We will now take evidence on the current state of Scottish tourism—an issue on which committee members have expressed an interest. For our first panel of witnesses, we are joined by Norman Springford, who is the chief executive of Apex Hotels, and by Gavin Ellis, who is the owner of the Knockomie hotel in Morayshire. Did I pronounce the name of the hotel correctly?
Thank you both for joining us as representatives of private sector industry. I do not know whether you wish to make some introductory remarks, but I will first ask some general questions to give you a chance to give us your views.Tourism is important to the Scottish economy, and concerns have been expressed about the state of the sector because of the recession, the weather, and other factors that have had an impact. Will you spend a couple of minutes giving us a sense of where you feel the industry is? Have we had a successful season? How are things looking for the rest of the year and next year? Are you receiving sufficient Government support? The Government’s target is to grow tourism revenue by 50 per cent by 2015. Is that target realistic? Are we on track to achieve it? I throw in those questions as my opening gambit, and invite you to respond.
I can answer from a national perspective, because as well as Edinburgh hotels and Dundee hotels, we have properties in London. The general consensus is that London has had an especially successful tourism season, and is showing improvements in corporate business as well. That has percolated up to Scotland—well, to the cities; I cannot speak for the rural areas.The general feeling is that we have had a good but difficult year. The difficulties have not been in top-line revenues—which, in some instances, are expanding reasonably well—but in costs. Costs throughout the hospitality sector have increased substantially, whether it be in local rates, wages or other areas such as utility costs. It is becoming more and more difficult for hospitality businesses to maintain their bottom-line profitability.
Good morning. Our businesses are in rural Scotland: I have interests in Mull and in Moray. As you will all know, Moray has had a tough time recovering from the instant closure of RAF Kinloss, but we are looking forward to 39 Engineer Regiment relocating there in June next year.What is tourism? How do we define it? Government, and people outside the industry, can get confused. Is tourism considered as part of the social infrastructure, and therefore covered by the bus network and other forms of transport? Where does tourism stop and business take over?It is tough out there—and the further you are from the centres of population, the tougher it is. That has to be taken into account in future decisions. The cost of fuel is just outrageous in some parts of rural Scotland, and we need to understand the impact of that the further you get from towns.You mentioned the Government’s ambition for us to grow by 50 per cent. We will make it, because things have got so desperate. We have gone down, and now we will come back up again. In 2007, the economy changed for ever. We should not hang on to the past; we are now in a very different place.I will also mention the impact of a Westminster issue. Our VAT rate of 20 per cent is the second highest in Europe. That travesty affects our competitiveness. Another issue is airport tax for people coming into the United Kingdom, which has a huge impact on how we do business and whom we do it with.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I am not so concerned about whether it is achievable. It was a historical aspiration, if you wish, rather than a hard-and-fast target. The world has moved on and the global economy has clearly changed. The target of 50 per cent growth by 2015 is now historical and, if realism kicks in, achieving it is unlikely. That is not to say that the tourism industry and VisitScotland cannot have such a target. We need something to aim for and whether we choose 50 per cent, 100 per cent or 20 per cent does not matter. The important thing is how the industry—which is a combination of the public and private sectors—strives to achieve an improvement in our economy.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
We have heard about the tourism opportunities that are coming up within the next few years—the Commonwealth games, the Olympic games, the Ryder cup, homecoming, and so on. We have been told that those events represent an unprecedented opportunity for the tourism industry. However, I heard the two witnesses say that the position for businesses depends on whether they are situated in a rural or urban area. Will those opportunities have the same impact in rural areas as in urban areas? How can we spread the impact out from the urban areas? It is obvious that Glasgow will benefit from the Commonwealth games, but how do we get people to come out from Glasgow and visit the rest of the country, including areas that are furthest from the urban centres?
There is clearly a difference between the rural and urban economies and how they are promoted. I am not being parochial just because I happen to come from Edinburgh, but my view is that London is the gateway to the UK in the same way that Edinburgh is the gateway to Scotland. The promotion of London and Edinburgh will percolate out to the other parts of the UK.Your specific question is about the benefits that we can derive from the unprecedented series of sporting events that are coming up in the next few years. The key is for VisitScotland and EventScotland to be a part of that. It is not quite niche marketing that is required, but those organisations should be—and will be—able to market the Commonwealth games, the Ryder cup and the various other high-profile events that will put Scotland on the map. It is up to the rest of the industry to seize the initiative that is being presented to us.I am afraid that I am one of the pessimists who subscribe to the view that, although the Olympic games will improve revenues in London for the six weeks of the games’ duration, the number of visitors to the UK as a whole will reduce over the year because people will look at the UK and say that it will be too busy and too expensive, and they will put off their visit. There might be an advantage to Scotland through the displacement of people who are based in London or the south-east of England, who might want to get away from it all for a while, but my overall view is that the Olympic games will not benefit UK tourism.
The Olympic games will be a challenge. I have never known them not to be a challenge. If we look at their history in Athens and other places, we can see that they have always caused problems.As for the Ryder cup, it is about how we do it, how we extend holidays on each side of the tournament, and how we inspire people to see Scotland as the home of golf. We have opportunities, but we also face threats.I will open up the point about events a bit more. The Scottish open up at Castle Stuart has had a great impact on the Highlands and I can see it being nothing but a benefit. However, we have to extend that impact and ensure that other, smaller events get out into all parts of Scotland. I am talking about bringing the orienteering championships to the north, for example. We should encourage outdoor concerts such as Rock Ness, which has had an incredible impact on its area. Mountain biking and general biking are also examples of activities that will go on all year if we have the right facilities. Such facilities must be extended throughout Scotland.09:45
It is interesting to know that we are perhaps not marketing smaller events and that the focus on larger events might be detrimental in that regard. However, why would the Olympic games be detrimental? Is it because London is the gateway to the UK, as you said? Do we need organisations such as VisitScotland to promote other gateways to the UK so that people need not be stuck in busy London but can celebrate the Olympic games from, for example, the comfort of a Highland resort?
My view is still that it would be like trying to push water uphill to move the gateway from London to another part of the UK. London has been and always will be the gateway.I am involved in the hotel sector rather than the hospitality sector as a whole, and when a particular market begins to dry up, we go for another. For example, when corporate business dried up during the financial crisis, Edinburgh was able to replace it with some leisure business. The same will apply in the case of the Olympics. There will be less inbound, general leisure business because it will be concentrated purely on those who wish to see the Olympics, but that does not mean that we in Scotland should accept that there will be a reduction in inbound tourism from European or other international visitors.Perhaps VisitScotland’s marketing approach should be focused on other parts of England outside London. As 78 per cent of Scotland’s tourism business comes from the UK, we should concentrate on, say, the south-east of England and tell people there that, if they wish to explore Scotland, this is the best time for them to do so.
The success of the framework for change will depend on close working relationships between the private sector and the public sector. Is that happening in practice? In that regard, are you a member of an area tourism partnership?
I am a great believer in the public and private sectors co-operating, although I accept that it is difficult to do. I am not saying that one sector is better than the other, merely that they are different. The public sector will think differently from the private sector and have different strengths and weaknesses. I accept that combining the two sectors is very difficult but, from a political point of view, it is essential. My view is that the hospitality sector has been dependent on state handouts for too long and that we have been reluctant to become involved in the promotion of our own industry. If we can encourage greater co-operation between the private and public sectors, that will be to the benefit of all.
I agree with Norman Springford. Where we may not have taken advantage of all our assets in Scotland plc is in not getting everybody to understand the impact of what growth means for Scotland. With the tourism framework for change, we could have done better if we had understood where we had capacity for waiters and chefs, for example, and then funded further education or degree courses to fill that capacity. Rather than allowing people to do courses for which we do not have jobs, we should have indicated where we had capacity and the ability to provide jobs and therefore growth. If that had permeated down to councils, the planning could have been faster and more efficient. We could still do that if we changed our attitude. A lot of it is just about attitude; it is not money but a change of attitude that we need. The attitude should be that we can grow. We can do that if we set people free in some areas, and planning is one of the biggest such areas that I hear people in our industry talk about. By the way, that is not just in relation to tourism; it is across the board.
Mr Springford, you mentioned earlier the importance of the private and public sectors coming together, but you say that you are not involved in any of the partnership work. Is that for any specific reason?
No, far from it. Until last year, I was chairman of Destination Edinburgh Marketing—Lucy Bird is appearing as a witness later; she will give you her own comments on Marketing Edinburgh—which is evidence of my enthusiasm for public and private sector co-operation.
Could I add that the Moray and Speyside tourism development company is a partnership between the council, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and VisitScotland? Everybody is at the table, and everybody is working together—perhaps not all at the speed that we would wish, or with the same sense of urgency, but we are there and we are working together.
Good morning, gentlemen. First, let me go over the issues of growth and the information flow. We often hear statistics being bandied about. According to an analysis by VisitScotland, tourists spent 77.2 million nights in Scotland in 2005, but the figure fell to 67.9 million in 2009. How do you interconnect, if you do, with VisitScotland? How does it gather information from your organisations? Also, given the nature of the products that we provide, and the fact that we have tourism products as diverse as restaurants, hotels and extreme sports all across Scotland, do you believe that the current organisation of VisitScotland is fit for purpose?
Part 1 of the question suggested that there had been a reduction in tourism. As part of the hospitality sector, and the hotel sector in particular, I see tourism as only part of our business; perhaps we could describe it as leisure business. Fifty-six per cent of our business in Edinburgh is corporate business. We are therefore a more balanced sector than we would be if we dealt only with tourism. There might have been a reduction in visitor numbers, but those numbers are not the only indicator of whether the sector is profitable. We also need to look at how much revenue is generated from the sector, where the business is coming from, and what the spin-offs are. Our view is that tourism is everyone’s business in Scotland. It is such an important industry that we can almost say that every facet of business in Scotland derives benefit from it, directly or indirectly. To my mind, it is not all about numbers. It is about what we do with the experience, and about how we generate more revenue from tourism. It is quite an important industry as far as Scotland is concerned.
I do not disagree with that, but if we consider the overall spend, we see that it is not just the number of nights that has gone down. The spend has gone down from £4.6 billion in 2009 to £4.1 billion. The Government has just committed an extra £8 million to VisitScotland. I accept that the tourism industry is much wider than VisitScotland, but I am trying to explore the interconnection between them. You referred earlier to the embracing of tourism as a whole. VisitScotland is the main body; I am trying to find out how you feed information to it about its performance. Does VisitScotland support the products that you are trying to sell?
If you are specifically targeting the performance of VisitScotland, we do not directly feed information into its statistics section. In fact, the opposite is true: VisitScotland has a particularly strong statistics section and we ask it for information that it has gathered from other sources. We find it to be a particularly valuable source of statistics such as the ones that you are quoting.In my view, VisitScotland is most definitely fit for purpose, especially if one looks at some of the economies that spend substantially more on marketing their countries than Scotland does. Ireland is a prime example: it spends a much larger amount of money than the funding to which VisitScotland has access, and that clearly benefits the country’s tourism infrastructure. If we view VisitScotland as a marketing organisation, I would say that it is producing and doing a good job.
I empathise with that view in relation to marketing, but I am talking about the operation and the drive to make things happen in disparate areas of Scotland. Is VisitScotland operationally effective?
VisitScotland would be able to tell you what its remit is, but I do not believe that it is an operational body—it is a marketing body, and I would not expect it to be operational other than in lobbying and influencing. It may well influence questions such as whether air passenger duty should be removed or whether there should be route support for airlines, but in relation to achieving those objectives it plays either a marketing or an influential role.
But you would agree that any good marketing organisation should collate information. You say that you do not provide information to VisitScotland, but you get information from it.
Yes, and it does so. VisitScotland will be able to speak for itself about what its statistical team does, but that work is why we can turn round and say, for example, that 78 per cent of visitors to Edinburgh are day visitors. We do not get that information from our own hotel systems because, clearly, those people are not staying with us. We are dependent on an outside agency to compile that statistic, and that agency is VisitScotland.
There are many people collecting statistics—usually for their own benefit—through PKF, the University of Glasgow, the University of Strathclyde or VisitScotland itself. There is also a sub-group called Tourism Intelligence Scotland that is doing some great work on market analysis. It has produced many useful information booklets for each sector to help people to expand their business. However, if you are looking for an excuse for commercial failure in parts of rural Scotland, you cannot blame VisitScotland for that—you have to blame the economy.
Hotels and pubs are closing; we cannot fail to see the number of pubs that have closed in cities and rural areas throughout Scotland, and that is because of market failure. That is a different question—we need to ask ourselves why that market failure is there.
How do you tap into the opportunities from business tourism? I am pretty sure that Apex is very much involved in that, but I would like to hear Mr Springford’s views on how we can attract even more business tourism. I am also interested in Mr Ellis’s view, given the recent events in Moray and the growth of opportunities in renewables from the increase in green energy facilities in that part of Scotland. How are you tapping into that?
It is initially a question of definition. Our view in undertaking our segmentation analysis is that a guest who stays with us is either one thing or another: they are either business—or corporate—tourism, or they are not. We do not have a definition of business tourism—we have the corporate guest and the leisure guest, and they do different things. Some business guests come on an incentive travel package. Places such as Gleneagles have suffered badly in the past couple of years because the benefit that they derive from corporate incentive travel had dried up to a large extent, as it has not been fashionable and there has been a general recession that affected the corporate area. We do not classify business tourism as a category or market. As I say, it is strictly business and leisure, and the two types do different things.10:00
There is no question but that the Moray economy has been hugely reliant on the Royal Air Force, although not wholly reliant on it, as we have vibrant whisky and forestry industries. The community is making an effort to change, through the Moray economic partnership. Over a generation, we will change, but we could change more quickly if there were fundamental infrastructure changes, such as those needed on the A9 and investment in rail transport to the north. The trains from Inverness to Edinburgh and Glasgow are pedantically slow. If they were faster, we could grow a lot faster and therefore contribute more to the economy.
While we are on that issue, I take Mr Springford’s point about London being the gateway to the UK, and we can talk about airline passenger duty until we are blue in the face, but how would you change the situation? We have very good airports in Scotland, including Edinburgh, Glasgow, Inverness and, in my neck of the woods, Prestwick. How might we change the situation in which London is the gateway to Scotland?
I do not necessarily believe that we should change it. As far as I can see, the system works reasonably well because most European or international guests visit London as the number 1 destination. Given the importance of London, I see no difficulty with that, just as I see no difficulty with regarding Edinburgh as the gateway to Scotland. If a leisure or tourist guest comes to the country—I am talking nationally, so about the UK, rather than Scotland—they might visit York, Stratford-upon-Avon and, likely, Edinburgh. That is the first visit. If they like what they see and we give them good value for money, they will come back and visit elsewhere.
I would like people to come to Edinburgh. Although York, Stratford and London are attractive, in these times of expenditure constraints on individuals, how do we get more direct flights? How do we market that? What is the airline strategy for Scotland?
On some issues, we cannot buck the market. Airlines internationally will only get bigger. We must concentrate on connectivity between us and England. I believe from conversations that I have had that we are losing our strong connectivity with Heathrow. We should worry about that a lot. On the other hand, we have opportunities. To avoid the air tax, many people coming from America fly into Schiphol and then on to Britain. Maybe we have the approach a little wrong—perhaps we should think of some of our European partners as the gateway to Scotland. If there is a punitive air tax, customers will avoid it. Perhaps we should think of Schiphol as part of the solution. However, we need connectivity with the south through fast trains and airlines that connect. The Heathrow connection is under threat.
I have one more question, which is on skills. One key reason why businesses such as yours are successful is not just because they sell at a price, but because of value. Value is largely contingent on the quality of your staff. What connectivity do you have with local colleges and other sources of employees to ensure that quality standards continue to rise? How easy is it for you to get the people whom you require with the skills that you require?
Personally, I think that connectivity is improving. Only three weeks ago, we had a pile of Moray College students in who looked keen and were ready to learn and ask lots of questions. Can we improve on the situation? Damn right we can. We need to look at our European competitors and find out what they have that we do not.At the risk of being controversial—not, I might add, for the first time—I wonder whether further education colleges should have a tiered system in which students can take foundation courses in some of the smaller colleges and then move up to more specialist courses in the bigger ones. Last week, when I visited Jewel and Esk College—an example of the sort of connectivity that we have been talking about—I was very impressed by the investment that had been made there. Perhaps we need to maximise investment in certain colleges to make them specialist and, indeed, residential. There is an opportunity to be taken, but we need to understand the change that we will have to make.
This is perhaps not the right forum in which to express this view, but I certainly feel that people coming out of further or higher education are generally not fit for purpose. Apex tries very hard to form links and associations with some of the FE and HE colleges and universities to ensure that there is a programme that offers more than just the normal one week’s work experience. I would not call that kind of work experience useless, but it does not help if someone who comes for a week or a couple of weeks gets thrown into filing or something else because the staff are too busy to carry out any training. Many of the programmes that we are encouraging and which we hope that politicians will take on board and encourage more of link a lengthy period of work experience to an FE or HE course. As a result, instead of taking a three-year degree, students might have a five-year programme, part of the curriculum for which would include going out into industry for several months. Industry would be able to do the basic training, improve its training methods and get some value back from the student. At the moment, students are being thrown out of colleges and universities with a particular academic record but no experience. The difficulty is that, for example, you can be taught how to deal with an irate guest only at a hotel’s reception. Indeed, I can tell members that there is nothing better than the experience of having to deal with an irate guest at 11 o’clock at night when you have had to tell them, “I’m sorry—your room’s been sold to somebody else.” If we can improve the communication and establish links between business and education authorities, it would improve ability, certainly in the tourism industry.
Our secondary school students need to be coming out of school with social confidence for the good not just of the hospitality industry but of all industry. Indeed, we should also focus to a certain extent on ensuring that they have commercial confidence because many of the people we employ do not understand that their wages are paid not by Norman Springford and me but by the customers.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I cannot believe that Apex Hotels ever has irate guests, but perhaps it happens occasionally.Before I bring in Mike MacKenzie, I believe that Rhoda Grant has what I hope will be a brief supplementary.
Indeed. With regard to the previous question on transport links, the witnesses will be aware of an on-going consultation that is seeking views on, among other things, London trains stopping in Edinburgh. What impact would such a move have on tourism north of Edinburgh?
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I understood that the proposal was for all the direct trains from London to stop in Edinburgh and for people to disembark in order to catch a connection north.
The real issue is the quality of the rolling stock going north, which is not fit for purpose and indicates a lack of understanding of the markets. For example, people who are into biking have to book their bikes on to the train, which requires them to make two bookings. The system is just not fit for getting to Aviemore, which is one of Europe’s biking capitals. Of course we would prefer the trains to go all the way to Inverness, but we have to get our own house in order and get the rolling stock fit for purpose.
We all welcome the recent phenomenon of the staycation as a response to economic difficulties. It seems to have given an uplift to tourism performance in Scotland over the past year to 18 months, but the figures for the preceding decade do not look very good at all, particularly against the background of steadily rising world tourism over the same period. I see that as something of a failure. What are your thoughts on the underperformance over that decade?
Although we can all do anything we want with statistics and show that there has been underperformance in certain areas, we as a company will benchmark ourselves against local and national competition and against past performance. Over the past decade, we can look to improved figures year on year. When one market share drops or one sector underperforms, we take steps to ensure that another market will replace it.In the hospitality sector, we have said that, over the past couple of years since the global recession, we are finding it more and more difficult to protect the bottom line, but we have done so and are showing growth in top-line revenues. The staycation market has been a particularly strong phenomenon, if you want to call it that, over the past several years. It certainly saved Edinburgh’s tourism several years on the trot. The staycation market is quite strong, but who is to say whether that will continue or evolve into something else? There may be something else on the horizon that we have not yet needed to promote. If you are saying that the staycation as a single entity has underperformed over the past 10 years, it may well have done, but we have to Iook at the overall market segmentation that we operate.
We have to understand the realities of the market we work in. In that time, the pound was particularly strong and it was therefore particularly attractive for people to visit countries such as Spain. This year, people have not only been staying in Scotland, or staying in Britain, but going to Turkey, because of currency fluctuations. There is a market reality check here. Also, I am the first to admit that we have not invested in our product across the country. Edinburgh and Glasgow have been able to invest in hotels and things, but there are parts of Scotland where that investment has not been possible due to the returns and the commercial reality of the money people are making. The past few winters have been particularly tough. Businesses have closed early this year already, which will affect the money that they can reinvest in their product.
We are placing a lot of hope in the events that are coming to Scotland over the next few years as a great opportunity for tourism—of course they are—but does it worry you that there may be a problem for tourism businesses dealing with a huge influx and then nobody? There is feast and famine and are you concerned that that may operate at the expense of longer-term tourist draws or attractions? Also, are you concerned about seasonality? Is there anything that we can do to improve that by lengthening seasons or whatever?10:15
I am not in the least concerned about the major events that are coming—they are great opportunities. As I see it, there is a tremendous opportunity to build on what those events will give us. What is important is how we do that, which is where VisitScotland becomes an extremely important entity. It must be properly funded, and the industry must be in a position to get involved in public-private co-operation to improve our lot. We have a great opportunity, globally, to put Scotland on the map, which we should be seizing. That is fine.The other part of your question was about whether we have any long-term concerns. I do not think so. If we continue to promote ourselves, Scotland will continue to be a particularly attractive destination.Was there another aspect of your question that you wanted me to comment on?
I guess that I was referring to what Gavin Ellis said in his introduction. He mentioned year-round attractions such as mountain biking, but I am concerned that, although the big events are undoubtedly opportunities, we might be putting too much focus on them at the expense of promoting the year-round, year-after-year activities that attract tourists.
Let me put it on record that events such as the Ryder cup and the Commonwealth games are essential, as they put Scotland on the world stage. They are broadcast on televisions in corners of the world that we do not know about. I often say that tourism is the Heineken industry, because we reach parts that others do not. The power of television is such that it reaches parts that we do not know about. That is extremely important.Seasonality has always been a challenge. It is a factor in countries in Europe such as Switzerland, Austria and France. I am not sure that we can buck all those market trends. We have made a good effort but, if there is no snow, people cannot ski. Hotels around the world have had to recognise that, but the economic machine behind them at Government level understands that well and has a tax system that compensates for it.
If I could wave my magic wand and grant you four wishes—one from the UK Government, one from the Scottish Government, one from VisitScotland and one from local authorities—what would you want those public agencies to do to assist you in achieving the 50 per cent target?
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I will give my four first. Nationally, I would go for fast trains from Inverness down to London; I would also like a wish on VAT, because I think that that has to be dealt with. I would like the Scottish Government to do something on infrastructure costs, to help with getting people around the place. Ever since the three wise men went to give Jesus presents, it has been about travel. I would like local government to understand that we are in this together and that it is not an us-and-them situation—it is about us working together rather than in isolation to make a better and more prosperous Scotland. I would like local government to understand tourism.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
The wise men came from the east—the good part of the country.I will go through my wishes in order of priority. Nationally, from the UK Government, I would like to see the reintroduction of better allowances for hotel buildings. As we are all aware, the capital allowances structure was changed a few years ago, which had a hugely detrimental effect on the provision of new hotel or other property-based accommodation. The removal of the industrial or hotel buildings allowance created a void. If no one is pouring concrete, the economy is not growing. The money in the company that is pouring the concrete eventually percolates down to the bookie or the pub, and it will flow back out again. Construction, which necessitates a far bigger discussion on the economy, is an important consideration but, from a purely insular, Apex Hotels point of view, we would like to see the introduction of enhanced allowances in the form of HBAs.I would like the Scottish Government to recognise that tourism is a particularly important industry in Scotland.On the local level, perhaps because I am Edinburgh based, I would like to see a bit more sense in the provisions of the bed tax that is being proposed by the council.At VisitScotland level, I would like to see more route support. That benefits us tremendously. Some people say that, if we do route support for Czechoslovakia, for example, more people go to Czechoslovakia than come the other way, but my view is that the people who are going to Czechoslovakia from Edinburgh are not going to stay with us in the first place. From a hotel point of view, there is a greater benefit in having more airline routes available.
I forgot about my request to VisitScotland. I would like our industry to understand that VisitScotland is all about marketing, not the other things. VisitScotland’s responsibility is marketing and we have to understand that.
Mike MacKenzie began by talking about domestic tourism and I want to follow that up. I am a wee bit worried by the idea that domestic tourism has become more important during the recession. We have just let that fall into our laps by happy circumstance. The Scottish Government’s headline interventions in tourism are mostly about international tourism and events such as homecoming and so on. Perhaps those measures or interventions made sense before the recession but I wonder whether we need to change our focus now. Mr Springford talked about the uncertainty about the future and how important domestic tourism will continue to be, but if recovery from the recession continues to be long and slow, we might expect opportunities from domestic tourism to continue in the short term.In the long term, most of the world expects oil prices to continue to rise. Aviation is already included in Scotland’s climate change emission targets and will soon be included in the European emissions trading scheme. Do we not need to think about a longer-term strategy for promoting domestic tourism as the priority, recognising that it is already significant and that we could be doing more to grow it, rather than placing what sometimes feels like all our eggs in the international tourism basket?
Yes, I agree. Although it is nice to be able to say that the market has an international flavour and that we would do best to promote it, as I said earlier, 78 per cent of the business that comes to Edinburgh hotels is from the domestic market. A surprisingly high number of people from the south-east of England have not been to Scotland. You ask whether we should be promoting more domestic than international tourism and I say that we should.
I offer caution, because we cannot buck the market. I go back to what I said about the currency. If it gets cheaper for people to go elsewhere, they will go there. We must keep our eye on the ball. The foot-and-mouth crisis affected our American market drastically and hotels that were particularly exposed to that market suffered. There is nothing so sure as change and we need to be ready to react to it. It is not about fitting people into little boxes and saying, “It must be one market.” We must be keeping an eye on the other markets as well. We must never expose ourselves in the way that we were exposed during the foot-and-mouth outbreak, because we really suffered then. We must learn from the past but try and predict the future. Our emphasis should probably be closer to home. From that point of view, I agree with Norman Springford, but I issue a word of caution.
I suppose that everybody would agree that“Prediction is very difficult, especially about the future”, but I am concerned that if we do not have a clear focus on domestic tourism as already the source of a great deal of business and an area in which we can easily do a lot more, regardless of what happens to international aviation prices and so on, then, when the world sees the first $200 barrel of oil we might find ourselves with lots of tourism businesses that are dependent on an international market that is suddenly not available to them.
Although I understand your sentiments and why you say that, if Britain and Scotland are to grow economically we must concentrate on some invisible exports as well. We need euros and dollars in, and the situation needs to be balanced.
Earlier, Mr Springford spoke about the need for more partnership working between the public and private sectors; he also said that the solution was not more state handouts. Mr Ellis said that we should be training people for existing jobs. In an average year, what vacancies will be available within your businesses? What training opportunities do you provide to your staff? How many people do you have taking modern apprenticeships? Do you promote posts in your companies as providing a job or as providing a career?
I will try to remember all your questions and answer them in sequence, going back the way.Do we promote a post as a job? No, we try to promote it as a career. The hospitality industry has suffered from having its posts regarded as jobs—indeed, as second-rate jobs that will do until someone can get a job elsewhere. We are trying to change that. Changing that perception is one of the biggest challenges that the industry has. In other countries, such as Italy, waiting or other aspects of hospitality are regarded as professions. For one reason or another, whether it is to do with schooling or whatever, such work is not regarded as a career in Scotland. That is a valid point about an area in which we are failing, but we are trying hard to change that. Do we employ modern apprentices? We have a human resources department that looks after 700 or 800 employees at present. We have a fairly detailed interaction with the HE and FE institutions in relation to recruitment. It is also fair to say that the attitude of the UK youth is different to that of Europeans. We have found that a European worker can have a better work ethic than their UK counterpart. A lot of our Polish friends have gone back to Poland because it is economically viable to do so now, but they were particularly good. Our London hotels employ many people from the Baltic states and, again, we are keen to keep them. The issue is not quite as simple as asking whether we can put in a modern apprenticeship scheme and get in a few employees from the colleges. Sometimes, the quality of the employee is not what we would like it to be, to be honest. Is that sufficiently hard hitting?
You admitted that there is a perception about job versus career. You said that you and the industry are working hard to try to change that perception. As well as the industry, what is your company doing in that regard?10:30
The prescribed programme is to say, “We’ll say this is going to happen and then it will happen.” Again, it is about attitude. For example, when a youth comes to us for employment, we will try to explain the career opportunities that are available and that their role is one not of subservience, but service. We use a programme called flow, which is part of an extended, on-the-job training programme. The intention is to say to an individual that there are many opportunities in the hospitality industry and that it is not about being just a room attendant or something similar—there are opportunities in every facet of the business, whether it be financial or whatever. We try to impart that message to people when they come to us. We want them to know that whether or not they are suitable for a particular role, they will have other attributes and perhaps other skills that they may want to develop and that the hospitality industry can develop them, but there is the difficulty that—probably at school level—careers officers paint the picture that the hospitality industry is not a particularly sexy industry to be involved with.
We employ up to 15 people, so we do not have the same infrastructure as Apex Hotels. We do not employ anybody on modern apprenticeship schemes, mainly because our seasonality affects the consistency of training. However, I support everything that Norman Springford said. As I said earlier, we are not preparing our youth for the real world. We have to get the attitude sorted out. The expectations and the culture are incorrect and we somehow have to change that.A recession does funny things to a business. For example, we certainly employ a lot more local staff than we have done in the past 10 years. I suppose that some people perceive that as a good thing, but my question is why some businesses prefer to employ people from the eastern bloc countries rather than people from our country. That is a tough thing to take in. I will make the situation real for the committee. We have to face people saying, “I’ll come to your job, but I won’t work on Friday or Saturday.” That is just not real in our trade or profession. We have to get people’s expectations in line with ours. If we do that, we will be able to employ a lot more of our young people, who deserve a chance.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
As of 1 December, everybody will be British. Our last Polish person will leave us on 1 December and we will be 100 per cent Scottish. One person was South African but is now Scottish. He has got a UK passport and is a very happy chappie. The reality is that the whole team will be Scots. I am proud of that, but that was not the reality 12 months ago.
I am conscious of the time, so I will ask just one more question. Both of you spoke earlier about work experience and people coming through the education system who perhaps understand the theory but not the practical side. Do you offer summer placements to people going through college and university so that they can gain experience of your sector and go back to college at the end of the summer with a better understanding that is not just about the theory?
We have a programme with Napier University whereby we will take a university student and offer them training modules at our cost. We have a number of modules, which can be anything from hotel accounting through to room attendants and waiting. The idea is that we offer week-long modules completely free, which people fit into their curriculum—the modules are not in addition to what they do; there is a choice as to whether they go on the programme or not. As part of the programme, they are encouraged to work up to 20 hours a week with us on a part-time basis, there is full-time employment over the summer and during breaks from the curriculum.The advantage to us is that we get staff who stay with us for several years during their university degree and they improve their abilities during that process. When they come out with their degree, we offer them a cash-incentive bonus as well as their paid employment. Our view is that they come out better able to take a job. Those who can show a prospective employer a CV with a 2:1 degree and our programme attached to it are better qualified, as they have a lot of practical experience. The advantage of the programme to us is that we have continuity with a member of staff for perhaps four years. As they go through their course towards a degree, they are better able to take responsibilities off shift supervisors and so on, which is particularly valuable for us. We have up to 15 to 20 people at any one time on the programme.
We do that in conjunction with Moray College. Two chefs are currently working on the programme with us. Across the board, however, I would like to see more earn and learn both to help fund students through their education and to help the industry. It is a two-way thing. I see a lot of potential in earn and learn.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
The hotel industry has not been seen as a good payer—it does not remunerate staff well. Indeed, in some areas, people can be paid more for stacking shelves in a supermarket than in the hospitality industry. Is that a fair assessment? Is the fact that once they have come through college or university people can get better remuneration and possibly have better career paths elsewhere part of the issue about the commitment of people to the hospitality industry?
That is old news. Our industry competes well in the marketplace. We have to do that. Tesco, Sainsbury’s and all the other supermarkets are competing for the same staff and we have to compete on an equal basis, although we can probably offer people more career aspects. What you describe happened yesterday; it is not the current reality. The minimum wage sorted that one out for starters.Would we like to pay our staff more? If the customer paid more, we might be able to do that, but there is a market reality. Many people have dreams about pay scales, but the reality is that it is a matter of what the market can afford.
I am inclined to agree with that, although to be honest I probably share the view that the industry is not seen as a good payer. Perhaps people in the industry are also seen as having to work long hours. Although there is a national minimum wage, which we clearly abide by, and we tend to aim our remuneration at the national living wage, quite a large number of management employees in the hospitality industry who work more than 48 hours a week—and expect to do so—opt out. Saying that is not a source of pride for me, but that is the reality. When an employee goes off the hourly paid process and becomes a management salaried individual, we generally find that they work more than 48 hours a week. It has almost become traditional and accepted that that is what people need to do in the hospitality industry. As I say, I am not proud of that, but that is the reality.
As a committee, we understand that tourism is not just about attracting visitors; it is about creating jobs, opportunities and the correct remuneration. I am glad to hear that Mr Ellis and Mr Springford see the hospitality industry moving forward, but we have to get that message out to our young people. Going back to Mr Ellis’s point, I wonder whether those young people are not seeing a career path in the industry because the industry itself and VisitScotland have failed to get across the real opportunities that exist in that respect.
I do not think that that is a particularly Scottish issue or challenge but, as far as Scotland is concerned, could we improve? Damn right we could—and should. We should get out of bed every day wanting to do things better and I hope that we will. Some, but not all parts of the industry are making an effort to go into schools, get involved in careers days and talk about the opportunities in our industry, but it is patchy.
I thank Norman Springford and Gavin Ellis for giving up their time this morning. The committee very much appreciates your input, which will be helpful in our examination of what I think is a very important sector for Scotland.10:41 Meeting suspended.
10:46 On resuming—
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I am chief executive of the Cairngorms Business Partnership, which is perhaps unique in Scotland in its merging of the traditional chamber organisation and the new destination management organisation. We look not only at tourism but at wider business and economic issues around the Cairngorms national park. We have 300 members and our board members are elected to represent the park’s five areas and its different business sectors.
I have just arrived in Edinburgh as chief executive of the city’s first DMO in its true sense as a public-private partnership. At the moment, we are owned wholly by the City of Edinburgh Council, but the majority of our board members are private sector individuals. Having been here for only 20 weeks, I am still on a learning curve. I will do my best to answer your questions, but I might not know absolutely everything.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I am the chief executive of Glasgow City Marketing Bureau, which is a destination marketing and management organisation. It has a membership organisation based around it and generates approximately £1 million of private income from business community support.We position Glasgow in international and national markets, working specifically to attract major events to the city. We also work with a range of partners in discretionary business tourism, in particular conventions; we promote Glasgow and the retail sector through the style mile initiative; and we are supported by 860 businesses that work alongside us daily. We work in partnership with the business community, with Glasgow Chamber of Commerce and with Prestwick and Glasgow airports, which have been actively bidding for new routes to generate traffic into the city.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
Thank you very much. It is interesting that, to one extent or another, you all represent public-private partnerships and membership organisations. I will kick off with the first question. Has the economic downturn in recent years impacted on the income to your organisations and the work that you have been able to do? What role do your organisations have in trying to cope with the fairly difficult economic times?
The model that we have taken forward combines private sector bodies. There has sometimes been the criticism that there are too many public sector bodies. Certainly in our area, we had an oversupply of private sector bodies—some local businesses were paying three or four subscriptions to organisations. The Cairngorms Business Partnership is attempting to pull those organisations together so that there is a single subscription to pay. That represents great value for money and, critically, means less expenditure for businesses. We recognise the pressure that is on the bottom line and on every pound of expenditure. The model is certainly being well received by businesses.
On-going promotion is as important for Edinburgh as capital growth. We must recognise that in England the core cities group, which includes Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds, Birmingham and Bristol, is considering how to develop the business improvement district—BID—structure into a TBID, or tourism BID, structure. As I understand it, legislation is in place to allow sectoral BIDs in Scotland. Funding in that context is a partnership between the private and public sectors. It is vital to ensure that the private sector gets what it wants from any sectoral BID and that it has the ability to drive forward the city in a way that is relevant to it. We must recognise that the English cities are considering that opportunity.
Our budgeted income from our membership has this month exceeded our target. Retail support for the Christmas campaign has increased from last year, with seven major UK retailers supporting it. Income from Glasgow City Council and from national Government support has increased, partly because of the bids that have been presented to the UK Government, the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council in relation to opportunities for growing business in the city. We have confirmed business up to 2021 and are bidding for up to 2023. Opportunities to secure income need to be generated so that income can be grown.
In the Cairngorms, as in Edinburgh and Glasgow, we have worked hard to pull together marketing campaigns. There has been no shortage of support for that at local-business level, although it has not been on the same scale as that in Glasgow. We have levered in funds from the private sector of about £200,000, which is the highest figure that we have ever had. Businesses recognise the requirement to invest in marketing and they will buy into a strong local collaboration with local leadership. They will see a return from that.Marketing is further supported by the fact that the area is a national park: there is a recognition that the area has massive potential if the national park is presented as such. National parks have international recognition, so there is a role to be played in the marketing of Scotland and what Scotland has to offer. We want more partnership working with VisitScotland; we have accessed its growth fund to support marketing, and we see national parks playing a role in that Scotland mix. National Geographic magazine voted the Cairngorms national park one of the top 20 places to visit, which corralled businesses into recognising that we are one of the big players. That confidence level has started to create more willingness to invest in joint marketing to secure market share.
This is about alignment of spend. In my first few weeks in post, I have been looking at how we might work with the private sector and some of the bigger employers, such as the universities, to align spend in order to ensure that the marketing effort is all going into one place. We are running a Christmas campaign with input from Edinburgh airport and various parts of the private sector, as well as from the central BID in Edinburgh, so we are beginning to align spend to maximise impact and return on investment. We are also working with VisitScotland; we accept that a big organisation such as that can buy media more effectively than some smaller organisations can. The creation of a partnership with its marketing team—while keeping our city’s individual identity as the capital city, of course—will, therefore, be an important part of our strategy.
In tangible terms, we have a restaurant booking engine on our site, and we work very closely with the Glasgow Restaurant Association, which is based in our offices. That makes things incredibly simple when we are putting packages together for events and conferences, because the association is literally one door away. We also have a flight booking engine on our site and, as you know, we do accommodation for people taking short breaks in the city. We are linked to 16 or 17 different websites at the moment, so in regard to reasons to visit, we are not the single portal for entry. We do large block bookings for accommodation for events, on which we work with the organisers. Our experience ranges from the G8 summit and the Special Olympics to the 2014 Commonwealth games, which will involve about 100,000 room nights going through contract. We also secured the rooms that were required for the Ryder cup; we had a process for that. Joint partnerships are critical to making money go further. Working with partners to leverage budgets to go further and to provide a range of options for clients is key. We work incredibly closely with the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre, and we have developed models that work well in the marketplace to reduce cost and risk for the organiser, and to leverage benefit for us as a city.Tying in with the universities and other networks is also critical because they can bring enormous value to an event or conference. For example, we are bidding for a conference with our partners in Glasgow and partners in the national Scottish context and the UK context. Nine universities from Scotland and the north of England are providing funding for that. The securing of additional funding from partners who would benefit from a conference or event is important in ensuring that it is not just the public purse that is generating that opportunity.
I am not a big shopper; I never have been and—to be honest—I never intend to be. However, I saw this week a news item that described a 9 per cent reduction in footfall in the retail sector. How will that affect your campaign? I ask all three witnesses how that could affect what you are trying to do.11:00
Our research indicates that retail is one of the primary reasons for short-break visits to Glasgow. It is critical that we support the retail sector. The UK footfall figures are approximately 9 per cent down and the estimates that we are getting from retailers indicate that Christmas retail sales might be some 5 per cent down on the previous year. We are working hard to counterbalance that, because 50 per cent of all retail sales are taken through the Christmas period; that is how important the period is to cities and to every retailer in the country. If the retail footfall is down, it has an immediate impact on their profitability and on employment. We will fight hard alongside our retailers to generate footfall and try to encourage spend in the city, because if we do not, 5 per cent might become 10 per cent. That is a substantial risk.
The trend in Edinburgh is slightly different, in that retail spend in October was up 5 per cent, which is good. We are obviously pleased with that.I echo Scott Taylor’s comments about the importance of the retail sector. Your capital city needs to invest in its retail opportunity and to consider how it can improve it. I am working with the City of Edinburgh Council to develop a new retail strategy for the city, which will be vital.Spend—not only footfall—is important. Obviously, if people do not come, we cannot extract the money from them. However, it is vital that we keep our eyes on both indicators.
Retail is not the prime economic driver in my patch; it is outdoor activities, which shows the difference between the destinations or key customer points in Scotland. This panel of witnesses represents three very different destinations and there are destinations the length and breadth of the country. However, we do not have a coherent destination development strategy. With our own areas of expertise and product areas, we each have a part to play in economic recovery, but we need more joined-up thinking and a destination development strategy for sequencing how VisitScotland attracts people to the country so that on-going work in each of the destinations can be linked. That work should retain its local flavour and the local businesses must buy into the strategy, but it should be integrated and joined up, which it is not.
If we want to create a joined-up structure, we need to have the players at the table. The tourism strategy that we have developed in Glasgow with our partnership approach has been key. VisitScotland, Glasgow Chamber of Commerce, Glasgow City Council, the Glasgow City Marketing Bureau and Scottish Enterprise are all at the table. Those five organisations meet regularly to develop the strategy and push out the actions against the action plan. Glasgow is in a good position. We have a strong relationship with the national tourism agency, and that is going from strength to strength. It has been built over a number of years, and the city is reaping the benefit of it.
Ditto in Edinburgh. We have a similar emerging tourism strategy, which will be the first for the city. It is a public sector and private sector partnership, and we are working with VisitScotland as the national agency. The key thing for Edinburgh will be delivery of that plan. We are exploring that as one of the actions.
My area might be able to trump that, because we are working closely with VisitScotland on secure growth funding. We have just announced a partnership programme to examine the visitor information centres and visitor information provision throughout the national park. We are working in partnership with five local authorities, two enterprise agencies, the Cairngorms National Park Authority and VisitScotland. We, too have a positive partnership, if a somewhat more complicated landscape.
I am keen to understand the mission and purpose of each of your organisations. I was interested in what Mr Rankin had to say about the economic remit of the Cairngorms Business Partnership being wider than tourism. What is the budget for each of your organisations?
As a round figure, the gross budget for the Cairngorms Business Partnership is £400,000. As I said, the split between public sector and private sector partnership funding is about 50:50. Four years ago, the organisation was 80 per cent public sector funded. Our organisation’s aim is sustainability in its truest sense.
My budget this year from the City of Edinburgh Council is £1.2 million. That will reduce by 10 per cent year on year for the next three years. I also have business membership income, because we also run the Edinburgh Convention Bureau and the accommodation booking service. We also currently have the private sector partnerships that I alluded to for specific campaigns, although there is a job to do more widely.
Our mission is simple: we create customers. That is the fundamental function of our organisation. Our funding from Glasgow City Council, which is the principal stakeholder, is £3.9 million. That will reduce by £100,000 next year. Our total expenditure is expected to reach £6 million this year. That includes funding for a variety of different activities. It includes financial support around events such as the Commonwealth games. Funding for route development and a subvention for conferences is also included.
You probably expect my next question. How do you ensure that you are getting best value and how do you measure success? Is it based on visitor numbers, growth in employment or income generated for the local economy? What metrics have you put in place to ensure that you measure success year on year?
On our tourism ambitions, growth targets are set down in the tourism development plan.You mentioned our wider economic remit. The national park is consulting on the national park plan 2. Our three pillars of activity are promoting the area; business development to help local businesses to increase their capacity and improve the customer experience; and advocacy. We are taking forward the proposal that the economy of the national park can be a main contributor to the national economic agenda, so we are looking to develop some key areas around promotion, skills and transport, which are items that appear on agendas across the land.We are essentially taking forward a business manifesto that develops a broad spectrum of activities as part of an economic development and diversification strategy that looks to attract new business into the national park, so that we will not be as reliant on tourism as we are now.
Edinburgh works across five priority areas—live, work, visit, study and invest—that are distributed to us by the City of Edinburgh Council. My board is consulting on where our priorities should lie, as we speak, and I would be surprised if tourism does not feature high up on our list of priorities. Following on from what you have said about progression routes—we can debate that further later, if you like—I suspect that the study market might be another priority. Another priority will be about how we can encourage new investment.On the metrics that we currently employ, the Edinburgh Convention Bureau has always looked at economic benefit as well as direct spend, among other things. We also consider accommodation booking rates and increasingly, along with visit Scotland, individual visitor figures.
Glasgow City Marketing Bureau has approximately 20 published key performance indicators. The board monitors the indicators bimonthly. One target this year is to achieve a 75 per cent hotel occupancy rate, which is about 0.5 per cent higher than last year’s target. From April through October, we have run at a rate of 80 per cent. Substantial different types of information support that, such as independent information from Deloitte, PKF and Lynn Jones Research, and we have daily analyses that go back for the past 12 years. That gives us a tangible measure of output for the 12,000 hotel rooms in the area that we seek to fill.Our target for conferences is £113 million, which is about 500,000 room nights this year. We are at 84 per cent of that target with five months to go, so I expect that we will exceed it, which will mean substantial growth on last year. Our events are closely targeted. We look for 400,000 unique visitors to Glasgow from the events that we bring in. We have about 10 routes in our target list and we have since April secured five of them—from Barcelona, Rome, Madrid, Amsterdam and Stavanger.
Thank you for those comprehensive answers. I have one final short question. As a Glaswegian who represents an Edinburgh constituency, I must choose my words carefully. To what extent do the two organisations that represent Edinburgh and Glasgow work together when that is in the country’s wider interest?
As Scotland’s major cities, we need to work together. I have been in Scotland for only five minutes, but I have already had three conversations and one meeting with Scott Taylor. The opportunity is great.Jim Eadie will appreciate that our local authorities are keen to keep their independence, to an extent. As a representative of the capital city, I think that it is vital that we behave as a gateway to opportunity not only for the city region but for the Lothians. We need to think about how we can develop the regional tourism opportunity and about the partnerships that we can have in bringing together a greater conurbation. Rail links and other aspects will be important.
I will pick up Lucy Bird’s point about rail. Glasgow and Edinburgh’s combined economies make a greater gross domestic product contribution than do any other combined economies in the United Kingdom outside London, so high speed 2 has a reason and rationale for going from the central belt to London. That would substantially support the UK economy and the growth that is generated.The Ryder cup provides a clear example of Glasgow and Edinburgh working together. A substantial number of rooms is required for it, and Edinburgh and Glasgow hotels were in difficulty with the contract, so we worked together to pull together the hotel associations in Edinburgh and Glasgow. We rewrote the contract for Ryder cup accommodation and, in conjunction with the team at VisitScotland, we provided that contract to Ryder cup travel services. The rooms have now been booked and are secured.An interesting point is that we will bring another large piece of business into Glasgow—a 6,000-delegate conference—while the Ryder cup takes place. We moved the rooms for the early part of the Ryder cup to Edinburgh hotels so that Glasgow could take the conference delegates from Saturday to Wednesday and Ryder cup visitors from Wednesday to Sunday. Through that process of working together, we have created more opportunity. The hotel associations in Glasgow and Edinburgh have demonstrated that capacity.
The conference bureaux work well together on the operational opportunity. They are in competition, but the staff work well together and complement each other’s work.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I remind members of my earlier declaration of interests: I am an unpaid director of an arts festival in Glasgow that has in the past received small amounts of tourism-related funding.I want to ask about the issues that I raised with the previous panel around the place that domestic tourism has. Are we doing enough to maximise the opportunities from domestic tourism as opposed to international tourism? Festivals in particular have a role to play; for example, they can be very effective at attracting long-weekend visitors from elsewhere in the UK. Obviously, both the cities have a strong festivals track record, but I might learn something about the Cairngorms that I was not aware of before. Are we doing enough to support the proliferation of those events rather than focusing on a handful of big events such as the Ryder cup and the Commonwealth games? It sometimes seems as though it is hard for an event to get noticed or attract support if it is not related to one of the big events. What are we doing to attract domestic tourism? Are we doing enough?
It is great that the Cairngorms national park is considered to be one of the big three destinations in Scotland. Our clear agenda is that we are looking to create all-year-round tourism in the national park. On promotion, we have a wide variety of local cultural and sporting events throughout the year. However, they have been happening in isolation; individuals have been working on them, and they have never had collective clout. We have a programme of local sustainable festivals that are not dependent on public funding but are run by the community. That is a different type of tourism proposition; it is rural tourism. The CBP supports those small individual organisations through a campaign to promote the calendar of events throughout the year. We are looking at food and tourism, cultural events and sporting events, of which there are many, although they are not presented as a year-round package. We are also looking to bring in the hotels and restaurants in promoting those events in order to get local collaboration. It is very much a bottom-up approach. We are looking to attract new events to the area, but we are primarily focusing on local sustainable events that attract the Scottish and UK market.
In Edinburgh, we are looking at how we create a year-round market. Of course there is a significant peak with our festivals in August, when seven of the 12 Edinburgh festivals take place. It is about how we bring the wings up to meet that tip. It is important not to forget that we have a year-round cultural offer of excellence in Edinburgh. We need to make sure that we can irrigate the market for that opportunity by using the festivals as a lever. We are working very hard with the festivals to see how we can develop the indigenous market and create opportunity for not only Edinburgh companies but companies such as the National Theatre of Scotland. In relation to the UK, we have to focus on where our primary markets are, which might be in the north of England or the south of England at any one time. It is absolutely vital that we segment the market and do promotional activity in each segment, because they are warm already.
Our focus is on major events that will bring customers into the destination. Festivals as well as community events and other smaller cultural and social events have support from organisations such as Glasgow Life, which quite rightly focus on developing and supporting such events. I am not saying that community events are not important, but our focus is people in and pictures out. That is where a significant amount of our energies are targeted. The relationship that we have with partners at EventScotland is absolutely targeted at some of the major events, and we have a list of those targeted events that we are looking to secure. The level of return on investment that I am looking for from events is 10:1, although I am obviously looking for a much higher return from conventions.
Is there a danger that the focus on a small number of very large events such as the Commonwealth games in Glasgow means that we miss opportunities elsewhere? Could we be better at developing small annual events around the year instead of focusing on a handful of big events?
Glasgow hosts more than 500 community events, and more than 130 music events take place each week. It is about where we, as a destination marketing organisation, are best able to bring focus. I completely agree that there is a need for a strong event community and a real creative community that delivers a different beating heart in Glasgow from those of other cities. That is really vital. It is pretty clear what we do for a living.
The focus of the national agencies—for example, VisitScotland is working closely with Creative Scotland to maximise the opportunities of the year of creative Scotland next year—is absolutely vital in that context. We must make sure that the capital infrastructure is brought up to a level that meets 21st century market standards. That is why my first comment was that on-going promotion is every bit as important as capital growth.
On Lucy Bird’s comment about reaching the 21st century market, a challenge that is particular to the Highlands, although perhaps not to the two major cities, is that of reaching our customers. As we know, the whole world is moving to mobile. There are more mobiles than there are televisions and personal computers together. Recent research from Morgan Stanley suggests that pc access will be overtaken by mobile access by 2014, and the Highland economy is massively disadvantaged right now because of the lack of mobile signal. We have black holes between Perth and Inverness. We have a 3G oasis at Perth, where I grabbed my e-mails this morning, and then nothing until Inverness. We are trying to present the information journey to our visitors from pre-departure to travel, arrival and afterwards, and we are finding it extraordinarily hard to communicate with the changing customer. We have an app that enables someone to buy a room or book a table or a ski-ing lesson with three taps, but we are working with one hand—in some areas, both hands—tied behind our back.There is a great deal of conversation around broadband roll-out, and we would like the targets for that to be brought forward, as they are particularly lazy. We also want mobile to be tacked right in there because the customer is shopping for and buying product by mobile. Tourism products such as hotels and leisure activities are being bought by mobile—just google it and you will see the trends. Unless we move, mobile signal will remain a bit of an elephant in the room. We really need to accelerate work on that.
Do you agree that there is a need for the UK Government and the Scottish Government to shift the balance from the priority always being wired broadband and to think more about the next generation of mobile signal? Never mind 3G; it could be much easier to reach some of the areas that you are talking about with 4G than with wired broadband.
Definitely. We are pleased to see the Government moving some of the budget from revenue to capital expenditure. However, I am concerned when I see roll-out deadlines of 2016 and 2017. The world will have moved on by then and we will need 4G. It is no use forecasting 3G delivery at that point; the customer will have moved on and will be going to the lakes or somewhere else. We wholly support your point.
I have a question for Ms Bird and Mr Taylor. You will be aware that the Scottish Government is consulting on a cities strategy. How much have you been consulted on that so far? How are you ensuring that you have sufficient input?It is great to see our major cities strutting the international stage, but we must ensure that the hinterland of those cities benefit to some extent from the work that is being done. What are you doing to protect the interests of your immediate hinterland?
As I said, I am keen for some of the Lothians to take the opportunity to benefit from their proximity to the capital city. I have met East Lothian Council and I will soon meet Midlothian Council.The film office for Edinburgh, which attracts productions to film in the city, sits within my office and provides us with opportunities in that regard. That organisation has been working across the Lothians for the past few years, which means that we have a bit of a track record in that area already. I have not been contacted yet about the cities strategy consultation, but I would be happy to be involved.
Glasgow has been working closely with Scottish Enterprise—and, as a result, the Government—on the economic strategy. Membership of the Glasgow economic leadership board was announced only a few days ago. Its chair is Jim McDonald, who is also on the board of Scottish Enterprise, and a number of business leaders are attached to it. Glasgow’s economic ties with Scottish Enterprise will be much stronger than they have been.The Cabinet’s involvement in tourism has been strong. We have a close relationship with Fergus Ewing, the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism, who is keenly involved in various areas of tourism, particularly around generating more income from business tourism. A progressive and active working party is moving forward on that and a strong relationship has developed.On the overall strategy for the city, we think that the economic leadership board, in partnership with Scottish Enterprise and the Government, will help to deliver the aspirations of Glasgow in that regard. I take issue with your second question to some extent, as we do not regard places outwith Glasgow as a hinterland. We have never used that terminology. For example, this evening, I will meet business interests from the Loch Lomond area to discuss the opportunities for business that are presented by the Olympic and Commonwealth games. We work closely with businesses across the region. There are 17,000 rooms across the area, and we need them on a regular basis. With regard to the Commonwealth games in 2014, we are having conversations and setting up contracts with businesses in Carnoustie and Dundee. We would never regard those areas as hinterlands.
I would not regard Dundee as the hinterland of Glasgow, either. However, I take your point. My next point was going to be about broadband capability and so on, but I know that the Government is addressing that fairly directly. We have talked about other parts of our infrastructure, such as rail and airports, and I would like you to comment on the development of our ports. As I understand it, cruise ship tourism has been growing—I do not know whether it still is. What relationships do you have with ports around your cities? Edinburgh has Leith, and Glasgow has the likes of Greenock, Troon and, now, Cairnryan.
You will be aware of the recent change of ownership of Forth Ports. We are developing a relationship with Forth Ports, as the strategy moves with the city. Obviously, the port is part of the city’s economic development, and we are working with Forth Ports to promote the city as a destination for the cruise market. However, areas such as South Queensferry do not feel as though they are taking the opportunities offered by the cruise market. There is some promotional work to be done in that area. Partnership with Forth Ports and Arcus Infrastructure Partners is the way to go. 11:30
We have a really good, tangible opportunity. We have worked with the port authority in Greenock to develop and fund a cruise brochure, which it uses overseas to promote Greenock as a stop-off point. That piece of print demonstrates what Scotland, and Glasgow and Greenock, have to offer the cruise market. It is an important opportunity. The challenge is probably to do with the arrival point at Greenock. How can that be invested in—cap-exed—and improved so that it is much more of an arrival point into Scotland and people not only come to spend money in Greenock but go up the west coast, down south, over to Edinburgh, up to Glasgow and so on? More can be done, but it will require funding.
We have contacts with Flybe, through Inverness airport and Highlands and Islands Airports Limited. The cruise market was using Invergordon, but the fact that I cannot answer in detail what the connections are means that we need to work harder in that market. The footnote to the point about infrastructure, which I suppose links to the previous subject of broadband, is the Scottish rail franchise, which will be renewed in 2014 and which is out for consultation. I sound like a stuck record, but I would love to see within the franchise the condition that 24/7 wi-fi is available on all trains, not just for tourists but so that our economy can keep working as people travel across Scotland.
On infrastructure funds, it is important that we look at air route development funds and how we incentivise Scottish airports, especially Edinburgh, to provide a one-stop shop to international visitors.
We have seen an upsurge in tourism figures over the past 18 months or so because of the growth of the staycation. For the 10-year period prior to that, our statistics look pretty poor. Why do you think that was?
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
If we are getting down to international statistics I am sure that VisitScotland might be the best to answer that. We have to recognise that the economy that we have now is a completely different proposition from what it was.
There are a number of possible answers. One of them concerns the international passenger survey figures that are collected. If you have ever been through an airport and been questioned about where you came from, where you are going and the purpose of your visit, you are probably the first person I have ever met who has had that experience. In all my travels through the airports in London I have never seen the international passenger survey—the desks have never been occupied. I question the analysis of some of the figures. I question the 2009 figures, for example, because they are just an aggregate of those for 2006, 2007 and 2008. We face a real challenge in understanding the volume and value of tourism in Scotland. A revision of the funding level to make much more substantive funding available to support the information that we get would be useful.As well as looking at those figures, we have the figures from Scottish Enterprise and VisitScotland, which start to give us a meaningful picture. Deloitte produces figures that indicate what is taking place in Glasgow, what our occupancy levels are and what our spends are. To be fair, a hotel investor would never use the national figures—they could not build a business on that basis. It is necessary to drill down and to see what is happening at a local level.Occupancy rates in Glasgow have not really grown—they have stayed at around 75 per cent since 2000—but since 2000, 46 hotels have been built, 4,000 rooms have been added to the supply and those 4,000 rooms have been taken up as a result of an increase in demand. Demand has grown and supply has grown, but occupancy percentages have not—they have stayed pretty static at around 75 per cent. A range of analysis could be provided to answer your question.
So you are telling me that the Government figures for that 10-year period are wrong and that the situation is much better than the underperformance reported in the Government’s figures.
I think that there is an opportunity to increase the infrastructure to ensure that the connectivity routes to Scotland—the air, rail and road links—are as speedy and as good as they can be.In addition, we need to focus on specific market segments—the warm segments that I mentioned earlier. We need to promote hard in those markets.Another factor is the cost of the available bed space. For example, Glasgow might have a price war on hotel rooms, but that is not the case in Edinburgh, where we are maintaining occupancy levels. Indeed, Scottish Development International figures showed that in May and June of this year, when the figures were more than 80 per cent and more than 90 per cent respectively, occupancy was higher than it had ever been. That drives up the rate.We must look at how we can encourage a range of offers. For example, Motel One is coming to Edinburgh. We could also think about how we could capitalise on the green tourism market, which would involve looking at the opportunities for camp sites and so on.The issues are infrastructure, promotion and ensuring that we are as fleet of foot as we can be, which relates back to planning and getting new opportunities for the various markets to be served.
I have a quick final question for Alan Rankin. I have always been impressed by the ability of Aviemore and the Cairngorms to overcome the problem of seasonality. You have done that much more successfully than other rural areas. What is your secret?
A lot of new, young businesses have come to the area. It is clear that we have had a bit of a mogul in the form of the snow that we have had over the past few years. The last two years have been an absolute exception.Great diversification is going on. New, young businesses are starting up. We did an audit of things for people to do from the roundabout at Aviemore to the top of the mountain, and we found that there are more than 100 different tourism activities and activity-based options to choose from. That underpins the idea of the Cairngorms being an all-year-round destination. We are no longer seen as a winter destination. A lot of the feedback that we get from customers is about their surprise at how much there is to do.
I want to ask about the target of increasing tourism by 50 per cent. All three of you have given quite an upbeat account of the industry in your various regions. Do you think that we will meet the target of achieving a 50 per cent increase by 2015?
I will carry on where Scott Taylor left off in his questioning of the figures. Tourism was recently valued at £11 billion. The 50 per cent target was based on a £4.5 billion baseline in 2006. Measuring the industry is a real challenge. What is tourism? We are jumping between £11 billion and £4.5 billion. Should we just pick a number and start from there? A lot of work needs to be done to evaluate the industry and the benefits that it brings to other clusters that support and work with it.It is a difficult question to answer. I know that a massive effort is being made but the 50 per cent ambition is well-nigh impossible to measure.
I echo that, and I go back to my answer about making sure that we are fleet of foot in recognising what the market requires, in making sure that our infrastructure and providers are able to provide it, and in promoting it effectively. I think that a 50 per cent increase is a very high target. We have a long way to go.
A 50 per cent increase is still our ambition. We should not shy away from that target; we should be measured on it and aim to achieve it.The measures that we have are on occupancy and yield, and we are having a strong year for occupancy. Glasgow has the highest occupancy rate of any Scottish city in the year to date. That is how strong we are. The yield from hotels and restaurants is always challenged through the available sell price.The market is changing dramatically. For example, people are shaving their two-night stays down to one night, which shows the differences in the way in which people are buying; it also makes a difference to hotels’ cost structures. The profitability of hotels, restaurants and service providers is being challenged significantly and the yield that businesses are able to get is genuinely being compromised by distressed inventory sellers. For example, lastminute.com or Groupon, which might have commission levels of 25 per cent or 30 per cent, are taking available profit or yield from businesses and distributing it elsewhere. The industry is facing a significant threat.Some positive things are on the horizon. These are the winning years, as Mike Cantlay said at last night’s presentation. He is absolutely right. The opportunity to take advantage of that is very clear. We forecast a need for 3,000 additional hotel rooms in Glasgow, the hotels want to come to Glasgow and we want to sell them the space, but there is such a big problem getting funding. The banks have withdrawn completely from the marketplace. The saying is, “Build it and they will come,” but if we do not build those hotels—if we are not pouring the concrete, as someone said earlier—we cannot generate the bed nights. That is a real challenge for us and we will experience its effects in 2014. We are hitting 80 per cent occupancy already, and physically we can only grow so far before we hit the limit. We are close to that limit.
That answer takes me to the question that I wanted to ask about occupancy rates and the availability of rooms. I also go back to a point that Mike MacKenzie made. In the statistics that the committee has been presented with, it looks as though the tourism figures for the past 10 years have flatlined. The picture that I am getting from the witnesses today is that the figures are increasing. For example, we heard that 40 new hotels in Glasgow have been developed during the past 10 years and they are creating occupancy rates that do not seem to match the figures that we got from elsewhere.Is enough accurate information being gathered by VisitScotland and others so that we can measure what is happening not only in direct tourism, but in conference tourism? Glasgow has shown leadership and has clearly indicated the expansion in the volume of conference tourism that is possible in such a city. Are we ticking the right boxes? Are VisitScotland and others gathering the right information so that we can make an accurate assessment of what has happened in the past 10 years?11:45
The simple answer is probably no. VisitScotland’s challenge is with the national gathering of those statistics at a UK level, which is compromised. That makes it very difficult for VisitScotland to take an overall picture to compare what took place last year with what took place the year before and the year before that. We work with VisitScotland, as we do with Scottish Enterprise—collectively, we put money in to give us an analysis that we can use. The work by Deloitte is a clear case in point: Scottish Enterprise, Glasgow and VisitScotland make combined contributions so that Deloitte can provide us with information about the performance not just of Scotland’s cities, but of European cities. That provides us with a measure of where we are going, and with that information to talk about we sit down with potential investors or hotel developers and SDI, which is active and supportive but which cannot use figures that are UK international passenger survey figures.
Absolutely. I echo every word of that. We also buy into the Lynn Jones research that Scott referred to earlier, which is part of the picture, but not all of it.
In the Cairngorms, we took matters into our own hands and created our quarterly business barometer because we did not have the facts and figures to hand. The barometer records occupancy rates, business levels, visitor sources, duration of stay—all the core information that we need to drive our business plan. However, that is just an island of information and if we could connect it for benchmarking purposes—I come back to my earlier point about more joined-up thinking around destinations—we would have a collectively stronger story to tell.
I have to put on record my congratulations to Scott Taylor and his Glasgow team on the figures he gave us. Conference bookings up to 2023 clearly show the confidence that people outwith Scotland have in Glasgow. However, how do we overcome the issue that Mr Taylor raised of being unable to build new hotels and new accommodation if the banks are not willing to lend? There will come a saturation point. We will not be able to grow any further if those resources are not released, if the hotels are not built and if the beds are not available. How do we overcome that, as businesses, as regions and as an economy?
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
That is a very good question. I am not sure that it is an entirely fair question to put to the witnesses, but if they have any comments, we will hear them.
I disagree: we heard evidence that all the panellists are working with enterprise agencies and other partners in their areas, and the more partners can come together and identify the shortfalls, the more that would help to free up some of the resources required by others to create opportunities. How do we grow the tourism and conference markets in Scotland when there seems to be a bottleneck in the release of resources?
The business barometer records businesses’ response to the access to credit issue, which is a significant challenge. Another element that needs to be put into the equation is the speeding up and consistency of the planning system across the country. In August, Travelodge announced a £35 million kitty to build properties in or near national parks. I am fearful of the speed of response to that investment plan through planning restrictions and hurdles that will be put in Travelodge’s way. Credit is a problem, but we also need to address inconsistencies in the planning process.
I echo what Alan Rankin has said. In some sectors, some banks are constricted by their own working practices. Their criteria could be more flexible than they are at present—some influence could be brought to bear there. It may be that some of the newer operators are more interested in flexibility, which may, in turn, create the market forces for the others to become flexible too.
We work closely with the hotels team in SDI, and with Glasgow City Council on planning and fast tracking. What we bring to the table is the ability to articulate demand and supply for the period ahead. I would not change the SDI hotels team at all. It does a super job at representing Scotland, and we get our share of the opportunities. It does really well. I compliment and commend that team.Other agencies with which we have challenges might include Historic Scotland. If it had a particular view on a planning process, it might slow it up or stop it.Yesterday morning the minister, Fergus Ewing, told me that he was keen to stimulate tourism and create a platform on which hotel developers could build. I have suggested that there could be a framework so that, across Scotland, we agree to fast track the planning process and agree the methodology for providing a seamless approach for hotel investors. We could work hand in glove with SDI across Scotland. The banks could be part of the solution by being engaged in that framework. The information that they need could be delivered on a Scotland-wide basis.Our approach with the banks has been, I have to say, piecemeal. We and our developers make presentations to the banks, but in a piecemeal fashion. Both locally and nationally, we could do something about that.
The Co-operative Bank is keen. It is based in Manchester, but we have made a presentation to its office in Glasgow. We have also made presentations with investors to the Clydesdale Bank, and it is always open to that sort of initiative. However, our approach is piecemeal, and it does not take in the big four.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
I have one final question for Lucy Bird and Scott Taylor. The Ryder cup, the Commonwealth games and the homecoming are coming up in 2014—a whole slew of important events. Time is running out. What detailed planning meetings have you had with VisitScotland? I do not mean general discussions, but active and detailed joint-planning discussions about how everybody can help with those events.
I have met EventScotland and discussed where it is at—although where my organisation is at comes into things, too. I have also held considerable discussions with the Edinburgh festivals, which have been taking things forward through their forum. I understand that the Edinburgh festivals have been working very closely with VisitScotland, and I will be upping the momentum over the next six months.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
Yes, but that is probably more about where my organisation is, rather than about where VisitScotland is. The experience of the Edinburgh festivals has been different.
We are closely embedded with EventScotland on the Ryder cup. We work tightly with Robbie Clyde and we are holding venues for him as requested. The accommodation side is pretty locked down. Our daily relationship with EventScotland is really tight. It is well run by Paul Bush, and there is a good team. EventScotland forms part of the strategic major events forum in Glasgow, which covers all the major events in the city. It is a tight partner in Glasgow, as is VisitScotland. Malcolm Roughead and I are closely involved with 2014, and VisitScotland is closely involved in the Olympics.
Murdo FraserConThe Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
Good afternoon, as it is now. I thank the third panel of witnesses for joining us. I ask you to introduce yourselves and say what your roles are. We will start with Willie Macleod and work our way across the panel.
I am representing the Scottish Tourism Forum, of which I am a board member. My day job is primarily in tourism and economic development consultancy, and I am a non-executive director of a couple of businesses that are involved in hospitality and heritage-related visitor attractions.
I thank you all for coming along. I apologise for the fact that we are running a little bit behind schedule, but I hope that you enjoyed listening to the earlier evidence session, and that you perhaps picked up on some of the issues that the committee is keen to pursue.I invite Chic Brodie to begin our questions.
We have heard very positive news this morning, and a lot of the things that we are doing, such as the winning years, are key.There is something that I would like to lay to rest so that we can move on. Malcolm Roughead has been here before—forgive me, Malcolm—but it is important that we dispense with all the talk of 50 per cent growth and get that off the table, after having spoken to you and to the cabinet secretary and having heard the information today.I am looking at the information that VisitScotland has produced on the millions of trips in Scotland. In 2005, the figure was 17.3 million and in 2009 it was 15.1 million, so it fell by 2.2 million. Spend in real terms went down from £4.7 billion to £4.1 billion.I return to the question that we have raised with you previously. Despite what the cabinet secretary believes, and what I would like to believe, you said at the previous committee meeting you attended that the target is not achievable, and VisitScotland’s submission refers to the budget that you were given. I want to feel that, with all the good news that is going on, VisitScotland is in control of the base numbers that form the foundation from which we can spring to do things such as the winning years and so on. Can you clarify for us once and for all exactly what the position is regarding VisitScotland in terms of the numbers that form the basis for our tourism projection?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.