4. To ask the Scottish Executive what action it is taking to protect Scotland’s built heritage and what support it is offering to programmes such as the Dysart townscape heritage initiative that aim to restore Scotland’s unique structures. (S3O-10585)
Official Report · Chamber
Built Heritage
Scottish Executive Question Time Europe, External Affairs and Culture
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fiona Hyslop SNP 5
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
- Aileen Campbell SNP 1
- Rhona Brankin Lab 1
- Ted Brocklebank Con 1
The record
10 contributions4. To ask the Scottish Executive what action it is taking to protect Scotland’s built heritage and what support it is offering to programmes such as the Dysart townscape heritage initiative that aim to restore Scotland’s unique structures. (S3O-10585)
The Scottish Government shares with all the people of Scotland a pride in our nation’s built heritage. It inspires us and gives us our sense of place. I have recently introduced the Historic Environment (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill to the Parliament. It is a tightly focused, amending bill that makes specific practical improvements to the legal framework for heritage protection and will provide a much improved legislative toolkit to help protect and enhance our rich historic environment for future generations.
The Scottish Government, through Historic Scotland, has awarded £395,000 to the Dysart conservation area regeneration scheme, which is part of a joint local authority, Heritage Lottery Fund and Historic Scotland conservation initiative aimed at addressing the needs of the area.
The Scottish Government, through Historic Scotland, has awarded £395,000 to the Dysart conservation area regeneration scheme, which is part of a joint local authority, Heritage Lottery Fund and Historic Scotland conservation initiative aimed at addressing the needs of the area.
I am sure that the minister will join me in thanking and congratulating everyone who is involved in that important local initiative.
Which recommendations from the review of building preservation trusts will be acted on as a way to preserve Scotland’s built environment culture, and what support will be given to local building preservation trusts to enable them to continue to restore and maintain Scotland’s important historic built environment?
Which recommendations from the review of building preservation trusts will be acted on as a way to preserve Scotland’s built environment culture, and what support will be given to local building preservation trusts to enable them to continue to restore and maintain Scotland’s important historic built environment?
There are a number of areas in which we can work, particularly with reference to Historic Scotland’s conservation area regeneration scheme, under which 20 local authorities across Scotland have been awarded grants for 20 individual conservation area scheme projects. Just over £30.4 million has been allocated in grants from the original programme reserve, and a further round of bids will be invited for round 4 of the programme.
In addition, the Scottish Government has been supporting a number of other areas. The presence of Jeremy Purvis in the chamber reminds me that I recently visited Abbotsford, where I announced contributions from Historic Scotland, Scottish Enterprise and the Scottish Government of £2.25 million to help the built heritage environment there and to preserve and promote a vital part of Scotland’s culture that is related to Sir Walter Scott.
In addition, the Scottish Government has been supporting a number of other areas. The presence of Jeremy Purvis in the chamber reminds me that I recently visited Abbotsford, where I announced contributions from Historic Scotland, Scottish Enterprise and the Scottish Government of £2.25 million to help the built heritage environment there and to preserve and promote a vital part of Scotland’s culture that is related to Sir Walter Scott.
The minister might be aware of work that I am doing to help to preserve the future of Carluke’s high mill, Scotland’s best-preserved example of a windmill. However, efforts to save it have been thwarted due to the fact that it is privately owned, and the owner has demonstrated absolutely no desire for the building to be maintained or restored.
Does the minister agree that the private owners of buildings with significant historic value have an absolute duty to help to preserve Scotland’s history and a responsibility to do all that they can to ensure that that history is not lost forever?
Does the minister agree that the private owners of buildings with significant historic value have an absolute duty to help to preserve Scotland’s history and a responsibility to do all that they can to ensure that that history is not lost forever?
I understand members’ frustrations with regard to certain buildings, but owners of listed buildings and scheduled monuments are responsible for their upkeep. Ministers encourage them to take that responsibility seriously. We provide advice and, indeed, grants are available from Historic Scotland to assist with repairs. If owners allow buildings to deteriorate, powers are available to allow local authorities to intervene and require repairs to be carried out. I understand that, in the case of Carluke’s high mill, South Lanarkshire Council is actively discussing with the owners the potential to secure its future.
I know that the minister has recently visited the Scottish Mining Museum in Midlothian. Although I welcome the funding that has been made available to the museum, it in no way sustains a long-term and sustainable future for the museum.
If the minister agrees that the museum in Newtongrange is a national—indeed, an international—asset for Scotland, will she finally commit this Government to making it a part of the National Museums of Scotland, which will put our coal-mining heritage up where it belongs, as a central part of Scotland’s cultural heritage?
If the minister agrees that the museum in Newtongrange is a national—indeed, an international—asset for Scotland, will she finally commit this Government to making it a part of the National Museums of Scotland, which will put our coal-mining heritage up where it belongs, as a central part of Scotland’s cultural heritage?
The member will be aware that the Scottish Government is conducting a review of such matters through the museums think-tank. That will be informed by considerations of our industrial heritage.
I was pleased to visit the museum recently and to make announcements of funding for it. We need to think about international heritage and our national heritage, and what shape that might be. As I saw when I visited the museum, there are challenges in relation to the capital that is required, which might require some challenging thinking. I am open to that and have encouraged all players to think constructively about that.
A solution has to be found and, as someone who comes from Ayrshire, and who is from a mining family, I share the member’s view that our coal-mining heritage is a vital part of Scotland’s culture, history and heritage. We have to find practical ways of taking action around that. I know that the member will continue to lobby effectively on the issue.
I was pleased to visit the museum recently and to make announcements of funding for it. We need to think about international heritage and our national heritage, and what shape that might be. As I saw when I visited the museum, there are challenges in relation to the capital that is required, which might require some challenging thinking. I am open to that and have encouraged all players to think constructively about that.
A solution has to be found and, as someone who comes from Ayrshire, and who is from a mining family, I share the member’s view that our coal-mining heritage is a vital part of Scotland’s culture, history and heritage. We have to find practical ways of taking action around that. I know that the member will continue to lobby effectively on the issue.
The minister has indicated previously that Historic Scotland is to adopt a more realistic attitude in its role of protecting Scotland’s built heritage. What steps have been taken to end the impasse at Crail in Fife, where, as I have previously outlined in the chamber, a derelict wartime airfield was given historic listing, which, for more than a decade, has prevented a local farmer from developing his own land?
I will ask Historic Scotland to tell me what the current situation is and will share that information with the member.
There are situations in which we have to ensure that places are protected but also that there is opportunity for change. The different climate and atmosphere that I know is coming to bear on Historic Scotland through its new leadership is making a difference, but we must ensure that we assess each case on its merits and continue to work with local authorities. The Government is bringing forward plans to engage with local authorities and give them more power where possible, because they are, in many cases, aware of the practical issues surrounding developments.
There are challenges. Previous questions that I have answered today have covered issues such as the requirement for protection. There is not necessarily movement in that area, but some people want development as opposed to preservation. The questions that members have asked in the past few minutes have exhibited the tensions that exist in this area, but we are trying to provide practical steps forward. The forthcoming bill will help the situation, and we have consulted heavily with local authorities to break some of the impasses that exist.
There are situations in which we have to ensure that places are protected but also that there is opportunity for change. The different climate and atmosphere that I know is coming to bear on Historic Scotland through its new leadership is making a difference, but we must ensure that we assess each case on its merits and continue to work with local authorities. The Government is bringing forward plans to engage with local authorities and give them more power where possible, because they are, in many cases, aware of the practical issues surrounding developments.
There are challenges. Previous questions that I have answered today have covered issues such as the requirement for protection. There is not necessarily movement in that area, but some people want development as opposed to preservation. The questions that members have asked in the past few minutes have exhibited the tensions that exist in this area, but we are trying to provide practical steps forward. The forthcoming bill will help the situation, and we have consulted heavily with local authorities to break some of the impasses that exist.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 May 2010 →- Protection for Workers Debate · 54
- Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Government (Taxation) Questions · 9
- Roads (Argyll and Bute) Questions · 7
- Volcanic Activity (Economic Impact) Questions · 6
- Midwives (Employment) Questions · 4
- Adult Obesity Questions · 7
- A9 (Berriedale) Questions · 4
- First Minister (Engagements) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Taser Use (Ministerial Guidelines) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Community Sentences First Minister’s Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Efficiency Savings) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scottish Executive Question Time Questions · 1
- Education and Lifelong Learning Questions · 1
- Schools (Music Teaching) Questions · 4
- Curriculum for Excellence Questions · 4
- Education (Funding) Questions · 6
- Curriculum for Excellence Questions · 6
- North Lanarkshire Council (Meetings) Questions · 12
- Forest Schools Questions · 4
- Europe, External Affairs and Culture Questions · 1
- Access to Information (Games for Scotland) Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Role in Europe Questions · 8
- Built Heritage Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Calman Commission (Recommendations) Questions · 8
- High-speed Rail Debate · 90
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 9
- Decision Time Decision time · 17
- Family Nurse Partnership Programme Members’ business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.