1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00270)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
The record
12 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00270)
I shall have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Presiding Officer, 215,000 Scots are unemployed and 100,000 young people are without work. How many Scots have to find themselves on the dole before the First Minister admits that his plan MacB is not working?
The unemployment situation in Scotland is extremely serious. The Government is working flat out to generate the maximum number of jobs, but even Iain Gray would have to accept that the position on aggregate demand in the United Kingdom is set by the UK Government. Within that context, the Scottish Government is being successful. We have lower unemployment, higher employment and lower economic inactivity than the rest of the United Kingdom. That is an important aspect that indicates that some of the efforts we are making are bearing fruit in bringing people back into employment and generating employment for our young people.
Is that really the limit of the Scottish National Party’s ambition? Is that what they call success, to be not quite as terrible as the Tories? Even given that very low bar, youth unemployment in Scotland is higher than in the UK as a whole. George Osborne is cutting too fast and too deep, but is it not the truth that Alex Salmond is cutting capital budgets and public sector jobs even faster and even deeper than the Tories?
I do not know where to start with Iain Gray, but let us examine his record. In the period when Scottish unemployment was higher than that of the rest of the UK—it was a brief period in comparison with the Labour Party’s record in office—Iain Gray mentioned it seven times, at virtually every First Minister’s question time. Indeed, in his valedictory address as leader of the Opposition, when he thought that he was going into government, he said:
“Here is the figure that matters. Alex Salmond inherited a Scotland with lower unemployment than the rest of the country, and he leaves a Scotland with higher unemployment than the rest of the country.”—[Official Report, 17 March 2011; c 34602-3]
So, on 17 March that was the figure that mattered. Now, at a time when, thanks to the efforts of the Scottish Government to mitigate the impact of Westminster cutbacks, employment in Scotland is higher than that in the rest of the United Kingdom and unemployment is lower, all of a sudden that does not matter any more. Of course it matters. It is one of the figures that matter. As for ambition, my ambition and that of the Scottish National Party is to have this country free to harness its resources and to bring wealth and employment to all our people.
“Here is the figure that matters. Alex Salmond inherited a Scotland with lower unemployment than the rest of the country, and he leaves a Scotland with higher unemployment than the rest of the country.”—[Official Report, 17 March 2011; c 34602-3]
So, on 17 March that was the figure that mattered. Now, at a time when, thanks to the efforts of the Scottish Government to mitigate the impact of Westminster cutbacks, employment in Scotland is higher than that in the rest of the United Kingdom and unemployment is lower, all of a sudden that does not matter any more. Of course it matters. It is one of the figures that matter. As for ambition, my ambition and that of the Scottish National Party is to have this country free to harness its resources and to bring wealth and employment to all our people.
If any of the 215,000 unemployed people are listening, that will not sound like a plan MacB to them. It will sound like nothing but a lot of MacMince, which is what they have come to expect from their First Minister.
Between last year and this, George Osborne cut capital budgets by 11 per cent; Alex Salmond cut them by 21 per cent. George Osborne got rid of 3.8 per cent of public sector jobs; Alex Salmond got rid of 4.1 per cent. George Osborne cut colleges by 3 or 4 per cent, but Alex Salmond cut ours by 10 per cent. If Alex Salmond cannot give those 100,000 young people a job, he can at least give them the truth. Will he admit that he is cutting faster and deeper than the Tories and that that is why unemployment is rising in Scotland?
Between last year and this, George Osborne cut capital budgets by 11 per cent; Alex Salmond cut them by 21 per cent. George Osborne got rid of 3.8 per cent of public sector jobs; Alex Salmond got rid of 4.1 per cent. George Osborne cut colleges by 3 or 4 per cent, but Alex Salmond cut ours by 10 per cent. If Alex Salmond cannot give those 100,000 young people a job, he can at least give them the truth. Will he admit that he is cutting faster and deeper than the Tories and that that is why unemployment is rising in Scotland?
Employment in Scotland is higher than it was at this time last year, unemployment is lower than it was at this time last year, and unemployment in the rest of the United Kingdom is at its highest for 20 years.
Let us dispense with the nonsense about capital spending that I have heard Labour Party spokespeople repeat many times over the past few days. Iain Gray should really beware of taking any lines from Richard Baker. The reason that capital investment is being cut in Scotland is that it is allocated using the Barnett formula. It is being cut harder in Scotland and Wales and in the devolved authorities because of the Barnett formula. In other words, the non-devolved departments are getting slightly less capital spending cutbacks than the devolved departments, but before we just blame the Tory-Liberal coalition Government, we should realise that it is proceeding with exactly the capital plans that were set out by the Labour chancellor, Alistair Darling—the man who was going to cut deeper and tougher than Margaret Thatcher. He said in his memoirs that his plans lacked credibility because they were not tough enough.
What are we doing about the Westminster cutback in capital spending? We are shifting £750 million from resource to capital spending, and we have a non-profit-distribution programme that will generate £2.5 billion in capital spending. That gives us a capital spending total that is unique in these islands, rising every year to 2014-15. That is real action to help real people. The Labour Party chooses to engage in collective amnesia about where the capital cuts came from: they came from Westminster Labour rule.
Let us dispense with the nonsense about capital spending that I have heard Labour Party spokespeople repeat many times over the past few days. Iain Gray should really beware of taking any lines from Richard Baker. The reason that capital investment is being cut in Scotland is that it is allocated using the Barnett formula. It is being cut harder in Scotland and Wales and in the devolved authorities because of the Barnett formula. In other words, the non-devolved departments are getting slightly less capital spending cutbacks than the devolved departments, but before we just blame the Tory-Liberal coalition Government, we should realise that it is proceeding with exactly the capital plans that were set out by the Labour chancellor, Alistair Darling—the man who was going to cut deeper and tougher than Margaret Thatcher. He said in his memoirs that his plans lacked credibility because they were not tough enough.
What are we doing about the Westminster cutback in capital spending? We are shifting £750 million from resource to capital spending, and we have a non-profit-distribution programme that will generate £2.5 billion in capital spending. That gives us a capital spending total that is unique in these islands, rising every year to 2014-15. That is real action to help real people. The Labour Party chooses to engage in collective amnesia about where the capital cuts came from: they came from Westminster Labour rule.
I see that the First Minister has won a couple of awards in the past week. It would be churlish of me not to congratulate him, but with unemployment in Scotland standing at 215,000 and at 100,000 for young people, if there was a complacent politician of the year award, he would run away with it.
The First Minister likes to talk about a mythical independence generation. This generation is on its own, okay—100,000 of them. He will give them a wristband that says, “It’s starting”, but he will not give them a start, a job, an opportunity or a future.
I see that Alex Salmond would like to be called Prime Minister in a separate Scotland. Does not that tell us everything that we need to know about his Government’s priorities? When will he stop thinking about his next job and give our young people a first job so that they can make a start in life?
The First Minister likes to talk about a mythical independence generation. This generation is on its own, okay—100,000 of them. He will give them a wristband that says, “It’s starting”, but he will not give them a start, a job, an opportunity or a future.
I see that Alex Salmond would like to be called Prime Minister in a separate Scotland. Does not that tell us everything that we need to know about his Government’s priorities? When will he stop thinking about his next job and give our young people a first job so that they can make a start in life?
Let us look at the track record of Scottish National Party ministers, who are working hard to generate employment in Scotland, and the great international companies that have decided in the past few months to locate their activities here: Mitsubishi, Doosan, State Street, BNY Mellon, Gamesa, Dell, INEOS/PetroChina, Aker, FMC Technologies, Vion Hall’s, Avaloq, Amazon and TAQA. Let us consider all those companies and the efforts of SNP ministers and our officials in gathering that investment to Scotland. What has the Labour Party been doing? It is in cahoots with the Tories, trying to talk Scotland down at every opportunity.
The Labour Party says that responsibility lies with only the Scottish Government, despite the fact that it knows full well where the cutbacks are coming from. Its five-point plan for growth gives the game away, of course. I have already dealt with capital investment, but the other four points that Labour’s plan for growth entails are all requests of the Westminster Government. Labour in opposition is lobbying the Westminster Government because it knows that that is where the economic power lies at present over the Scottish economy and the Scottish people. That is why the SNP’s ambition is to harness Scotland’s resources and put them to work for the Scottish people, and that is why Iain Gray will never be called First Minister.
The Labour Party says that responsibility lies with only the Scottish Government, despite the fact that it knows full well where the cutbacks are coming from. Its five-point plan for growth gives the game away, of course. I have already dealt with capital investment, but the other four points that Labour’s plan for growth entails are all requests of the Westminster Government. Labour in opposition is lobbying the Westminster Government because it knows that that is where the economic power lies at present over the Scottish economy and the Scottish people. That is why the SNP’s ambition is to harness Scotland’s resources and put them to work for the Scottish people, and that is why Iain Gray will never be called First Minister.
Let the First Minister not dare call it talking Scotland down when I speak up for 100,000 unemployed young Scots. Somebody must speak for them, because neither he nor his supine back benches are doing so.
Let us look at his ministers’ record. Over the past two years, the number of people unemployed is worse; the unemployment rate is worse; the employment rate is worse; and the economic activity rate is worse. That is their record. Not only should ministers be ashamed of it, but the First Minister should tell us now what he is going to do about it.
Let us look at his ministers’ record. Over the past two years, the number of people unemployed is worse; the unemployment rate is worse; the employment rate is worse; and the economic activity rate is worse. That is their record. Not only should ministers be ashamed of it, but the First Minister should tell us now what he is going to do about it.
I note that Iain Gray has changed to talking about two years. Otherwise, he would have to acknowledge that in Scotland—uniquely, in the United Kingdom—unemployment has gone down and employment has gone up over the past year.
In the UK, Labour is in power in one place: Wales. I am not going to criticise the Government of Wales, because it is under the same strictures of Westminster cutbacks that we are. If Labour has the answer to economic problems and unemployment, why are unemployment and youth unemployment in Wales higher than they are in Scotland? If Labour has the magic solutions, why is it not implementing them in the one place in these islands where it is still in government? The failure to come forward with answers when in government in the UK, or to realise that it was in cahoots with the Tories in trying to discourage investment in Scotland, is why Labour failed in the election and why it is on the route to extinction in this country.
In the UK, Labour is in power in one place: Wales. I am not going to criticise the Government of Wales, because it is under the same strictures of Westminster cutbacks that we are. If Labour has the answer to economic problems and unemployment, why are unemployment and youth unemployment in Wales higher than they are in Scotland? If Labour has the magic solutions, why is it not implementing them in the one place in these islands where it is still in government? The failure to come forward with answers when in government in the UK, or to realise that it was in cahoots with the Tories in trying to discourage investment in Scotland, is why Labour failed in the election and why it is on the route to extinction in this country.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 17 Nov 2011 →- Housing Debate · 79
- Public Sector Debate · 63
- Road Equivalent Tariff (Orkney) Questions · 6
- Gritting (North Lanarkshire Council) Questions · 4
- Combined Heat and Power Questions · 6
- Tenancy Deposit Protection Scheme Questions · 4
- Public-private Partnerships (Scottish Trades Union Congress Protocol) Questions · 4
- Tourism (Olympic Games) Questions · 6
- British Waterways Scotland (Waterfront Development and Public Safety) Questions · 4
- Unemployment (Older People) Questions · 4
- Motorway Gantry Signage Questions · 4
- VAT (House Extensions and Improvements) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Teachers (Industrial Action) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Inward Investment First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Unemployment (Women) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fossil Fuel Levy First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Scottish Prison Service Questions · 8
- Police Complaints Commissioner for Scotland (Single Police Force) Questions · 6
- Proceeds of Crime (Allocation) Questions · 4
- Drug Dealers Questions · 4
- Criminal Cases (Evidence of Similar Fact) Questions · 4
- Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 Questions · 4
- Prisoners (Looked-after Children) Questions · 4
- Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (Discussions with Victims’ Families) Questions · 4
- Animal Welfare Questions · 6
- Landfill Sites (Life Extensions) Questions · 6
- NFU Scotland Questions · 6
- Litter Questions · 6
- Common Agricultural Policy (Reform) Questions · 6
- Greenpark Energy (Licence to Extract Shale Gas) Questions · 8
- Climate Change Questions · 4
- Food Safety (European Regulations) Questions · 4
- Oil and Gas Sector Debate · 81
- Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures Bill Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 22
- Heartstart Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.