1. To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day (S4F-00876)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 6
The record
20 contributions1. To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day (S4F-00876)
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland. That programme includes protecting the council tax freeze, protecting free university education, protecting personal care and bus travel for pensioners and protecting healthcare free at the point of need.
The late Campbell Christie was one of the finest trade unionists that this country has ever produced. He fought uncaring Tory Governments at every turn and helped to deliver the Parliament to protect the people of Scotland. His commission report on the future delivery of public services, which was written for the Scottish National Party Government, said:
“Contentious issues such as the continuation of universal entitlements must be considered openly and transparently, rather than in the current polarised terms.”
This is about the kind of fairness that we want to achieve for our communities. Spending is projected not even to get to 2010 levels for another 15 years, and Scotland’s population is ageing. I agree with Campbell Christie and believe that the debate about how we make spending choices fair for people throughout Scotland must happen before the referendum. Does Nicola Sturgeon? [Applause.]
“Contentious issues such as the continuation of universal entitlements must be considered openly and transparently, rather than in the current polarised terms.”
This is about the kind of fairness that we want to achieve for our communities. Spending is projected not even to get to 2010 levels for another 15 years, and Scotland’s population is ageing. I agree with Campbell Christie and believe that the debate about how we make spending choices fair for people throughout Scotland must happen before the referendum. Does Nicola Sturgeon? [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
That begs the question why Johann Lamont has set up a commission that reports after the referendum in 2014. She clearly does not have the courage of her convictions. I agree—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
I agree with Johann Lamont about the late Campbell Christie. He had a tremendous record in fighting uncaring Tory Governments. If only there were people on the Labour benches today who fought uncaring Tory Governments.
This Government makes its choices. We deliver to the Parliament balanced budgets that focus on growth, protecting public services and—yes—protecting the household budgets of families that are struggling to make ends meet. We will be proud to protect the council tax freeze, free education for working-class young people and free personal care and bus travel for our pensioners. If Johann Lamont wants to make that the dividing line of Scottish politics, I have only one thing to say to her: bring it on. [Applause.]
This Government makes its choices. We deliver to the Parliament balanced budgets that focus on growth, protecting public services and—yes—protecting the household budgets of families that are struggling to make ends meet. We will be proud to protect the council tax freeze, free education for working-class young people and free personal care and bus travel for our pensioners. If Johann Lamont wants to make that the dividing line of Scottish politics, I have only one thing to say to her: bring it on. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Nicola Sturgeon needs to understand that this is not a game about dividing lines. Nor is it about her electoral future. It is about what is happening in our communities throughout Scotland. She ought not to believe what her spin doctor tells her about what I said—I said that we need an open and honest debate, just as John Swinney said in 2010.
If Nicola Sturgeon does not want to agree with Campbell Christie and me, perhaps she will agree with one of her own. In another report that her Government commissioned, her chief economic adviser, Crawford Beveridge, said of free services:
“concessionary travel, prescription charges, eye examinations, free personal and nursing care and tuition fees”
are
“commendable, but simply may no longer be affordable.”
Critically, he added:
“A debate needs to be had on whether those who can afford to pay might be invited to do so, thus allowing better targeting of those in most need.”
When Nicola Sturgeon’s own minister, Alex Neil, got rid of the universal provision of central heating systems, he said:
“It would be inappropriate to use scarce resources to provide free central heating systems for some of our retired bankers, for example, who receive substantial pensions.”—[Official Report, 14 May 2009; c 17481.]
What Nicola Sturgeon says is not about the principle of universality; it is an electoral calculation. Why will she not have the debate that Campbell Christie and Crawford Beveridge demanded and ensure that we have it this side of the referendum?
If Nicola Sturgeon does not want to agree with Campbell Christie and me, perhaps she will agree with one of her own. In another report that her Government commissioned, her chief economic adviser, Crawford Beveridge, said of free services:
“concessionary travel, prescription charges, eye examinations, free personal and nursing care and tuition fees”
are
“commendable, but simply may no longer be affordable.”
Critically, he added:
“A debate needs to be had on whether those who can afford to pay might be invited to do so, thus allowing better targeting of those in most need.”
When Nicola Sturgeon’s own minister, Alex Neil, got rid of the universal provision of central heating systems, he said:
“It would be inappropriate to use scarce resources to provide free central heating systems for some of our retired bankers, for example, who receive substantial pensions.”—[Official Report, 14 May 2009; c 17481.]
What Nicola Sturgeon says is not about the principle of universality; it is an electoral calculation. Why will she not have the debate that Campbell Christie and Crawford Beveridge demanded and ensure that we have it this side of the referendum?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
Johann Lamont should make no mistake: I relish this debate.
Johann Lamont is on pretty dodgy ground in invoking spin doctors in the debate because, within 20 minutes of making her brave speech on Tuesday, she had dispatched her spin doctors to say that she did not really mean police numbers, bus travel for pensioners or free personal care. However, Arthur Midwinter has told the truth today, has he not? He said that everything is on the table.
There are many things that we can call that kind of approach from Labour. The word “shambolic” immediately springs to my mind. Let me tell Johann Lamont something for free: Labour’s approach is not brave, and it is certainly not honest.
The Government will put forward balanced budgets. Delivering balanced budgets is not easy when the Tories are cutting those budgets. That is why we argue for the control of our own resources. Johann Lamont’s answer to that is to pass on Tory cuts to hard-pressed Scottish households.
Johann Lamont is on pretty dodgy ground in invoking spin doctors in the debate because, within 20 minutes of making her brave speech on Tuesday, she had dispatched her spin doctors to say that she did not really mean police numbers, bus travel for pensioners or free personal care. However, Arthur Midwinter has told the truth today, has he not? He said that everything is on the table.
There are many things that we can call that kind of approach from Labour. The word “shambolic” immediately springs to my mind. Let me tell Johann Lamont something for free: Labour’s approach is not brave, and it is certainly not honest.
The Government will put forward balanced budgets. Delivering balanced budgets is not easy when the Tories are cutting those budgets. That is why we argue for the control of our own resources. Johann Lamont’s answer to that is to pass on Tory cuts to hard-pressed Scottish households.
The Deputy First Minister might think that that sounds good in here, but in the country, it sounds like a lot of nonsense. The fact of the matter is—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I agree with the Deputy First Minister that the budget has been cut, but if it has been cut, why does she stick with the same priorities that she set out in 2007? The dispute is not about whether there are cuts, which is how Nicola Sturgeon wants to present it; it is about which cuts should be made in tough times.
Let me explain what real people think. [Interruption.]
Let me explain what real people think. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Nicola Sturgeon lives in a household with an income of more than £200,000 a year. She gets free prescriptions. Free prescriptions cost £57 million a year. How many nurses is that? Like me, Nicola Sturgeon will have saved more than £400 from the council tax freeze, but my children’s school and schools across the country are getting to the stage at which they cannot even do the basics, such as photocopy materials. If spending cuts threaten the kind of free care for the elderly that we want to deliver, is it fair that a woman such as her on 200 grand should get free prescriptions? Is it fair that the Sturgeon household, on £200,000 a year, gets universal benefits when families on average earnings pay more for childcare than for their mortgage?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
Obviously, Labour is more out of touch than I thought that it was. Let me remind Johann Lamont that, under the system of prescription charges that she and her party presided over, people who earned as little as £16,000 a year paid prescription charges. That is why it was fair to abolish them.
If Labour thinks that the council tax freeze is so wrong and that it is doing so much damage, why did it promise to continue it just five months ago in the local government elections? I have here the “Glasgow Labour Manifesto 2012”. Number 1 on the “100 things we will do” list in that manifesto says:
“Labour ... will continue to freeze council tax for the next 5 years.”
Johann Lamont likes to talk about honesty, but if she was being honest then, is not it the case that, by definition, she is being deeply dishonest now?
If Labour thinks that the council tax freeze is so wrong and that it is doing so much damage, why did it promise to continue it just five months ago in the local government elections? I have here the “Glasgow Labour Manifesto 2012”. Number 1 on the “100 things we will do” list in that manifesto says:
“Labour ... will continue to freeze council tax for the next 5 years.”
Johann Lamont likes to talk about honesty, but if she was being honest then, is not it the case that, by definition, she is being deeply dishonest now?
We know that the Government’s council tax freeze is underfunded. I have been to too many meetings at which I have listened to care workers describing their lives and terms and conditions now, and I have listened to too many carers who are mopping up due to the fact that budgets are being cut, to stay silent on the issue.
Talk about not opening the gas bill but putting it in the drawer—that is what Nicola Sturgeon is doing with the nation’s bills. As every decent household knows, that never ends well. These are serious times. She said that she wants a debate: have one and let the people of Scotland choose. [Interruption.]
Talk about not opening the gas bill but putting it in the drawer—that is what Nicola Sturgeon is doing with the nation’s bills. As every decent household knows, that never ends well. These are serious times. She said that she wants a debate: have one and let the people of Scotland choose. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
If Nicola Sturgeon shuts down the debate in the way that she has started to do this week, she had better explain to the carer who is told that they can care for the pensioner for only 15 minutes why that is happening; to the son why that is the only care that his mother gets; and to the parent why their child cannot have the classroom support that they require to maintain them in mainstream education.
A public spending crisis is happening now and it is going to get worse. Nicola Sturgeon should face up to that. The Tories are cutting the budget, but within that budget we will all be judged on the choices that we make, whether it is our benefits or the needs of the people of this country. She could get that and she could change her mind now.
A public spending crisis is happening now and it is going to get worse. Nicola Sturgeon should face up to that. The Tories are cutting the budget, but within that budget we will all be judged on the choices that we make, whether it is our benefits or the needs of the people of this country. She could get that and she could change her mind now.
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
I remind Johann Lamont gently that the people of Scotland chose: in May 2011, they overwhelmingly chose free prescription charges, a freeze on the council tax and free university education for working-class kids. If Johann Lamont is saying that she wants to reverse all those policies, she should not set up a commission; she should have the guts to say so and let the people of Scotland choose after that.
Do not just listen to me about this. Let us have a look at some of the reaction from Labour posters on the LabourHame blog site:
“What are we doing? Did we learn nothing from the ‘New Labour’ nonsense?”
and
“This is not a speech based on any reasonable interpretation of Labour values”.
That is what Labour members are saying.
All is not lost for Johann Lamont, however, because Murdo Fraser was quick to take to Twitter. He said:
“Good to see Johann warming to Tory”
policies. [Laughter.] We can laugh, but it is actually quite tragic: Johann Lamont, poster girl for the Tories. Whatever happened to Labour? We used to have new Labour; now we have Johann Lamont—new Blair.
Do not just listen to me about this. Let us have a look at some of the reaction from Labour posters on the LabourHame blog site:
“What are we doing? Did we learn nothing from the ‘New Labour’ nonsense?”
and
“This is not a speech based on any reasonable interpretation of Labour values”.
That is what Labour members are saying.
All is not lost for Johann Lamont, however, because Murdo Fraser was quick to take to Twitter. He said:
“Good to see Johann warming to Tory”
policies. [Laughter.] We can laugh, but it is actually quite tragic: Johann Lamont, poster girl for the Tories. Whatever happened to Labour? We used to have new Labour; now we have Johann Lamont—new Blair.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 27 Sep 2012 →- Remploy Stakeholder Group Questions · 7
- Nuclear Weapons Questions · 4
- Rail Links (West Scotland) Questions · 6
- Electricity Grid (Access Charges) Questions · 6
- Multi-agency Public Protection Arrangements (Assessments) Questions · 4
- Credit Unions (Proposed Bankruptcy Bill) Questions · 6
- Remploy Aberdeen Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Drug Misuse Treatment (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- College Mergers (Support) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Patients with Heart Conditions (Treatment) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children Members’ business · 11
- Common Agricultural Policy Debate · 92
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.