Good morning, convener. It is a pleasure to be here with you. The Finance Committee fulfils such an important role in the Scottish Parliament, and I think that that role will become even more important, if that is possible, in the months to come.The report was published last month and was given preliminary consideration at the Public Audit Committee on 7 September. It was published at a time when the results of the United Kingdom spending review had been announced but the implications for Scotland were not absolutely clear. As we all know, the Scottish Government published a detailed budget for 2011-12, but figures for the subsequent years to 2014 remained provisional. We also all know that the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth will make a statement to Parliament shortly on the spending review. We expect, as I am sure others do, that his statement will broadly confirm previous estimates of a significant real-terms reduction in Scottish public expenditure over at least the next three years.There are three main sections, or themes, in the report. The first takes a look at the current financial climate and how much money is available; the second gives an overview of some of the main cost pressures; and the third takes a first look at what public bodies are doing to address the challenges that lie ahead. I will not dwell on the first theme, because the committee will be well aware of the revenue-side challenges that face the public sector. If I may say so, the committee has an excellent adviser at its disposal in Professor David Bell. I will remind members briefly of the headline numbers. Through the public spending review period to 2014, the Scottish departmental expenditure limit budget, which is the money that the Scottish Government controls, will reduce by approximately £3.3 billion, which is about 11 per cent in round terms. The key point, which I think everyone fully realises, is that that is a big turnaround from the first 10 years of devolution, when growth was more than 5 per cent a year in real terms. We have reached a tipping point in that regard and are coming down the other side now. That means that we face difficulty for many years to come.I will concentrate a bit more on the cost pressures, if I may, as the analysis might be useful to the committee as background to the publication of the spending review. The section starts on page 16 of the report. We have categorised the cost pressures into six areas: demand pressures, finance pressures, workforce pressures, investment pressures, pressures in maintaining existing assets, and environmental pressures.One pressure that has been with us for a few years now is the ageing of the population. The number of people who are aged 75 or over is set to almost double by about 2030, which will have significant implications. To give the committee just one statistic, I would point out that the ratio of older people to people who are active in the workforce is currently 31:100, but that will rise to 40:100 by 2030.What implications will there be for our public services? If we consider the example of the ageing population, fewer people will be around to deliver care to older people who need it; fewer people will be contributing to pensions; and fewer people will be contributing significantly to tax revenues, national insurance and so on. A larger proportion of tax revenues from people of working age will be needed for the pension costs of others in the public sector. Working people will be contributing more to national insurance and their own pension provisions, and that will reduce what economists call their disposable income. A greater proportion of tax revenues will probably have to go on paying for the care of very elderly people in need. It is a very serious issue for society. A question that I think must be asked—although I cannot provide an answer—concerns the extent to which we can continue with our existing models of care provision against the background of a scenario that is developing as we speak.Demand for services that are free at the point of delivery continues to rise. In round terms, we estimate that they cost about £870 million at the moment. I will consider one example: not long ago, we produced a report on the national concessionary travel scheme, and we projected that the uncapped cost of the scheme—in other words, the cost if the scheme is not altered but carries on indefinitely—could reach anything between £216 million and more than £500 million by 2025. Auditors look in the rear-view mirror and not in the crystal ball, but we made an attempt, based on some assumptions of future rises in the numbers of eligible participants and in fuel costs, to give some indication of the future risks to public finances from the scheme. Such indications could be replicated in other parts of the public sector.Some other demands are difficult to control. In higher and further education, there is a debate about what is called the funding gap. We note in the report that there were 8,000 more students in 2009-10 than we had in 2008-09. That must partly be a result of the lack of employment opportunities, but I presume that it was also a result of young people and others coming back to study to improve their chances in the jobs marketplace. That is another demand pressure on the higher and further education sector, in addition to the challenges of finding funds.The question of efficiency savings is important. As I am sure we all know, there have been targets for public sector efficiency savings for quite a number of years now. The previous Government, and the Scottish Executive before that, imposed targets for efficiency savings across the public sector. By and large, the results reported by the Scottish Government and the Scottish Executive were encouraging, and efficiency savings have been identified. That has been difficult for us to audit because of the quality of the information but, as we move further into the period of retrenchment, there must be an increasing risk that efficiency savings will have an impact on service delivery. We have considered the efficiency programme in the past, but have been able to offer only limited comment and assurance because of the data problems that we encountered.Inflation is much higher than it was expected to be when plans for public expenditure were being prepared. One area where inflationary pressures are especially severe is in the health service. For example, in the health budget, spending on drugs—whether administered in hospitals or issued by general practitioners—has tended to rise by between 4 per cent and 11 per cent on past trends. That is significant inflation, and it must be accommodated in the health budget. Although the health budget is increasing slightly in cash terms in 2011-12, pressures are building up in the system.All public bodies are experiencing reductions in other important sources of income. I will give one example of what has been happening, concerning asset sales in councils. In 2006-07, local authorities raised almost £500 million for capital spending from asset sales. By 2010-11, the estimated figure was under £150 million. That is a big reduction by anyone’s standards.There has been considerable interest in public sector pay freezes. That is understandable, because the pay bill accounts for about 60 per cent of the Scottish Government’s revenue budget. One point that we are trying to make in the report is that even a pay freeze will not prevent the pay bill from going up, because the freeze applies only to the annual cost-of-living rises that people generally look forward to and does not affect movement up the scale points. The Scottish Government has a policy of offering a degree of protection to the lowest paid—although we are not quite sure whether that protection will be in cash terms or real terms.In parts of the public sector, there are some quite complex and expensive pay deals, which have ratcheted up costs. We have reported on examples of that in the health service in previous years.Public sector pension schemes are under very significant long-term cost pressures. We put a report on that before Parliament in the previous session in which we described the increase in employers’ contributions, which has been followed by increases in employees’ contributions. The UK Government has said that it will accept the recommendations of the Hutton commission. It is too early to say what impact all the pensions changes will have, but there is certainly a very large cost pressure on the public sector, both for employers and for employees.Members will be well aware that, as part of the public spending reductions through to 2014, capital spending is likely to be significantly affected. Based on its analysis of the UK spending review, the Scottish Government calculated that its capital budget might come down by 36 per cent over the period but, of course, the spending review will shortly provide an up-to date-position, which will reflect the Scottish Government’s developing policy in the area.I mentioned that income from asset sales is coming down, giving local authorities as an example. The Scottish Government has 182 major capital projects planned, with a combined estimated value of somewhere in the range of £13 billion to £15 billion. It is committed to using the non-profit-distributing private finance method and it has earmarked about £2.5 billion in what is, in effect, a top-slice for that expenditure; nevertheless, it looks as if, in aggregate, there will be some challenges because of the shortfall in resources.There are also some signs that local authorities and others will try to use revenue funding to compensate for the reduction in capital allocations. The auditors will keep an eye on that issue to ensure that whatever financial strategies are put in place across the public sector are sustainable, but it is primarily for management in public bodies to ensure the financial sustainability of their organisations. In the report, we comment on the build-up of private finance initiative commitments, which will reach more than £1.1 billion in cash terms by 2024-25.In other reports, we have commented on the serious issue of the backlog of maintenance and repairs in the Scottish public sector. As I said to the Public Audit Committee, it is not just an abstract accounting issue. In effect, we are using up assets and running the real risk of simply passing them on to our children and future generations in a worse state than they were in when we inherited them. There is a big issue with intergenerational transfer of burdens.In the past, I have mentioned the need to spend about £2.25 billion to eliminate the defects on Scotland’s roads; the costs of removing the backlog of maintenance of council-owned property assets, which amount to £1.4 billion; and the fact that the national health service estate needs more than £500 million. I could go on, but the point is that the maintenance problem is very significant, and it is important that we all bear that in mind when we consider choices around new projects.Finally in the section on the pressures, we outline certain environmental issues. In reports that we have produced on energy management, we have found that public sector spending on energy increased dramatically by 21 per cent in real terms between 2006-07 and 2008-09. However, energy use has not declined. Of course, that increase largely reflects trends in energy prices. All the expert opinion, including that of the UK Department of Energy and Climate Change, estimates that fuel costs will continue to rise over the long term—certainly over the next 10 years—by as much as 35 per cent on average. That will mean, for example, that a litre of fuel will cost 162p. That is another pressure that is very difficult to control in public bodies, because for a lot of them, such as hospitals, heating bills and so on are very difficult to contain.There is a link back to my earlier comment about the decline in capital spending, because a very important purpose of capital spending can be to support and sustain energy efficiency and spend-to-save approaches generally in relation to the energy strategy.The Scottish Government has set some ambitious energy targets. The independent budget review offered a comment on that, in the report that came out last summer. It estimated that, over the next decade, the cost of meeting the Government’s energy targets would be about £8 billion—that is not our figure; it is one that I am recounting from the independent budget review.11:15
In the third part of the report, we make a first stab—it is no more than that—at describing how public bodies are starting to address the challenges. The first piece of good news—although even this is a glass half empty, I am afraid—is that pretty well all public bodies are planning to balance their budgets for the current year. However, I am receiving anecdotal evidence that things are getting very tough, and the auditors are monitoring the situation carefully. There are some real risks out there in achieving those balanced budgets, and in future years the situation will be even more challenging.In the report, we describe how public bodies have tended to concentrate on reducing staff numbers as quickly as they can through voluntary early severance agreements, retirements, natural turnover and so on. That can take organisations quite far, but it is not straightforward. For example, public bodies have lost quite a lot of senior staff in key areas such as the finance function just as we are entering a period of financial stringency and cutbacks. When I was a local authority chief executive—which I was for many years—I was always concerned to ensure that the council had a strong finance function that was led by someone in whom the councillors and I could have absolute confidence. The need for such strength is even greater in difficult times. That is something on which I comment in other places—at conferences, and so on. A lot of experience has gone out of the door in a short time, just as we have reached the tipping point in public finances. Therefore, good workforce planning must not only look at how to reduce staff levels quickly, but must ensure that the skill mix that is needed to sustain the organisations is there and that valuable experience is not being lost at this critical time.We set out one of our checklists in appendix 4 on page 38 of the report. We hope that that will help all public sector leaders to ask the right questions in their own organisations. It is a complex report that covers a lot of areas, and my colleagues and I will be happy to answer any questions that we can.