There is a distinct choice in our approach to childcare. One reason why childcare is not only expensive, but patchy in its quality and therefore in its impact on children, is that our marketplace has so few price controls. Therefore, as we have ramped up our supply-side subsidies to parents over the past decade, we have been propping up an expensive, fragmented and averagely good childcare market. At present, England is choosing to go further down that route, along with countries including the Netherlands.However, there is a choice. The Danish approach relies much more on subsidies to providers in all the sectors. Those subsidies are much more about holding down price and ensuring investment in workforce development, so that the sector does not end up with a largely low-paid and low-skilled workforce. On average, Danish childcare workers are paid twice as much and are twice as skilled as those in the UK. There is a real choice to be made between demand-side and supply-side subsidies.10:45
On whether work is the best route out of poverty, everyone would agree that it ought to be. If you work, you should not be poor, but we know that that is not always the case, which is why we have said that it is a half-truth. Work is a route out of poverty roughly half the time, but half the time it is not, given what we know about people working fewer hours, getting low pay and having a lower level of skills.If we are to create a vision of how to get ourselves out of the present situation, we need to realise that the best-performing labour markets across the world have active labour-market policies that are not cheap. It costs money to do such work well, but it is more likely to lead to better outcomes that are sustainable—in other words, it is a case of investing to save in the long term. High-quality job matching—understanding the skills that people have and what they need for the future labour market—is at the heart of that.We must involve employers in our welfare to work programmes much more than we have done in the past 15 years. There is a lot of evidence internationally about what we could do, but it involves making different choices.