Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Youth Football (PE1319)

Tuesday 24 January 2012 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 10 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

PE1319, which was lodged by William Smith and Scott Robertson, is about improving youth football. Members have a note by the clerk, which is paper 4, a briefing from the Scottish Parliament information centre, and submissions. There was a helpful article on the RealGrassroots campaign in The Herald today. It was well written and put the arguments extremely well.I remind members that I am a trustee of Inverness Caledonian Thistle Football Club.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I am not a member of a board, but I thoroughly enjoy football and I would like our young people to be trained up so that we can have a great national team and be as successful as some of the European teams are—FC Barcelona is one of my favourites and I would love to watch some of the Scottish teams play like that.When I looked through the papers I was shocked by the contract issue. I am a lay person, so I did not realise that kids are tied into a contract for three years—the Scottish Football Association says that it is for a year—and that if they want out of the contract or back in again they must appeal to the secretary. There are dangers in that approach. I would dearly love our consideration of the petition to continue. We need to look into the issue, particularly the SFA’s point of view, in greater detail.I congratulate RealGrassroots on what it is trying to achieve. Such an approach is taken in other countries in Europe and we should perhaps take the good points from, if not emulate, what is going on. It is quite frightening to think that a young person can enter into a contract for three years and not be allowed to play school football or for other teams. I am concerned about the whole thing—Interruption. Sorry, the clerk is reminding me that the petition is not necessarily about young people playing for other football teams. We must think about the future of football in Scotland, and youth football is the start of that. I will listen to other members’ comments, but I think that we need to investigate the whole issue, particularly in relation to the SFA and others.

Bill Walker SNP Dunfermline
link

I declare an interest as a long-serving, longsuffering fan of Heart of Midlothian Football Club.Sandra White put it well, and I am all for helping to develop football, too. There are many positive aspects, despite some of the negative stuff—I am thinking about recent behaviour. I am concerned that very young people are tied into contracts, even when there is parental guidance and so on. It is a big issue. We should continue our consideration of the petition and look into the issue a bit more.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

As you know, convener, I am keen that we continue the petition. I found some of the responses quite interesting, particularly the response from IFK Gothenburg and what it said about the comparisons that can be drawn between the experience of young players in Sweden and that of young players here. In relation to the school football issue, which Sandra White raised, it would appear that in Sweden there is no objection to players continuing to turn out for their school team as well as for IFK Gothenburg’s youth team, provided that there is some form of liaison between the club and the school on the timing of matches and so on.I am disappointed that we did not receive a response from the Scottish Professional Footballers Association. Given that it is, essentially, the trade union for footballers, I would have thought that it would have had some comments to make on contracts and compensation. I wonder whether, in addition to pursuing the recommendations of Sandra White and the clerks and continuing the petition, we might write again to the SPFA to ask it for its response to the petition, because it is important that the organisation that works on behalf of professional footballers in Scotland has some input to consideration of the petition.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I am not sure how other members of the committee feel about this, but the submission from RealGrassroots makes a number of suggestions about people from whom we could take further oral evidence. I know that we have taken quite a lot of oral evidence on the petition, but perhaps it would be worth inviting some or all of those people to discuss matters with the committee.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My view is that the petition would be an ideal one on which to hold some sort of round-table event. I know that our predecessor committee took evidence on the petition, but some things have moved on.Although I understand the point that FIFA and the Scottish Football Association make with some strength—that football is their responsibility and that our job lies somewhere else—it is clear that issues arise to do with the employment of young people, the European convention on human rights and contracts generally. Those are areas in which we have a responsibility, and my view is that we should take up the suggestion from RealGrassroots. We should, however, let the clerk look at the detail of its suggestion, because it might not be appropriate for us to take evidence from all the organisations that it suggests.One person whom I think it might be quite useful to invite to give evidence is Henry McLeish. As the author of the review of Scottish football and a prominent former First Minister, I think that he would have a lot to offer in a round-table event. Would members feel comfortable if we continued the petition and got the clerk to look into the detail of whom it would be appropriate to invite?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I accept that it might be possible to hold a round-table discussion, but our predecessor committee had Henry McLeish here on 5 October 2010 and, 12 months ago, it held a round-table discussion involving the SFA, the Minister for Public Health and Sport and representatives of two of the major football clubs in Scotland, so we need to be careful about having another round-table discussion on the petition.Although I welcome the suggestion from RealGrassroots about which people we could invite, I would prefer to see something in writing from the organisations concerned before we set up another round-table discussion. Developments are under way. As the convener rightly identified, the debate has moved on quite a bit, particularly with the McLeish review and the fact that the SFA’s structures are changing to accommodate it.I support the clerk’s recommendation that we write to the SFA to ask what discussions there have been within the organisation on contracts and compensation, in relation to which Trish Godman put on record her commitment in the previous session. When our predecessor committee discussed the issue, a number of comments were made and it was clear that there was a lack of clarity from the SFA on what was happening on the ground.Although we got feedback from two major clubs, several other clubs—including Hearts, which has been mentioned—were disappointed that they were not asked to give evidence at the round-table discussion. Several Scottish clubs have good youth development programmes. The issue is how we sift through that to find out what is happening and what opportunities young people are being denied or given to participate fully in football at every level in their life.As I said, we should ask the SFA whether there have been any developments or discussions. We should also write to the Scottish Government to ask how it monitors the use of the public funds that go to the SFA from the cashback for communities programme. When the SFA gave evidence to our predecessor committee a year ago, it said that there were issues regarding public money but that the SFA had to be separated from the political system. However, the SFA receives a substantial amount of money from the cashback for communities programme. It would be useful to find out how that feeds into the youth football programme. The wider point in the petition is about how we develop football in future, not only at the local level, but at the national and international levels. Those issues could be raised to try to take the debate forward.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I do not think that our predecessor committee heard from the Scottish Youth Football Association—I cannot remember, but I see no mention of it in the papers that are before us. That organisation would have a relevant input so, if we were to have an evidence session, I would like it to be involved.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link

A round-table session on the issue would be worth while, although I query whether we should invite all the people whom RealGrassroots has listed, as that would not necessarily give us the balanced discussion that we want. Some individuals on the list have a particular niche interest, whereas we want a wider overview of the situation. We should write to some of the organisations that have been mentioned, particularly those that have not yet responded. At a future meeting, we can discuss whom to invite to a round-table session.The issue of youth development in Scotland is extremely important and has been set in stark light recently because of the high-profile transfers of Scott Allan from Dundee United to West Bromwich Albion and Jack Grimmer from Aberdeen to Fulham. Those transfers have raised questions about how youth football and youth development in Scotland can produce players to ply their trade in Scotland.The convener mentioned that the SFA and FIFA had suggested that we should not pay too much attention to the issue because, in essence, it is their domain. I do not have the statistics at my fingertips, but I suspect that a tiny percentage of the children who are currently on the books at football clubs will ever actually make it in the game. The issue is about who is responsible for the wider development of those youngsters and who, in essence, picks up the pieces when those kids are put on the scrap heap by football clubs. It is absolutely imperative that we take an interest in that. We should invite people for a round-table session once we have written to the various organisations and discussed the responses at a future meeting.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Mark McDonald makes a strong point. All members are heading in the right direction, in that the suggestion that we hold a round-table session is good in principle. However, there is a stage before that that involves sifting through the information and seeking written evidence. We agree that, as representatives of the Scottish Parliament, we have a locus in the issue that relates to the employment—or otherwise—of young people, the European convention on human rights and the generation of sport. As John Wilson said, lots of public funding goes into football. We are not here to put a downer on the football management bodies in Scotland. Individually, we all have great faith in football. However, the petitioners have raised good points and the petition is original and strong. I suggest that we consider it carefully in what will be an interesting round-table session. We will organise that with the help of the clerk once we have further information.Do members agree that we should continue this strong petition, with a view to having a round-table session once we have received written information, and to pursue the points that have been raised?Members indicated agreement.

  1. 14:00 Interests Procedure · 4
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 10
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.