Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Gypsy Traveller Encampments (Guidance) (PE1364)

Tuesday 21 February 2012 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 11 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are six current petitions for consideration today. The first is PE1364, in the name of Phyllis McBain, on clarifying guidelines on Gypsy Traveller encampments. Members have a note by the clerk on the petition. Two members, Alison McInnes and Nigel Don, have taken a great interest in the petition. Does either of them wish to make any initial comments?

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Thank you, convener. I am very happy to do so. Wearing the constituency MSP’s hat, I guess that I should at least try to do so. As members will be aware, I have been involved with the petition from the beginning because I was a member of the committee when it first appeared before us. It seems like a very long haul and I cannot see it finishing any time soon.However, I think that the story has moved on from where we started. The Government and local authorities now clearly understand that we cannot do anything to resolve the issues around Travellers unless there are enough sites. That has not happened, so I do not think that we need to have too much discussion about it. That is where we have now got to.The particular issue that the petitioner brings to us today—I welcome her again and I think that her presence helps us to clarify our thinking—is the position of the private landowner who finds herself, quite simply, being invaded. The document “Guidelines for Managing Unauthorised Camping by Gypsies/Travellers in Scotland”, which is being reviewed, sets out what local authorities and the police should do, but it essentially speaks in terms of local authority land. The “Site Protection” section of the guidelines tells local authorities what to do if it is their own land, but it also states:“Local authorities ... can advise private landowners how best to secure their land.”However, local authorities have no responsibility to do so. Equally, the advice states:“The local authority is seen as the lead agency in the management of unauthorised encampments including removals”but“Private landowners should take their own legal advice and action, where appropriate.”That is as much as private landowners are left with, which I think is the nub of the problem.I have said before—I am grateful to the clerk for reminding us, and the Government did respond to this—that local authorities could take some initiative here. The fact that Travellers are on private land does not change the fact that they are in the local authority’s area and the local authority understands the legal process. In fact, for the local authorities in question, this is standard practice. It would be easy for a local authority lawyer to go through the process of eviction or whatever, whereas it is difficult for a private landowner who has suddenly been invaded to do that when they have no experience of it.The other point that I think the petitioner is making is that the local authority knows how to manage sites. I suggest that, when an unauthorised encampment arrives on private land, it would be sensible for the local authority to inspect it, to give it a temporary licence and to get some rudimentary organisation around it.The final thing that I extract from the papers in front of me is the petitioner’s concern that the police struggle to deal with what are undoubtedly criminal activities on a site that are often to do with litter and damage. She recognises that, as I think that we all will, although it might be clear that somebody in the group did it, it is almost impossible for the police to decide which individual did it and therefore to bring charges under the current legal regime.Those are the issues that are in front of us and that we must try to deal with. There are some suggestions as to how that might be done.15:15

Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

I endorse all that Nigel Don has said. I am here to support the petitioner, who is one of my constituents, too. Although the Government has set up a review, there are concerns about the transparency, speed and thoroughness of that review. I urge the committee to keep an eye on the petition for some time yet and not to give up the ghost just because a review has been put in place. There is no doubt in my mind that the local authorities’ role should be enhanced. There must be a way of harnessing their experience and expertise by providing clarity. That is the clarity that the petitioner seeks from the Scottish Government. We are looking for leadership from the Scottish Government on this thorny issue.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

I will comment, just to make it a north-east trio, which Nanette Milne might make a quartet in a minute.I agree that we should keep the petition open. I recall that we raised the issue of the responsibilities relating to private land when the committee discussed the petition previously, but the questions do not seem to have been answered in any meaningful way. I used the example of an area in Dyce that I represent as a councillor in Aberdeen and now as an MSP, where there is a section of public land with a piece of private land adjacent to it. A Traveller encampment arrived and spread itself across the two pieces of land, which are separated by a small access road. The private landowner and the public authority both pursued evictions, which happened at different speeds. The private landowner achieved the eviction in advance of the local authority doing so, but the Travellers who were evicted moved across to the public land and suddenly a new eviction process had to be considered because the size of the encampment had changed.There is an issue with the way in which the judicial process works for public bodies and private individuals. It does not always work at the same speed or in a joined-up way. We need to highlight that and clarify the situation. Perhaps in circumstances in which a boundary is crossed, we need to have one responsible individual or authority so that, rather than having two applications for eviction, there is a single eviction application, which would make the process simpler.Aside from that, we all recognise that the Traveller community has rights, but we must ensure that we provide sites for Travellers so that we do not have situations such as those that have been experienced by Mrs McBain and others. That is another aspect that I am keen to tease out in the review. The problem that we found in Aberdeen was that everybody thinks that a site for Travellers is great, but nobody wants it where they are. Squaring that circle is a problem. How do we get people to accept not just that we need sites, but that we need them in particular locations? That is another issue that we should explore.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I will indeed make us a north-east quartet.I agree with everything that has been said so far. We know that a review has commenced and that the Government agrees that the guidance is out of date and needs to be changed. According to our papers, officials will meet with COSLA to agree an approach to updating guidance and, thereafter, there will be wider liaison with stakeholders, including people such as Mrs McBain. The “thereafter” bit concerns me, because the stakeholders should be an integral part now and not thereafter. The petitioner has asked what the terms of reference for the review are. We should know that. The issue should be opened up for public debate. We have the papers before us that set out what the petitioner would like. I totally agree with her requests. I suggest that we write to the Government in fairly firm terms suggesting that people such as Mrs McBain—I am sure that there are other private landowners in the same situation—should be involved as stakeholders in formulating what is important guidance for their future.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I will throw my tuppenceworth in as someone from the Glasgow area. I found the evidence from Nigel Don and Alison McInnes very helpful because I am not involved in the issue as closely as they are. From what they said, I wonder whether the Government’s recommendations for new guidelines go far enough. I very much agree with what Nanette Milne said about stakeholders, and about taking the issue further and involving the petitioner and others. I thank Nigel Don and Alison McInnes for their evidence, which enlightened me about what is happening up in the north-east. We should continue the petition.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Although I am from the central belt and not the north-east of Scotland, I live quite close to a former Gypsy Traveller site that was closed by the local authority some years ago. I am at a loss about the wider debate because we hear that there are not enough sites for Gypsy Travellers, yet local authorities are closing down sites in central Scotland. It raises the question of how Gypsy Traveller sites have been identified in the past and how the resources could have been used to more beneficial effect. Where I live, a number of Gypsy Traveller families have moved into residential properties with land at the back of them. Some of the land is being used by individuals who would see themselves as part of the Gypsy Traveller community. The petitioner has put down in black and white the kind of issues that the Government should be considering. The committee should send the petitioner’s latest submission to the Government and ask it to address all of the issues raised. There are many practical solutions to the problems that are faced by landowners, Gypsy Travellers and others in relation to the management of sites. I support other colleagues who have said that we need to know what the remit of the review will be. There is no point in carrying out a review if it does not cover the issues that have been identified by the petitioner, and others throughout Scotland who face similar problems. It would be useful if we could urge the Government to give us sight of what will be in the review and what the criteria for the review will be.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank members for their contributions. We have a unanimous view on the importance of keeping the petition open. Members have raised a series of questions that remain unanswered, not least on the issue of site development. Members will know that we have had a letter from the minister, Michael Matheson, saying:“Officials have written to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA), to set up a meeting early in the New Year to agree an approach to update the Guidance and to link into any other work that is being progressed. Following this, a wider liaison with stakeholders, including the petitioner ... will be undertaken.”It is a good suggestion that the petitioner’s latest comments should be forwarded to the minister. There is a series of unanswered questions. It is a very difficult issue, but it is vital that we continue the petition and keep an active interest in it.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

We should involve the petitioner now rather than waiting until further down the line.

Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

Nanette Milne made the point that we ought to see the terms of reference for the review. It would be good if the Government were open about that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a good point. I am sure that the clerk will take that on board when writing to the Government. I thank members for the discussion and thank our two guests for attending.

  1. 14:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petition Petitions · 94
  3. 14:00 New Petition Petitions · 4
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.