The second and third current petitions are PE1273, in the name of Anne Massie, on overnight running of freight trains, and PE1302, in the name of Colin Sloper, on rail noise and vibration at Larbert. Members have the note by the clerk—paper 6—and the submissions. I invite contributions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Rail Noise and Vibration (Larbert) (PE1302)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 5
- Bill Walker SNP 3
- John Wilson SNP 2
- Mark McDonald SNP 2
- Sandra White SNP 1
The record
13 contributionsI declare an interest in that the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line runs through both my council ward and my parliamentary constituency, so I know quite a lot about the subject.The first petition, PE1273, on the overnight running of trains, should not be taken any further, because the railway line was never closed. Although it was unused for a number of years, it was never closed. It is unreasonable to ask for the line to be closed to the running of trains overnight.Option 4 on page 5 of the clerk’s note outlines the reasons for closing the petition, which I accept, because they are reasonable. The companies involved are private companies and they must operate properly but—I might make myself very unpopular with one or two constituents in saying this—we must remember that these trains, to a large degree, supply coal to Kincardine power station, which requires the regular running of trains.More work requires to be done on the second petition, PE1302, although I do not know quite what. The second petition’s request that there be far more co-operation to make life more tolerable for everyone who lives along the line is reasonable. I would separate the two petitions out.
I bow to the knowledge of the local councillor and constituency MSP but, on the second petition, PE1302, I am concerned that the petitioner has not responded to requests for feedback on two occasions. I might be presumptuous in saying that the reason why a response has not been forthcoming is that he is happy with what has happened and that the petition has achieved what it set out to achieve. I do not know whether that is the case. I am concerned that, on two occasions, we have had no response from the petitioner, which suggests that he is happy with what is happening and that the petition can be closed.
I disagree with my two colleagues on closing the petitions. As I have indicated in the past, I am very knowledgeable about these freight trains, particularly coal freight trains, because they pass by my door; indeed, I might be seen to have a vested interest. I welcome the responses from Network Rail and DB Schenker on the operational requirements. I received notice this morning from Network Rail on the level of rail workings that will take place over the next three months, which will directly impact on my overnight sleep, so, if I get a bit crotchety over the next three months, I hope that committee members will take into consideration the amount of rail working that is taking place.We asked Transport Scotland to tell us what discussions had taken place with Clackmannanshire Council on the mitigation works. Transport Scotland indicated in its response that it hoped that the work would start by August 2011, but it now admits in its letter that the work has not commenced. I would like us to keep the petitions open to enable us to get definitive dates from Transport Scotland and Clackmannanshire Council on when the mitigation works are likely to commence and whether they will satisfy the residents who live along the line.I take on board Bill Walker’s comment that, although the railway line was derelict, it was still there and was just reopened. However, houses were built next to the line on the basis that it was not being used at that time. I know that it is a question that we have asked Transport Scotland, Network Rail and DB Schenker, but why we are shipping in coal to the south-west of Scotland and transporting it by rail to the east of Scotland is still beyond me, given that there are port authorities on the east coast. I do not understand why Scottish Power and DB Schenker continue to use freight trains to transport coal across central Scotland to its destination when two ports on the east coast could handle and accommodate it. I know that these issues have already been raised and realise that the last time we discussed the petition Scottish Power, DB Schenker and Network Rail told us that it was a contractual issue. However, there are still questions as to why the transportation of freight across central Scotland is disrupting many communities in the area.
I am afraid to say that I disagree with my colleague John Wilson. I entirely understand the points that he has made, but I do not think that the petition should be used to shoehorn particularly that last point into the discussion.As far as PE1273 is concerned, work to begin the mitigation measures is in progress. I understand the argument that we should wait for that work to be completed, but it might then be argued that we should wait and see whether the measures are effective and we might never be able to draw a line in the sand. The petitions have achieved much, but I think that we should certainly close PE1302, particularly given that, on two previous occasions, the petitioner has not responded to the committee’s requests.Moreover, given that work to begin the mitigation works is in progress, I think that PE1273 has served its function and should be closed. If the mitigation works prove to be unsatisfactory, a new petition can be submitted. In short, though, I think that these petitions have achieved their purpose and should be closed.
I sympathise completely with the view that importing coal via the west coast and shipping it over to the east is crazy; indeed, I and other people on Fife Council have gone through the issue several times with various bodies. However, it all comes down to business economics, where the coal is available and the relative costs. We are trying to reopen various port facilities in Fife to import coal, but the main thinking is that, although coal can be imported there, it is simply not economic to do so. Obviously, I am in regular touch with Scottish Power in my constituency.When the issues faced by those living along the railway line were brought to my attention as a councillor some years ago, I was very sympathetic to the people who had bought houses beside the line in the belief that it would never be used again and found that suddenly—or so it seemed—trains were running along it. However, I am afraid that it was only hope on the part of the purchasers, as at no time had there been any legal closure of the line. In other words, the people bought the houses on the understanding that there was no such legal aspect and no estate agent ever said that no trains would ever run along the line. I was very annoyed when I found that out, but I am afraid that this is a case of caveat emptor for the home owners.
Although we have run these petitions together, we should take a separate decision on them. Although I very much sympathise with John Wilson’s position on PE1273, I do not think that we can take it any further than the overnight running issue that it has raised. The other complexity is the incentivisation of the use of trains to carry cargo and the fact that, through the freight facilities grant, successive Governments have funded the ability to take freight off roads and on to rail—and, indeed, boats.Mark McDonald has suggested that PE1273 be closed. Do members have any views on that?
I second that suggestion.
Do you agree, Nanette?Nanette Milne indicated agreement.
My views are on the record, convener.
The committee has agreed to close PE1273 in light of the points that are set out in the clerk’s note and which will be identified in the minutes for the meeting.On PE1302, on Larbert rail noise and vibration, I seek confirmation of members’ views on the next steps for the petition.
I suggest that the petition be closed. Given that the petitioner has not responded to two previous requests, the committee takes the view that he is satisfied with progress.
Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Nov 2011 →- 14:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 14:00 Current Petition Petitions · 84
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.