I would like to talk about a couple of the points that Laura Brewer made in a bit more detail, particularly in relation to how public employment services and their officers can have an impact at various stages in the cycle.It has been mentioned a number of times in your discussions that prevention is the first course of action and that it should be taken as early as possible. Along with public employment services around the world, we promote the idea that career guidance in the school system needs to be supported by information that public employment services officers have. We encourage a much closer linkage between the educational system and the staff who work in public employment services so that they can share labour market information that provides indications of what job opportunities are currently in demand and what job opportunities are projected to be in demand in the medium and—sometimes—the longer term, depending on what information is available in a country. We also want much better occupational information to be provided, which includes job descriptions, the activities that are typically involved in particular occupations and the educational requirements, as well as the anticipated wage levels and the opportunities for career advancement that exist in those occupations.Young people need to have as much of that information as possible at the point at which they are in the latter part of their secondary school education and are planning for their further education so that, in preparing for the workforce, they can make as informed a career decision as they can. That will ensure that, as they get closer to the point at which they want to enter the labour market, they will be able to take up positions that they will be happy with and be willing to remain in later in their lives.One thing that we have found has worked extremely well in that regard is the inclusion in curriculums in many countries of on-the-job work placements for many students who are in the final two or three years of secondary school education. Such placements enable them to assess what it means to be a welder or a carpenter, or to work as a computer programmer. Such arrangements require very close dialogue between worker organisations and employer organisations, of course, as well as very close dialogue with the school system. Those linkages can be made with the assistance of public employment services, which regularly deal with all of those organisations.10:15
Prevention also means ensuring that people who have got into the workforce are able to stay in it. That involves life skills training and, in times of economic downturn, reacting quickly and offering interventions such as short-time work programmes to keep people in the workforce, even at a reduced level of productivity, to ensure that they do not lose their skills.A lot of research and evidence shows that young people tend to be much more vulnerable in economic downturns and that they are usually the first to lose their jobs. It is important that we do everything we can to prevent that from happening because, once they get into the unemployment ranks, it is much more difficult to move them back into employment.The next stage of intervention is the stage that we usually think of when we think of public employment services: job placement activities that are performed for all unemployed jobseekers. Again, an early response is essential—that has been proved over and over—but that is not the only thing that is essential. We recognise that jobseekers come into the system with differing levels of ability and facing different types of barriers, so jobseeker profiling is important. Such profiling is common in Europe. It has different names in different parts of the world but, basically, it involves individual counselling and discussion with jobseekers to determine what types of barriers they face in order to assist them in developing a transition from school to work or from job to job. It involves an action plan that will suit their needs, which will include various labour market interventions and will look at their current level of education, work experience—if they have any—aptitudes, interests and other activities. It is a matter of looking at the whole picture, and helping people to determine, from what they already have, an immediate job to which they can realistically aspire and identify where there may be gaps and interventions that can help to close those gaps and help them to move into higher levels of the same occupation.The approaches that seem to have the most impact with jobseekers in general, including youths, are those that combine a number of different interventions in a package. That has been acknowledged in a lot of the responses to your consultation. I am talking about a combination of individual counselling to jobseekers to ensure that they are well aware of what they already have and what they will need, and labour market interventions. In some cases, job subsidy initiatives can be the perfect solution in dealing with educated unemployed youths. They can give employers opportunities with reduced wages or holidays from paying social security benefits to test the jobseeker’s skill level and compatibility in their organisation. Well-targeted internships can provide the same opportunities. Internships can also be used in school breaks so that students who are still in the education system can learn a little bit more about the occupations for which they are training. That will help them to focus on the things that they need to fill the gaps.Well-targeted public employment programmes, particularly those that have included some types of skills training and life skills training, have been very effective in moving young people into the workforce. In some cases, entrepreneurial training for people to start their own businesses can be successful, but we realise that many young people do not necessarily have the business background, networks or capital that they would need to successfully start their own business. Therefore, such training is often not necessarily the first choice.I mentioned at the beginning that I would share a couple of delivery models. Many Governments around the world have realised that there are many things that need to be addressed and many groups of vulnerable workers with issues that need to be resolved. In most cases, however, they simply cannot afford to do all of this on their own and do not have expertise at the required level to deal with certain issues. As a result, many countries have looked at partnership arrangements with other stakeholders, both not-for-profit and non-governmental organisations and private employment agencies, to provide these services on their behalf to a certain degree and to some of the target groups.I will give the committee two examples. In many countries, one of the most effective approaches has been a decentralised model in which public employment offices continue to provide the full range of services in large urban centres while in more outlying and rural areas agreements are reached with municipal offices, training institutions and in some cases private agencies to offer the same level of service on their behalf. In other words, the public employment service is actually provided by different external service providers. That can happen through a contractual financial agreement or, as in the Philippines and Argentina, through sharing training costs or providing access to electronic labour exchanges that Government offices have developed and used. Such an approach has proved to be very successful in extending outreach and ensuring that services are provided to those most in need.Another very interesting model can be found in Canada, which has not only decentralised the delivery of many enhanced employment services to the provincial level but adopted a contracting-out process that involves many third-party service providers, many of whom have specialised expertise in issues relating to one or more of the target groups. In what has been a particularly effective approach, many NGOs and not-for-profit organisations provide services that deal with a wide range of issues faced by youth, from employment matters to other types of problems such as leaving school early, drug issues and interpersonal issues, all of which impact on their ability to find employment. The model has also worked particularly well with persons with disabilities.I will end there, convener, but I am more than happy to answer any questions you might have about this area.