do not recall the specific date.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

We were not asked in the context of post-Lothian. When something erupts in the health service—

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

Let me finish. If something comes to light that is a concern to the Government, the vehicle for discussing that is the monthly joint meeting. That is the context in which the Lothian issue was raised—in my view, appropriately.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

Asked what?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You were not asked by Mr Feeley to take up the issue of unavailability codes when it burst into the public domain because of the Lothian scandal.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

We discussed the consequences of the Lothian report. As the accountable officer for the NHS in Scotland, Mr Feeley—rightly—sought assurances that we were giving the issue due attention. We discussed the possibility of an internal audit and an Audit Scotland process. That is the normal conduct of business that I recognise.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

In response to the convener, you said that you commissioned a report. Was that in the context of what you have described?

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

No—that was my local report.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

Me.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

No—it was on the board’s behalf.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

We were reporting to our board on a monthly basis, in the normal way. At a board meeting, I advised the board that I had commissioned work. That was not to do with any national request; that was me as the accountable officer in the local system seeking to satisfy myself, on my board’s behalf, that we had the issues dealt with in Tayside. The decision was entirely local. I informed the board that I was taking forward the decision, and we subsequently reported.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Your board did not initiate any of that. In the “post-Lothian” period that Dr Cook described—that was his term, not ours—did your board not say, “This is something we need to be aware of, Mr Marr. Is this going on here? Should we be assured that this isn’t happening here?”

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

In fact, we undertook a very comprehensive review of our data, including those from the organisational development exercise that I described. That was comprehensively reported to our board.As I said—and I repeat—that report did not flag up to us that there was a serious problem with social unavailability. If the auditors subsequently point out systems weaknesses to us, we have to accept that. I have never in any way criticised or sought not to accept the findings of the internal audit. We did a huge amount of work after the Lothian report was published to assure our board that we did not have a difficulty with social unavailability.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You have made the point about the wider context and so on, but do you feel that the overall target has become more important than anything else?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Sorry—is that question for me?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

No—I am asking Mr Marr. He has the floor at the moment, but I will let you in as well if you want, Mr Calderwood.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

No, that is all right—I am quite happy.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

No, I do not think that it has become the preoccupation of the health service. It is one of many targets that I believe are justified. The general public deserve to know that they can gain access, given that a number of years ago, we had waiting times that we were all not particularly proud of.There is a debate for the future about what the irreducible minimum waiting time is when we have 500,000 transactions.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I think that 12 weeks is a pretty good place to be, but transacting 500,000 patients will take a number of weeks.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I accept that—that is a very fair point. It is the consequence of the target that concerns many of us, however—and that probably goes much wider than those of us in the room. Did your board, and did you, as a chief executive, address the consequence of that target and what it meant for people in your area?

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

Yes, absolutely. Our view is that the target is achievable with a great deal of hard work and effort. Balanced against that—and I can only speak from my own context—we put as much emphasis on other aspects of quality in our 2020 vision for the health service of Scotland. I would not want to distort our effort on accident and emergency waiting times, unscheduled care and all the other things that we have to do in order to fulfil our local delivery plan for Government. I do not believe that the target is a distortion of that effort; it is part and parcel of the challenge that we face on a daily basis.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You do not feel that your staff were put under unnecessary pressure because of the target with regard to how they had to perform.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

They feel pressure—I refer back to the local report that I commissioned, in which the staff acknowledged that they felt pressure. They also felt supported, which is a very different conclusion from their feeling pressured and consequently feeling bullied. The staff said that they felt pressured but also supported, and it is our responsibility to support our staff as much as we can.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So you do not feel that the target is an impediment to what you are trying to achieve—and, more important, you do not feel that the target puts any undue pressure on staff.

Gerry Marr NHS Tayside
link

I would take out the word undue: it creates pressure, but our performance in Tayside shows that we are meeting all the other targets that we have to meet while delivering the 12-week TTG.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I also have questions about ISD. I wish to clarify this—I tried to write down the words that were used earlier. Susan Burney said that the Government accepted that there were “plausible reasons”—I think that that was the phrase that she used. Do you meet Government representatives on a monthly basis to discuss a range of performance indicators?

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

We meet regularly to discuss data and data development. Much of the work that we do on data development is in partnership with and in support of boards and the Scottish Government. ISD people will typically be involved in many meetings and groups, examining data development, including that relating to waiting times.In terms of data quality, which I discussed before, we will have spoken to boards about anything that we see as unusual. The boards will come back to us and either acknowledge that there is something wrong—and tell us that they will change that or that there is something that we need to know and therefore include in our publication—or they will confirm that the data are correct. If they say that the data are correct, we do not take the matter further. Those conversations will be among many conversations about a range of data quality questions.11:00

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I am struggling to understand what you do that flags up problems—please do not think that I mean you, personally; I mean ISD. What does ISD do that helps the system?

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

We bring the data in and validate them. We look across the data from quarter to quarter, ahead of publication, looking for anything that looks unusual, which might lead us to go back and check that the data are okay. We have a range of processes for that. The result is a list of questions that we want to ask each board, just to check that the data are correct—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You are talking about an internal challenge function, rather than—

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

Yes, we look for unusual things in the data, which might mean that we want to reassure ourselves that there has been no mistake in the submission, before we publish.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Do you accept that none of us would have heard anything about the issue were it not for a whistleblower? It was not due to any part of the NHS that the situation—for want of a more pejorative word—emerged.

Susan Burney Information Services Division
link

I come back to the fact that the data are published, so anything unusual is also published.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Some of the data were not published. That is the point.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

May I take us back to roles? Roles are fundamental in this context. The Scottish Government is responsible for performance management on a national level; ISD’s responsibility is to ensure that the statistics that we publish have a quality to them; and boards have accountability and responsibility to ensure that the figures that they submit to us are correct and that patient care is delivered. Those are the clear roles that we are transacting.Part of what you get from us, in terms of value add, is some comfort that the timing of our releases is not politically driven and is independent. The numbers that you are looking at are what we believe the numbers actually are, as opposed to anything that people would like you to believe. We do quality control to a statistically acceptable level, and I think that you can take comfort from the external work that was done in 2010 by the UK Statistics Authority.What we are not designed to be is a proxy for audit. We cannot compensate for what board systems themselves should be capable of regulating. Any board will have a board of governance—members asked about that—which has a role. Sitting underneath that is a clinical governance committee, which has a role in seeing what goes on with waiting times. It is important to understand that in relation to scrutiny, challenge of probity and so on, a board has far more information than ISD has on what is happening, and will remain the best place in which to gauge the probity of numbers. We can provide you with an external counterpoint, but not much more than that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I take your point about roles. However, Audit Scotland said on page 34 of its report:“ISD Scotland was not clear about what issues to escalate to the Scottish Government.”Do you recognise that?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

No, I do not accept that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Do you not understand why Audit Scotland came to that conclusion?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

I do not understand that, and I do not understand why Audit Scotland did not discuss making the point with us before it made it.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Do you think that there is any basis for the comment?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

No, I do not. The report contains good suggestions for improvement, and we are keen to improve—

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

We have always been quite clear about our role. It is really important for us to be clear, because if we were less clear—if we were too close to Government or if we were confused about our role in supporting boards—that would be unfortunate.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Okay. Did you at any stage raise with the Government the statistical imbalances that you mentioned were coming through in relation to social unavailability codes?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

It comes down to what you mean by “raise”. If the question is whether the Government was aware of the statistics, in the way that anyone else who was looking at our website would have been aware of them, the answer is yes—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

No, I was not asking that. Did you have formal meetings with the Government, at which you could say, “Look, there’s something going on here. We don’t exactly know what it is, but we think that the Government should look into it”?

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

No.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You did not have such a meeting at any time during the whole episode.

Ian Crichton Information Services Division
link

No.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

There has been a great deal of discussion about how the figures are extracted and the limitations on them. On page 7 of its report, Audit Scotland said:“The systems used to manage waiting lists have inadequate controls and audit trails, and the information recorded in patient records is limited.”The appendix, on audit methodology, shows that a huge number of detailed questions were asked to which the systems could not produce answers. The multiplicity of systems, which I know is being worked on, especially in Glasgow, caused problems. What reassurance is there that those systems will be brought together, that we will have uniformity of reporting and that we will not have the different boards using different criteria in the future?

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is well on its way with a project plan to reach a situation in June 2013 in which we will have only one information technology system—TrakCare—which, when completely rolled out in Glasgow, will represent the principal IT system in NHS Scotland. The system will be operational in NHS Lothian, NHS Lanarkshire, NHS Ayrshire and Arran, NHS Grampian, NHS Borders and NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, which together represent about 70 per cent of NHS activity. The consortia are working with TrakCare to ensure that we develop an audit program in the suite of software modules that will give us complete transparency and auditability of every individual patient’s journey. We are very confident that, from this summer, that system will be in place and there will be a degree of consistency across a significant proportion of the NHS in Scotland.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I accept that there will be a uniform system, but will every board have the same criteria in using that system? As we all know, the approach can be different on a number of things.

Robert Calderwood NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

The new ways approach and the treatment time guarantee have a series of protocols that must be applied uniformly across NHS Scotland. Each board published its own access policy, which determines how it will address the needs of its patients—in other words, where they will obtain that activity from. Each board has slightly different access criteria, so what represents a reasonable and fair offer to an individual patient will be determined by reference to the access policy of their own resident board, and those are clearly quite different across Scotland.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Who will have the overarching responsibility for ensuring that there is uniformity?

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Report Committee business · 459

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.