Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Charity Test (Specified Bodies) (Scotland) Order 2008 (Draft)

Wednesday 18 June 2008 Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Subordinate legislation 26 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

26 contributions
Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Good morning. I open the 17th meeting of the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee this year. I remind all those who are present that mobile phones and BlackBerrys should be switched off. Agenda item 1 is consideration of the draft Charity Test (Specified Bodies) (Scotland) Order 2008. I am delighted that the committee has the opportunity this morning to hear from Fiona Hyslop, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning. She is accompanied by Sean Ledger, the head of charity law in the civil law division; George Reid, head of the college strategy team in the further and adult education division; and Lorraine Stirling, principal legal officer in the development, education and local authorities division of the legal directorate. My apologies to Siân Ledger—I pronounced her name incorrectly at the beginning; I might even have performed a sex change inappropriately. I am sorry about that, Siân. I invite the minister to make some opening comments on the draft order.

Fiona Hyslop SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning · Lothians
link

Good morning, convener and committee. I am pleased to have this opportunity to outline the need for the Charity Test (Specified Bodies) (Scotland) Order 2008. It addresses a specific point that was raised by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator in relation to the charitable status and independence of the incorporated further education colleges. All incorporated Scottish further education colleges are charities. As such, they must meet the charity test as set out in the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005. The act states:"A body … does not … meet the charity test if … its constitution … expressly permits the Scottish Ministers or a Minister of the Crown to direct or otherwise control its activities,"or if its assets can be distributed"for a purpose which is not a charitable purpose".As part of its pilot rolling review in July 2007, OSCR concluded that John Wheatley College failed the charity test, because ministers' powers over the college meant that it did not meet the independence requirement. OSCR found that the college also failed the charity test because, in one instance, college assets are not tied to charitable purposes. The relevant ministerial powers are contained in the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992, and they apply to all colleges that are incorporated under the act. Therefore, all those colleges will also fail the charity test for the same reasons that John Wheatley College did. Following OSCR's ruling, we carefully considered the three options that were available to us. First, we could do nothing, which would result in colleges losing their charitable status. Secondly, we could remove or amend all the powers of control and the asset distribution provision so that colleges could pass the charity test. Thirdly, as a last resort, we could exempt the colleges from the independence requirement and the asset distribution requirement of the charity test.Ministers considered it important to maintain the charitable status of all the incorporated colleges. We believe that charitable status is entirely consistent with the standing and activity of colleges, the challenges that they address and the way in which they conduct themselves. We share OSCR's view that colleges have an inherently charitable purpose and deliver substantial public benefit. Therefore, taking no action was simply not an option.After detailed consideration of and consultation on the various powers and whether they could be amended or removed, we concluded that the most appropriate way forward is to amend the provision on asset distribution in the 1992 act to tie it to charitable purposes. That will be done through an order that will be laid later this year. However, we agreed that it is not appropriate to amend or remove all the powers of control. That is because we need to retain control over college powers and constitutions to ensure that they continue to operate within a framework that reflects relevant policies and priorities. An example of the need for that power arose when previous ministers asked Parliament to amend the powers of colleges to enable them to deliver their now highly acclaimed programme of skills courses for young people who are still at school.We have therefore decided to proceed with the draft order that is now before the committee, which requires the approval of Parliament, to exempt all the incorporated colleges from the independence requirement because of their unique governance structure, the distinctive role that they play in Scottish society and the significant amount of public funding that is invested in them.The draft order is the first of two that will address the issues that OSCR identified and enable colleges to retain their charitable status. The second order, which amends the provision on asset distribution in 1992 act, will be laid later this year. It will be a technical amendment. Since the creation of the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, ministers no longer have a direct interest in the funding issues of individual colleges, including what happens to the proceeds of any assets of which they dispose.I highlight the fact that the order exempts the colleges that are listed in it only from the requirement under section 7(4)(b) of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005 for charities to be free from ministerial control. The colleges will still be subject to all the other aspects of the charity test, including the asset distribution provisions and all the requirements of charity law. However, without the exemption, they would lose their charitable status.Four publicly funded colleges are not incorporated under the 1992 act. They do not face the problem that OSCR identified because the ministerial powers of control in the act do not apply to them. Accordingly, they do not need to be included in the order.The order is important, as it addresses the uncertainty that incorporated colleges face about their charitable status following OSCR's ruling on ministerial powers.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Thank you very much for those comments, minister. Members of the committee now have an opportunity to ask questions.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I compliment the Government on the move to exempt our colleges. It is vital for their future that it take place as soon as possible. Colleges have their own constitutions. Is the cabinet secretary confident that individual colleges will not have to rewrite their constitutions to accept the order?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

There will not have to be any rewriting for the purpose of maintaining charitable status. We have thought about that carefully, which is why we have taken the steps to exempt colleges as a last resort. The order will provide the powers that we need to exempt them from the requirement for independence from ministerial direction, so the responsibility is the Government's and the colleges are not required to change their constitutions.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Do you anticipate that any of the colleges will have to change their structure or organisation, educational or otherwise?

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

I, too, welcome the move and agree with Elizabeth Smith. I will ask one question for clarification. The order covers the colleges' boards of management, which means the colleges themselves, but many colleges have subsidiary or partnership organisations, such as trading operations; are they covered by the order as well?

George Reid Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Jeremy Purvis is right that many colleges have set up subsidiary organisations. They are not covered by the 1992 act, so they do not require to be covered by the order.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

The convener will remember—because, I think, she was convener of the committee that considered the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Bill—that the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Bill was being considered at the same time as the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Bill. That was one of the key constraints at the time.I welcome Jeremy Purvis's and Elizabeth Smith's support for what we are trying to do. I hope that the rationale that we have set out is clear enough, but we are more than happy to provide further briefing if the committee needs it.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

To continue the spirit of consensus, I also welcome the order. We are all agreed that it is important that colleges retain their charitable status, because it would have a huge detrimental impact if they did not. Did any of the consultation respondents object to retaining charitable status through exemption and, if so, how were those concerns addressed?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations raised concerns similar to those that were raised during the passage of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Bill. We have now had some time for the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005 to bed in, and it is important to reflect that we are approaching the matter very much in the spirit of the act, which emphasises the importance of charities being independent. That is why we are rolling back some of the ministerial powers that we might want to have over colleges, but we have to maintain the powers to determine and alter board constitutions and to change the powers that are given to boards of management to enable initiatives such as the skills relationship with schools that I mentioned earlier. In the spirit of the act, we recognise that colleges are unique and that they have a particular governance structure and public interest that we need to protect.The SCVO's concerns are more about the importance of the Government protecting the independence of charities, which we want to do—that is reflected in our approach. The exemption that we will bring forward later on the disposal of assets for charitable purposes will be an important signal of the importance that we give to the independence of charities.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

I was indeed the convener of the Communities Committee when it considered the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Bill. This issue concerned the committee at the time, so I welcome what the Government is doing and agree with my colleagues that it is the appropriate course of action.Mr Macintosh picked up one of the big issues that the Communities Committee wrestled with when it was considering the bill: the importance of the independence of charitable organisations. Following on from Mr Macintosh's question, are you confident that these proposals will not in any way undermine the independence of other charitable organisations or allow challenges to be made? I am sure that the Government considered that, because it has been widely debated, but it would be helpful if we could get an assurance that it did.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Yes, we did. We examined the other options first, because one of those might have been the easiest and simplest way to reflect the thinking behind the charities legislation. However, we also have to consider the matter in the context of the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992.Colleges are distinct. Because of the establishment of the Scottish funding council by the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 2005, the Government is to a great extent removed. We cannot interfere with individual colleges in matters such as employment issues or the funding of particular courses, although a number of MSPs frequently write to ministers to ask them to do so. Remarkable independence has been established through the development of the Scottish funding council, which—as other charitable organisations can reflect on—means that there is no ministerial responsibility and direction for individual colleges, although we provide strategic guidance for the sector as a whole.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Item 2 is continued consideration of the subordinate legislation. We have the opportunity to debate the matter, but I am not sure that there will be a lengthy debate.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the Charity Test (Specified Bodies) (Scotland) Order 2008 be approved.—Fiona Hyslop.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

I see that members have no additional points to make. Cabinet secretary, do you have anything to add? We do not have much of a debate for you to respond to.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I thank the committee for its co-operation in this matter, which is important to many colleges and their students.

Motion agreed to.

That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the Charity Test (Specified Bodies) (Scotland) Order 2008 be approved.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow for a change of witnesses.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 18 June 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 26
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 57
  4. Petition Petitions · 227

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.