link
I reconvene the committee. I apologise to the committee for starting almost three minutes later than I said we would.Agenda item 3 is to receive a report back from members on the employability workshops that took place on Friday. As part of its examination of the need to improve the employability of those furthest from the labour market, the committee held one-day workshops in Ardrossan, Dundee and Dumfries, involving more than 45 organisations from the public, private and third sectors as well as individuals, to hear about people’s job-seeking experiences. We will now have a discussion on what happened. We will try to keep this reasonably brief, but I do not want to restrict people if they want to make any comments.Let me kick off with the workshop in Ardrossan, which I attended with Michael McMahon. I will talk to a couple of points, but I will not go through the excellent notes that Jim Johnston and Ross Burnside prepared for the meeting, which will all be appended to our report so that people can look at them in depth and things are not missed out. Michael McMahon can follow on from my comments with any salient points that he wishes to make.An interesting point in the Ardrossan workshop was that there seems to be a disconnect between the perceptions in some of the different groups. For example, in the first session the local employability partnership representatives talked about providing employers with the individuals and skills that they need. They talked about partnership working and the complex employability landscape, but they also conceded that there is an issue about competing with each other for funding to reach targets. They talked about how big public sector employers are doing a lot less on the employability issue than the private sector is, and they also talked about the need for co-location—providing employability services in a shared space or physical close proximity—and the importance of schools and local flexibility.11:45
That view was contradicted by the local business sector, which seemed to feel that it did not have much engagement at all with employability agencies. Businesses said that they got what they referred to as aggressive phone calls from various different organisations and agencies asking whether they would take someone on and offering financial inducements to do so.The problem is that those inducements do not seem to be particularly important to employers relative to the need to have the right person sent to them. A lot of employers were concerned that someone would just be sent to them regardless of that individual’s particular interests, aptitudes or skills. In the hotel and catering sector, for example, there was a deep sense of frustration that there appears to be no acknowledgement of different types of employers, and that businesses are simply sent someone just so that targets can be met.It seems that there is not enough focus on asking employers what they need. There was talk among employers of building attitudes to work, and of the desire to do that as early as primary school, particularly in areas where there are second and third generations of unemployed people.Businesses did not believe that the education system is fit for purpose in getting some school leavers ready for work. They believe that there is a real issue with the effectiveness of some placements with regard to soft skills. The Department for Work and Pensions came in for particular criticism for sending people who are not appropriate. Businesses also talked about the lack of long-term placements, and said that people are being sent to them without the basic necessary skills.Businesses’ experience of Scottish Enterprise was mixed, which somewhat contradicts some of what we heard earlier today. There was concern about the process of allocating grants, and we have heard some of those concerns today with regard to RSA grants. Some people seem to be exasperated by how difficult it is to get grants and by who gets them.There was an issue with the planning system in North Ayrshire. It seems to be easier to say no to an application than to approve it, which is apparently restricting some business developments. Businesses believe that they should get direct funding to do their own training rather than funding being allocated to agencies, where there is perhaps a mismatch with training needs.There was a real concern about the benefits system and flexibility, and businesses talked about things over which we do not have any control, such as reserved issues. For example, they said that cutting VAT on building developments would help in getting banks to lend more money.Among third sector organisations, there was a feeling that the agencies are less joined up than they have been previously, and that they need to co-design and co-produce services. The view was that work programmes are done on the cheap and that the compulsory component of the benefit system is counterproductive.There was a real issue—which was also raised later by the service users—about the need to build the confidence and self-esteem of people in the school system. The organisations believe that support for employability programmes and entrepreneurship programmes in school is crucial in giving young people the right focus.There was real concern about the focus on targets and numbers, and the view was that soft skills should be included when measuring outcomes. The problem—as those organisations perceive it—is that the DWP in particular is focused only on getting people into work, which is not very helpful as some individuals are effectively bypassed by the system as a result.With regard to tenders, not enough weight is given to the quality of schemes that need greater time and intensity rather just processing numbers. There is an issue with the sausage-machine mentality in processing some of those things.The organisations are supportive of what local authorities—and North Ayrshire in particular—are doing, but they feel that the NHS is more difficult to work with on employability. Again, they emphasised that the private sector is better than the public sector in that regard. They said that we need less short-term funding, to be less reactive and to take more of a long-term approach, which the trade unions commented on some months ago. They believe that there needs to be more accountability and transparency with regard to what the employability budget is spent on and what it can deliver. They emphasised that the priority should be a one-to-one focus—that was not exactly what the International Labour Organization said last week, but it was something that was also emphasised today.In the service users session, there was a consensus that the most effective work programmes are those that focus on positive thinking, confidence building and teamworking. However, there was concern among the participants, most of whom were older than the 18-to-24 age bracket, that because most interventions are directed towards the young, older long-term unemployed people are at a major disadvantage in employability programmes. That is a particular issue for women who have been out of the labour market, perhaps because they have been raising children.All the participants had had negative experiences with Jobcentre Plus and the Department for Work and Pensions. Problems with a lack of flexibility and unwelcoming and intimidating environments were mentioned, as was inconsistent advice from the DWP on people’s entitlement to benefits while on training courses. If someone goes on a certain course, will they or will they not lose their benefits? That is clearly a real issue for people.There was also concern that the compulsory element means that square pegs are being put into round holes for the sake of box ticking at the DWP. There was criticism of some of the training courses that are offered, which are viewed as being mass-produced and generic. There is real concern about people not being treated as individuals.Michael, do you have anything to add?