Agenda item 2 is subordinate legislation. There is one affirmative instrument for the committee to consider: the draft Evidence in Civil Partnership and Divorce Actions (Scotland) Order 2012. The Subordinate Legislation Committee did not draw the Parliament’s attention to any concerns in its report on the draft order.I welcome to the meeting the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy—that is some title—and the two Scottish Government officials who are accompanying her: Simon Stockwell, who is head of the family and property law branch; and Felicity Cullen, who is a solicitor in the legal directorate.This is an evidence session. I invite the cabinet secretary to make a short opening statement before I invite questions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Evidence in Civil Partnership and Divorce Actions (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 7
- Christine Grahame SNP 6
- David McLetchie Con 3
- Roderick Campbell SNP 2
The record
18 contributionsThank you.The matter is quite technical. With your permission, convener, I will explain exactly what the issue behind the draft order is. The main point of the draft order is to correct an omission from the implementation of the Civil Partnership Act 2004.By way of background, when a couple wish to divorce or dissolve their civil partnership, they must apply to the court for a decree. In certain cases—for example, where there are no children or there is no dispute over finances—they can seek a court decree by means of a simplified procedure. Just over half of all divorces in Scotland are granted using that procedure.Under the Civil Evidence (Scotland) Act 1988, the court has to see evidence from a third party before it can grant a decree of divorce or dissolution. However, the 1988 act contains the power to disapply the requirement for the court to see third-party evidence.In 1989, the Lord Advocate made an order that removed that requirement in relation to divorces under the simplified procedure. When the Civil Partnership Act 2004 was being implemented in 2005, an order should have been made to remove the need for third-party evidence for the dissolution of civil partnerships under the simplified procedure, but, unfortunately, that was not done. The draft order that is before the committee makes that provision.Around 150 couples have used the simplified procedure to obtain decrees that dissolve their civil partnership without the court seeing third-party evidence. The Scottish Government’s view is that the court decrees in those cases are legally effective, but it would be possible for someone to ask a court to reduce a decree of dissolution because the court that granted it did not see evidence from a third party. I believe that the risk of challenge to a decree of dissolution on that basis and the possibility of successful challenge are low, but we recognise that the consequences of a successful challenge would be serious.We cannot do anything in secondary legislation about existing dissolutions, because we do not have the power to do that in secondary legislation. However, as the Executive note makes clear, we are committed to introduce primary legislation to prevent a challenge to any decree on the ground that the court did not see any third-party evidence. We will do that as soon as a suitable opportunity arises.Finally, the draft order makes a minor technical change to the 1989 order so that it refers to the periods of time that spouses must live apart in order for the court to grant a divorce on the basis of their non-cohabitation. The amendment to the 1989 order reflects changes that were made to divorce legislation by the Family Law (Scotland) Act 2006.I am happy to answer any questions.
Who first noticed that 150 dissolutions had been wrongly granted?
The omission to which I referred in my opening remarks was spotted by officials within the Scottish Government when they were looking at the legislation generally. It is not for me to ask supplementary questions, but I suppose that a reasonable supplementary question would be why the issue was missed in 2005. As members know, the Civil Partnership Act 2004 is a large and complex piece of legislation. It spans both reserved and devolved matters and has an impact on many different areas of law. The omission is unfortunate, but it happened in the context of the implementation of that large and complex piece of legislation.
So it was not identified by any of the sheriff clerks who normally process affidavit divorces or dissolution applications.
No. My understanding is that the omission and its implications were not brought to our attention by any outside organisation.
So it was not brought to your attention by anybody in the courts. Right. Thank you very much.
Do I take it that the primary legislation will be retrospective?
The draft order under consideration will deal with the issue for the future. The primary legislation would protect the decrees that have already been granted from challenges.
When will that legislation be in train?
We have not yet identified the appropriate vehicle in that respect. As I said in my opening remarks, we consider the risks to be very low, although any successful challenge will, of course, have serious implications. Nevertheless, we will identify an appropriate legislative vehicle at the earliest opportunity and I am happy to keep the committee apprised of what that vehicle might be and when it might be introduced.
That is very helpful.
Just for the record, does this mean that, procedurally, there will be equality between dissolutions of civil partnerships and divorces?
I am sorry—did you say “inequality”?
No, I said “equality”.
Although up until now courts have been dealing with these cases on the basis of equality, the law itself did not permit such equality. Under the simplified procedure, the position with dissolutions of civil partnerships and divorces will be the same in the sense that no third-party evidence will be required.
I note that it was all lawyers who wanted to ask questions on the draft order.The next item on the agenda is the formal debate on the draft order. I invite the cabinet secretary to speak to and move the motion.Motion moved,That the Justice Committee recommends that the Evidence in Civil Partnership and Divorce Actions (Scotland) Order 2012 draft be approved.—Nicola Sturgeon.Motion agreed to.
We will consider a report on the draft order at next week’s meeting. I thank the cabinet secretary and her officials and suspend the meeting briefly to allow a changeover of witnesses.09:51 Meeting suspended.
09:53 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Mar 2012 →- 09:45 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 18
- 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
- 09:45 Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 272
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.