The sixth and final current petition for consideration today is PE1416, by Eileen Baxendale and others. It seeks a review of health issues and planning guidance with respect to telecommunications masts. Members have a note by the clerk, which is paper 10, and submissions. Robert Brown, one of the petitioners, is an ex-MSP. I congratulate him on his recent election to a council. He sent a useful letter that clarified some of the points in the petition. If members have not seen the letter, they should have a quick look at it. Members may also wish to look at some additional papers that have been tabled, which give some technical advice.15:00
In his letter, Robert Brown’s key point was that the petition has called not for phone masts to be banned near residential properties, but for the position to be reviewed in the light of developments. He also raised the issue of the Sitefinder database, which members might recall was the technical database that, in theory, held all the locations of sites in Scotland. The difficulty was that three of the major companies, including Orange, did not participate and the database was not kept up to date. Clearly, individuals who had an interest could update it personally if they knew where particular masts were. However, the fact is that, although having some unified comprehensive database sounds like a great idea on paper, if the main companies responsible are not going to update it because of some legal dispute, problems will arise. Robert Brown’s main argument, however, centres on the need to continue the precautionary approach.