Item 2 is consideration of six current petitions. We will take the first two petitions together; they are on school bus safety. PE1098 is by Lynn Merrifield, on behalf of Kingseat community council, and PE1223 is by Ron Beaty. I welcome Mr Beaty, who I understand is in the gallery.Members have a note by the clerk—paper 3 refers—and the submissions. I invite contributions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
School Bus Safety (PE1098 and PE1223)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 7
- Mark McDonald SNP 3
- Nanette Milne Con 3
- Joe FitzPatrick SNP 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
15 contributionsThe saga continues. I note the letter from the Department for Transport and what leaps out at me is that this“is unlikely to be a short process, perhaps taking up to 12 months to complete.”This does not strike me as the most complicated matter for Governments to resolve between them. It worries me that we may be looking at another 12 months of protracted wrangling between legal teams from Transport Scotland and the Department for Transport. Beyond the suggestion in the clerk’s note, I want to find out exactly what is so complicated that resolving the process will require another 12 months of to-ing and fro-ing. We should write to Transport Scotland and the Department for Transport to ask that question, because frankly this is getting beyond a joke.
I agree with Mark McDonald; he makes a good point.The letter that I got from Mike Penning MP, who is the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport, stated:“Of course, if the powers are devolved, you will be able to take the matter further than I intend to do—regarding the size of the signage, anyway”.Mike Penning has been positive and he understands that the issue would sit better as a responsibility of the Scottish Government, rather than at Westminster.
I do not think that anyone doubts that the political will is there, but it seems that there are issues behind the scenes that are holding this up. Essentially, it seems that the legal teams are dragging their heels. I do not question the politicians’ desire to get the matter resolved; the problem appears to be the process.
I am not sure where the stumbling block is, but I am concerned that although Transport Scotland’s response indicates that signage is reserved to the UK Government—we know that—there are no plans to devolve it to the Scottish Government. After all that has happened in the past couple of years, I am intrigued as to why, as far as Transport Scotland is concerned, there are no plans to do that. Like Mark McDonald, I want to find out what is behind that.It has been suggested that a meeting could be held with local authority representatives and other stakeholders to discuss what could be done on school safety ahead of the matter being devolved. If we are to have such a meeting—I think that it is a good idea—I would want the petitioners to be included as attendees. Mr Beaty, who has been a regular attender at the committee’s meetings, would have a significant input to make.
I echo Nanette Milne’s point: the area should be devolved and it would be good if we could clearly send that message. However, I do not think that we should wait for that to happen for the issue to be resolved. Mark McDonald is correct in saying that, if the political will is there, the legal heads should be forced to ensure that that happens as quickly as possible.
I express my disappointment, too. The committee heard evidence on 26 October 2010 from the UK and Scottish Government ministers during the previous parliamentary session. At that time, the clear indication was that the issue could be resolved in a matter of months and that it was just a case of the two teams from the Department for Transport and Transport Scotland getting together to work out what powers would need to devolved to the Scottish Government. However, the issue has been dragging on.Mike Penning’s letter is worrying in a number of respects, not least in the suggestion that, as Mark McDonald indicated, it could take up to 12 months for the matter to be resolved. We are 18 months down the road from the meeting at which we were told that that could be done in a matter of months.I seek the committee’s leave to request clarification from Transport Scotland and the Scottish Government minister on the comment that is made about Transport Scotland in Mike Penning’s letter. The second paragraph states:“I also indicated that I understood Transport Scotland was discussing options with Scottish ministers before providing further clarity on this point.”It would be useful to find out why there has been such a delay in Transport Scotland advising the minister.We took evidence in a follow-up session with the Minister for Housing and Transport on 28 June 2011—almost a year ago—and were assured that matters were moving apace. Clearly, that is not the case, which is disappointing. Therefore—as well as writing to the Department for Transport—we should write to Transport Scotland and to the Scottish Government minister to ask what is happening, what powers should be transferred to the Scottish Government and why there has been such a delay.The petitioners, Lynn Merrifield and Ron Beaty, have explained exactly what they are looking for and what powers to change legislation they want to be transferred to the Scottish Government. If the Department for Transport and Transport Scotland do not by now understand the petitioners’ message or what powers they want the Scottish Government to have, we might be at a bit of a loss to convince those bodies in future.
The letter from the UK Government suggests that the delay is at the Transport Scotland end. We need some form of satisfaction, through a response from Transport Scotland. I am minded to suggest that, if we do not get a satisfactory response, the committee should have Transport Scotland back in front of us on the petition. Mr Beaty gives up a huge amount of his time to come to committee meetings, only to find that there has been pretty much zero progress. That is not acceptable, given the amount of time that he is devoting to the issue and the amount of time that the committee is taking to try to get some form of resolution to the issue.
On one level, there is almost a disrespect to the committee, because it is not as though Transport Scotland is in any doubt about the strength of our view. Therefore, Mark McDonald makes a reasonable point.I want to return to Nanette Milne’s suggestion that, notwithstanding the delay, we should have an event that involves local authorities. The clerk has suggested that it might be sensible to seek to have an event in the chamber so that we can invite several local authorities. I am sure that the Conveners Group would be interested in a bid for such an event. Do members agree that we should pursue that?Members indicated agreement.
It is clear that we want to continue the petition and indicate our strength of feeling to Transport Scotland on the issue. Obviously, we will also refer the issue to the other agencies that members have mentioned. Do members have any other suggestions for action?
If we are inviting stakeholders to an event in the chamber, will that include Transport Scotland?
We should perhaps discuss that later, but it is certainly a possibility.
We should bear it in mind.
Do members agree to continue the petition in the ways that I have set out?Members indicated agreement.
I thank Ron Beaty for coming along again today and for his patience.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Jun 2012 →- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 56
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 10
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.