2. To ask the Scottish Government what support it provides to national health service boards for the delivery of paediatric services. (S4T-00253)
Official Report · Chamber
Paediatric Services
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Neil SNP 5
- Jim Hume LD 3
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Aileen McLeod SNP 1
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
11 contributions2. To ask the Scottish Government what support it provides to national health service boards for the delivery of paediatric services. (S4T-00253)
In response to changing demands for paediatric services, the Scottish Government and NHS Scotland have invested significantly in the NHS workforce, resulting in increased numbers of consultants, trainees and advanced nurse practitioners in paediatric services.
The Scottish Government submitted evidence to the Migration Advisory Committee that all grades of paediatric doctors should remain on the shortage occupation list, to ensure that all avenues remain open when recruiting.
We are working with NHS Education for Scotland to develop a sustainable training programme that will increase the number of advanced nurse practitioners in paediatric services in the NHS in Scotland.
The Scottish Government submitted evidence to the Migration Advisory Committee that all grades of paediatric doctors should remain on the shortage occupation list, to ensure that all avenues remain open when recruiting.
We are working with NHS Education for Scotland to develop a sustainable training programme that will increase the number of advanced nurse practitioners in paediatric services in the NHS in Scotland.
Last June, the children’s ward at St John’s hospital in Livingston was forced to close for three weeks, due to chronic staff shortages, which left patients and parents in limbo. That should have been the moment for decisive action. Instead, yesterday—eight months on—we learned of the true scale of the problem nationwide: NHS Forth Valley has half the doctors that are required; NHS Dumfries and Galloway should have seven but has fewer than three; and in NHS Borders two posts have been vacant for two years.
Dr Andrew Eccleston, of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, said:
“There is a national crisis in terms of paediatric staff.”
Does the cabinet secretary agree?
Dr Andrew Eccleston, of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, said:
“There is a national crisis in terms of paediatric staff.”
Does the cabinet secretary agree?
There is an international shortage of paediatric consultants. Despite that, we have increased the number of paediatric consultants operating in Scotland by 34 per cent since we came to power in 2007. As well as increasing the number of consultant paediatricians, we have expanded other relevant occupations. The whole-time-equivalent number of advanced nurse practitioners has expanded from 27.4 in 2009 to 44.7 in September 2012. I do not accept that we have been anything other than active, as I said in my reply to the member’s initial question.
It is consultants themselves who are beginning to question the future of vital paediatric services in communities across Scotland. The last time that the cabinet secretary was confronted with uncomfortable headlines, he was concerned enough to produce an emergency action plan worth £1 million. It seems that headlines motivate him into action, so will he advise the Parliament when an action plan on paediatric staff shortages will be produced and how much funding he is willing to allocate? Will he assure us that no paediatric services in Scotland will close?
Mr Hume has a cheek, given that he represents a party that in government is cutting the budget in Scotland by 8 per cent for revenue and 26 per cent for capital. Far from waiting for headlines, as he clearly did before he was motivated to ask the question, we have been involved in a host of action items to deal with the problem, not since last week but over the past few years, because of the mess that we inherited from the previous, Labour-Liberal Democrat Administration.
It appears that the message that should go out from the cabinet secretary and the Parliament is that there is no problem and doctors are completely wrong in saying that there is.
Will the cabinet secretary answer the second part of Jim Hume’s question? Will the Government give the public in Scotland an absolute guarantee that children’s wards will not close in future due to staff shortages? If he cannot give that guarantee, all the stuff about additional consultants and so on is worthless. The public are entitled to know whether their children’s wards will remain open. Can he guarantee that?
Will the cabinet secretary answer the second part of Jim Hume’s question? Will the Government give the public in Scotland an absolute guarantee that children’s wards will not close in future due to staff shortages? If he cannot give that guarantee, all the stuff about additional consultants and so on is worthless. The public are entitled to know whether their children’s wards will remain open. Can he guarantee that?
First, I did not say that there is no problem; I said that there is a shortage of paediatric consultants in Scotland. There is a shortage of paediatric consultants in England. There is a shortage of paediatric consultants in Wales. There is a shortage of paediatric consultants internationally. There is an international problem, which is made worse by the fact that the Labour Government followed a right-wing agenda on immigration and cut off opportunities to recruit people from outside the European Union. I therefore do not think Dr Simpson is in a very good position to criticise.
As has been evident from the action that I have taken to keep St John’s paediatric services going 24/7, I am absolutely committed to maintaining the quality and quantity of paediatric services throughout Scotland.
As has been evident from the action that I have taken to keep St John’s paediatric services going 24/7, I am absolutely committed to maintaining the quality and quantity of paediatric services throughout Scotland.
Given that it is of course the responsibility of NHS boards to plan and deliver clinical services taking into account local demands, demographic changes and other relevant local issues, will the cabinet secretary clarify again the number of consultants specialising in paediatrics who are currently employed by the NHS and how that compares with the number employed when the Scottish National Party first came to office in 2007?
At the moment, there are 223.8 whole-time-equivalent paediatric consultants in Scotland, compared with 167.2 in September 2006. That unprecedented 34 per cent increase in the number of paediatric consultants in Scotland is something that we are very proud of.
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
That ends topical questions.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 19 Feb 2013 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 2
- Structural Funds (European Union Financial Framework) Questions · 8
- Paediatric Services Questions · 11
- Horsemeat Substitution in Europe Statement · 34
- Tuition Fees Debate · 141
- Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill Bill debate · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
- Lothiansound Members’ business · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.