PE1425, by Maureen Harkness, is on the adverse impact of Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency local office closures. We have submissions and a note by the clerk. We took evidence from Maureen Harkness. Just for the record, I note that she and some of her colleagues met me in my constituency office to talk about the impact of the Inverness office closure, which I am clearly concerned about, as other members will be about the office closures in their areas. I ask members for comments.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
DVLA Local Office Closures (PE1425)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 9
- John Wilson SNP 5
- Mark McDonald SNP 2
- Jackson Carlaw Con 2
- Sandra White SNP 1
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
The record
21 contributionsThis is an important petition that touches on a subject that will affect all our constituencies and many people around Scotland. The evidence session brought out to me that, rather than the issue being only about job losses and office closures, it is about a form of criminality. We had not thought about that.I want the petition to be kept open and I support the recommendation at paragraph 17(1) of the clerk’s note, which is that we“write to the Scottish Government seeking an update on the discussions it intended to have with the DVLA and UK DfT”—I know that those discussions have taken place—“regarding the decision, consultation results, impact assessments and crime issues, with particular reference to the local offices in Scotland.”The issue affects many constituents and many people’s jobs, so it is important that we get as much evidence as possible.
I agree. Another vital aspect is the concept of spreading public sector jobs around Scotland. Successive Scottish Governments have looked at that important issue and we should ensure that the UK Government does not forget how important public sector jobs are to the Scottish economy and avoids the centralisation of jobs.
I would go further, and suggest that we write back to the Department for Transport and the responsible minister, be that Mike Penning or somebody else—after the coalition reshuffle, who knows?—to ask for a firm timetable for decision making because Mike Penning’s letter states only that the consultation results are being analysed and that“No decisions have yet been taken and a further announcement will be made”.There is no reference to a timeline, so we should write back to ask when it is expected that a decision will be taken. We should also keep open the option of inviting a UK Government minister to come to the committee. The issue is extremely important for many Scottish communities—including for the convener’s area, given that we received evidence about the impact in the Highlands and Islands—and warrants inviting the UK Government to come and give evidence.
I declare an interest in that I was in the motor industry for 25 years. I disagree with the fundamental aspect of the petition. I found DVLA offices positively obstructive and unhelpful in processing many individual constituents’ licensing requirements. The new arrangements will be far superior. For people who do not live in Aberdeen, Dundee, Edinburgh, Glasgow or Inverness, there is nothing local about the facilities whatsoever. I am not particularly sure why, in an age when applications can be progressed online and much more efficiently, as is proposed, the people living in those areas should have a superior service—if that is how they see it—over those who live elsewhere in Scotland. When I was in the motor industry, I did not find the existence of DVLA offices to be helpful. We were actively looking for an alternative way in which we could speedily progress the licensing and other requirements relating to vehicles on behalf of customers and those people who were seeking to reregister vehicles. I have considerable difficulty in being sympathetic to the petition.
As usual, I disagree with Jackson Carlaw’s interpretation of what we are trying to achieve. Although in his previous life he may have found difficulties with local DVLA offices, there is clearly a move by the UK Government to turn the DVLA into an electronic format. As well as the issue of the five access points, we have figures that show that anything between 30 to 40 per cent of the Scottish population does not have access to the internet. If everything is to be done electronically, the difficulty is how those without access to the internet or a computer do that. For many people, it is about going along to their local DVLA office. However inconvenient that may be, for some people that is a better option.I take issue with the penultimate paragraph of the minister’s response, which states:“The equality impact assessment and cost-benefit analysis were not published as part of the consultation because of its high level nature.”The equality impact assessment and cost-benefit analysis are crucial to identifying whether individuals might be affected by the issues that I have raised regarding internet and broadband access and access to computers. As we all know, people without access to those facilities are extremely restricted. If anyone attempts to find that phone number for the DVLA, they will have great difficulty doing so and, when they do so, they will find it even more difficult to get a response when they call it up. We need to ensure that everyone has access to those services, no matter how onerous that might be to the present UK Government. There are crucial issues for people seeking the services of the DVLA, as people can face harsh penalties if they do not comply with the current legislation because they do not have access to the information or to the internet in order to make the appropriate registrations and applications to ensure that they are legal.
Members have seen the various dates for closure in the committee papers. The updated information that we have is that the DVLA will centralise enforcement operations by March 2013 and close 39 offices by the end of 2013.
My major concern is that Glasgow will lose 67 jobs. Although I appreciate Jackson Carlaw’s experience of visiting the DVLA offices, we have to take on board the fact that more than 30 per cent of people do not have access to computing systems and that it is sometimes better to go and get some advice from the office itself. I would be concerned if we were simply to close the petition.
I could not help but hear Jackson Carlaw say, “Go to the post office,” when Anne McTaggart was speaking. If post offices in communities the length and breadth of Scotland were not being closed, that might indeed be an option for people.
That was going to be my point, too.I have some sympathy with Mark McDonald’s suggestion that we ask the relevant UK Government minister to appear before us. I think that the proposal is a serious threat to the service in Scotland and we must address that.Following on from Mark McDonald’s point, I think that if Governments—particularly the previous Government, under the urban intervention scheme—had not closed so many post offices, the proposal would have less of an impact, but it is still a serious issue that we must address.
If my memory serves me correctly, I was not here on 30 March when the committee heard evidence on the petition, so I do not know whether the committee discussed the fact that the UK Government is reviewing the issuing of road tax applications from some post offices and is talking about restricting that further. When we write to the UK Government minister, could we ask that they consider extending a wide range of DVLA services to local post offices—particularly sub-post offices—if they are concerned about ensuring that services are being delivered at a local level?
That is a useful point. Members will be aware that not all post offices currently have the full range of services. Normally, what were called Crown post offices had that right, which means that the local village post office probably never had the right to deal with road tax. However, that is not in any sense to argue for the closure; I am merely making the point that greater diversification of services in post offices is important.I believe that the previous UK Government had a pilot e-commerce scheme for post offices. It is important that we increase the range of services that post offices can provide, so that they can survive. Unfortunately, many rural post offices in my area have very low turnover. It is important to get footfall through post offices so that they can survive.10:30
I do not wish to extend the debate, but I make the point that, even though not all post offices can provide the service, more than five of them can do so, which is the number of DVLA facilities that we are talking about. We should not simply state that, because DVLA branches existed throughout the United Kingdom to meet a need at a particular time, they should be retained in perpetuity if things move on. Given my experience and that of customers and people whom I know who have reregistered vehicles, if there was a modern way of doing that, whether it be online or at a local post office—which we want to support—that would seem to me to be a perfectly sensible way forward.Therefore, I am happy with the measure. It would be useful to get the minister to confirm how many post offices in Scotland can provide the service and where they are. In the event that the closures proceed, we should have a published list of post offices where vehicles can be registered or reregistered and advice can be obtained. That would be useful public information, irrespective of the ultimate outcome of the Government’s policy.
I am sure that the committee would agree with Jackson Carlaw’s final point. It is certainly important to get an understanding of what our post offices do.
I seek clarification, convener. At the previous meeting, did the committee agree to write to the Scottish Motor Trade Association on the issue?
My understanding is that we did not.
I suggest that we write to that association to ask for its views on the issue. Although Mr Carlaw makes the point that visiting a local DVLA office was not helpful and he feels that the UK Government’s planned move to an electronic system might be beneficial, it would be useful to find out the views of the Scottish Motor Trade Association. In particular, we should ask whether the transfer of ownership when cars are bought is being done at the speed that the motor trade would like. It can take up to a couple of weeks just to get a new road tax disc issued by the DVLA. The change of ownership of motor vehicles sometimes has to be done quickly, particularly given the turnover in the motor trade. I would appreciate it if we wrote to the SMTA to ask for its views on the issues for its members.
Are members happy with that approach?Members indicated agreement.
It is clear that we do not have a complete consensus on the way forward. I am conscious that it is not necessarily fair for members who have not had the benefit of hearing the evidence to consider the next steps but, in time, all of us will see all the evidence as the petition moves through the system. It appears that we have a consensus on action point 1, which is that we write to the Scottish Government, and on the suggestion that we invite the relevant UK minister to attend. We can also take up Jackson Carlaw’s point by asking for an audit of post offices in Scotland and of what they can and cannot do. In effect, we want a breakdown of key post offices that carry out DVLA functions. We will also write to the Scottish Motor Trade Association, as John Wilson suggested.
When we write to the UK Government, could we ask for a copy of an executive summary of the equality impact assessment and cost benefit analysis?
Yes, that is a good point.Are members happy with that approach?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Sep 2012 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 New Petition Petitions · 6
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 21
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.