I have not seen that.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Mike Watson only · show everyone- Alasdair Morgan SNP 12
- Mike Watson Lab 5
- Christine May Lab 5
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Susan Deacon Lab 1
- Chris Ballance Green 1
Mike Watson’s contributions
5 contributionsThere is a problem with the outcome—democracy has its problems and complications, and this is one of them. All of the six subjects that we have chosen come under the enterprise heading. There is nothing on culture and sport, although there is one inquiry into energy, which is a distinct issue. Given that our current inquiry is into higher education, it is not possible for none of our next six inquiries to deal with culture or sport—that would be publicly indefensible. We must find a way round it.
That comes under enterprise—it is about business, rather than culture. There are cultural and sporting aspects of tourism, but those do not affect the area tourist boards to a great extent. The point that I made stands.A number of aspects of culture and sport are being examined. The Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport has announced a review of cultural bodies, so it would not be appropriate for us to consider that issue at this stage. We have a broad remit and there is no doubt about what the most important part of it is, but it should not dominate to the exclusion of all the other parts of our remit. If we are looking this far ahead but are scheduling no inquiries in the two important areas of culture and sport, we will come in for immediate criticism—and justifiably so.
If you will forgive me, convener, I would like to develop the argument that Christine May has put forward. I am aware that we are reinventing the wheel with regard to what we decided last week, and perhaps I should have made this contribution then and not now, but if we lock ourselves into those six inquiries, it will be difficult to cover any other subjects. We should bear in mind that we will have to deal with the budget process too. Rather than agreeing on three major inquiries and three minor inquiries, I think that it would be better at this stage to agree on two major ones and two minor ones, which would give us more flexibility. Those four inquiries will take us a considerable distance down the road. We have flagged up the issues and the order in which to consider them based on preferences, but we are leaving ourselves open to criticism from those in the cultural and sporting sectors, who might ask, "If the Enterprise and Culture Committee is not looking at issues in our area, who is?"
I have an alternative suggestion, in fact. I think that we should go down that road, although the other possibility is to revisit a decision that we have just made—although that is always a dangerous thing to do. We could investigate the arts and cultural bodies in relation to the budget, and not necessarily in relation to their organisation, which we know is being reviewed. Although I am attracted to what Brian Adam said on the possible relocation of headquarters of bodies such as the Scottish Arts Council, I suggest that that does in fact fall within our remit—relocation of such bodies falls within the remits of the respective ministers. Members will be aware of the controversy last week, when Ross Finnie was alleged to have passed responsibility for the SNH move to Allan Wilson. We could claim legitimacy on that, although that might be some way further down the road. It is my understanding that the SAC, sportscotland and VisitScotland all have leases that are coming up for renewal. It has even been suggested that they might all co-locate somewhere. There is ground for a future inquiry on that subject, although I would not suggest that as the subject of a short-term inquiry. I would prefer to nominate two subjects for inquiry in each section of our remit, which would give us a bit more flexibility.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Culture Committee Tuesday 9 September 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
- Scottish Solutions Inquiry Committee business · 68
- Budget Process 2003-04 Committee business · 31
- Work Programme Procedure · 27
- Petitions Petitions · 5
- Petitions Petitions · 34
- Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.