1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00774)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 2
The record
16 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00774)
There will be meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
There were fun and games at Leveson yesterday. I am pleased that the First Minister managed to get through the whole day without telling Robert Jay that he was not asking the right questions.
The First Minister said yesterday that the only reason why he backed the Murdoch takeover of British Sky Broadcasting was for Scottish jobs. Can he confirm how many jobs would have come to Scotland if the Murdochs had taken over BSkyB? Will he say what the civil service and Scottish Enterprise assessments were of the deal?
The First Minister said yesterday that the only reason why he backed the Murdoch takeover of British Sky Broadcasting was for Scottish jobs. Can he confirm how many jobs would have come to Scotland if the Murdochs had taken over BSkyB? Will he say what the civil service and Scottish Enterprise assessments were of the deal?
Maybe that was because Robert Jay was asking the right questions yesterday.
The evidence for the impact on jobs and investment in Scotland comes in three parts. First, there is the evidence of James Murdoch—under oath, of course—to the Leveson inquiry on 24 April. I will read Johann Lamont the relevant part:
“I think we have to recall that this merger was about the creation of a pan-European digital television platform with major operations in the United Kingdom, and particularly that meant potentially quite a lot of operations and an increase in operations in Scotland, where technical support, IT, service centres, et cetera, were located for British Sky Broadcasting as an important employer there”.
Secondly, we know—and Johann Lamont knows now—that 36 per cent of BSkyB’s global employment is located in Scotland. At a meeting that I had with Mr Murdoch last year, it was explained that there would be an increase of 150 jobs in Livingston; those jobs were announced on 13 March and 16 May last year.
Thirdly, and crucially, there is the question of the outsourcing jobs. Johann Lamont will have studied my letter to James Murdoch after the meeting last January, when I quoted back the key point that he had conceded, which was that Scotland is a world-class centre for outsourcing. We were in danger last year because of the decision to move from six to two suppliers, which potentially put almost 2,000 jobs at risk in Scotland. Fortunately for Scotland, HEROtsc—with the assistance of Scottish Enterprise—was able to win one of the two contracts and, instead of losing jobs, we gained jobs in Scotland.
Those are the facts of which Johann Lamont was not aware the last time she started asking such questions. Now that she is aware of the facts, will she concede that, whatever politicians elsewhere were doing, jobs and investment for Scotland were the priority for this Government?
The evidence for the impact on jobs and investment in Scotland comes in three parts. First, there is the evidence of James Murdoch—under oath, of course—to the Leveson inquiry on 24 April. I will read Johann Lamont the relevant part:
“I think we have to recall that this merger was about the creation of a pan-European digital television platform with major operations in the United Kingdom, and particularly that meant potentially quite a lot of operations and an increase in operations in Scotland, where technical support, IT, service centres, et cetera, were located for British Sky Broadcasting as an important employer there”.
Secondly, we know—and Johann Lamont knows now—that 36 per cent of BSkyB’s global employment is located in Scotland. At a meeting that I had with Mr Murdoch last year, it was explained that there would be an increase of 150 jobs in Livingston; those jobs were announced on 13 March and 16 May last year.
Thirdly, and crucially, there is the question of the outsourcing jobs. Johann Lamont will have studied my letter to James Murdoch after the meeting last January, when I quoted back the key point that he had conceded, which was that Scotland is a world-class centre for outsourcing. We were in danger last year because of the decision to move from six to two suppliers, which potentially put almost 2,000 jobs at risk in Scotland. Fortunately for Scotland, HEROtsc—with the assistance of Scottish Enterprise—was able to win one of the two contracts and, instead of losing jobs, we gained jobs in Scotland.
Those are the facts of which Johann Lamont was not aware the last time she started asking such questions. Now that she is aware of the facts, will she concede that, whatever politicians elsewhere were doing, jobs and investment for Scotland were the priority for this Government?
First, that compelling case would have been interesting if, when the First Minister was first asked about the matter, he had not dismissed out of hand the fact that he was going to make a call to James Hunt. Secondly, my question was about what assessments the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise had made, not about what James Murdoch told the First Minister or anyone else that the deal would mean.
The fact is that the First Minister did not make the case on jobs. At the Leveson inquiry, Robert Jay QC put forward a compelling case that the First Minister appeared to be lobbying on Rupert Murdoch’s behalf in return for the support of The Sun. The First Minister admitted that he was prepared to lobby—in secret, bizarrely—for Murdoch because a takeover would have been good for Scottish jobs. How many jobs did the Murdochs tell him would be created in Scotland if they had taken over BSkyB—or did they threaten to pull jobs out if he did not back the bid?
The fact is that the First Minister did not make the case on jobs. At the Leveson inquiry, Robert Jay QC put forward a compelling case that the First Minister appeared to be lobbying on Rupert Murdoch’s behalf in return for the support of The Sun. The First Minister admitted that he was prepared to lobby—in secret, bizarrely—for Murdoch because a takeover would have been good for Scottish jobs. How many jobs did the Murdochs tell him would be created in Scotland if they had taken over BSkyB—or did they threaten to pull jobs out if he did not back the bid?
James Hunt was an English racing driver. James Murdoch was chairman of BSkyB. James Murdoch is the one who, under oath at the Leveson inquiry, made the commitment and the argument that the digital television platform would have led to an increase in jobs in Scotland.
BSkyB has credibility in Scotland because it has more than 6,000 direct jobs in Scotland—36 per cent of its entire global workforce. Incidentally, the success of HEROtsc—and of Scottish Enterprise and Scottish Development International in working with it—in winning one of the two outsourcing contracts is not a particularly strong suit for Johann Lamont, given that when she discussed it in April she was totally unaware of its importance, despite the fact that it led to the opening of a new centre in Glasgow.
The people who are aware of the importance of those jobs are the people in Livingston, Dunfermline, Uddingston and Glasgow. They are glad that they have a Government that fights for jobs in Scotland.
BSkyB has credibility in Scotland because it has more than 6,000 direct jobs in Scotland—36 per cent of its entire global workforce. Incidentally, the success of HEROtsc—and of Scottish Enterprise and Scottish Development International in working with it—in winning one of the two outsourcing contracts is not a particularly strong suit for Johann Lamont, given that when she discussed it in April she was totally unaware of its importance, despite the fact that it led to the opening of a new centre in Glasgow.
The people who are aware of the importance of those jobs are the people in Livingston, Dunfermline, Uddingston and Glasgow. They are glad that they have a Government that fights for jobs in Scotland.
Everybody knows that those jobs have nothing to do with the BSkyB takeover. If the First Minister believed that, he might have shared the information that it was about those jobs rather than being prepared to make secret phone calls on behalf of Murdoch.
The First Minister tells us of the importance of BSkyB to Scottish jobs, and he is right. [Interruption.] Indeed, that is a novelty, but he is right. BSkyB was a major employer in Scotland before the bid and it remains a major employer after the withdrawal of the bid—so what was the benefit to Scotland of the Murdochs taking over BSkyB?
The First Minister tells us of the importance of BSkyB to Scottish jobs, and he is right. [Interruption.] Indeed, that is a novelty, but he is right. BSkyB was a major employer in Scotland before the bid and it remains a major employer after the withdrawal of the bid—so what was the benefit to Scotland of the Murdochs taking over BSkyB?
To quote James Murdoch’s evidence again,
“that meant ... quite a lot of operations and an increase in operations in Scotland, where technical support, IT, service centres ... were located for British Sky Broadcasting”.
When the chairman of a company that employs more than 6,000 people in direct jobs in Scotland says that the digital television platform would lead to an increase in its operations and more jobs in Scotland—and when he announces another 150 jobs in March and in May—he has a great deal more credibility than Johann Lamont, a Glasgow MSP who was not even aware of the huge threat to jobs in Glasgow.
What ultimately reveals Labour’s difficulty in this is that, when Johann Lamont was asked on Radio Scotland whether she would meet Rupert Murdoch because he was an important investor in Scotland, her answer—after a bit of hesitation—was that yes, she would meet him. That makes Johann Lamont the only Labour Party figure who wanted to meet either James or Rupert Murdoch to talk about jobs—the rest of them were apparently talking about many other things.
“that meant ... quite a lot of operations and an increase in operations in Scotland, where technical support, IT, service centres ... were located for British Sky Broadcasting”.
When the chairman of a company that employs more than 6,000 people in direct jobs in Scotland says that the digital television platform would lead to an increase in its operations and more jobs in Scotland—and when he announces another 150 jobs in March and in May—he has a great deal more credibility than Johann Lamont, a Glasgow MSP who was not even aware of the huge threat to jobs in Glasgow.
What ultimately reveals Labour’s difficulty in this is that, when Johann Lamont was asked on Radio Scotland whether she would meet Rupert Murdoch because he was an important investor in Scotland, her answer—after a bit of hesitation—was that yes, she would meet him. That makes Johann Lamont the only Labour Party figure who wanted to meet either James or Rupert Murdoch to talk about jobs—the rest of them were apparently talking about many other things.
The difference between me and the First Minister is that if I met Rupert Murdoch, I would ask him how many jobs the deal brought with it. The First Minister seems to have taken him entirely at his word. The First Minister did not ask Scottish Government officials or Scottish Enterprise to assess things. Apparently, if Mr Murdoch says it, it must be true—meaningless assertion after meaningless assertion.
If the Murdoch bid would have created jobs in Scotland, why did the First Minister not ask Scottish Enterprise to assess the plan? What did the civil servants say about the bid and when did his Cabinet sign off the Government support for the deal? Why has he not answered the more than 40 questions that we have put to him about his dealings with Murdoch? As Robert Jay QC said yesterday,
“at the very least, there was a perception of cosiness”
between the First Minister and Rupert Murdoch. Nothing the First Minister has said changes that fact. Is it not true that Alex Salmond became Rupert Murdoch’s lackey not to create Scottish jobs but in an attempt to keep his own?
If the Murdoch bid would have created jobs in Scotland, why did the First Minister not ask Scottish Enterprise to assess the plan? What did the civil servants say about the bid and when did his Cabinet sign off the Government support for the deal? Why has he not answered the more than 40 questions that we have put to him about his dealings with Murdoch? As Robert Jay QC said yesterday,
“at the very least, there was a perception of cosiness”
between the First Minister and Rupert Murdoch. Nothing the First Minister has said changes that fact. Is it not true that Alex Salmond became Rupert Murdoch’s lackey not to create Scottish jobs but in an attempt to keep his own?
I have told Johann Lamont what James Murdoch said under oath at the Leveson inquiry, which speaks for itself. I have told her about the increase in jobs in Livingston, of which she seemed totally unaware. I have told her about the saving of 2,000 jobs through the intervention and excellence of HEROtsc, of which she was totally unaware in April. The Labour Party has been blissfully unaware of all those things.
I pointed out that I have had five meetings with Rupert Murdoch in the past five years. I also pointed out to the Leveson inquiry that that is not in the same league as the Labour Party of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. In fact, over Gordon Brown’s brief period as prime minister, he managed some 17 meetings with Rupert Murdoch.
In case it is said that that was all in the past, in the bad old days of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, I remind Johann Lamont as gently as I can of the words of Ed Miliband in The Sun on 22 April 2011. He said:
“Red Ed has died a death.”
He explained for The Sun’s readers, who were his main concern, that he was going to develop a new set of policies. He told the readership of The Sun that, even before the new policies would be known by Johann Lamont or any other MSP,
“You will read it first in The Sun.”
That strikes me as a pretty cosy relationship.
I pointed out that I have had five meetings with Rupert Murdoch in the past five years. I also pointed out to the Leveson inquiry that that is not in the same league as the Labour Party of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. In fact, over Gordon Brown’s brief period as prime minister, he managed some 17 meetings with Rupert Murdoch.
In case it is said that that was all in the past, in the bad old days of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, I remind Johann Lamont as gently as I can of the words of Ed Miliband in The Sun on 22 April 2011. He said:
“Red Ed has died a death.”
He explained for The Sun’s readers, who were his main concern, that he was going to develop a new set of policies. He told the readership of The Sun that, even before the new policies would be known by Johann Lamont or any other MSP,
“You will read it first in The Sun.”
That strikes me as a pretty cosy relationship.
The First Minister has the cheek to accuse me—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order!
He has the cheek to accuse me of using a script, when he has prepared abuse that has nothing to do with the question that I asked him. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order! We will hear the member.
The First Minister has to confront the contradictions between the fact that, on 11 February 2011, Fred Michel said that the First Minister
“will call Hunt whenever we need him to”
and the fact that, according to written evidence to the Leveson inquiry, the Scottish Government had not expressed a view in early 2011 on the takeover. The First Minister must explain why he supported a takeover when it was self-evidently not about jobs. Everybody knows that it was not about jobs, so he needs to answer the question.
“will call Hunt whenever we need him to”
and the fact that, according to written evidence to the Leveson inquiry, the Scottish Government had not expressed a view in early 2011 on the takeover. The First Minister must explain why he supported a takeover when it was self-evidently not about jobs. Everybody knows that it was not about jobs, so he needs to answer the question.
I thought that I explained this at some length at the Leveson inquiry yesterday. I am afraid that Johann Lamont’s interpretation of that does not meet the general interpretation of what was said. Let me see whether she can understand the key point. The responsibility of this Government is not competition policy—that lies with Westminster. Nor is it plurality in the press—that, too, lies with Westminster. The statutory responsibility of this Government is jobs and investment for Scotland. I assure Johann Lamont that that is the priority of this Government and that it is what we fight for every day of every week. If the Labour Party does not like that, that is fine, because this is a contest between two parties, one of which cares about jobs and the second of which cares about whatever Labour cares about. Certainly, the Scottish people care about jobs, jobs, jobs.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 14 Jun 2012 →- Women’s Representation (Public Sector Boards) Debate · 69
- PIP Silicone Breast Implants Debate · 29
- Factoring (Buildings in Mixed Tenure) Questions · 7
- NHS Boards (Targets) Questions · 4
- Sheriffhall Roundabout Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games (Benefits to North-east) Questions · 4
- Scottish Government (Off-payroll Employees) Questions · 4
- Ferry Routes (Tendering Process) Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust (Hubs) Questions · 8
- Renewable Energy Investment Fund Questions · 9
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Suicide Rate First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Modern Apprentice Programme (New Jobs) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher English Curriculum First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Rural Affairs and the Environment Questions · 1
- Proposed Water Framework and Industrial Emissions Directives Questions · 8
- Common Agricultural Policy Questions · 11
- Water Pollution Questions · 7
- Public Bodies Climate Change Duty Questions · 8
- Waste Reduction and Recycling (Promotion) Questions · 6
- Canals (Environmental Improvements) Questions · 4
- Seafield Waste Water Treatment Works Questions · 4
- Water Framework Directive Questions · 4
- Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary Questions · 4
- Scottish Court Service (Review) Questions · 5
- Knife Crime (Education Campaign) Questions · 6
- Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (Legal Trainees) Questions · 9
- Antisocial Behaviour Questions · 4
- Fiscal Fines Questions · 6
- Police Officers Questions · 6
- Common Fisheries Policy Statement · 30
- Youth Employment Debate · 100
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 19
- Ardroy Outdoor Education Centre Members’ business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.