Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 17 May 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00671)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Today, Bruce Crawford, the Cabinet Secretary for Parliamentary Business and Government Strategy, is meeting Jens Stoltenberg, the Norwegian Prime Minister, to welcome him to Shetland on Norway’s national day, and to discuss plans for a deepwater quay decommissioning facility in the Shetland Islands.

I am delighted to announce to the chamber that, following discussions that I had in Oslo on Tuesday, the Scottish Government and Highlands and Islands Enterprise will together make available £10 million to support a hugely ambitious project for the northern islands.

I know that the whole chamber will wish to welcome the exciting partnership between the Norwegian company ÅF Group and Lerwick Port Authority, which looks forward to securing decommissioning work on major offshore structures in the North Sea. The project could create up to 150 jobs in the Shetland Islands and Aberdeen, and deliver a scale of industrial capacity unmatched across these islands.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The Parliament debated the national parenting strategy this week. There was unanimous agreement that there had to be more support for struggling parents. That support is important because we know that some parents do not get it right, that the child is not always the priority, and that that can have tragic consequences.

Following the Declan Hainey case, the First Minister and I had constructive talks about child protection. Will the First Minister update the chamber on what progress has been made in that area?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I agree that we had constructive talks on that tragic case. As we discussed in the meeting, the Government will move forward through the children and young people’s bill that is to be introduced. We will explore options on a range of areas to improve the situation so that we can get it right for every child.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We welcome progress. We urge the First Minister to recognise how serious the issue is and how quickly we need to move on it, given that we now know that in March 2010, just two weeks before Declan Hainey was found dead, Renfrewshire Council received a report from another case review. The case was known as family 10. It is worrying that the review highlighted systemic failures in child protection. In that case, children were mistreated to a deeply distressing degree. The family 10 review was too late to save Declan. Two serious case reviews in Renfrewshire have found systemic failure, yet no one has been held to account. Does the First Minister believe that, after one death and two findings of systemic failure, Renfrewshire Council was best placed to investigate itself?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont should accept that the reviews that have taken place have certainly identified failings in provision. As have other investigations in the past, those reviews inform our intent to improve and enhance child protection across Scotland. These are vital matters and I am certain that if we show good will on all sides we can take them forward together as a united Parliament. We have both a legislative framework and a forum for ensuring that we improve not just our current inspection services, but our monitoring services. I think that, on that basis, the Parliament will do itself great credit by taking things forward in that manner on behalf of Scotland’s children.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Hoping for it does not make it happen. This is a really serious issue and here is the real point: in 2009 the First Minister told members in the chamber that we had the best child protection inspection system

“anywhere in these islands and perhaps anywhere in Europe.”—[Official Report, 25 June 2009; c 18904.]

Indeed, before the case of family 10 and before the death of Declan Hainey, the First Minister said in the chamber that his inspection system had found Renfrewshire Council to be one of the top five councils in Scotland. A few months after Declan Hainey was found dead, the inspectors went back to Renfrewshire Council to follow up on their first visit. This time, they concluded that Renfrewshire Council’s efforts to keep children safe were excellent. They reported:

“As a result of the very good quality of provision to protect children and meet their needs, we will make no further visits in connection with this inspection.”

In the case of family 10 there were systemic failures. In the case of Declan Hainey there were fatal systemic failures. Yet, before and after those failures, the First Minister’s inspectors provided two positive reports, the second of which claimed that the protection of children was excellent.

In light of the contrast between the First Minister’s rhetoric about child protection and the reality, does the First Minister still believe that his inspection regime is the best in Europe?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Three times in that question, Johann Lamont referred to my inspection regime and my inspectors, but those people undertake vital work on behalf of the Parliament and the country. There is no doubt that the process of inspection and re-inspection has resulted in an improvement in child protection throughout Scotland. There is also no doubt that that systematic process, which I believed was supported across the chamber, has resulted in substantial improvements. As Johann Lamont must know,

“no place in the world can give a 100 per cent guarantee on the safety of all its children.”

Tam Baillie, the Scottish Commissioner for Children and Young People, said that in January.

There are always—and should be—lessons to learn from such tragic cases. The SNP Administration and, I hope, the Parliament are perfectly prepared to learn them and are capable of doing so. If we act together, in not just legislative but administrative terms, we can further improve the situation for and protection of Scotland’s children. We can do that on the basis that it is something that all politicians of all political persuasions want to do, and as a national Parliament we can take national action on child protection.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The people who are carrying out the inspections are doing an important job, but they are accountable and the First Minister is responsible for the capacity of the system to deliver. The First Minister’s approach seems to be a counsel of despair. Although we cannot provide 100 per cent protection, we must do everything that we can to understand where the failures are in order to ensure that they do not happen again. Can he explain why the best child protection inspection system in Europe has failed to find the systemic failures that led to the maltreatment of children by a family and a baby’s death? Can he explain why, after those tragedies caused by systemic failures, the best child protection inspection system in Europe still says that the child protection service is excellent?

The family 10 inspection was being carried out at exactly the same time as the significant review of the Declan Hainey case was saying that there were at least 16 actions that needed to be taken. In the light of those failures, will the First Minister please order a full independent public inquiry into child protection, not just in Renfrewshire but throughout Scotland, so that the public can be confident that our systems are protecting our most vulnerable children?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Let us see whether we can identify areas of agreement. Child protection measures require constant vigilance, therefore the Parliament should support our partners on the ground across Scotland to ensure that there is continual improvement. We have updated “Getting Our Priorities Right”, the good practice guidance for professionals who work with children where substance misuse is a factor. We are also piloting the risk assessment toolkit, which will help with the protection of vulnerable children throughout Scotland. The development of a multi-agency learning and development framework is crucial because, in a number of tragic cases, it has been clear that the contact between the various responsible agencies has not been as good as it could have been. The revision of the child protection guidance for Scottish health professionals—the pink book—is also moving forward, and we will introduce a children’s services bill that will ensure that all children’s services have a stronger focus on early years prevention and early intervention. Those are the actions of the Administration.

The Parliament, which is not in the slightest complacent about the tragedies that have occurred, should know two things. First, the responsibility for wrongdoing and for the most tragic cases lies with the perpetrator. The idea that individual social workers, although accountable, are responsible for the actions of others is not the way that Scotland should look at these matters. We should support our social workers and social work departments to give the best possible protection to Scotland’s children.

The second thing, which I hope will carry the entire Parliament, is that the actions that have been identified, both administrative and legislative, show no sign of complacency on the issue, but reflect an understanding that constant vigilance and continuous improvement are absolutely necessary. As we bring forward the measures, as a Government and as a Parliament, I hope that members throughout the chamber will rise to the occasion on behalf of Scotland’s children.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Civilian Police Staff Debate · 68
  2. Waiting Times Debate · 63
  3. Education (Finland) Questions · 4
  4. New Farming Entrants Questions · 6
  5. Supply Teachers Questions · 6
  6. Housing Options Hubs Questions · 4
  7. Public Facilities (Transport Links) Questions · 6
  8. UBC Group (Administration) Questions · 4
  9. Scottish Water (Consultation) Questions · 4
  10. Air Passenger Duty Questions · 4
  11. Early Years Change Fund (Childcare) Questions · 5
  12. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  14. Fostering Disabled Children First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Alcohol Minimum Pricing (Effects) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. Care Home Patients (Prescription Drugs) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Scottish Government (Public Relations Services) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  18. Alcohol Abuse (Armed Forces) Members’ business · 8
  19. Carers (Mental Health) Questions · 7
  20. Health Waiting Times (NHS Grampian) Questions · 4
  21. Clostridium Difficile (Raigmore Hospital) Questions · 6
  22. New-build Community Health Facilities Questions · 4
  23. National Health Service (National Planning Forum) Questions · 6
  24. Waiting Times (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) Questions · 4
  25. Obesity (Schoolchildren) Questions · 9
  26. Ambulance Cover (Shetland Islands) Questions · 3
  27. Lung Cancer (Early Symptoms) Questions · 8
  28. Day-case Targets (NHS Tayside) Questions · 4
  29. Health and Social Care Integration Questions · 8
  30. National Health Service Dentists (Orkney) Questions · 4
  31. General Practitioners (Remote and Rural Areas) Questions · 4
  32. Selective Dorsal Rhizotomy Questions · 4
  33. Commonwealth Games 2014 (Edinburgh) Questions · 5
  34. Air Ambulance Helicopters (Faults) Questions · 4
  35. Physical Activity Debate · 48
  36. Member’s Statement Debate · 3
  37. Decision Time Decision time · 20
  38. James Graham, Marquis of Montrose Members’ business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.