Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 1 November 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 17 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

In welcoming the First Minister back to his place, I ask him what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00932)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I have written to the Government and the President of the United States, expressing the sympathy and solidarity of Scotland in relation to the extraordinary weather conditions that have engulfed the eastern seaboard.

Later today, I will have meetings to take forward this Government’s programmes for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

I am sure that in that letter, our sensibilities and sympathies go, too, to the people of America in these difficult times.

Last week, the Deputy First Minister’s spokesman said that there was a “cast-iron position” that an independent Scotland would retain the pound. I congratulate the First Minister on gaining such unequivocal agreement. When was the agreement with the Treasury and the Bank of England reached? When and where was it signed? When did negotiations start?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I am sure that even Johann Lamont has heard that the Secretary of State for Scotland pointed out that there was no legal bar to Scotland having sterling as its currency. The proposition that we put forward for a sterling zone is an extremely reasonable one. I am not certain what the Labour Party’s position is on what the currency of an independent Scotland should be, but we think that it suits the interests of Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom to have a sterling zone.

In terms of Scotland’s interest, there is an argument for continuity of the sterling position. In terms of both countries’ interests, it is what would be called an optimal currency area in terms of the productivity of both countries—[Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

It is not my description; it is the description of the Institute for Fiscal Studies. [The First Minister has corrected this contribution. See end of report.]

Lastly, on the question of why it would be in the interests of the rest of the UK, revenues from Scotland’s resources would of course come to Scotland, but it would also afford some £40 billion protection to the balance of payments of the sterling zone. I think that the rest of the UK would be biting our hands off for Scotland to retain sterling membership.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

In the First Minister’s own words, that was a very, very convincing response

“in terms of the debate”.

There is not a legal bar to a lot of things, but that is a different point altogether from a cast-iron guarantee. Hope, expectation and, “It would all be great if they could just agree with it,” are not the same as a cast-iron guarantee. Surely even the First Minister understands that.

Let me recap. According to the First Minister, we will be in the European Union, without having to apply, and we know that without asking any other member state or asking anyone for legal advice; we know that we will not have to have the euro, and we do not need to ask about that either; and we know that we will keep the pound, and we do not need to ask anyone about that either.

I ask the First Minister: without looking at the long-range forecast, what will the weather be like in an independent Scotland? [Laughter.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

In the interests of a serious debate on the issue, if Johann Lamont managed to cast her eye over the evidence of Graham Avery to the House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee, she will recall that Graham Avery is a senior member of St Antony’s College, University of Oxford, a senior adviser to the European Policy Centre and an honorary director general of the European Commission. He points out that

“Scotland’s 5 million people, having been members of the EU for 40 years; have acquired rights as European citizens ... For practical and political reasons they could not be asked to leave the EU and apply for readmission”.

I know that this is very inconvenient for the political weather that is facing the Labour Party, but it does rather put the lie to the scaremongering campaign of Labour and its unionist colleagues in the Conservative Party.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

In the interests of a serious debate, the First Minister ought to stop finding someone that he alleges agrees with him and quoting them in this place. There are many different positions on the matter, including that of the First Minister’s back bencher John Mason, who said on Tuesday that

“all these things are subject to negotiation”—[Official Report, 30 October 2012; c 12703.]

and they are not definite.

The charge at the First Minister’s door is that he asserts things for which he has no evidence.

It is about time that the First Minister got serious about the future of Scotland. The First Minister thinks that he can treat the people of Scotland like fools and that we will believe everything that he says when, after last week, no one trusts a word that he says.

I understand why the First Minister did not turn up to Tuesday’s debate to defend his reputation. It was because even he knows that he no longer has a reputation to defend.

What is it that the First Minister is so scared of that he cannot ask the Bank of England about the pound and cannot ask other EU members about Europe? Is it just that he cannot face the truth when he is presented with it?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

On the question of sterling, I ask Johann Lamont to remember that we have set up a fiscal commission with two Nobel laureates in economics to pursue that matter. That seems to me to be a pretty serious contribution to the debate.

I have read out Graham Avery’s credentials. Given that he is an honorary director general of the European Commission, I suspect that he knows rather more about these issues than even Johann Lamont does.

On the issue of trust and the serious debate that Johann Lamont thinks that she wants to argue for, I point out that these matters have been tested not only in the Scottish elections last year but in the social attitudes survey, which tests the trust in the Scottish Government against the trust in the United Kingdom Government—that is running at 64 per cent compared with 24 per cent.

Of course, there is also the question that YouGov asked last week, which concerned who people trusted to stand up for Scotland. Johann Lamont’s figure was 6 per cent. Therefore, on behalf of the other 94 per cent of the people of Scotland, I say that the reason why people do not trust the Labour Party in Scotland is that it stood on manifesto commitments to defend the freeze on council tax, to defend free tuition and to defend free prescriptions and a free health service, yet Johann Lamont is in the middle of tearing up every single one of those commitments. Labour is the first political party to betray its commitments when it is in opposition—an extraordinary achievement.

If the Labour Party wants to regain the trust of the people, why not have that debate on the issues that face this country, and why not acknowledge that oil-rich, gas-rich, energy-rich and fishing-rich Scotland will be welcomed with open arms in the European Union?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

In the debate about Scotland’s future, I stand with Campbell Christie in saying that, in tough times, we should look at competing good demands and ensure that those of us with the broadest shoulders are the ones who take the heaviest burden.

The First Minister says that he is setting up his fiscal group. However, surely it would have been an idea to pursue the matter of whether we are going to have the pound with the Bank of England and the Treasury. They are the people who will decide that matter.

Of course, the First Minister has long sought international profile and, my goodness, he has got it.

The Washington Post, the newspaper that exposed—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Members may have read it.

The Washington Post, the newspaper that exposed Richard Nixon’s corruption, knows a chancer when it sees one—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

It has made a serious charge. The Washington Post said—[Interruption.] I am sure that Scottish National Party members have read this quote; I would like to share it with others. The Washington Post said:

“Mr. Salmond’s cheerful assurances that Scotland could quickly join the European Union while retaining the British pound as its currency remain to be tested; London would have a veto over both. EU states might demand that Scotland commit to the wobbly Euro; if the pound were split between two nations, it could become subject to the same troubles that have afflicted the European currency.”

These are serious matters being addressed by serious people. If The Washington Post can see that from Washington, why can the First Minister not see it from here?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Those who have read the editorial of The Washington Post will realise that it made almost as many mistakes on points of fact as Johann Lamont did in the week.

I welcome the contribution of newspapers in the United States of America to the Scottish political debate—The Washington Post is not alone. The Los Angeles Times of 22 October stated:

“Arguably the most important difference would be that an independent Scotland would be master of its own economy and natural resources.”

I very much agree with that. This quote from The Wall Street Journal is particularly apposite for Johann Lamont:

“All too often this debate rarely gets past the sneering view that Scotland would be too poor ... or too small to stand on its own two feet outside the U.K. But the claim that ... Scotland is a subsidy junkie has already been proved a myth. New accounts of revenue and expenditure from Treasury data show Scotland regularly gives more than it receives from U.K. coffers.”

If that is known and understood by The Wall Street Journal, why has that news not reached the Labour Party in Scotland?

I am fascinated by Johann Lamont’s approach to this serious political debate at this point in her leadership. I came across an interview that she did with The Guardian just a year ago in which she talked about her great frustration. She said:

“What I’m more frustrated by is the politics where you play the man not the politics”.

After a few weeks in which Johann Lamont has managed to call me stupid, Wee Eck, a sucker, devious and a corkscrew, given what she said in that interview it is no wonder that nobody believes a word that she says. [Applause.]

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Prisons (Drug Use) Questions · 6
  2. Higher Education (Computer Science and Software Engineering) Questions · 4
  3. Portobello High School Questions · 4
  4. Schools (Science) Questions · 8
  5. Edinburgh to Tweedbank Railway Project Questions · 6
  6. National Health Service Estate (Energy Efficiency) Questions · 4
  7. Further Education (Community Business Set-up and Management) Questions · 4
  8. Sewerage Network (Persistent Flooding) Questions · 5
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  12. Trident Replacment (Economic Benefits) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. National Health Service (Financial Pressures) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Equal Pay First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Organ Donation (Presumed Consent) Members’ business · 26
  16. Drink-driving Debate · 121
  17. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  18. Decision Time Decision time · 13
  19. Correction Procedure · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.