Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 7 June 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00744)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will meet the aforementioned Prime Minister of Lower Saxony. It is of huge interest to Scotland that somebody with strong Scottish roots is Prime Minister of such an important German state. The discussions will be for the mutual benefit of Scotland and Lower Saxony. [Applause.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I join the First Minister in hoping that he has very constructive and useful discussions.

Last week, the First Minister advised me that I had made the mistake of not asking the right question. I think that I am going to do it again. Last Thursday, the First Minister said:

“The Bank of England is an independent central bank that does not take direction on policy”.—[Official Report, 31 May 2012; c 9629.]

Does he stand by that statement?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The Bank of England is an independent central bank that is independent of Government. That position was awarded to it by the Labour Government in 1997, when Gordon Brown was Chancellor of the Exchequer. He regarded it as one of his greatest achievements during his term in office.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister now knows that the statement that he made is not true—or perhaps the First Minister is again struggling with the definition of “independence”. The only independence that the Bank of England has is to set interest rates to meet the inflation target that is set by the United Kingdom Government. When it comes to printing money, it needs the Treasury’s approval. Indeed, the Bank of England does not have any money—it is all taxpayers’ money, through the Treasury. The First Minister’s spokesman is quoted as saying:

“The UK government has had no say over monetary policy since the Bank of England was made independent in 1997.”

He was wrong, was he not?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The Bank of England is an independent central bank. If that is not the case, what on earth was Gordon Brown boasting about in 1997 as his great démarche? Johann Lamont disagreed with the former Prime Minister on a range of things: perhaps she should consult him to see what on earth he was doing in 1997.

I welcome Johann Lamont’s continuing contribution to the debate. She will have read this morning the comments of Professor Blanchflower, one of the most prominent members of the monetary policy committee in recent years, which substantially support the very reasonable suggestions that have been made by the Scottish Government. I know that Professor Danny—[Interruption.]—David Blanchflower was quoted at length by the then Labour Government in a range of ways. Given that her party accorded such importance to his comments, will Johann Lamont accept that there must be something in the arguments that have been put forward by the Scottish Government when such a prominent member of the monetary policy committee says that they are substantially based?

Johann Lamont should move away from the idea that Scotland is, for some reason, the only country that cannot have normal procedures, that cannot conduct a monetary policy effectively and that cannot have control over its taxes and finance, which would enable us to direct the Scottish economy in a substantially better way than it is being directed under the dead hand of the UK Treasury.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister’s problem is that he said:

“The Bank of England is an independent central bank that does not take direction on policy”.

That is simply not true.

The First Minister also cited David Blanchflower, but Professor Blanchflower was talking about whether there should be a Scot on the current monetary policy committee; that there is not is the First Minister’s objection to it, as it stands. He was not making an observation on the First Minister’s and the Deputy First Minister’s assertion—and absolute statement—that an independent Scotland would have representation on the monetary policy committee. That is not true, because he has not even asked the Bank of England whether that would be the case.

Let us see what the Treasury says. It has said that

“Scotland using the pound through a sterlingisation mechanism”—

last week, the First Minister called it the “sterling zone”—

“would have no say over its own monetary policy as set by the Bank of England.”

The First Minister wants to leave the United Kingdom, remove Scotland’s representation at Westminster and have less say in the formulation of monetary policy. Why does the First Minister plan to lessen our influence over our own economic policy? [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
It is arithmetically impossible to have less than zero say. We have zero say at present. This new interpretation of the status of the Bank of England is fantastic. The Bank of England is an independent central bank. It was established as such by Gordon Brown when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer in 1997. If he was not establishing that, what on earth was the direction of policy about that he announced in 1997?

Johann Lamont will be delighted to know that the fiscal commission that has been appointed by John Swinney, and which comprises two Nobel laureates and other distinguished economists, is working on these very matters in order to develop proposals. I will inform Professor Joseph Stiglitz and Professor Jim Mirrlees that Johann Lamont has an important contribution to make, and I will pass on that expertise to them.

However, I think that we had better start with the premise that the Bank of England is an independent central bank, because it was established as such in June 1997, and that Scotland has no influence at present. The proposals that we are putting forward, which are supported by Professor David Blanchflower, represent an entirely better position than the one that we are in at present. [Interruption.]

Regardless of that, control over Scotland’s spending and taxation, which are crucial matters, is currently directed by the United Kingdom Treasury. I think that it should be directed in Scotland because no one—certainly not the UK Treasury—would do better by the Scottish people and the Scottish economy than Scots making decisions about our taxation and spending here in Scotland.

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
One moment, Ms Lamont. If Mr Paterson, Mr Gibson and Mr Scott could please cease their conversations, perhaps we might hear the questions and the answers.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister would require his colleagues with the Nobel peace prize—or whatever kind of Nobel prize—to explain the answers that he has just given. They are entirely incomprehensible to us.

On the question of Scottish influence, we had a Scottish Chancellor of the Exchequer making policy for 13 years, but that was not good enough for the First Minister. Now, we are hoping that, in an independent Scotland, we might possibly have representation on the monetary policy committee—but, of course, that has not been confirmed.

The truth of the matter is that the First Minister’s plans for leaving the United Kingdom will leave Scotland with less control over our economy, not more. Either monetary policy is handed over to a foreign Government under sterling or it is handed over to German bankers under the euro. All the assertions in the world will make no difference to that. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If the First Minister had the courage of his convictions, he would be alongside his old deputy Jim Sillars, arguing for a separate Scottish currency. We can only presume that he has worked out that no one would vote for that. Is he just coming up with an incoherent assortment of assertions in the hope that he can hoodwink the Scottish people for long enough to win his referendum?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont is in desperate need of a new scriptwriter so that she can read out better questions each week. Her argument is that we have some sort of control over policy at present. If we follow her argument and the Bank of England is not really independent—despite what happened in 1997—that means that the Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, is directing things at present.

Johann Lamont’s argument rests on the idea that we have some influence and control over the activities of a Tory chancellor. It seems quite obvious that we have no control and zero influence at the moment. As I pointed out to Johann Lamont, arithmetically we cannot have less than zero control. Let us establish the point: in terms of direct monetary policy, the Bank of England is independent.

Let us move on to fiscal policy, which is control of taxation and spending. Currently, this Parliament has control of 8 per cent of our taxation base, which will rise to about 18 per cent with the changes that are being made by the Scotland Act 2012. The Scottish National Party and very many people in Scotland want to control 100 per cent of our taxation. That—I say to Johann Lamont—is what we call “independence”. She thinks that “control” means that we should rely on a Tory chancellor in London. We would rather rely on a Government that is elected by the people of Scotland to take decisions in the interests of Scotland.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Legionella Outbreak Statement · 23
  2. Common Fisheries Policy Debate · 48
  3. Air Passenger Duty Questions · 6
  4. Nuclear Waste Questions · 6
  5. Judicial Reform Questions · 6
  6. Acceptable Behaviour Contracts Questions · 4
  7. Tenant Farming Forum (Rent Reviews) Questions · 6
  8. Mobile Coverage Questions · 4
  9. Public Sector Contracts Questions · 4
  10. Illegal Cockle Fishing (Solway Firth) Questions · 5
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. “The National Fraud Initiative in Scotland” First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Year of Homecoming 2014 First Minister’s Questions · 10
  15. Prisons (Proposed Statutory Monitoring Service) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  16. Population First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth Questions · 1
  18. Jobs Questions · 7
  19. Council Tax Exemption (Students) Questions · 4
  20. Local Government Taxation Questions · 6
  21. Unemployment (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  22. Employment Initiatives (Central Scotland) Questions · 6
  23. Business Support (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
  24. Monetary Policy Committee (Scottish Representation) Questions · 6
  25. Subsea Sector Questions · 4
  26. Beecroft Report Questions · 4
  27. Gross Domestic Product (Measures) Questions · 4
  28. Scottish Enterprise (Meetings) Questions · 6
  29. Economy (North Ayrshire) Questions · 6
  30. Economic Support (South Scotland) Questions · 4
  31. Employment (Disabled People) Questions · 4
  32. Community Planning Partnerships Questions · 4
  33. Mobile Telephone Masts (Siting) Questions · 4
  34. Sustainable Economic Growth Questions · 4
  35. Taxation Statement · 37
  36. Agricultural Holdings (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 29
  37. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  38. Decision Time Decision time · 8
  39. Death Penalty in India Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.