PE1364 seeks to clarify guidelines on Gypsy Traveller encampments. Members have the note from the clerk, which is paper 6. I invite contributions from members. I understand that Nigel Don, Alex Johnstone and Ken Macintosh wish to contribute.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Gypsy Traveller Encampments (Guidance) (PE1364)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nigel Don SNP 4
- David Stewart Lab 3
- Alex Johnstone Con 3
- John Wilson SNP 2
- Sandra White SNP 1
- Mark McDonald SNP 1
- Bill Walker SNP 1
The record
15 contributionsI am prepared to defer to the petitioners’ constituency member.15:30
Thank you, convener. Good afternoon, committee members. It is interesting to be here in support of a petition, having spent several years on the other side of the committee table.The petition derives from a horrifying experience that the petitioner went through on her mother’s property, from which many things have flowed. I am conscious of the fact that you do not want me to rehearse it all—it is in the committee papers. Via a working party that was set up in the previous session of Parliament, the Scottish Government has looked at the way in which local authorities and the police should respond to such situations. The good news is that, although there were plenty of warm words, that has sharpened the pencils and minds of those who are involved. I think that, if similar circumstances were to recur, the public authorities would respond a wee bit better.The situation has also clarified in the Government’s mind and, therefore, the local authorities’ minds, the fact that we need permanent sites for Gypsy Travellers. I am conscious that the committee dealt with a petition on that issue two petitions back in the agenda. The Government is now absolutely clear that we will not solve the problems that arise from friction between the travelling community and the settled community unless there are adequate sites for Travellers. That is the good news.As the petitioner points out, however, we still have to get from where we are—which is unsatisfactory—to a satisfactory position. The petitioner feels that two issues need to be addressed. The first is how we deal with and set up sites that, when they are first set up, may not be legal and authorised but which are necessary to get through the current situation. The second issue—which is much higher on Ms McBain’s agenda—is what public authorities should be required to do to help private landowners who find themselves with an encampment that they do not want.In the first situation, there is a tacit agreement that people can use a field—the landowner allows them to use it and the local authority can cope with it for the time being. The issue still needs to be addressed, but the site is needed. In the second situation, which is the one that I want to emphasise, a private landowner who does not want an encampment and has given no permission for one—fences or whatever may have been removed—finds himself or herself with a group of people simply squatting on their land. It seems to me that, if there is a general duty on local authorities to provide sites, we might ask the Government whether there is a general duty on local authorities to help those who find themselves in that position because the local authorities have not provided sites. That is the help that the petitioner is looking for, for those who find themselves in similar circumstances in the future.
I back everything that Nigel Don has said. The circumstance that led to the petition was quite horrifying and involved property in the Stonehaven area being under siege for a considerable period. At different times, there were encampments on public land in the town and on private land around the town. We are lucky because, at the moment and in recent months, there is not and has not been a further issue to be drawn to the committee’s attention. However, as Nigel Don suggested, that is perhaps due to more vociferous pursuit of local authorities and police, in some cases, taking responsibility, and by action that has been taken by local authorities and private landowners to introduce physical measures that make it more difficult for the sites to be accessed.When the problem occurred, there was a failure to recognise the appropriate action that should have been taken, other than the council’s action in having court orders placed on its own land to have Travellers removed from sites in the town. Beyond that—in the eyes of the public, at least—there was confusion over rights and responsibilities in respect of whose duty it was to take relevant action and what relevant action could be taken. That is a significant part of what prompted Phyllis McBain to lodge her petition asking for the guidelines relating to trespass and encampments for Gypsy Travellers to be clarified to ensure that their intent is clear and that they are applied.The fact that conflict, which originally motivated the petition, is not currently taking place in the area is a matter of luck as much as judgment. Should it happen again, we will require clear guidelines as much as we ever did.
I want clarification on one of the issues that has been raised. Nigel Don or others can respond. We talk about seeking more robust guidance from the Scottish Government. The papers mention that guidance will be updated, but that this will be done on a website. Will that be enough? Should there be more guidance about meeting people and promoting the law on the matter?
My instinct is that the people who need to know about the guidance will find the website and will know that it is there. The guidance is for public authorities, police and local authorities or others who deal with the Traveller community. These people know who they are and know where to look. That is not really a problem. I accept that the guidance may not be totally available to the general public, who might struggle to find it, but it is not really for the general public; it is for those who have a duty to do something.
I have expressed the view that I have a great deal of sympathy for those who work in local authorities and in the police force when faced with these difficult circumstances. I understand why, quite often, what would be the appropriate line according to the law is not taken because of fears of accusations that may be made. I wish to see clear guidelines—as much for the benefit of those on the front line of the local authority or the police force as for the communities that suffer this imposition—so that we know where the line lies and what action is appropriate. When this situation arose, a great many people were afraid to act because they did not know what the guidelines said.
I am familiar with the petition and the wider issue from a local authority perspective. My council ward is frequently visited by unauthorised encampments and the Clinterty site, the official halting site for travellers in Aberdeen, is on the border of my ward. Nigel Don raises the correct point that halting sites are required across Scotland: the difficulty is that everyone agrees that they are a great idea as long as they are put somewhere else. That is a difficulty with which local authorities must wrestle. Regarding what the petitioner is looking for, one of the sites that is frequently visited in my area is one with a small access road dividing public authority land and privately owned land. Very often, the encampment is sprawled across both sites and it is not always clear who has the lead in dealing with the unauthorised encampment. Also, the judicial process moves at two different speeds for the different sides of the road, which can be confusing. Perhaps there can be clarification of guidance as it relates to private land ownership, so that if an eviction is required in circumstances such as I have described, it can be pursued on a joint basis rather than two different eviction approaches being made. That would be beneficial. Clearing up the guidance as it pertains to individual private landowners would be helpful and we should write to the Government on that.
I have some experience of this in Fife, as I mentioned during discussion of an earlier petition. We need more than guidelines. The problem is that guidelines are only guidelines—an idea that we hear a lot in local government. Local authorities think that because there are only guidelines they can do their own thing. To an extent that is probably right, so we need something stronger than guidelines. We had a workshop on the subject last year in Fife. The conclusion was that the police and the council did not know quite what to do at certain times and so it was decided to petition—or perhaps I should use the word “ask”—the Scottish Government for clearer law. We used the word “law” rather than guidelines.To me, guidelines are not strong enough. We need guidelines for where Gypsy Travellers can legitimately stay, but we need laws to ensure that there is no unfair discrimination against them if they are obeying the law like every other citizen.In my opinion, we have to get away from the sort of thing in paragraph 3 of the Government’s guidelines, which states:“Policies should seek to manage unauthorised encampments”.If they are unauthorised encampments, what authority do we have to manage them and how will we manage them? The situation is a mess. There should be a firm law, because the guidelines are just not strong enough.
We have seen examples south of the border of unauthorised encampments, and legal debates are taking place on that as we speak. I am aware that Nigel Don and—I think—Alex Johnstone were involved in a working group that discussed the issues that we are considering for this petition. Is that correct?
I was in such a group.
I directed that question to Nigel Don because there is clearly a need for more official sites in the Angus and Aberdeenshire areas. Six years ago, my local authority had an official Gypsy Traveller site less than a mile from my home. The council closed it down and put the land on the open market after spending lots of Government money preparing the site and making it ready for Gypsy Travellers to use.What discussions took place with Gypsy Travellers in Angus and Aberdeenshire about the creation of official sites? I am well aware of the issues that have been raised by the petition previously, but the issue for us today is to discuss how the petition is being progressed and whether progress is being made to identify enough official sites that Gypsy Travellers can utilise in their travels around Scotland, or whether we have a continuing problem in that—as Alex Johnstone indicated—private landowners are imposed on because the regulations or guidelines are not strong enough to deal with the situation when Gypsy Travellers move on to private land, which means that the private owners do not have recourse to the appropriate statutory agencies to take the action that is required to remove the Gypsy Travellers from the land.
I am conscious of the time, so if no other member wishes to contribute, we will move on. I think that we have had a good discussion about the petition and it is clear that we wish to continue to seek answers from the Scottish Government. The clerk has given us some suggestions for the way forward, and we will pick up on helpful suggestions from committee members, and from Alex Johnstone and Nigel Don. Do we agree to continue the petition and to try to get some crucial answers to the questions?Members indicated agreement.
Can I just try to answer John Wilson’s question briefly? We did not have particular discussions with the travelling community in the context of renewing the guidelines. That was partly because it is immensely difficult to communicate with those different communities, because they are actually families and not just a group of travellers.I reiterate that getting enough sites is very difficult. As Mark McDonald rightly pointed out, everybody thinks that they are a good idea, but nobody wants them close by themselves. We are in a situation where there are going to be unauthorised encampments. On Bill Walker’s point in that regard, it would be nice not to have unauthorised encampments, but we must recognise that we will continue to have them because there are not enough authorised ones. We must work from where we are to get to where we want to go, but that will take time.
Thank you for that helpful contribution. I thank the earlier speakers, too.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Sep 2011 →- 14:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 33
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 26
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.