Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Public Transport Users’ Committee for Scotland (Removal of Functions) Order 2013 (SSI 2013/79)

Wednesday 20 March 2013 Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 21 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

21 contributions
Maureen Watt SNP The Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

We move on to agenda item 3, which is evidence from the minister on a negative instrument. The order removes from the Public Transport Users Committee for Scotland all the functions that it currently has. As witnesses we again have Keith Brown, Minister for Transport and Veterans, and Tom Davy, team leader for bus and local transport policy; and we are joined by Jill Mulholland, unit head for transport accessibility and road safety at Transport Scotland. I welcome you all and invite the minister to make opening remarks.

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Thank you, convener. The Passengers’ View Scotland review paper, which acknowledged the work, knowledge and experience of PVS members, concluded that it was difficult to identify many tangible outputs or outcomes from the body and that its continuation therefore did not represent good value for money.The main recommendation of the independent review was that PVS should only continue with the functions of the subcommittee, bus passengers’ platform—BPP—which deals with second-tier bus complaints in Scotland. The review also highlighted the fact that that bus complaints process should itself be subject to a review. Before making any decision on the review, I asked officials to provide an overview of the landscape of passenger representation across all modes of public transport and for a proposal on a way forward that would reinvigorate and repackage advice and complaints handling for bus users in Scotland. Our overall review of passenger representation in Scotland highlighted that rail was dealt with by Passenger Focus, ferries by the regional transport partnerships and air by the Civil Aviation Authority. That left a gap for bus user representation and complaints handling, which was partly being addressed by a small amount of funding to Bus Users UK, to part fund a Scottish representative on national groups.Alternatives were investigated for bus representation and complaints handling, but the most straightforward and value-for-money approach and the best case scenario for bus users in Scotland is to grant fund an independent organisation, based in Scotland, to carry out the functions. Through grant funding we can enable an organisation to develop its ability to represent bus users and to extend the range of activities it carries out. A grant offer letter sets out the agreed activities, processes and appropriate standards that should be used. A monitoring and reporting process will ensure value for money and, as with any agreements, if there is a need to change anything, that can be accomplished without recourse to legislation.Finally, Bus Users UK is keen to expand its existing Scottish representation for buses. It proposes forming a distinct Scottish branch to be entitled Bus Users Scotland, which provides a very convenient acronym. That branch will have an office and staff based in Scotland. The Government proposes to grant fund BUS to enable it to develop the range of activities it provides in Scotland to match similar representation in England and Wales. Those activities include bus complaint handling and bus service compliance monitoring, which will deliver real benefits for the Scottish Government, the traffic commissioner and bus users. BUS will also provide a function relating to bus compliance monitoring that the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency is no longer willing to provide on a regular basis, and thus it will help us to implement the bus regulatory regime.

Maureen Watt SNP The Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Thank you. At our last committee meeting with PVS, it highlighted its problems to almost all committee members. Elaine Murray was not on the committee then, so I presume that she has some questions.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

I apologise, minister—it is actually my fault that we are having to speak about a negative instrument. I did not intend to move a motion against it; I just wanted to ask some questions about the successor arrangements—and you have answered some of them already. How will the members of Bus Users Scotland—or BUS, as it will presumably be known—be appointed? You say that it is part of Bus Users UK. Will BUS have any separate accountability to you?

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

We will not be appointing members to BUS. I know that you have asked a written question about the issue, and I have responded to it, although it might not have come to you yet.BUS is not of the same type as PVS, for which there was an appointments process. PVS will now be taken off the relevant list of public bodies, and the appointments process for BUS will not be the same. The new group is to be funded through the grant scheme whereby we say that we want certain things done and it is up to the organisation to make provision and to provide information to the required standards.We are asking BUS to do a bit more than before because, as I said, VOSA has taken away its inspection regime for vehicles and we are adding that into the BUS process. We feel that we will get more for the money that we spend and more control over what is done. Perhaps Jill Mulholland wants to add to that.

Jill Mulholland Transport Scotland
link

That is exactly what we are trying to do in the proposal. We have a Scottish representative in Bus Users UK, whom we fund, and the proposal is to enlarge that and to bring in the compliance function that is now not being done by VOSA. It was a question of timing that through the new organisation we could prepare a whole package for bus users in Scotland and put bus users advice, policy guidance, complaints and compliance in that one package.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

Despite Passengers’ View Scotland’s name—although I know that that was not its formal title—it only really looked at buses, so there will be no loss of service to ferry service passengers or rail service passengers.

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

That is correct: they are dealt with by different organisations.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

Is the review, which we have a copy of with our papers, to be published on the Transport Scotland website? I have not yet seen it on there.

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Yes, the review has been published and should be on the website.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

I looked for it yesterday and did not see it on the website.

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

I will check that but it should be published by now.

Jim Eadie SNP Edinburgh Southern
link

On page 30 of the review that Elaine Murray mentioned, under section 9.2 there is a recommendation that:“the bus complaints process should be subject to a ‘root and branch’ review with consideration being given to the development of a ‘one stop shop’ for bus passenger complaints.”Is that something that the Government intends to progress? What do you see as the advantages of that approach?

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

No, what we have decided is not quite a one-stop shop because we have the traffic commissioner who will also have responsibilities for complaints. The traffic commissioner also has other important functions and we do not intend to change them. We considered whether it was possible to give all the complaints function to the traffic commissioner, but we decided that that was not the best approach and that we should use the expertise of Bus Users UK.Our decision was based in some part on the representations that we had from members, both in debates in the chamber and from the previous committee in the last session of the Parliament. It was felt that there was a need for a specific organisation with the requisite expertise to take things forward, and we think that BUS is the best outcome—but it is not quite a one-stop shop.

Jim Eadie SNP Edinburgh Southern
link

Are you confident that the proposals will allow for members of the public to make complaints that will be investigated fully?

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Yes. There are still some things that operators are statutorily obliged to do that the traffic commissioner will be responsible for. For example, if they give adequate notice for starting up a new route or deregistering a route, that has to be done through the traffic commissioner—that is set out in statute. However, I think that BUS is the best way forward for other things. More importantly, having come to an agreement with Bus Users UK over how exactly everything is to be achieved, we retain an element of control. If we think that one part of the group is not working as well as it should, through the grant process we are able to change things much more quickly than would have been the case if, for example, we had had to set up another body in statute and think of all the different things that we would want it to do. BUS gives us a better prospect for investigating complaints by bus users and also the ability to change the service if we think that that is necessary.

Margaret McCulloch Lab Central Scotland
link

In relation to the existing PVS committee, page (i) of the review states: “there is evidence that its activities are more reactive than proactive.”The review also states that there is little evidence in the annual reports that those documents have driven forward the work plan of the committee.What steps will you take to ensure that the new organisation achieves the standards that you are looking for? The previous organisation produced four annual reports, yet no intervention took place and no work was done with the organisation to bring it up to an acceptable standard. What sort of key performance indicators will you put in place to ensure that that does not happen with the new organisation?

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

A great deal of work was done, although perhaps not in the public way that is suggested, to try to make the previous organisation more proactive and evidence based. Its annual reports were the subject of substantial discussion between Government and the organisation. It was not the case that it was left to wither on the vine. A lot of work was done, but it just did not seem possible to get to where we wanted to be with that organisation.How can we ensure that we have the right level of service from the new organisation? Well, we know a great deal about what it does already and, of course, it has a Scottish representative. We have said that there are certain things that we want to do. We have chosen the things to ask it to do; I have mentioned compliance inspection of vehicles, which VOSA has drawn back from. We are the ones who will say in the grant letter exactly what level of service we want, and we will retain that control. If the body does not provide that service, we can of course change things.Jill Mulholland might want to speak about the specific things that we want the body to do.

Jill Mulholland Transport Scotland
link

We will specify in the grant letter what we want the organisation to do and we will have performance indicators to make sure that it meets those specifications. There will also be quarterly reporting and an annual report to Transport Scotland to evidence what the organisation has done during the year.A couple of my civil servants carry out the bulk of the complaints on behalf of the bus passengers’ platform on an on-going basis. The majority of complaints should go to bus operators. One of the main things that we have asked the new organisation to achieve is to ensure that the public are aware that their first recourse for complaint is to the bus operators, because they are most appropriately placed to deal with complaints. Bus Users Scotland will be the second tier, which will be able to deal with complaints that the customer believes have not been resolved by the bus company. Looking at it in that way, therefore, there should be more of a one-stop customer complaints shop. The complaints process should be much more integrated and Bus Users Scotland will have much more involvement with the bus companies to ensure that that takes place.

Maureen Watt SNP The Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

As there are no more questions, I thank the witnesses for their evidence.The committee appears to have no issues to raise in relation to the order. Members should note that no motions to annul the order have been received. Does the committee therefore agree that it does not wish to make any recommendation in relation to the order?Members indicated agreement.11:13 Meeting suspended.

11:18 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 83
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 21
  3. 10:00 Petition Petitions · 155
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.