Item 2 is consideration of five current petitions, the first of which is PE1236, by Jill Fotheringham, on A90/A937 safety improvements. Members have a note from the clerk. Once again, I welcome Nigel Don, who has a strong constituency interest in the matter; indeed, he has attended so many of our meetings that he has become an honorary committee member. I ask Mr Don to make a submission. We are a bit better off for time this afternoon, Mr Don, so you should feel free to take slightly longer.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
A90/A937 (Safety Improvements) (PE1236)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 11
- Nigel Don SNP 6
- Mark McDonald SNP 4
- Anne McTaggart Lab 3
- Nanette Milne Con 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
The record
26 contributionsThank you very much, convener. Good afternoon, colleagues. Most members will be very familiar with the petition and I have no desire to repeat anything just for the sake of it. I have in front of me the draft development masterplan for south Montrose, as a consequence of which I have written a letter that the committee will have seen. As members will recall, Montrose is to the south-east of the Laurencekirk south junction and is the source of much of the traffic that comes on to the A90 at that aforementioned junction. The last paragraph of the masterplan’s introduction says:“The primary purpose of this Development Masterplan report is to guide future change within South Montrose in order to further promote the competitive advantage of the area, capture the new opportunities associated with Offshore Renewables and secure and attract new commercial business interest, investment and jobs.”You would imagine—and you would be right to do so—that, as the constituency MSP, I would be delighted to read that. However, you will also immediately recognise that all of that is likely to involve traffic, at least some of which will go north, by road, through the aforementioned Laurencekirk south junction—hence my letter to Transport Scotland, which has been copied to the local authorities in question. Essentially, my letter says, “Dear Transport Scotland, what do you think this masterplan does to the equation as far as the flyover is concerned?”That is the point we have reached. My request to the committee is to keep the petition open until we have received a response from Transport Scotland. Convener, forgive me for telling the committee what to do—I do not think that it need do anything but, of course, if it feels inclined to do something that would be wonderful. I just want to point out that the basic things that need to be done have been done and we are essentially awaiting replies.
Thank you for coming along and for those comments. I throw the discussion open to members.
I agree with Nigel Don. We have worked together on the issue for a long time, on both the previous Public Petitions Committee and the current one. I agree that the petition should be kept open. The letter from Aberdeenshire Council states:“work is underway that will allow a case to be put to Transport Scotland setting out the long term strategic benefits of putting in place a grade separated junction at Laurencekirk at the earliest opportunity.”That is interesting. The council anticipates that the work will be complete by the end of June. The letter continues:“If it were considered of benefit Nestrans and Aberdeenshire Council would be willing to make officers available to attend a future meeting of the Petitions Committee to discuss this area of work further.”We should extend an invitation to those bodies to come to the committee, immediately after the summer recess, if possible.
I echo Nanette Milne’s sentiments. Nigel Don’s letter mentions the Tayside and central Scotland transport partnership, or tactran, which is the other transport partnership stakeholder. We should extend the invitation to it, given that the Laurencekirk junction straddles the boundary between the north east of Scotland transport partnership, or Nestrans, and tactran areas, and given the considerable interest that both bodies will have in the management of traffic going from Montrose via Laurencekirk.The petitioner’s submission mentions a grade separation at the north junction, but I was not aware that that was going to happen. Nigel Don, as the constituency member, might enlighten us on that point. I was not aware of grade separation being planned at either of the Laurencekirk junctions, but perhaps he knows more about that.
I can enlighten the committee. The study that Transport Scotland undertook examined three junctions—the north, south and middle ones, for want of better terms. The study considered the possibility of work at those junctions and the benefits of it. The issue of grade separation at the north junction arises out of the long-term development plan for Laurencekirk, which recognises that new housing will be to the north of the town, rather than the south, and that many of the houses will be occupied by folk who want to commute by car to Aberdeen. That makes it sensible to have a flyover at the north junction. However, that is a completely separate issue from the south junction, where, as members will recall, the A937 Marykirk to Montrose road comes in and which is currently the source of the most obvious hazard. I envisage that, in 20 years, we will have north and south flyovers at Laurencekirk, but the two issues are completely separate and arise for completely different reasons.
I hope that that does not mean that we will have the petition before us for another 20 years—I am sure that that is not what Nigel Don meant.Another interesting point in the petitioner’s submission is that the studies have tended to focus on the traffic travelling north and south and not on the traffic crossing at the junction. As a frequent user of the A90, I am aware that heavy goods vehicles and buses cross at the junction, which is different from small vehicles doing so. While we are waiting for the responses to Nigel Don’s letter, and as well as inviting stakeholders to come before the committee, perhaps we could ask Transport Scotland about work that it has done to monitor crossings at the junction, rather than simply the traffic flows and speeds travelling north and south. Obviously, the traffic flows going north and south are not an issue if nobody crosses the road. They become an issue when large vehicles—often slow-moving, agricultural ones—cross at the junction. We should find out what work has been done to monitor that, as well as the north and south traffic flows.
I presume that, given the nature of the junction, there are real dangers with slow-moving vehicles, so that is a good point.14:30
We have some information in our papers about the cost refinement exercise. Nigel Don talked about a flyover, but what alternative options have been costed?
All the costings were essentially for flyovers—grade-separated junctions at the south and the north. There are no viable alternatives. Laurencekirk is on one side of the road, and a dual carriageway runs down the side of it. I do not think that anybody looked at building a bridge that might provide a detour or whatever. To build a standard flyover—a grade-separated junction—is the only thing that we can sensibly do in the long-term at the north junction and at the south junction.People looked at roundabouts and other ideas, but such ideas are quickly dismissed by the experts on the basis that roundabouts generate more accidents than they prevent where there is busy traffic.
What about traffic lights or even something that goes under the road as opposed to going over it? Have those ideas been considered?
Yes. We get the same answer on traffic lights that we get on roundabouts. In the process of stopping and starting traffic, we generate the opportunity for serious accidents. In those circumstances, the experts tell me that traffic lights would not be productive.The idea of something that goes underneath the road is perfectly viable. Ground conditions and the fact that there is a small tunnel under the road at one point nearby tell me that that would be possible. The civil engineers tell me that going underneath and going over the top are just two different ways of achieving the same result. There is no significant difference in terms of cost or difficulty. The assumption has been that a flyover is the right answer.
You made a great plea on television last night in favour of the option. It was fabulous. The matter is extremely concerning and I hope that we get some results soon.
The letter that I have in front of me states that a comprehensive accident investigation and prevention study has been done. It was commissioned in 2009. Is there merit in our writing to Transport Scotland again? Are there any gaps that have not been covered?
My instinct is that Transport Scotland is, perhaps quite fairly, looking at recent accident statistics, the work that was done a couple of years ago to give us a 50 mph limit and various other bits of information. For example, as a vehicle approaches the junction, if traffic is trying to turn across it, a warning sign comes up that says “Traffic turning”. Transport Scotland is looking at the work that has been done and saying, “This has made a significant improvement.” That is a fair comment in its own terms.What Transport Scotland does not see—I am sure that my constituents would agree—is that a very serious accident is just waiting to happen. The high-speed traffic might have slowed down to 50 mph on approach, but in careless hands vehicles will be the other side of 60 mph by the time they pass the junction, given the nature of modern cars. We are all aware that large numbers of heavy trailer lorries and buses have to cross there. This is a 20-mile stretch, dare I remind folk, without any kind of flyover, bridge or underpass. If someone wants to take an articulated lorry across, they have no option but to pull out and stop on the central reservation with their tail out on the other carriageway. There is nothing else that they can do.I think that Transport Scotland is still blind to the fact that that situation is an accident waiting to happen. As the local MSP, I, like many other people, suggest that we ought to solve the problem before the accident happens.
You are saying that there is still room for manoeuvre to have another AIP study on the aspect that you have just identified.
I do not know whether we need a study to look at the situation and say that it is dangerous. A single photograph of an articulated lorry sitting across the dual carriageway of a main road is enough to tell us that we have a problem. If somebody needs to study the situation in order to provide evidence, let us have the study. However, I think that it is obvious, and so does everybody who lives there.
You make a good point. We need to write to Transport Scotland, draw its attention to your evidence and ask it to comment. We will not ask it to do a full study; rather, we will ask it to comment on a very obvious fact.
When was the last time that we had Transport Scotland in to give evidence on the petition?
We have not had evidence from it this session. We will check the details, and I will get back to you on that shortly.
I have a great deal of sympathy with the request to keep the petition open, given that it is guaranteed that traffic will increase on the A937 and the A90 as a result of developments in south Montrose and the building of new houses in Laurencekirk that has been mentioned. There is still merit in writing to Transport Scotland, which has to be given time to allow it to take the matter into account. If we are going to invite it to the committee, that is all well and good, as it is clear that there is an issue. I have been up and down the road umpteen times, and it is obvious to anybody that there is an issue. We do not need a survey to see that.
We believe that Transport Scotland came in and gave evidence at the end of session 3. What do members feel about inviting it to come in and give us evidence on the petition?
Indeed, that was the genesis of my question. Perhaps it might be worth keeping that on the back burner for now. We could see the evidence from Aberdeenshire Council and the transport partnerships first; we may then want to invite Transport Scotland in. It is interesting to find out how long it is since we last took evidence from it.
That is a sensible suggestion. Are members happy with that course of action?Members indicated agreement.
We will write to the stakeholders that have been identified and Transport Scotland. Obviously, we are awaiting the developments that Nigel Don identified. If necessary, we will ask for an evidence session with Transport Scotland, but perhaps that will be in the longer term, once we have more evidence, including from the local authority. Do members agree to that course of action?Members indicated agreement.
I thank Nigel Don again for coming to the meeting and for his contribution.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 May 2012 →- 14:00 New Petition Petitions · 14
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 26
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.