1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00725)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Tricia Marwick 2
- Michael McMahon Lab 1
The record
16 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00725)
Later today, I will join Mary Robinson, the former President of Ireland, at the launch of Scotland’s climate justice fund. The Scottish Government is providing £3 million for the fund—£1 million each year over the next three years. That will support water projects in Malawi, Rwanda, Tanzania and Zambia, which will increase the resilience of some of the world’s poorest communities to the impacts of climate change. The chamber will agree that this is an area where Scotland is providing strong leadership on a hugely important issue, and we call on other industrialised nations to share our ambitions on climate justice.
We of course support Scotland working in partnership across the world on these very important issues.
On Sunday night, on BBC Scotland, the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, assured viewers that an independent Scotland would have a seat on the Bank of England’s monetary policy committee. Will the First Minister confirm that that is the case and provide us with the details of the agreement? If that agreement has not been finally signed off, will he at least tell us when negotiations started?
On Sunday night, on BBC Scotland, the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, assured viewers that an independent Scotland would have a seat on the Bank of England’s monetary policy committee. Will the First Minister confirm that that is the case and provide us with the details of the agreement? If that agreement has not been finally signed off, will he at least tell us when negotiations started?
The Bank of England’s monetary policy committee has nine members, four of whom are appointed by the Treasury. We expect to be a part of the appointments process—[Laughter.] There is nothing unusual about that. For example, the chair of the Committee on Climate Change—we have just been talking about climate change—is jointly appointed. In addition, the Treasury has a non-voting observer on the monetary policy committee, and we expect to have the same representation.
The issue is that we have no influence as a country on the monetary policy committee. The Bank of England is an independent central bank that does not take direction on policy, but we should move from a position of having no influence to having proper regard in a sterling area—[Interruption.]
The issue is that we have no influence as a country on the monetary policy committee. The Bank of England is an independent central bank that does not take direction on policy, but we should move from a position of having no influence to having proper regard in a sterling area—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. Let us hear the First Minister.
These are arrangements that are put in place between independent countries. It really requires a remarkably diminished view of Scotland and its position not to believe that we are entitled to the same representation as other people making the same arrangements would get. There is a United Kingdom Treasury observer on the Financial Services Advisory Board, which is a Scottish Government committee. Why should Johann Lamont think that any of these things would be unusual for an independent Scotland? As I have discussed with her before, given that we are providing £30,000 million sterling of protection for the UK balance of payments, the UK Treasury and the Bank of England will be glad to have us there.
Even by the First Minister’s standards that was an astonishing response to what was a very simple question. I think that the response to the question was that Nicola Sturgeon was wrong when she said that, and that it is about assertion, belief and hope. Of course, the problem is that the First Minister thinks that an independent Scotland would have influence on the monetary policy committee—although we do not have influence now, we will somehow have influence when Scotland is a foreign country. That simply beggars belief.
Of course, crucial to the First Minister’s plans to keep the pound after Scotland leaves the United Kingdom is that the Bank of England and therefore the UK Treasury agree to be Scotland’s lender of last resort. A deal like that would come with a lot of conditions attached. Clearly, the First Minister has not spoken to the Bank of England about the monetary policy committee, but can he confirm that he has at least spoken to it about being our lender of last resort?
Of course, crucial to the First Minister’s plans to keep the pound after Scotland leaves the United Kingdom is that the Bank of England and therefore the UK Treasury agree to be Scotland’s lender of last resort. A deal like that would come with a lot of conditions attached. Clearly, the First Minister has not spoken to the Bank of England about the monetary policy committee, but can he confirm that he has at least spoken to it about being our lender of last resort?
Johann Lamont is reverting to reading her script again, which indicates that, regardless of how I answer her question, she is going to get her head down and read the script. The Scottish Government and I spoke to the governor of the Bank of England on 16 February, if I remember correctly.
I have set out exactly why Nicola Sturgeon’s answer was correct. It is the case that we have no influence at the moment. Johann Lamont might remember yesterday’s debate in which I asked her how many Scottish members of the monetary policy committee there are. I did not get an answer to that, because the answer is zero—nul points, none whatsoever. We have established that we have no influence at present and that the Bank of England operates as an independent central bank. I have set out why it would be entirely reasonable for an independent Scotland to have the influence that the UK Treasury has at present and I have pointed out that, in a range of other areas of key importance, we have joint, shared arrangements on appointments at present.
That seems to me a grown-up attitude to how you conduct government. What it does not depend on is the peculiarly unionist coalition attitude to the world and hand-in-glove assumption that a country that provides under present circumstances £30 billion protection for the UK balance of payments would have no influence whatsoever. Why does Johann Lamont always want to diminish Scotland’s abilities and its influence?
I have set out exactly why Nicola Sturgeon’s answer was correct. It is the case that we have no influence at the moment. Johann Lamont might remember yesterday’s debate in which I asked her how many Scottish members of the monetary policy committee there are. I did not get an answer to that, because the answer is zero—nul points, none whatsoever. We have established that we have no influence at present and that the Bank of England operates as an independent central bank. I have set out why it would be entirely reasonable for an independent Scotland to have the influence that the UK Treasury has at present and I have pointed out that, in a range of other areas of key importance, we have joint, shared arrangements on appointments at present.
That seems to me a grown-up attitude to how you conduct government. What it does not depend on is the peculiarly unionist coalition attitude to the world and hand-in-glove assumption that a country that provides under present circumstances £30 billion protection for the UK balance of payments would have no influence whatsoever. Why does Johann Lamont always want to diminish Scotland’s abilities and its influence?
I have always told my children that it is not grown up just to cross your fingers and hope for the best. It is not grown up for the First Minister to be incapable of arguing for something that he has believed in for 40 years. Never mind a script, he cannot answer basic questions about simple economics in an independent Scotland.
We know that the First Minister has not asked the question about the MPC or the question about the banker of last resort. If he gets his way, we are less than four years away from leaving the UK on a wing and a prayer, yet on the currency and our interest rates and how much we would be able to spend, how much we could borrow and how much tax we could raise, he has done nothing. He asserts that an independent Scotland could rely on the Bank of England, but he has not even asked the bank; it is just meaningless assertion after meaningless assertion. If he wants the Bank of England to back a separate Scotland, why does he not at least ask it what it is willing to do?
We know that the First Minister has not asked the question about the MPC or the question about the banker of last resort. If he gets his way, we are less than four years away from leaving the UK on a wing and a prayer, yet on the currency and our interest rates and how much we would be able to spend, how much we could borrow and how much tax we could raise, he has done nothing. He asserts that an independent Scotland could rely on the Bank of England, but he has not even asked the bank; it is just meaningless assertion after meaningless assertion. If he wants the Bank of England to back a separate Scotland, why does he not at least ask it what it is willing to do?
I am answering and giving an explanation of what I believe the position would be. I am not responsible for Johann Lamont not being able to ask the right questions. I am answering the questions—[Laughter.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I have set out the context of monetary policy and how it is administered. I have set out the shape of the monetary policy committee of the Bank of England. I have pointed out to Johann Lamont that the Bank of England has been an independent bank since 1997 to give it freedom from political determination. I have set out the reasons why it would be not just to Scotland’s advantage but to the advantage of the rest of the UK to have the sterling zone that we propose.
The sterling zone! [Laughter.]
The sterling zone is a matter that is well understood in terms of currencies and polity. [Interruption.] I do not know why the Labour Party should find such a simple explanation so—it is revealing of the Labour Party’s attitude.
It is a reasonable proposition in the current circumstances that it is to the advantage of Scotland to have the sterling zone. It is of substantial advantage to the rest of the United Kingdom because of the protection that Scottish resources give to the balance of payments. Under the circumstances, why is that not a proposition that we should put to the Scottish people? As Johann Lamont knows, we will publish a white paper next year that will set out the independence proposition, and I will be delighted to take her forecast on the timescale for Scottish independence. On whether she should throw in the deck at this stage or wait for four years, four years sounds fine to me and I think that it will sound fine to the people of Scotland.
It is a reasonable proposition in the current circumstances that it is to the advantage of Scotland to have the sterling zone. It is of substantial advantage to the rest of the United Kingdom because of the protection that Scottish resources give to the balance of payments. Under the circumstances, why is that not a proposition that we should put to the Scottish people? As Johann Lamont knows, we will publish a white paper next year that will set out the independence proposition, and I will be delighted to take her forecast on the timescale for Scottish independence. On whether she should throw in the deck at this stage or wait for four years, four years sounds fine to me and I think that it will sound fine to the people of Scotland.
I did not realise that there was a right question for me to ask the First Minister, given that the only right question that his back benchers are allowed to ask is, “Just how good are you, First Minister?”
This is a serious issue. Given the First Minister’s response today, it is no wonder that he flopped at the box office last Friday; it is no wonder that his deputy bombed on the television on Sunday night; and it is no wonder that, this week, some supporters have started backing away from independence. If he is going to put the country through another two and a half years of this constitutional quagmire, he could at least do some work so that his words have some meaning. When will the First Minister realise that just saying something does not make it true?
This is a serious issue. Given the First Minister’s response today, it is no wonder that he flopped at the box office last Friday; it is no wonder that his deputy bombed on the television on Sunday night; and it is no wonder that, this week, some supporters have started backing away from independence. If he is going to put the country through another two and a half years of this constitutional quagmire, he could at least do some work so that his words have some meaning. When will the First Minister realise that just saying something does not make it true?
On the proposition that we will put forward in the white paper next year and the timescale for the referendum that we have set out, I am interested in Johann Lamont’s belief that the independence campaign will lack the strength and vigour of the Tory-Labour alliance that will be set against it. The secret six met recently at Alistair Darling’s home. When I was a child, I occasionally read Enid Blyton’s books about the secret seven, and the secret six are no doubt something very similar. The Labour-Tory alliance against independence—which we see so well displayed in this chamber—will be limited in numbers, limited in enthusiasm and, above all, limited in its ambition for the people of Scotland. I know that, these days, Johann Lamont has taken to speaking on behalf of the people of Scotland, but maybe she should take the precaution of getting herself elected before she makes that presumption.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 31 May 2012 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- European Strategy and Minor Rule Changes Debate · 3
- Land Registration etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 28
- Land Registration etc (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 30
- Victims of Crime (Support) Questions · 6
- General Practitioner Surgeries (Remote Areas) (Support) Questions · 6
- Land Reform Questions · 8
- Unemployment Questions · 4
- International Trade Forums Questions · 4
- Concessionary Travel Scheme Questions · 4
- Scotland-Norway Interconnector Questions · 8
- Planning Applications Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- RAF Leuchars First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Healthcare (Access Target) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Business Start-ups by 18 to 24-year-olds. First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Diploma in Professional Legal Practice Students (Financial Assistance) Questions · 7
- Modern Apprenticeships Questions · 4
- Commission on the Delivery of Rural Education Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games (Schools Refurbishment) Questions · 5
- Adult Apprenticeships Questions · 5
- Health and Safety (Primary Schools) Questions · 6
- Curriculum for Excellence Questions · 4
- “Communication Matters: Improving Communication in Additional Support Needs” Questions · 6
- Special Schools Pupils (Assistance into Employment) Questions · 4
- Integrated Learning (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 4
- Degrees (Employer Demand) Questions · 6
- Post-16 Education Questions · 7
- Student Management Fees (Legal Advice) Questions · 4
- Postgraduate Education (Access) Questions · 4
- New Technologies in Schools Questions · 6
- Further and Higher Education (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Youth Unemployment (Co-ordination with United Kingdom Government) Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Future Debate · 158
- Decision Time Decision time · 8
- A75 (Improvements) Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.