1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00164)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00164)
I have a range of engagements that will carry forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
How disappointingly mundane. On Tuesday, the First Minister told a conference that he was leading the greatest step forward for civilisation since the hunter-gatherers put down roots 10,000 years ago. I thought that, this afternoon, he might at least be ushering in an epoch of world peace or perhaps personally parting the North Sea for the interconnector to Norway. Perhaps he could just try to keep his promise to protect the national health service budget in real terms. Why is he cutting Scotland’s NHS budget by £300 million?
The budget to health boards—the revenue budget of the NHS—has been protected in real terms by the Government. Of course, that is unlike what would have happened if the great misfortune had occurred—which would almost be approximate to parting the North Sea and just about as likely, incidentally—and the Labour Party had come to office. I know that Iain Gray has spent a lot of time this week reprising the election campaign and I do not want to add to his agony, but does he not remember saying on “Newsnight Scotland” a year ago:
“We wouldn’t ring fence the health budget”?
We know that Labour did not mean to pass on the consequentials because the Labour Party in government in Wales has not passed on the consequentials to the health service. One thing of which we can be absolutely certain is that, if that great North Sea misfortune had befallen the people of Scotland and Iain Gray had triumphantly led the Labour Party into government, less money would have been spent on the national health service than will be spent in this spending review period.
“We wouldn’t ring fence the health budget”?
We know that Labour did not mean to pass on the consequentials because the Labour Party in government in Wales has not passed on the consequentials to the health service. One thing of which we can be absolutely certain is that, if that great North Sea misfortune had befallen the people of Scotland and Iain Gray had triumphantly led the Labour Party into government, less money would have been spent on the national health service than will be spent in this spending review period.
See what the First Minister did there? I asked him a question about NHS budgets and he gave me an answer about Labour’s manifesto, the Welsh Labour Party and NHS board budgets. That was not the promise that he made. He promised that a Scottish National Party Government would protect the health budget, but it has not done that. Since the First Minister was re-elected in May, we have had fewer doctors, midwives and nurses. He has got rid of 1,700 nurses since 2009. Does he still have the brass neck to say that he is protecting our NHS?
All the commitments that we made to the national health service are being met, and we will protect the NHS budget. Table 7.02 on page 64 of the “Scottish Spending Review 2011 and Draft Budget 2012-13” shows how the NHS budget is being protected. We pledged to pass on the consequentials, which Iain Gray would not commit to do during the election campaign. We have done that; he will find that on page 58 of that document. We promised to protect the national health service and ensure shorter waiting times and treatment that continues to improve. That means extra investment of £1 billion over the next four years. He will see that in table 8.03 of the document. The SNP Government has met—indeed, more than met—each and every commitment that we gave the national health service.
I know that it is a long time ago, but Iain Gray should remember that, when he was the deputy health minister at a time when there was not a Tory Government imposing massive cuts from Westminster, nursing numbers in Scotland—guess what?—fell during his period of office, and there were 5,000 fewer nurses in the national health service than there are now under this Government.
I know that it is a long time ago, but Iain Gray should remember that, when he was the deputy health minister at a time when there was not a Tory Government imposing massive cuts from Westminster, nursing numbers in Scotland—guess what?—fell during his period of office, and there were 5,000 fewer nurses in the national health service than there are now under this Government.
Table 1.06 in a financial scrutiny unit document on the draft budget shows that the change over four years in the total health spend is -£319 million. That is a cut. If the First Minister cared to examine nurse and midwife numbers, he would find that there are fewer nurses and midwives in our NHS now than there were in 2007 when he became First Minister. However, members do not have to take my word for it; let us ask the people who really know. The Royal College of Nursing states:
“Our nursing workforce is at breaking point”.
General practitioners tell us that “panic measures” to compensate for SNP cuts will compromise the NHS. Who should we trust on the NHS: the First Minister, who made the choices in his budget, or the doctors, nurses and patients, who have no choice except to live with the consequences? Who is telling the truth: Alex Salmond or the doctors and nurses?
“Our nursing workforce is at breaking point”.
General practitioners tell us that “panic measures” to compensate for SNP cuts will compromise the NHS. Who should we trust on the NHS: the First Minister, who made the choices in his budget, or the doctors, nurses and patients, who have no choice except to live with the consequences? Who is telling the truth: Alex Salmond or the doctors and nurses?
In May, people had the opportunity to judge between Alex Salmond and Iain Gray and, fairly resoundingly, they decided on the Scottish National Party Administration. I named the three key tables in the spending plans, but Iain Gray chose not to reference them; instead, he glided across to the budget including capital spending, presumably oblivious to the fact that the Conservative Party is cutting capital spending in Scotland by 36 per cent over a four-year period. That is the dreadful Conservative Party, but it adopted the plans that were left to it by the Labour Administration.
What did we do to try to counter that? Did we say, as Iain Gray did last year, that we would not even pass on the consequentials? No; the Government, through the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth and the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy, introduced a non-profit distribution programme that will add £750 million to expenditure in the national health service in the next few years.
I have quoted the three tables, cited Iain Gray’s deplorable record and explained how we are getting another £750 million investment in the national health service. Perhaps Iain Gray will have the grace to acknowledge that, if he comes along to ask questions on the NHS, neither on his record, performance nor understanding of statistics is he on safe ground.
What did we do to try to counter that? Did we say, as Iain Gray did last year, that we would not even pass on the consequentials? No; the Government, through the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth and the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy, introduced a non-profit distribution programme that will add £750 million to expenditure in the national health service in the next few years.
I have quoted the three tables, cited Iain Gray’s deplorable record and explained how we are getting another £750 million investment in the national health service. Perhaps Iain Gray will have the grace to acknowledge that, if he comes along to ask questions on the NHS, neither on his record, performance nor understanding of statistics is he on safe ground.
No matter where the First Minister goes in his budget, it unravels. Last week, he promised that the Government would invest in capital infrastructure. Then the Centre for Public Policy for Regions examined the figures and we discovered that the Government is cutting capital investment even faster than George Osborne and the Tories are. The First Minister promised to protect businesses, but then we discovered that he is taking an extra £850 million off them. Last Thursday, he promised to protect universities, but on Friday he gave the University of Abertay Dundee five weeks to merge into the University of Dundee. To paraphrase Al Gore, is not the truth just an inconvenience for the First Minister?
Last week, I wondered why Iain Gray kept asking about closures, since there will be no closures of colleges or universities in Scotland. Then, as Mike Russell mentioned in the education debate earlier, we found out that one of Ed Miliband’s advisers is advocating the closure of half of England’s universities. It is no wonder that Iain Gray was obsessed by closure.
I turn to the figures that were produced on capital departmental expenditure limits by the CPPR, an institute that seems to engage in treble counting. The last time that we had treble counting in the United Kingdom was when Gordon Brown was the Chancellor of the Exchequer in 1997 to 1999; coincidentally, that was exactly the same period in which John McLaren was a Labour Party special adviser. It seems that old habits die hard.
The capital DEL is only part of the capital spending story. It is because of the near 40 per cent cut that the Tories introduced, and which was planned by the Labour Party, that Mr Swinney has engaged in the non-profit distribution programme and the transfer from resource to capital in the budget. That is why the capital budget is increasing in Scotland, which is the only place in the United Kingdom where it is increasing. I heard that same mistake repeated by Ed Miliband on the radio this morning. I can only imagine that he got his information from Iain Gray. As that interview wended on, as the BBC news site tells us, Ed Miliband was unable to name all the Scottish Labour leadership candidates. He got two out of three, which is two more than the rest of the population.
I turn to the figures that were produced on capital departmental expenditure limits by the CPPR, an institute that seems to engage in treble counting. The last time that we had treble counting in the United Kingdom was when Gordon Brown was the Chancellor of the Exchequer in 1997 to 1999; coincidentally, that was exactly the same period in which John McLaren was a Labour Party special adviser. It seems that old habits die hard.
The capital DEL is only part of the capital spending story. It is because of the near 40 per cent cut that the Tories introduced, and which was planned by the Labour Party, that Mr Swinney has engaged in the non-profit distribution programme and the transfer from resource to capital in the budget. That is why the capital budget is increasing in Scotland, which is the only place in the United Kingdom where it is increasing. I heard that same mistake repeated by Ed Miliband on the radio this morning. I can only imagine that he got his information from Iain Gray. As that interview wended on, as the BBC news site tells us, Ed Miliband was unable to name all the Scottish Labour leadership candidates. He got two out of three, which is two more than the rest of the population.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 29 Sep 2011 →- Cancer Drugs Debate · 33
- Scotland’s Colleges Debate · 78
- NHS Lothian (Meetings) Questions · 7
- Advertising Budget (Allocation) Questions · 5
- Modern Apprenticeships Questions · 8
- Community Councils Questions · 7
- Mechanical Engineering Graduates (Career Destinations) Questions · 5
- Public Procurement Procedures Questions · 10
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Crown Estate (Minerals) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Nurses First Minister’s Questions · 4
- University Mergers First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Rural Affairs and the Environment Questions · 1
- Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Scotland Rural Development Programme (Application Process) Questions · 7
- Cereal Farmers (Wet Weather Assistance) Questions · 7
- Scottish Environment Protection Agency (European Bathing Water Directive) Questions · 6
- Bracken Control (Support for Farmers and Crofters) Questions · 4
- Forestry Commission Scotland (Leased Farmland) Questions · 6
- Distillery By-products (Biofriendly Renewable Energy) Questions · 4
- Glasgow City Council (Environmental Improvement) Questions · 4
- Diffuse Pollution (South Scotland) Questions · 6
- Court Cases (Closed Session) Questions · 6
- Offences Aggravated by Religious Prejudice (Convictions) Questions · 7
- No Knives, Better Lives Initiative Questions · 6
- National Police Force (Accountability) Questions · 4
- Police and Fire Service Accountability (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 4
- Prisons (Transfer of Medical Nursing and Pharmacy Services) Questions · 4
- Single Police Force (Allocation of Resources) Questions · 4
- Scottish Sentencing Council Questions · 5
- Scottish Studies Debate · 96
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
- Lightburn Hospital Members’ business · 39
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.