Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Jobcentre Plus (Work Experience)

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 11 December 2012 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link


2. To ask the Scottish Government what impact the Jobcentre Plus system of encouraging work experience is having on its policies that support people into paid employment. (S4T-00162)

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Youth Employment · Almond Valley
link
As the Parliament knows, the Scottish Government does not duplicate services for which the United Kingdom Government has the responsibility and resources to provide. Therefore, there is no direct impact on the Scottish Government’s policies to support young people into work. Indeed, we are trying to make Department for Work and Pensions and Scottish Government policies work coherently and effectively in the interests of young unemployed people.

The Scottish Government recognises that periods of work experience can be highly valuable to improving the employability and skills of young people, but we have been clear with the DWP that work experience schemes should in no way exploit those who take them up. We are supportive of voluntary, non-sanction based work experience opportunities that do not substitute substantive jobs and which give young people valuable experiences that help them to move towards employment. Clearly, we are not supportive of employers who use work experience as a form of cheap—or, indeed, free—labour.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link
As the minister said, work experience is clearly a very good thing. However, the Sunday Mail indicated that Jobcentre Plus managers are under pressure to encourage employers to turn paid vacancies into unpaid work experience. Can the minister tell us whether there are any estimates of the number of people filling real jobs in Scotland under the guise of work experience? Will the Scottish Government make urgent representations to Westminster regarding that practice?

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Youth Employment · Almond Valley
link
I am aware of the article that appeared in the Sunday Mail and an article that appeared in the Daily Record last week. Should the allegations be true, Mr Mason is right that the practice would be scandalous, but such serious allegations need to be investigated and the DWP must be given the opportunity to respond. Therefore, I have today written to the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Iain Duncan Smith, to seek an urgent investigation into the allegations. I will of course be happy to provide Parliament with details of his response when I receive it.

If the allegations were found to be true, the situation would be scandalous, but it would be difficult to estimate how many work experience placements to date have displaced real job opportunities.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link
I am grateful that the minister has already written to the Westminster Government; that is excellent. Does she agree that, if the allegations are true, it is exploitation of people in Scotland who are looking for real work? Does she also agree that Jobcentre Plus and the DWP should be on the side of job applicants if there are unscrupulous employers out there? Can the Scottish Government do anything to offer such protection if the DWP will not? Finally, does the minister agree that Westminster’s record on running the DWP has been very poor and that that is another disadvantage of Scotland remaining in the UK?

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Youth Employment · Almond Valley
link
I believe that everybody should be on the side of those who are seeking work. I have a strong belief in the value of work experience for young people, but—as I have already said—such placements must be voluntary and of a high quality, and they must support the young person’s move towards and into employment. Employers are key partners in that regard, and we are clearly opposed to any form of exploitation.

Earlier this year, the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development published a charter and guide for employers on work experience. It is a good-quality guide and it is very clear that work experience should not be used to fill job vacancies. I encourage every employer to apply the guidance that is contained in the document.

On a personal note, from my engagement with DWP staff I think that they work hard to try to deliver for unemployed people in very difficult circumstances. However, I am also clear that, where services impact on the lives of people in Scotland, the responsibility for those services should lie with this Parliament and no other.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link
I remember being quite struck when the Minister for Youth Employment said that she was relaxed about unpaid work experience. I think that that was said in response to an intervention by Patrick Harvie in a debate last year.

The minister says that she wants voluntary and high-quality work experience. Will she consider a time limit on work experience? It is certainly my experience that work experience often morphs into an unpaid job. We need to understand the difference between work experience and paid employment.

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Youth Employment · Almond Valley
link
I am surprised that Miss Dugdale would find me relaxed about anything. I assure her that I am not relaxed by instinct.

I will clarify what I said. It was actually a journalist who asked me not about a DWP scheme with sanctions but about the principle of work experience, and I said to him that I thought that work experience could make a positive contribution. In that regard, I was relaxed about it. In providing a comment to that journalist, I was not providing—

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Yes, but can we get the answer to Miss Dugdale’s question, please?

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Youth Employment · Almond Valley
link
Yes, indeed. I simply thought that it was important to clarify the point.

There is an issue about time limits. If we believe in the principles that the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development has set out, work experience should be focused on and tailored to the needs of young people, it has to enable them to progress towards and into work, and there should be clear boundaries. We cannot be prescriptive about every work experience scheme, but I would have concerns if work experience continued for protracted periods. I am therefore minded to support time-limited work experience, although flexibility is needed in working with individuals to meet their and employers’ needs.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Affirmation Procedure · 1
  3. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  4. Unconventional Gas Exploration Questions · 18
  5. Jobcentre Plus (Work Experience) Questions · 10
  6. Creative Scotland (Severance Package for Chief Executive) Questions · 8
  7. Role of Science in Public Policy Debate · 100
  8. Point of Order Procedure · 3
  9. Decision Time Decision time · 5
  10. Camphill Scotland Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.