To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00511)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
12 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
We all continue to be shocked by the revelations that are coming from the Leveson inquiry about phone hacking, pay-offs and the inappropriate relationship between journalists, police and politicians. It would be naive to dismiss those as London practices that stop at the border. What steps are being taken to learn from the Leveson inquiry? Did the First Minister discuss the matter when he last spoke with the chief executive officer of News Corporation, Rupert Murdoch?
A statement was released yesterday on the meeting that I had with the chairman of News Corporation, Rupert Murdoch. In terms of meetings with Rupert Murdoch, I think that an open statement, which says what was discussed, is probably a pleasant change from past practice in the Labour Party.
On the serious point and on the Scottish input into Leveson, Johann Lamont should know that the chief constable of Strathclyde Police will appear at the Leveson inquiry later this month, to talk specifically about Scottish police force liaison. I strongly support the police action that has been taken, just as I support the Leveson inquiry itself.
Johann Lamont said that we must assume that there are Scottish aspects to this, but it is important to remember that, although a range of newspapers and newspaper groups was involved in the widespread malpractice in the press that the Information Commissioner reported at the end of 2006—I will gladly place the information in the Scottish Parliament information centre—there were very few Scottish examples or, indeed, English regional examples.
We must be vigilant, and it is right and proper that Strathclyde Police is pursuing the matter and appearing at the Leveson inquiry, but it is also fair to say that the evidence that we have so far is such that that co-operation is the way that we should go at the moment. We stand ready and willing to act, because the criminal law must be upheld, north and south of the border.
Fine words must be tested against the action that we take. We know that the police are not the only people who leak stories to Rupert Murdoch. The first edition of the Scottish Sun on Sunday revealed the date of the referendum—Saturday 18 October 2014—citing a Government source. For the sake of a front-page splash, the date was leaked before the consultation was completed, before the Parliament was told and before the people of Scotland had their say. Has the First Minister, who of course wrote a column in the paper’s first edition, thought about who might possibly have been the source of such a mutually serving leak? What steps has he taken to determine the source of the leak?
We would never, ever encounter a situation in which a Labour politician had a column in The Sun newspaper.
On the serious point, I direct Johann Lamont to my remarks on the radio on Sunday morning. I will quote them exactly. I said:
“It is a possible date, of course, because we said it’d be in the autumn of 2014, but we also said we’re considering a Saturday, as opposed to a Thursday, to increase turnout. But we’re only a month into a three-month consultation. I think the last check I’ve made we’ve got 2,700 responses already, so we’re heading towards perhaps upwards of 10,000 responses to the consultation. Once all these are in and analysed, then we’ll announce what the date will be, not until after the consultation.”
That is what I said last Sunday and that still pertains today.
I am sure that, in the First Minister’s world, that sounds believable, but it is testing credulity to the point of destruction. Just a few weeks ago, I read out the First Minister’s cringeworthy letter to Fred Goodwin, backing the deal that broke the bank. This week, we have been reminded how far the First Minister was prepared to go to accommodate Donald Trump. That did not end well, although apparently, First Minister, he still likes you. I will not embarrass the First Minister by reading out his musings to Rupert Murdoch—or Sir Rupert, as the First Minister likes to address him—but it seems that the First Minister has finally learned that theatre tickets and golf DVDs will not get a reply but a good exclusive will. Despite what the First Minister says, the editor of The Sun says that the date is 18 October 2014. He is so sure that he told Twitter:
“See what odds you can get on 18/10/14. We’re right.”
Is the First Minister saying that the editor of The Sun is wrong?
The First Minister is saying that Johann Lamont is wrong. The position is as I read out a few seconds ago. I do not know that citing Donald Trump is Johann Lamont’s strongest suit at present because, as I understand it, Donald Trump’s ire seems to have been roused because he believes that he was given an assurance by my predecessor, Lord McConnell—although he was not a lord at that stage—that he would block planning permission for the test wind farm off Aberdeen. I have no way of knowing whether such an assurance was given but, if it was, it should not have been, because First Ministers cannot determine wind farm applications in Scotland.
There is a serious issue about renewable investment in Scotland. The front page of today’s Press and Journal cites the thousands of jobs that are being created in the drive towards renewables. I hope that, as we progress that argument against whoever might criticise it, we will have the support of Johann Lamont and her colleagues, even if we cannot count on the support of Lord McConnell.
I have tried to be extremely restrained so far on relationships with newspapers, but I must now read out a quote about the attendance at News International’s summer party. It states:
“At News International’s summer party in London on Thursday night, guests including David and Samantha Cameron drank Moet & Chandon champagne and ate oysters. Labour leader Ed Miliband and shadow chancellor Ed Balls sheltered from the inclement weather in a giant canopy at the Orangery in Kensington”.
Given the enthusiasm among the Labour Party leadership for drinking the champagne and eating the oysters—incidentally, all you get in Bute house is a cup of tea and a Tunnock’s caramel wafer—some people might think that there is more than a trace of double standards emanating from the people’s party.
The First Minister’s restraint is admirable but, in the middle of all that, I do not think that we got an answer. Simply asserting that I am wrong does not dispute the fact that the editor of The Sun says that he is right. The First Minister is trying to make people believe that the exclusive in The Sun had nothing to do with him. His defence is, “It wasnae me and it wasnae just me.” That will not do.
It is said that we can tell a lot about a man by the company that he keeps. [Interruption.]
Order.
What does it say about the First Minister’s judgment if he is prepared to compromise the referendum for Sir Rupert, to compromise our planning system for the Trump and to compromise Scotland’s economic future for Fred the Shred? We all know that Sir Rupert ran with Sunday’s story on the First Minister’s nod. After five years of asking, will the First Minister simply confirm what date he intends to hold the referendum? Just name the date.
I will stick to my position of having the consultation with the Scottish people. I have an update for Johann Lamont; there are now more than 3,000 responses to the consultation. We will consider the responses to the consultation, although we have not had one from the Labour Party yet. I understand that it has submitted a response to the Tory-Liberal coalition Government’s consultation—no great surprise there. The Labour-Tory alliance has continued right through Westminster to this chamber and even to Stirling Council in the past week. We will have the consultation and then we will announce the date, which will be determined by this Parliament in the best interests of the Scottish people.
Johann Lamont’s remark about the company that we choose is extraordinarily rich coming from a Labour Party that pursued a 15-year courtship of News International and only decided that dreadful things were going on after The Sun stopped supporting the Labour Party in politics. That is hardly a position of high principle.
The serious issue for us all is to back the police inquiry and the Leveson inquiry. It is remiss of a party that, according to the previous Prime Minister, knew about these activities in 2007—that is what he said in his House of Commons speech last year—yet still consumed the champagne and the oysters, to now attack a meeting to determine jobs and the economic footprint of Scotland, and at which there was no champagne and no oysters. We have a police inquiry and the Leveson inquiry and, quite rightly, News International has said that it will leave such practices behind. The Labour Party that was prepared to support and court newspapers when it knew about the malpractice is in no position to criticise anyone in this chamber or across the body politic.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 1 Mar 2012 →- Climate Justice Debate · 46
- Constitution (Negotiations) Questions · 6
- Tyre Dumping (Rural Areas) Questions · 8
- Youth Employment (Education and Training) Questions · 8
- Economic Activity (Rural Areas) Questions · 4
- Fire and Rescue Service (Location) Questions · 4
- Carer Information Strategy (Funding) Questions · 4
- Business Rates Incentivisation Scheme (Aberdeen) Questions · 4
- Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Schmallenberg Virus First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Childcare Provision First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Children’s Hearings System First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Lockerbie Bombing (Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Transport Infrastructure Investment (North Ayrshire) Questions · 6
- Homelessness (2012 Target) Questions · 6
- Ayr to Stranraer Railway Line Questions · 6
- Forth Replacement Crossing (Tendering Process) Questions · 6
- Rail Services (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
- Fuel Poverty (Collective Bargaining Energy Schemes) Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing Programme (Targets) Questions · 6
- European Commission (Public Procurement Processes) Questions · 6
- Europe (Emerging Democracies) Questions · 4
- BBC Scotland (Service Reductions and Job Losses) Questions · 4
- Contemporary Arts Initiatives (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- V&A at Dundee Questions · 6
- Antarctic (Scotland’s Role) Questions · 6
- Children (Cultural Visits) Questions · 6
- Historic Buildings (Disposal) Questions · 4
- Culture and Arts (Youth Employment) Questions · 5
- Living Wage Debate · 100
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- BBC Scotland (Job Cuts) Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.