There are 12 current petitions for consideration today. The first two will be considered together. They are PE1098, in the name of
Lynn Merrifield, and PE1223, in the name of Ron Beaty, on school bus safety. Members have a note by the clerk and submissions. I refer members to an additional letter from Keith Brown, which gives an update on his original letter on the issue. It is a fairly positive letter—I will say no more than that. I invite comments from members.
I am delighted to see Mr Beaty here again. He has been at almost every meeting at which his petition has been discussed and he has taken a keen interest in it. The situation is a little difficult, because the petitions have been on the go for a long time. Although we have not quite reached stalemate, it sometimes feels like it. However, the letter from Keith Brown gives us a good handle that will allow us to keep the petitions going. He has a meeting on 15 December with the Minister for Local Government and Planning and the Minister for Learning, Science and Scotland’s Languages. It would be a good idea to wait for the outcome of that meeting and to ask for feedback on it.
I agree that we should continue the petition. My colleague Dr Eilidh Whiteford MP has written to the Secretary of State for Transport and received a response that sets out that the current legislation requires all coaches and minibuses that carry groups of children aged three to 15 on organised trips to be equipped with seat belts. That applies only to organised trips, so I am not sure whether it covers day-to-day school transport. However, Keith Brown’s response is encouraging.Although one of the petitions deals exclusively with seat belts, a fundamental aspect of Mr Beaty’s petition is the issues of signage, lights and overtaking stationary school buses. That is a key concern, particularly in the north-east, where such overtaking has led to a number of tragedies. We need to make representations on the issues of signage, lights and overtaking to ensure that they do not fall off the agenda and that we do not become focused purely on seat belts. I realise that measures on signage and lights will be difficult because buses in Scotland tend not to be used purely for school transport, whereas school buses in other nations are used for school transport alone. The committee ought to keep an eye on that aspect of the petition to ensure that we do not focus simply on seat belts. Although seat belts are important, the issues of signage, lights and overtaking are equally important.15:15
As Nanette Milne said, the committee has been dealing with the two petitions for some time.I want to put on record my disappointment at the response to the convener from the minister, Keith Brown, in his November letter. I thought that the committee had moved forward in the debate and got on record the willingness of the United Kingdom Government and the Scottish Government to move the agenda forward. In some respects, the November letter suggested that the Scottish Government was drawing back from that position. However, Keith Brown’s December letter seems to contain open signs of encouragement that he is going to sit down with his ministerial colleagues to discuss the wider impact on other departments of any legislation that comes to Scotland. I hope that the committee will be able to get a full report of the meeting on 15 December and the action points that emerge from it, to allow us to take both petitions forward. Both petitions are crucial for the safety of those travelling in school transport and those boarding and alighting from it.
As Mark McDonald said, that is particularly important for buses picking up children in rural areas, but it is also important in urban areas where such services still exist. Many local authorities have cut back on them. It is encouraging that the minister has now taken the matter forward and, given the willingness of the UK transport minister, we should see some developments in the near future. I hope that they will not take as long as it has taken to get to this stage.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I thank Mr Wilson for raising that point. My own feeling was that the original letter was inappropriate and that the minister did not treat our committee with very much respect. Having said that, I believe in sinners who repent, and I think that the most recent letter was a big improvement. I should like to put that on record, as it is Christmas. We are now considering the next stages for the petition, on which we have heard strong recommendations from Nanette Milne and Mark McDonald.
Do members agreed to continue the petition in the light of the comments made by Nanette Milne, Mark McDonald, John Wilson and Neil Bibby?Members indicated agreement.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.