Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 19 April 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00608)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Later today I will discuss with Pat Watters, the president of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the very important joint announcement that is being made today on the United Kingdom Government’s misguided plans to abolish the existing council tax benefit and cut the successor budget by 10 per cent.

As members know, council tax benefit is being devolved to Scotland and to English local authorities, but the sting in the tail is a 10 per cent cut in the budget. More than 0.5 million low-income Scots benefit from council tax benefit. I am delighted to say that, by agreement with our local authorities, the Scottish Government and COSLA will jointly fund the £40 million shortfall, which means that there will be no cuts in council tax benefit in Scotland in 2013-14.

We will work with councils when the universal credit is announced in 2014-15 to ensure that we continue to protect some of the lowest-income Scots in the country. I am sure that all members in the chamber will welcome that joint action with Scotland’s local authorities.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
In March 2011, just before the Scottish Parliament election, the First Minister announced that Doosan Power Systems Ltd was going to invest £170 million in a new research facility in Renfrew and a manufacturing facility elsewhere in Scotland. In the same week, he suggested that the factory was going to Dundee. That was welcome news for the Scottish economy and the renewables industry.

Since then, the word “Doosan” has been a key part of the Scottish Government litany of supposed economic successes—indeed, John Swinney was talking about Doosan just last Sunday. However, it has now been reported that the First Minister was told in December last year that Doosan was scrapping the planned investment. The First Minister announced that Doosan was coming; when was he going to tell us that it is not?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am sure that Johann Lamont really meant to welcome the important news on council tax benefit, as I am sure she would like to welcome the better news that we had yesterday on the Scottish economy.

Johann Lamont could not have listened very well to John Swinney’s interview on Sunday, because it discussed Doosan’s announcement that it would not proceed with its investments in offshore wind—a decision that the company made last December. That is what the interview was about; I have the text of it here. I am not certain that Johann Lamont actually listened to the interview that she is citing.

The reason why we are supportive of Doosan is that it employs 1,300 people in Scotland. The research and development in its worldwide skill centre for boilermaking is continuing that investment, and we expect it to make more important investments in Scotland in the future. John Swinney was talking last Sunday not only about the decision on offshore wind, but about the hope and belief that Doosan will continue to be an important investor in the Scottish economy, which is why he is meeting the company in South Korea today.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The fact of the matter is that the First Minister announced that project. He said that it was a “great stride forward”, but why would he not tell us of the stride backwards? It has been reported that the Scottish Government wanted that news to be suppressed until after the local council elections. A Scottish Government spokesman in the same article denies that and is reported to have said that the Scottish Government wanted the statement out earlier.

Page 84 of the First Minister’s budget bill reports the planned investment, yet on 25 January and 8 February, when that document was debated in this chamber, the new information was not provided. If it is true that the First Minister wanted the statement out earlier, why did he not make it? Clearly, Doosan was not sensitive about it, because it let the story out at a trade fair in Denmark. Surely the Scottish people deserve to hear the news before the Danes do.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The ABCs of international investment and our relationship with companies mean that we do not make companies’ announcements for them. [Laughter.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
If Doosan wishes to make an announcement to its supply chain, it has the right to do that; that is its decision. However, the announcement that Doosan made and the information were available. That is why John Swinney was discussing it with Douglas Fraser on the radio last Sunday. Johann Lamont clearly did not listen to the radio interview that she cited.

What has happened since Doosan made its decision last December? We have had an announcement from Samsung of 500 jobs resulting from its investment in Methil, which will be the centre of its research and development for offshore wind. We have had an announcement from Gamesa of 700 jobs in the port of Leith. We have substantial expectations for both Nigg and Dundee as the offshore renewables industry gathers strength.

Many companies are investing in offshore wind, and many of those companies are investing in Scotland. However, one thing is absolutely sure: as that succession of announcements is being made, and as thousands of jobs are brought to the economy, Johann Lamont will not welcome a single one.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am beginning to get how this works. If it is good news, the First Minister announces it; if it is bad news, it is not in the business of the Government to make announcements on behalf of companies and it would be highly inappropriate for us to take any responsibility because that is all the job of the companies.

The fact of the matter is that, regardless of the other investment announcements, this is a hugely significant decision for Doosan that we must all be concerned about, given the implications for jobs and our shared commitment to reaching our climate change targets.

I repeat the point that, in January and February, we debated a budget that included the positive news of the investment, but the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth did not mention the new information. Instead, we are told, he mentioned it in the bygoing in a politics debate on a television programme months later. The fact of the matter is that the First Minister, his ministers and their officials knew at the end of last year about this significant announcement. In that case, why did he, his ministers, his MSPs and his press office keep on talking as if the investment was coming?

I know that Doosan invests in much more in Scotland than just this project, but I think that we all know what impression the First Minister wanted to create. Why did he allow his colleagues and his press office to keep on giving the impression that this project was coming to Scotland when he knew that it was not?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that the rule is, actually, that if it is good news, Johann Lamont will not welcome it, and, if it is bad news, the Labour Party will revel in it.

The reason why we keep a good relationship with Doosan is that it is an important employer in Scotland. We have every expectation that Doosan will make further investment in Scotland. I repeat that the world specialism research and development centre for boiler production continues. That is an important investment in the Scottish economy; Doosan is, therefore, an important investor.

Not every major engineering company in the world will go into the offshore wind market. Many are, however, and are combining with Scottish companies all around the coastline of Scotland. That is news that we should welcome.

I repeat that, since December, when Doosan made its decision as a result of what it described as the “liquidity crisis” in the eurozone, huge investments have been made in the Scottish economy in relation to offshore wind. The question is, are we prepared to welcome the investors combining with our companies to chart the future of engineering in Scotland? This side of the chamber says, “Yes, we should,” and, “Yes, we are.” The Labour Party seems to be mired in that streak of negativity that cost it so dear in last year’s elections.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister again wilfully misses the point. We were unable to respond to a significant decision because the First Minister chose not to tell us. This is not about talking the Scottish economy or Scotland up or down; it is about the First Minister’s integrity and the honesty of his Government.

If this were a one-off, we might give the First Minister the benefit of the doubt, but there is a pattern. Before the last election, while he was taking the credit for Doosan’s planned investment, he used taxpayers’ cash to keep the truth about his local income tax plans hidden from the public. When he was forced to come clean, he chose to do so on the day that his pal Rupert Murdoch got embroiled in the hacking scandal. When academics criticise the First Minister, his aide writes false letters in their name recanting. Good grief. The Advertising Standards Authority has even had to pull him up about the pandas.

The serious point is that we have a shared concern about the decision about Doosan. If the First Minister will suppress serious issues such as the Doosan investment announcement before the local elections, goodness knows what he will conceal before the referendum. After this, how can any of us believe a word that he says?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Let me quote exactly what John Swinney said on Sunday morning. He said:

“Doosan are one of the companies I plan to visit when I’m in Korea. Obviously the decisions that Doosan have made have been explained by the wider economic circumstances within the Eurozone particularly. I want to ... make clear the very great encouragement and the very real opportunities that exist within the renewable energy market”.

Where was the famed Labour press office when John Swinney was discussing Doosan last Sunday morning? Where were the statements from Johann Lamont to say that she is very concerned about what has happened with the Doosan investment? There was also a lack of statements of encouragement on the Samsung and Gamesa investments. There was silence from the Labour Party, which was asleep on Sunday morning.

Johann Lamont says all these dreadful things to me, but I know that she does not actually mean them. How do I know that? I know that because I have been reading LabourHame.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Yes I have. I confess it. I have been reading LabourHame. I know that it is a bad habit, and I have to get out of it. [Laughter.]

Dominic Dowling, who is the election agent for every Labour candidate in Glasgow—including what is left of the Labour Party in Johann Lamont’s constituency—said about the Labour Party’s attitude to me that

“to deny he has connected with the electorate, in a way that none of Labour’s post-devolution Scottish leaders has managed to do, is ridiculous.”

Out of the mouth and tweets in LabourHame of the man who is masterminding Labour’s campaign in Glasgow comes the essential word: Labour leadership—“ridiculous”.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Bus Services Debate · 128
  2. General Questions Questions · 1
  3. Water Environment (Controlled Activities) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 Questions · 8
  4. Local Authorities (Pay and Conditions) Questions · 8
  5. Graduate Employment Questions · 4
  6. Welfare Reform (Carers) Questions · 6
  7. Forensic Services (Relocation of Post-production Staff) Questions · 5
  8. NHS Lothian (Management Culture Inquiry) Questions · 6
  9. Social Impact Bonds Questions · 4
  10. Graduate Unemployment and Underemployment Questions · 8
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Council Tax (Abolition) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  15. Women Offenders First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. NHS Ayrshire and Arran (Allegations) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  17. Year of Creative Scotland Questions · 4
  18. Year of Creative Scotland Questions · 8
  19. Scotland Week Questions · 4
  20. Significant Historical Artefacts (Location Policy) Questions · 4
  21. BBC (Licence Fee Income) Questions · 4
  22. Heritage Societies Questions · 4
  23. Own Art Scheme Questions · 4
  24. Historic Built Environment (Towns and Villages) Questions · 4
  25. Historical Artefacts (Location Policy) Questions · 4
  26. Scottish Maritime Museum Questions · 6
  27. Scottish Water Questions · 13
  28. A85 (Road Safety Improvements) Questions · 8
  29. Concessionary Travel (People Aged between 60 and 65) Questions · 7
  30. Welfare Reform (Homelessness) Questions · 4
  31. Transport Infrastructure (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
  32. Commonwealth Games 2014 (Regeneration) Questions · 4
  33. Bus Travel Questions · 7
  34. Economic Infrastructure (South-west Scotland) Questions · 4
  35. Criminal Cases (Punishment and Review) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 44
  36. Decision Time Decision time · 7
  37. Community Radio Members’ business · 18

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.