Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

National Donor Breast Milk Bank (PE1426)

Tuesday 1 May 2012 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 36 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Our second petition is PE1426, by Donna Scott, on a national donor breast milk bank service. Members have the clerk’s note, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition.I welcome Donna Scott and Jase Kelly to the meeting. Before I invite Donna to make a short presentation of, say, five minutes, I will let in Mark McDonald, who has been trying to catch my eye.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

Before we begin, convener, I declare that the petitioner, Donna Scott, is one of my constituents and that I know her and have been working with her on this issue.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. I ask Donna Scott to make her presentation, after which I will invite the committee to ask some questions.

Donna Scott
link

Good afternoon, convener and committee members.My petition relates to the unequal access to donor milk for babies across Scotland. Understanding of the value of donor breast milk in neonatal units has been growing in recent years. Everyone has heard of blood banks, but not everyone will have heard of milk banks, and parents who find themselves in neonatal units—usually in emergencies—will not know to ask for donor milk or even know whether it is available.I completely understand why units that cannot provide such milk do not offer it as an option, because it is not helpful to discuss something that cannot be provided. However, the situation has changed in recent years, with more and more research confirming that babies thrive on donor breast milk and much more evidence about the risks of formula, particularly to vulnerable pre-term babies in respect of necrotising enterocolitis and allergies. We also know more about the lifelong benefits of breast milk to cardiovascular health, bone growth and neurological development. Moreover, a recent phenomenon—even outwith neonatal circles—that has been facilitated by social media is informal mother-to-mother milk sharing.As a result, parents who find themselves in neonatal units will perhaps be much more informed and they will ask about the availability of donor milk for their baby. The World Health Organization has made it clear that formula is the fourth best option for feeding babies, pre-term or otherwise. Obviously, direct breastfeeding from the mother is the best option, second is the feeding of expressed breast milk either by tube or cup, and third is donor milk.There is evidence that clinicians and parents in Scotland are happy for donor milk to be used in neonatal units. In the period 2008 to 2011, the Yorkhill milk bank, which is the one milk bank in Scotland, increased by four times the amount of pasteurised milk that it processes. It is providing donated milk for three times more babies than it did in 2008 and it has twice as many donors as it had before. Interestingly, 40 per cent of donors come from outwith the greater Glasgow and Clyde area, and the health boards in Lanarkshire, Ayrshire and Arran and Lothian have utilised the service at Yorkhill.Recently, the Scottish Emergency Rider Volunteer Service has been involved in delivering milk to other neonatal units. However, as I pointed out, the only milk bank in Scotland is at Yorkhill and it is funded and run by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde as a local service. Over the next few months, parents who find themselves in a neonatal unit will be receiving a DVD called “Small Wonders”, which includes a section on donor milk, and they will start to ask whether such milk is appropriate for their child.Donor milk is also important because it supports maternal lactation. International evidence is emerging that suggests that breastfeeding rates are better in maternity units that use donor milk. It is easy to see why that might be the case; it shows that healthcare professionals value breast milk so much that they are willing to use screened and pasteurised product from other mothers. If those women are pumping milk for a mother’s child, it encourages them to keep going. This is only a temporary stopgap or an emergency option. Women do not simply sit back and get brought bottles of frozen milk; the understanding is that their own milk production has to be kept up to allow them to take over in due course.My son was born at 32 weeks and, having spent three weeks in a neonatal unit, I can genuinely say that expressing exclusively is one of the most relentless and exhausting tasks that I have ever undertaken. Some women have to do it for three months or even more, depending on the gestation of their baby or the medical conditions that it has.I argue, therefore, that we need to consider the establishment of a national donor breast milk bank. Because NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde meets all the costs of running the Yorkhill milk bank, if there is a 27-week-old baby in Aberdeen and another in Glasgow that have identical clinical needs, the baby in Glasgow will get priority. I do not find that an acceptable position for the national health service in Scotland.As demand increases—as it has done so far and will surely continue to do—the question is whether the Glasgow milk bank will be able to cope without extra funding and improved infrastructure. There have been points in the past few months at which milk supplies have been quite tight because so much milk is going out.I propose that, instead, there should be a central milk bank based at Yorkhill that can source locally screened donors as well, and a transport network such as the Scottish Emergency Rider Volunteer Service should co-ordinate supply and demand throughout Scotland. That would make the milk bank service much more equitable, efficient and well supported. Yorkhill would need investment and infrastructure to facilitate that expansion.Another option would be to set up separate milk banks. However, that would be quite expensive and it is not the most efficient option.Yorkhill has the required expertise and facilities, so it would be a good foundation from which to reach all the main neonatal units in Scotland. To base a central milk bank there is a feasible way in which to expand the milk bank service.As a parent living in Scotland, if I had another baby who was in a neonatal unit that was not in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde’s area, my baby would not be considered for this resource in the way that a baby born in Glasgow would be. I do not find that acceptable.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for your evidence. You make a strong and compelling case. You mentioned the international evidence. What best practice can you identify—first, in the rest of the UK, and secondly throughout Europe? Are there examples of a national milk bank service that works in a particular nation state or large territory?

Donna Scott
link

Throughout the rest of the UK, the provision of donor milk is a patchwork. I cannot cite any examples, because services tend to operate in their own local areas.I do not have extensive knowledge of this, but countries such as Sweden certainly have a network of milk banks. Sweden has 27 milk banks for a population of about 9 million people. I imagine that they provide full coverage across the whole country.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Have you identified any constraints on health boards, apart from money? Why are other health boards not looking at the milk bank as an excellent initiative on which Yorkhill is leading the way in Scotland?

Donna Scott
link

Given Scotland’s population distribution, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has a larger number of babies who require neonatal care, and they are treated at Yorkhill. Because other health boards have not had access to the resource, they have not been using it, so on the surface the demand has not been there. The more that clinicians and parents realise that the resource is available and can be used, the more use of it will become common practice.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Has there been any interest from the third sector or the co-operative movement? There seems to be an ideal opportunity for them to get involved in this development across Scotland.

Donna Scott
link

Not to my knowledge.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps that is something that we can pursue as a committee.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Thank you for your interesting presentation. As the convener said, you make a good case. Politicians inevitably think of money, and at present budgets are stretched, including health board budgets. Have you done any research on relative costings for a national donor breast milk bank and for banks set up by individual health boards? Do you have any figures on that, or is there anywhere we could go to get them?

Donna Scott
link

I have read estimates and my understanding is that to set up a new milk bank would cost about £200,000. That includes staff training, all the necessary infrastructure and everything that is required within that. It would therefore be quite a big financial undertaking to set up separate banks around Scotland. That is why enhancing and expanding what we have is the most effective and efficient approach.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

It strikes me that that cost is not enormous in terms of health service budgets. I do not know whether the Government has done any costings, but that is something that the committee can find out.14:45

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

Welcome to the committee, Donna. My first question is for Mr Kelly, who I know has been working with the Yorkhill milk bank to transport milk from donors to the bank, and from the bank to other health boards where there is sufficient capacity, although there is also demand from elsewhere. Will you expand on the work that ScotsERVS does with the Yorkhill milk bank?

Jase Kelly Scottish Emergency Rider Volunteer Service
link

ScotsERVS is a charity that operates throughout Scotland and transports any medical items that the NHS needs quickly. The NHS might be used to using other means such as taxis or expensive couriers, but we transport for free.We operate nearly every night in Edinburgh, Ayrshire and Lanarkshire. It seems that our services are primarily being requested around Yorkhill. However, we are a Scotland-wide charity and we do not discriminate; if a call comes from NHS Grampian, NHS Tayside or another health board, we will respond to the request for transport.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

There will be a certain window of time within which donated milk has to get from the donor to the bank or from the bank to the health board that requested it. What is that window? If you were in Glasgow and a call came from Inverness because donor milk was required there, are you confident that you could deliver within a viable timeframe?

Jase Kelly Scottish Emergency Rider Volunteer Service
link

All our vehicles are specially adapted, and we have specialist refrigerated boxes. The boxes that the NHS supplied to us can only refrigerate for a maximum of eight hours, which is more or less fine for Scotland. The boxes that our charity has purchased refrigerate for 24 hours, so we can provide unlimited UK coverage for what is inside the box.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

Donna, I am aware that you took a large amount of milk to donate to the Glasgow milk bank, which I think was before ScotsERVS was involved. Will you expand on what you did?

Donna Scott
link

My son was discharged from the neonatal unit at the end of April 2011. I was in the fortunate position of being able to fully breastfeed my son upon leaving the unit. However, I had been expressing to save, and by June 2011 I had 5.5 litres of expressed milk. Of course, that was far more than I needed, so I wanted to make a donation. However, doing that was very difficult.A large part of the problem is that the screening must be done in Glasgow, although the milk bank staff will come out to within an hour of Yorkhill. For women who do not live in that area, that means that bloods cannot be taken, so screening cannot take place and milk cannot be used, even if ScotsERVS can come and pick it up. That raises another issue—if there was remote testing for donors, that would free up the situation and keep the supply and demand balanced.I decided that, rather than the milk being wasted, I would take it to Glasgow. I had online screening before I went, which was acceptable to Yorkhill. I took the milk there and had my bloods taken, and the milk was put to good use.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

You spoke about the issues of demand and the difficulty in measuring demand in areas that do not offer a donor milk service. If the service is not there and the available service is not being promoted, how can demand be measured?It is clear that you have done a lot of work on the issue. Have people said to you that, if they had known that the service was available, they would have requested it? Also, have people said that they did not request the service because they knew that it was not available, but that they would have wanted it if it had been available?

Donna Scott
link

Many people that I have spoken to—parents and non-parents—have said that they did not know that milk banks existed. People think that milk banks are a great idea. At an individual level, one friend that I spoke to was particularly concerned that she might need donor milk, which she knew could not be accessed—at the time—in Aberdeen. I have also heard that health professionals have assumed that people can get donor milk outwith Glasgow. For example, some surgeons have assumed that milk is available. They do not realise how the system falls short.Many people would have used the service if they had known about it. Speaking to mothers in the neonatal unit, I found that many of them did not know that it was possible to get donor milk or that they could donate it. Although awareness is growing, many people are still unaware of the service. The more people find out about it, the greater the demand will be.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

When we spoke to NHS Grampian, it stated that it would be interested in linking into a national service but that it would not be able to set up its own milk bank. Have you had any contact with other health boards on whether they would be interested in Scotland having a national infrastructure rather than their having to face the up-front costs of establishing their own milk banks?

Donna Scott
link

I have not.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

The committee might want to take that up.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I declare an interest as, many years ago, I was a contributor to the milk bank at Yorkhill. Also, I believe that I know Councillor Brothers’s father from a number of years ago, when I was a councillor in Renfrewshire.I was interested in what was said about the lack of information and awareness, and I echo Mark McDonald’s point about a national network of milk banks.I note that there is informal liaison between NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and other health boards, particularly NHS Lothian and NHS Ayrshire and Arran, which feed—pardon the pun—into the national milk bank in Glasgow.Jase Kelly’s voluntary service does fantastic work, and I know that it has purchased new motorbikes and so on in the past couple of months. However, if we are going to have a national milk bank, can we rely on a voluntary service, or would the service have to be brought in house?If we had a national network of milk banks, which would no doubt be based at the Southern general hospital, because the Yorkhill baby unit will be moved there in a couple of years’ time, how could we ensure that other areas, such as Inverness and Aberdeen, would get parity of access? As you said, at present, people who stay within an hour of Glasgow get priority.

Jase Kelly Scottish Emergency Rider Volunteer Service
link

As you say, ScotsERVS is a voluntary organisation that relies on public generosity and companies sponsoring us to meet our costs for fuel, vehicles, repairs and so on.We did our sums before starting the project—ScotsERVS was about three or four years in creation, and it has been active for only about six months. It is going well at the moment. We have enough money in the bank to sustain ourselves for a little while longer. However, as you say, sustainability will probably be an issue. We will have to consider getting lottery, Government or national health service funding to support our service.

Donna Scott
link

If there is to be true parity, some sort of contribution will have to be made by the other health boards as well, or we will need some central funding in order to make the milk banks into a national resource. I do not know how that would work within the NHS, but that would be important.I can understand NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde’s position, but it means that there is a postcode lottery. Anything that can help to iron that out and ensure that babies throughout Scotland can be catered for on the basis of clinical need would be helpful, as that is the ideal.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that this is an excellent initiative and I recommend to the committee that we continue the petition. I suggest that we write to the Scottish Government to find out whether it might want to roll out the service across Scotland. It would be in the best position to do that, although in saying that, I do not mean to knock the work that Yorkhill is doing. Do members have any other suggestions?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I absolutely agree that we should continue the petition. We should write to the Scottish Government to find out its response to what the petition seeks. We should write to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde to get its response and to ask about its experience of its work on the donor breast milk service that it provides. We could also write to ask ScotsERVS—Jase Kelly’s organisation—and the United Kingdom Association for Milk Banking for their responses.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I call Mark McDonald, who has been very involved in the issue.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

When we write to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde to ask about its experience, we should ask it about the potential for expanding what it offers and whether it has assessed how much an expansion would cost. I suggest that we also write to the other territorial health boards to ask them what internal discussions they have had about donor milk, whether they would be interested in linking into a national infrastructure and whether they have considered establishing a milk bank. We spoke about the national versus the network approach. Ironing out such issues in the responses would be the way to go.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I have no idea what the proposal would cost. I presume that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde knows what its service costs, but I do not know whether financial investigations have been done by other health boards or the Government. It would be interesting to find out about that from the organisations that have been mentioned.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

I suspect that the UK Association for Milk Banking will be able to help on the costs, as it works with all the milk banks across the UK. There are a number of milk banks in England, which could perhaps provide comparative figures.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

Elaine Smith MSP brought the issue to Parliament and the cabinet secretary Nicola Sturgeon replied on it, but it is important to go back to the cabinet secretary, because she gave an assurance that she would involve her officials, so some answers might be available already. It is obviously unfair that a postcode lottery applies to who gets milk.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that we all agree that the petition is interesting and that we will pursue it with the various bodies that members identified. We will keep the petitioner informed about the next step with the petition. I thank both witnesses for giving useful evidence.I suspend the meeting for two minutes to allow the next witnesses to take their places.14:57 Meeting suspended.

14:59 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 48
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 36
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 26
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.