1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00911)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 2
- Sarah Boyack Lab 1
The record
15 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00911)
Yesterday I had the great pleasure of meeting the Ambassador of El Salvador and today I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I would like to ask the First Minister a familiar question about whether a separate Scotland would be a member of the European Union. It is a question that Andrew Neil asked him on 4 March:
“Have you sought advice from your own Scottish law officers in this matter?”
Starting his answer with the words, “We have, yes,” could the First Minister get to, “No, we haven’t,” in 27 words?
“Have you sought advice from your own Scottish law officers in this matter?”
Starting his answer with the words, “We have, yes,” could the First Minister get to, “No, we haven’t,” in 27 words?
The 27 words that Johann Lamont refers to are, of course, the words that were taken out of the Labour Party press release. I do not think that it is a great argument to attack the probity of Government when you remove 27 words from your press release. It is not the most ingenious tactic, even from the Labour Party.
Yes, of course, an independent Scotland will be a member of the European Union.
Yesterday, the member of the European Parliament, Catherine Stihler, wrote to me to ask me to formally investigate whether the ministerial code had been broken in relation to the existence and content of legal advice on Scotland’s continued membership of the European Union. I confirm to the chamber that today I have agreed to that request by referring the matter to the independent panel of advisers on the ministerial code.
Because the matter touches on an area of the code that relates to the law officers’ prerogative in terms of the existence and content of legal advice, and our two members of the panel are both distinguished former Lord Advocates, on the advice of the permanent secretary I have invited Sir David Bell to join the independent panel of advisers. Sir David is vice chancellor of the University of Reading and a former permanent secretary of the United Kingdom Department for Education. He will lead the investigation into this matter.
The findings of the independent advisers will be made public. I will accept them and I hope that all members of this chamber will do the same. I observe that there have been five references since I have been First Minister and that each one has found in favour that the ministerial code has been abided by. I hope that on this sixth occasion, given that I have said that I will accept the findings, the Opposition parties will find themselves able to do the same.
Yes, of course, an independent Scotland will be a member of the European Union.
Yesterday, the member of the European Parliament, Catherine Stihler, wrote to me to ask me to formally investigate whether the ministerial code had been broken in relation to the existence and content of legal advice on Scotland’s continued membership of the European Union. I confirm to the chamber that today I have agreed to that request by referring the matter to the independent panel of advisers on the ministerial code.
Because the matter touches on an area of the code that relates to the law officers’ prerogative in terms of the existence and content of legal advice, and our two members of the panel are both distinguished former Lord Advocates, on the advice of the permanent secretary I have invited Sir David Bell to join the independent panel of advisers. Sir David is vice chancellor of the University of Reading and a former permanent secretary of the United Kingdom Department for Education. He will lead the investigation into this matter.
The findings of the independent advisers will be made public. I will accept them and I hope that all members of this chamber will do the same. I observe that there have been five references since I have been First Minister and that each one has found in favour that the ministerial code has been abided by. I hope that on this sixth occasion, given that I have said that I will accept the findings, the Opposition parties will find themselves able to do the same.
In among all that, the First Minister astonishingly asserted what Scotland’s position would be in Europe post independence. That is despite the fact that in five and a half years he has not asked the question and that he now tells us that, when he gets the answer, he will not share it with us.
The First Minister talks about the interview and the 27 words. I have the transcript here. The First Minister seems to be asking the people as Marx—Groucho Marx, that is—asked before him:
“Are you going to believe me or the evidence of your own eyes?”
I suppose that you cannot expect a straight answer from a First Minister who is as straight as a corkscrew, but let us try again. Why did the First Minister—[Interruption.]
The First Minister talks about the interview and the 27 words. I have the transcript here. The First Minister seems to be asking the people as Marx—Groucho Marx, that is—asked before him:
“Are you going to believe me or the evidence of your own eyes?”
I suppose that you cannot expect a straight answer from a First Minister who is as straight as a corkscrew, but let us try again. Why did the First Minister—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Listen to the question.
Why did the First Minister say that he had sought advice from the law officers when he had not? Why did he give that impression to this chamber and why did he go to court at our expense to stop the release of advice that he knew did not exist?
Of course, if that had been the case, the Labour Party would not have found it necessary to omit 27 words across three answers from its statement.
Let me see if I can explain the point to Johann Lamont. In terms of asking for specific advice on a legal question from law officers, you are bound by the ministerial code in terms of not revealing not only the content of the advice but its existence. Many times in this chamber—and I will cite them for Johann Lamont if she wishes—I have upheld that.
However, there is a second, quite different process. Every major document published by this Government is underpinned by law officers’ advice. When asked for specific advice, the law officers give their opinion on what is legal; with regard to the underpinning of documents, they will point out anything that is obviously against the law. That is the difference, and it is a distinction that I have made a number of times in this chamber. It is absolutely clear when we read the full interview with Andrew Neil that what is being talked about is in terms of both the debate and the documents. That is why that section of the interview finishes with the comment that the documents that have been published are
“consistent with the legal advice that we received”.
That is exactly the format of what was said.
In terms of the Government’s defending the ministerial code through court action, I have been doing a little bit of research and now find that in the two years that the Labour Party was bound by the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 it took five cases to the Court of Session to defend these principles and on disclosure. That compares with the two cases that we have taken to court in five years. I say as gently as I can to Johann Lamont—who was a member of that litigious Government in the Labour Party—that those who take five cases in two years to the Court of Session are in no position to preach to other people about the allocation of public money.
Let me see if I can explain the point to Johann Lamont. In terms of asking for specific advice on a legal question from law officers, you are bound by the ministerial code in terms of not revealing not only the content of the advice but its existence. Many times in this chamber—and I will cite them for Johann Lamont if she wishes—I have upheld that.
However, there is a second, quite different process. Every major document published by this Government is underpinned by law officers’ advice. When asked for specific advice, the law officers give their opinion on what is legal; with regard to the underpinning of documents, they will point out anything that is obviously against the law. That is the difference, and it is a distinction that I have made a number of times in this chamber. It is absolutely clear when we read the full interview with Andrew Neil that what is being talked about is in terms of both the debate and the documents. That is why that section of the interview finishes with the comment that the documents that have been published are
“consistent with the legal advice that we received”.
That is exactly the format of what was said.
In terms of the Government’s defending the ministerial code through court action, I have been doing a little bit of research and now find that in the two years that the Labour Party was bound by the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 it took five cases to the Court of Session to defend these principles and on disclosure. That compares with the two cases that we have taken to court in five years. I say as gently as I can to Johann Lamont—who was a member of that litigious Government in the Labour Party—that those who take five cases in two years to the Court of Session are in no position to preach to other people about the allocation of public money.
I have to say to the First Minister in the gentlest of terms that, given the seriousness of the charges that have been made to him, the idea that that constitutes any kind of answer is completely ludicrous. The people of Scotland need to trust what he says and, on that performance, they certainly do not. He says, “We can’t say that we are even asking for advice”—but the Deputy First Minister stood here on Tuesday and said that she was asking for that advice. Why does it have to be secret?
This is the reality about what is a serious issue. The First Minister wants an honest debate about what is going to happen to the future of Scotland so he starts it by asserting—and he did it again today—that we would be in the EU but would not have to join the euro. However, the First Minister does not actually know that because in five and a half years he has not asked. Yesterday, the Spanish foreign secretary said that Scotland would have to apply to be in the EU and would be at the back of the queue. The First Minister says that he is wrong, but he does not know because he has not asked. The First Minister says that we would keep the pound, but he does not know that either, because he has not asked.
The reality is that the First Minister will say anything to get through the moment and then ask us to take his assertions on trust. Does he not realise that after this week nobody trusts him?
This is the reality about what is a serious issue. The First Minister wants an honest debate about what is going to happen to the future of Scotland so he starts it by asserting—and he did it again today—that we would be in the EU but would not have to join the euro. However, the First Minister does not actually know that because in five and a half years he has not asked. Yesterday, the Spanish foreign secretary said that Scotland would have to apply to be in the EU and would be at the back of the queue. The First Minister says that he is wrong, but he does not know because he has not asked. The First Minister says that we would keep the pound, but he does not know that either, because he has not asked.
The reality is that the First Minister will say anything to get through the moment and then ask us to take his assertions on trust. Does he not realise that after this week nobody trusts him?
I would have thought that, given that this debate has lasted for a considerable time, Johann Lamont would have taken the precaution of at least reading the ministerial code. She just made the contrast when she asked why I could not reveal the existence of legal advice while Nicola Sturgeon this week told the chamber that we were seeking specific advice on this question. I point her towards understanding and reading the ministerial code, paragraph 2.35 of which says:
“The fact that legal advice has or has not been given to the Scottish Government by the Law Officers and the content of any legal advice given by them or anyone else must not be revealed outwith the Scottish Government without the Law Officers’ prior consent.”
When Nicola Sturgeon obtained the law officers’ prior consent, she was able to tell the chamber that we were seeking the specific legal advice.
I would have thought that, given that Labour ministers upheld the same ministerial code and that Johann Lamont was a Labour minister, that at least would now be understood in this debate. I hope that, now that the point has been cleared up for Johann Lamont, she will accept it. [Interruption.]
“The fact that legal advice has or has not been given to the Scottish Government by the Law Officers and the content of any legal advice given by them or anyone else must not be revealed outwith the Scottish Government without the Law Officers’ prior consent.”
When Nicola Sturgeon obtained the law officers’ prior consent, she was able to tell the chamber that we were seeking the specific legal advice.
I would have thought that, given that Labour ministers upheld the same ministerial code and that Johann Lamont was a Labour minister, that at least would now be understood in this debate. I hope that, now that the point has been cleared up for Johann Lamont, she will accept it. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
It is clear that the issue is about prior consent—I did not have prior consent and Nicola Sturgeon had prior consent. Is that really complicated?
I direct Johann Lamont to the comments of the Spanish foreign minister on 24 February this year, when he said:
“If in the UK both parties agree that this is consistent with their constitutional order, written or unwritten, Spain would have nothing to say, just that this does not affect us. No-one would object to a consented independence of Scotland.”
That brings us to the key point, which is that, in the Edinburgh agreement, under clause 30, the process by which independence for Scotland could be secured was agreed. That is the point that the Spanish foreign minister was making this year. Under those circumstances, we have sought the advice of the law officers, and that advice will inform the white paper on independence. That seems to me to be substantial progress in the debate, giving Johann Lamont the information that she claims she needs.
I direct Johann Lamont to the comments of the Spanish foreign minister on 24 February this year, when he said:
“If in the UK both parties agree that this is consistent with their constitutional order, written or unwritten, Spain would have nothing to say, just that this does not affect us. No-one would object to a consented independence of Scotland.”
That brings us to the key point, which is that, in the Edinburgh agreement, under clause 30, the process by which independence for Scotland could be secured was agreed. That is the point that the Spanish foreign minister was making this year. Under those circumstances, we have sought the advice of the law officers, and that advice will inform the white paper on independence. That seems to me to be substantial progress in the debate, giving Johann Lamont the information that she claims she needs.
I am asking for the information that the people of Scotland require to make the decision in future. The First Minister says that the difference between him and the Deputy First Minister is that she asked permission to tell us that she was going to get advice. Could he not have asked permission to tell us that he had not asked for any advice?
Members might find this hard to believe, but I actually feel for the First Minister. All his life, he has fought for this and now he knows that his argument does not meet the times. Now he knows that it does not make sense for Scotland, so he makes things up instead. No one wants the euro, so in his world he pretends that we would not have to have it, even though he knows that we would. Before now, Alex has always got his way. His need for a place in Scottish history comes before the needs of the people of Scotland.
As I said, I feel for the First Minister. His argument is falling apart in front of his eyes, and his own back benchers know it. His deceptions are being found out and no one believes him any more. How can this country have an honest debate about our future when we cannot trust a word that Alex Salmond says?
Members might find this hard to believe, but I actually feel for the First Minister. All his life, he has fought for this and now he knows that his argument does not meet the times. Now he knows that it does not make sense for Scotland, so he makes things up instead. No one wants the euro, so in his world he pretends that we would not have to have it, even though he knows that we would. Before now, Alex has always got his way. His need for a place in Scottish history comes before the needs of the people of Scotland.
As I said, I feel for the First Minister. His argument is falling apart in front of his eyes, and his own back benchers know it. His deceptions are being found out and no one believes him any more. How can this country have an honest debate about our future when we cannot trust a word that Alex Salmond says?
In the climax of Johann Lamont’s question, she actually almost directly quoted the Prime Minister. How appropriate that those in the better together campaign are even sharing phrases.
Let me tell Johann Lamont something for nothing. I think that it is worth while for Scotland to govern its own affairs and to escape from the welfare reform that is impoverishing our fellow citizens. I think that it is important for Scotland to take its place as an independent member of the European Union. Johann Lamont should look at the huge number of authorities who have said that over the years, which I have cited many times in this chamber.
It is of fundamental importance that we elect the Government that we want and that we do not have one foisted on us by Westminster. It is fundamentally important that this chamber and the Scottish people see Scotland as an independent member, equal with other nations in the European Union. Self-government for Scotland and proper representation by a Government that reflects the interests of the Scottish people—that is entirely the argument that will carry Scotland in two years’ time.
Let me tell Johann Lamont something for nothing. I think that it is worth while for Scotland to govern its own affairs and to escape from the welfare reform that is impoverishing our fellow citizens. I think that it is important for Scotland to take its place as an independent member of the European Union. Johann Lamont should look at the huge number of authorities who have said that over the years, which I have cited many times in this chamber.
It is of fundamental importance that we elect the Government that we want and that we do not have one foisted on us by Westminster. It is fundamentally important that this chamber and the Scottish people see Scotland as an independent member, equal with other nations in the European Union. Self-government for Scotland and proper representation by a Government that reflects the interests of the Scottish people—that is entirely the argument that will carry Scotland in two years’ time.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 25 Oct 2012 →- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (Glasgow Provan) Questions · 4
- Sea Lice Questions · 6
- Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Enforcement Actions) Questions · 4
- NHS Tayside (Patient Transport) Questions · 6
- Ferry Services (Islay) Questions · 4
- Healthy Eating Questions · 6
- Scottish Rail Franchise Questions · 4
- European Arrest Warrant Questions · 4
- Road to Recovery Programme (Methadone) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Forth Replacement Crossing First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Wind Farms (Landscape) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Neil Armstrong Members’ business · 9
- Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 65
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.