Good morning. I welcome members to the 12th meeting in this session of the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee. I remind everyone that mobile phones and BlackBerrys should be switched off. I welcome Richard Baker, who is again substituting for Ken Macintosh.Agenda item 1 is the budget process 2008-09. The committee will take oral evidence on the Scottish Government's budget as part of its stage 2 budget process scrutiny.The first panel of witnesses is from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. I welcome Councillor Isabel Hutton, who is COSLA's spokesperson on education, children and young people; Jon Harris, who is a strategic director; and Robert Nicol, who is a policy manager. Thank you for your helpful written submission, which we received in advance of the meeting.We will move straight to questions to allow us the maximum time for discussion. First, I want to ask about the Scottish Government's education priorities. How much money has been provided in the settlement to reduce class sizes?
Official Report · Committee
Budget Process 2008-09
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fiona Hyslop SNP 90
- Jeremy Purvis LD 71
- Jon Harris Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 67
- Karen Whitefield Lab 53
- Robert Nicol Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 45
- Mary Mulligan Lab 31
- Liz Smith Con 26
- Richard Baker Lab 19
- Councillor Hutton 16
- Rob Gibson SNP 14
- Christina McKelvie SNP 6
- Aileen Campbell SNP 5
- Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate 3
- Councillor Isabel Hutton Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
The record
450 contributions · showing 1–200The concordat that is associated with the spending review sets overall funding. Within that funding, we have made certain commitments in respect of the manifesto commitments that we think we can deliver. There are no specific allocations for each of the manifesto commitments. Based on the overall sum of money that will be made available to local government, we have made a judgment on the commitments that we can make, which are set out in the concordat.
COSLA has made commitments, so it must have some idea of the cost of implementing the commitment to reduce to 18 class sizes for primaries 1 to 3 over the session. What are COSLA's costs for that? I am not asking how much you will be given by the Scottish Government.
Certain costings were done on the basis of different assumptions. One question was how much such a reduction would cost within the parliamentary session. In the negotiations, we made choices. We considered what we were capable of doing to fulfil each manifesto commitment. In respect of class reductions, we decided not to allocate funding; rather, we decided that we could deliver reductions because of demographic changes, which will result in the number of pupils in classes reducing. We decided that we would use such changes to make progress across Scotland in delivering on that manifesto commitment.
How can you be confident that, under the settlement, you can deliver on the Scottish Government's manifesto commitment if you do not have any idea of the overall costs of reducing class sizes to 18 for primaries 1, 2 and 3?
Overall, class sizes will diminish in Scotland as a result of the fall in the number of pupils. Some councils will find it difficult to reduce class sizes because their pupil rolls are increasing, but there will be a commitment across Scotland to moving in the direction of smaller class sizes for primaries 1, 2 and 3.
Are you suggesting that where a child in primary 1, 2 or 3 was born or goes to school will determine whether they will be educated in a primary class of 18 or fewer than 18?
We are saying that more resources will be required to reduce class sizes in areas in which the pupil roll is increasing. Choices will be made within the total funding that is available. Councils will make choices on how they will collectively deliver on the commitment that has been made.
Have you carried out any evaluation of which local authorities will face additional pressures because of challenging demographics and growing populations and which you are confident will naturally be able to have class sizes of 18 because their population is declining?
Well, the pupil roll in West Lothian Council, which is Councillor Hutton's council, will increase.
But has COSLA carried out any modelling to allow you to reach that conclusion?
We have a good understanding—
Have you carried out any modelling, Mr Harris?
We have not carried out any specific modelling with regard to areas where the demographics will change, but we are aware that school rolls will vary from local authority to local authority and even within certain local authority areas. In the concordat, we have agreed that progress will be made by maintaining teacher numbers in the face of falling school rolls. Of course, that will be for local authorities to decide, because they know their own demographics best and where to focus effort to reduce class sizes.
In other words, you have agreed a commitment—and are confident that you have the resources to fulfil it over the next three years—on the basis of your perception that class sizes in some areas of Scotland might well fall because the population is declining, but you have done no work to ascertain whether that is the case or to find out where the pressures will be felt.
We have not agreed in the concordat to reduce all P1 to P3 class sizes by the end of the specified period. The concordat says that"the pace of implementation … will vary"due to a number of local factors, the most obvious of which is the situation with school rolls. In some areas, some class sizes will be reduced to 18 whereas in other areas, such as West Lothian, where the population is increasing, class sizes will not be reduced. Progress on this issue is down to individual local authorities deciding the priorities in their areas.
Some local authorities have produced figures for the cost of reducing to 18 class sizes in primary 1 to P3. Have you spoken to those local authorities about that? Have you attempted to come to a global figure by using their information base?
As the finance directors of all the local authorities were involved in negotiations on the overall budget, any information that they had would have been fed into the process.
After that information was fed into the process, did you reach a global figure for the cost of reducing class sizes in schools, regardless of whether the rolls were falling, rising or remaining static?
As we have said, the package that has been agreed is for the whole of local government. No specific amount has been allocated for class size reduction.
I find it incredible that you can agree to a commitment that has not been costed. However, what I find even more incredible is your acceptance that children in a local authority area such as West Lothian, which Councillor Hutton and I represent and where school rolls are continuing to rise, will not receive the same advantages that children in other areas will receive simply because COSLA and other local authorities have not costed the provision—I understand, though, that West Lothian Council has done so—and then sought the necessary resources from the Scottish Government to make it happen. Perhaps Councillor Hutton can answer that question.
We should remember that not only COSLA but the leaders of all 32 local authorities were involved in the negotiations.West Lothian Council has costed the increase in its school rolls. I understand that the Scottish Government has already given West Lothian Council just over £2.5 million of the £40 million across all 32 local authorities towards reducing class sizes. Again, it is a question of the pace of implementation of class size reductions.
Let us be clear: the £40 million is for 2007-08, which is the current year. What we are talking about is the budget for 2008 to 2010. You do not seem to have the figures that would assure me that the agreement that you reached in the concordat can be delivered for every child in P1 to P3. I am particularly concerned that children in areas such as mine, where school rolls are increasing, will be disadvantaged. You are quite happy with that.
We agreed in the concordat that the pace of implementation will vary. Our focus is still on improved outcomes for children. The pace of implementation of class size reductions throughout the country will vary due to local factors, but we are still focused on improving the overall educational outcomes and other outcomes for children. They will not necessarily vary in the sense that you mean, but the way in which class sizes contribute to that will vary due to local factors.
Rest assured that, unlike some, I appreciate that it is not just reducing class sizes that will increase educational attainment. However, given that you signed up to the agreement but are unable to tell me why you signed up to it at the rate that you did, I have to say that I am not reassured.
Did the negotiating team give the Government an estimate of the cost of implementing the policy in full in the current session of Parliament? I need not remind you that you are on the record.
The finance directors and others who were involved in the negotiations had a number of figures, probably, which they used to inform our negotiating position. I do not have at my fingertips the figures that they may or may not have used, but the finance directors in our negotiating team had a number of pieces of information that they would have used to inform our negotiating position.
What was the figure for implementing the policy in full that COSLA put to the Government?
The issue was how quickly we could move to reduce class sizes—one session, two sessions or three sessions. What we negotiated as part of the overall package is that we would look to demographic change to make improvements—
Shall I ask the question again? I am not sure that you heard it. What is the figure that was presented to the Government for implementing the policy in full in the current session of Parliament?
We do not have the figures at our fingertips.
We do not have the figures to hand, but our approach to negotiating was always that the policy would be implemented through demographic change. We negotiated an overall settlement. How councils prioritise within that settlement will determine how much is spent locally on class size reduction.
You do not have the figure to hand. Will you furnish that to the committee before we conclude our deliberations on the budget? One would have thought that, in preparation for attending a parliamentary committee, you would get that information. However, you will be able to provide it to the committee.
If we provided that information during the negotiations we can feed it back to the committee, but I cannot say for sure whether we did provide it.
I have been advised that no specific amounts of money were assigned to any commitment in the concordat. It was part of the overall settlement, which was part of the package that COSLA and the Scottish Government negotiated. If there was anything, we will provide it.
If we did have figures, we can provide them to the committee.
Did you present to the Government a figure for how much it would cost local government to implement that policy in full during the current session of Parliament?
I will repeat exactly what I have said before.
You do not know?
We negotiated it as a whole deal. There might have been information that the finance directors used to steer our negotiations, but we were negotiating a whole package, not specific moneys for specific commitments.
We also have to re-emphasise that the concordat did not say that there would be a reduction in class sizes within the current session of Parliament. COSLA did not sign up to that.
Given the significant differences between councils and the fact that COSLA has a co-ordinating role, I can understand why it is quite difficult to draw out specific figures. Even the variations in the number of pupils and schools in different councils would make it difficult to draw those figures together. In the past three years, councils have had an average 4.3 per cent increase in spending, but because of the budget settlement that has been handed down by the chancellor in London, we are talking about a 1.4 per cent increase for this year and over the next two or three years. How will efficiency savings help you to find cash, whether in a council such as West Lothian, which needs to fund a growing population, or a council in a deprived area that is trying to renew its school stock? Two per cent is expected—which is, of course, lower than the ambition in the rest of the UK.
As regards the overall deal in the concordat, the sums of money that are available are extremely tight. That is why we felt it was important to look at the non-cash benefits that give flexibility in how money can be used—to allow us to prioritise. It also gives us an incentive to drive our efficiencies and bring that into front-line services. Previously, we were the only part of government that had its efficiency savings top-sliced at source. We hope to use the increased flexibility and the ability to retain efficiency savings to shift resources into the front line. As people have rightly said, there are pressures on us regarding how we use our resources—whether energy, pensions or whatever—and we will have to meet those pressures. The deal in relation to the manifesto commitments was negotiated in that context and the context of the resources that are available for, for example, reducing class sizes. We will reduce class sizes if the demographics and the teacher supply allow us to do that.
That sounds a good deal more like the reality of recognising the diversity in Scotland. You obviously agreed in the concordat that it would allow local government a good deal more flexibility to do what it thought was best in each area.
Yes.
The spirit of the concordat was that, rather than being prescriptive from the top down, local authorities are being allowed to make decisions as they know best what is needed in their areas. It provides for mutual respect between the different spheres of government—local government and the Scottish Government. We are moving into interesting times.
It seems to be a cultural shift that some people are finding it difficult to accept.
Nevertheless, COSLA's submission mentions clearly "our costed understanding of our spending requirements" and the "overall year on year progress" that will be made on that commitment.If local authorities are to be held to that commitment, it will important for them to know how much it will be costed at and for the Parliament to be able to examine the budget to see whether it is achievable in the settlement that you have reached with the Government. As Mary Mulligan said, local authorities are now calculating what they believe will be required to meet the commitment on class sizes, in particular. Will you gather those figures together, to inform your approach to the budget? Will there be local figures for people in councils to look at and a national figure for us to look at?
There will be regular meetings between COSLA representatives and ministers—that is quite new and groundbreaking—and COSLA will have meetings with the 32 local authorities. That will give everyone the opportunity to feed in any pressures, benefits or experiences that they have, so that COSLA representatives can feed them in as part of the equal partnership with the Scottish Government.
So, if those figures are available, you will collate them and feed them in?
Yes. If there is anything that local government wants to raise, we will be more than happy to raise it.
And once you have collated those figures, they will be available to the committee?
Councils will make their own estimates in fixing their budgets for this year, and the figures will be different from council to council. Those differences—for example on the issue of class sizes—will become clearer in the course of that budget setting. We will monitor that. The concordat also contains an agreement that we will have regular meetings with the Cabinet to monitor progress towards the commitments. That will be an on-going process. Councils are approaching the issues from slightly different perspectives, reflecting differences in their demographics, teacher supply, infrastructures, and so forth. We will have to monitor the situation council by council.
That is fair enough, but at the end of that process there should be figures that you are able to collate. Will COSLA make those figures available for the committee's deliberations?
We are not collating figures. If pressures arise, we can identify them and feed them in through the oversight processes of which Councillor Hutton and Jon Harris have spoken. Councils set their own budgets, but they do not yet know the amounts that have been allocated to them. Once they have the whole picture, they will be able to decide for themselves whether to sign up to the agreement.
But in your negotiations there will be transparency about the figures they are using?
As I have said, we do not plan to collate any figures on class sizes; however, we will monitor the process and our information is readily available on the internet.
We are seeking to do that in a way that allows us demonstrably to measure progress, not just in relation to the manifesto commitments on class sizes, but in relation to all the commitments that we have made. That will become transparent. The issue is the decisions that individual councils will take. Councils that have different demographics and falling school rolls can use the opportunity to make progress. Some councils will use their flexibilities to prioritise class sizes in their spending. Such decisions will be made council by council, and we will monitor the situation overall. It is not just about money; it is about opportunity.
Good morning. I want to ask about the six main priorities for education spending that are set out in the concordat and in the paper that you have presented to the committee. Are those the only six priorities or are there others? You say that the concordat includes those six priorities. Does that imply that there are other priorities as well as the six that are listed?
What we have listed in our submission are the specific concordat commitments that we have agreed with the Scottish Government. There are other areas of partnership working between local government and the Scottish Government, and outcome agreements that will contribute to education and children's services. One piece of work that has just started is our partnership work on the early years strategy. The commitments that we set out in our submission are the concordat commitments that COSLA negotiated with the Scottish Government. Some of those flow from manifesto commitments.
Did some of the six priorities appear to be more important than others?
There is no ranking. The priorities flow from manifesto commitments. We have agreed that local government as a whole will take them forward, as set out in the concordat.
Are they national commitments?
Yes.
So you envisage no variation on a regional basis?
Naturally, there will be variation in approach and in how the priorities are delivered. It is a tenet of the new agreement that local authorities have the freedom and flexibility to decide how best to deliver the commitments, within what has been agreed overall. That means focusing on demographics to meet the class sizes target through falling school rolls, where possible. The same approach applies to early-years provision.
In answer to questions from Mary Mulligan and Jeremy Purvis, you said that you had no financial figures to back up the commitment on class sizes. If the priorities were not based on financial figures, how did you arrive at them? What were the governing factors that made you pick out these six commitments, rather than others?
Some of them—for example, that on class sizes—flow from the Government's manifesto commitments. The expansion in early-years provision is also a manifesto commitment. The negotiations were for the whole package of measures. We tried to reach the best possible settlement in the circumstances.
When you drew up your COSLA manifesto prior to the election, did you have formal costings for the overall package?
The commitments do not flow from the COSLA manifesto, but from the Scottish Government's manifesto.
In other words, you have accepted the Scottish Government's manifesto commitments.
We have not. We have accepted that we will take forward the commitments, based on the wording of the concordat.
I would like get this point absolutely clear. Are you accepting the six commitments in the concordat as educational priorities?
I make clear that we have signed up to what has been agreed on class sizes, early years, kinship care and free school meals.
I return to the answers that you gave to Mary Mulligan and Jeremy Purvis. If there is no financial costing behind the six commitments, can you guarantee that there is some logic or reason for deciding that they are the right priorities for the future?
I have tried to explain that local government's work will not be limited to the six commitments. They flow from the Scottish Government's manifesto, which, as you know, included commitments on early years and class sizes. Those are specific commitments that were part of the overall negotiated package.
They were manifesto commitments that the Government brought to us. It asked us what we could deliver for the finances that will be made available to local government. The commitments were considered as a package. Clearly, decisions were made about what needed money up front and what could be delivered in other ways. In effect, the deal was for the whole package. Given the resources that were available to us, the flexibility that we were being offered and the incentive of being able to recycle efficiency gains, we thought that, in the concordat, we could sign up to the commitments, which are not the commitments that were in the Government's manifesto.
If you have an overall package, surely there must be a financial figure for that. It would be only reasonable to break down the package into the six component parts to assess or estimate the costs of putting it together. Will you clarify whether that has happened? It would be worrying if such a breakdown had not been done.
There is no breakdown for any specific commitment. We are saying that, within the overall settlement, local authorities can prioritise their move towards fulfilling the commitments in a way that is appropriate locally. That may mean that levels of investment differ among the local authorities, to allow them to meet their local priorities. We have agreed the overall package. Local authorities will sign up to it if they want to and, within that, they will decide how much they can focus on each commitment, given the other flexibilities that have been granted with the agreement.
Are you confident that the 32 local authorities in Scotland are likely to sign up to the concordat? Do they see it as containing the main policies that they want to deliver, or will there be a lot of variation on a theme?
The concordat was put to the council leaders, who agreed that it was the best deal that could be made in the circumstances. It has now been referred to individual councils, but the leaders have all signed up to it.
Before I let in Jeremy Purvis, I ask Mr Nicol to clarify his response to Liz Smith's question about costings. Did you say that COSLA did not have costings for any of the six policy commitments on children's services in the concordat?
I meant that there is no specific allocation of funding for any policy commitment. We have an overall package. Local authorities can take the overall funding that they are given and, based on their local circumstances and needs, prioritise how it is spent. I hope that that is clarification enough.
When you entered into negotiations with the Scottish Government on behalf of COSLA, did you go with costings for the delivery of any of the priorities?
As I said, the negotiations involved senior finance directors and our presidential team. They were negotiating to get the best overall package, which included several non-funding matters, such as the outcome agreements. They were negotiating the whole package—that is what we set out to achieve. Obviously, there would have been indicative figures and information from local authorities would have been fed into the negotiations. We tried to get an overall package that would give local authorities the freedom to decide locally how they prioritise the spend.
Perhaps Councillor Hutton would like to respond. The reason why I ask the specific question is that paragraph 3 of your written submission states:"The negotiations with the Scottish Government were clearly based on our costed understanding of our spending requirements".What are COSLA's spending requirements and how do they match up to the spending commitments that you have signed up to deliver in the spending review period?
As I said, we did not sign up to deliver the commitments in the concordat in this session of the Parliament. As a result of the detailed negotiations between the presidential team and the Scottish ministers, local government was given £11.137 billion, which I understand was the best settlement that local government could get, given the tight financial restraints.
Is that how much COSLA asked for?
Pat Watters gave evidence at committee yesterday. I am sure that he would also have been asked that. Would that information have been provided, Jon?
Obviously, Mr Watters is not here, but you are here, Ms Hutton. I would have thought that, as you were coming to the committee, some preparation would have been made. Having such figures to hand might have been helpful. It is not unexpected for the committee to ask questions of this nature and detail.
There was a negotiation, and the cost impacts would vary from council to council. There would also be a variation in the commitment. If a commitment was made to deliver class sizes of 18 in primaries 1 to 3 in this spending review period, there would be a significant cost to that. We did not end up in that situation; we ended up with what we have in the concordat. We will deliver that throughout Scotland on the basis of the opportunities that are presented by demographic change. Overall, Scotland-wide, that will lead to progress on the delivery of that manifesto commitment. However, it will not be delivered in this spending review period or this parliamentary session.
In the negotiations between COSLA and the Scottish Government, local authorities know how much they spend to deliver education services, nursery care, pre-school services, school meals, school building programmes and future liabilities. They know how much money they require to meet those commitments. The committee is asking you how much COSLA asked for in the negotiations to fulfil those on-going commitments. Also, what additional money do you require to fulfil your commitments on the six priorities that you have signed up to deliver?
We can forward you the submission that we made in terms of the spending review, which gives a picture of where we see pressures and so on. We made a conscious decision not to go with a long list of funding pressures but to negotiate the best overall deal that we could. The outcome is challenging in that the money is not as we would have hoped. However, we felt that it was the best possible deal. We feel that, given the Scottish Government's manifesto commitments, what is written out in the concordat is affordable. That is not to say that it will be easy to afford, but it will be affordable, particularly given the flexibilities for the use of money and the fact that our efficiency savings will not be top-sliced. That was the judgment.The negotiations and figures varied depending on what was on offer, what was being committed and what was not being committed. The agreement was made on the basis that we got an overall amount of money: £11.137 billion. We felt that, within that package, the commitments as set out in the concordat—which are not the same as the commitments that were contained in the Government party's manifesto—represented a deal that we could sign up to. That is what we recommended to council leaders.
First, did COSLA not in fact ask for £3.92 billion, meaning that you got considerably less than you asked for? Secondly, how can you be confident that something is affordable if you do not know how much anything costs?
As I said, it was a negotiation in terms of what, overall, we felt we could—
You have already stated that. I am specifically asking you how something can be affordable when you do not know the cost of delivering any of the policy commitments. How can you make that assessment?
We made that assessment as part of our negotiation.
I want to go back to the specifics regarding the class sizes promise. You will have noted that the First Minister was asked, when he outlined the programme for government, whether the class sizes promise for primaries 1 to 3 would be delivered within this parliamentary session. He confirmed to Parliament that it would be. Is it your evidence that that is now not the case and that the policy will not be delivered this session?
We have certainly agreed with the Scottish Government that progress on reducing class sizes in primaries 1 to 3 will be made as quickly as possible. However, we have also agreed that the pace of implementation will depend on local circumstances, such as changing populations and school estate constraints. There might be some areas where implementation could happen within the session, but there are others where it will not. The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has advised us that she would like to see year-on-year progress. I think that she has made subsequent statements to that effect.
Overall, for Scotland in its entirety, the policy will not be delivered in this session of Parliament.
Our position has always been that there will be year-on-year progress.
You said that some areas will experience constraints such as changing demographics. What evidence will you use to show that in Scotland overall school rolls will fall over the period of the spending review?
We have the population projections of what class sizes will be. Therefore, we know that there will be an opportunity in much of Scotland to make progress. That will not be uniform, because there are areas, such as around Edinburgh, where the school rolls are rising.
You will know that the most recent indicators from the General Register Office for Scotland show that there will not necessarily be falling school rolls. Can we tell local authorities that are forecasting falling school rolls that they have to retain the same level of teaching staff that they have at the moment?
We see an opportunity to reduce class sizes by retaining the same level of staff.
Is each local authority free to make that decision?
Yes.
So, even in the areas where the rolls are falling, there is still no guarantee that local authorities will choose to retain teacher numbers.
Individual local authorities are now considering the concordat and the terms of commitments that are made. We are saying that the concordat is the best deal that could be made, given the circumstances.
Forgive me, Mr Harris, but you said clearly to the committee a number of times that the policy is predicated on the commitment being met in areas where there are falling school rolls and demographic changes. Are local authorities that have falling rolls able to decide not to cut teaching staff levels?
The agreement was negotiated with the 32 local authority leaders and they felt that we could sign up to the policy. There is shared understanding that one way of increasing pupil attainment is to reduce the size of the classes.
Have all councils signed up to the policy?
The leaders signed up collectively, as COSLA. COSLA said that the agreement was the best deal possible. Obviously, it needs to refer that to individual councils, which will have to make their commitments as part of setting their budget.
How many councils have falling school rolls in their area?
I do not know the exact detail, but I can come back to you on that.
Given that you have said that the policy is predicated on having such councils meet the commitment, I would have thought that you might have known how many of the 32 councils are expecting falling schools rolls. Of those councils, how many have signed up to retaining teaching numbers as they are at the moment?
No council has signed up to that; they are waiting until they learn what their allocations of funding are later in the month. Once councils have their allocations, they will be able to agree the overall package.
But there is no guarantee that local authorities that are expecting falling school rolls will choose to retain staffing numbers because they are not receiving any additional money in the settlement.
The deal was on the terms of the overall package. We would expect those commitments to be made and we will monitor that as part of the process.
But you cannot expect the commitments to be made if they have not made the commitments.
The budget-setting process is under way. As part of that process, those commitments will be made—
Is it your expectation that those councils will sign up to this and retain teacher numbers?
Our expectation is that we will make progress in reducing class sizes during this parliamentary session.
What are you defining as progress?
A reduction in the school class sizes.
By one, in Scotland?
I cannot answer that.
Progress will be down to individual local authorities. We have said that we would like to make year-on-year progress. However, that will be built up from the ground level.
Would it be progress if any class in Scotland that currently has more than 18 pupils were to get down to that level? If one class in Scotland has a lower number in 2011 than it has today, would you say that that is progress?
Well, limited.
We have set out how we want to make progress. How much progress is made depends on local factors. There are no targets set.
Under the concordat, we will be regularly monitoring the situation in partnership with the Scottish Government.
It does not look as if you are going to be busy.
I think we will be.
How are you going to be busy monitoring something when you do not know what the situation is at the moment, you do not know how many authorities have falling school rolls and you do not know which authorities have said that they will retain teacher numbers? How are you going to monitor a situation like that?
These are situations that are down to individual local authorities, as employers—
Forgive me, Mr Nicol, but COSLA has said that it will be monitoring the situation.
That is not what we have said. We have—
Mr Harris just said it.
We have been saying that, as part of the oversight arrangements, pressures that are identified can be fed into the process between COSLA and the Scottish Government. Obviously, that will require information to be fed up to COSLA on an on-going basis. We have in place executive groups whose memberships include elected politicians and we have good relationships with the professional associations. All of that will enable good partnership working between local government and the Scottish Government to identify and address any issues that occur during the concordat period.
Scottish Borders Council has said publicly that it will not deliver this policy because it has no resources to do it and it has increasing school rolls throughout its area. How will you monitor progress in that area?
The same monitoring arrangements will continue. Education, for example, is a statutory responsibility, which means that the monitoring will continue. We will be monitoring the situation to determine the extent to which we are delivering on those commitments.
How many classes in Scotland have fewer than 18 pupils at the moment?
We can come back to you on that. I do not know precisely how many—
But COSLA knows?
There are Government statistics on average class sizes in primaries 1 to 3 and elsewhere. I do not have those figures to hand, but they are available on the Scottish Government website.
If the costs vary between local authorities, will that be monitored in your regular meetings with the cabinet secretary? How significant will those meetings with the Government be in ensuring that COSLA can make progress towards achieving some of the national policies that have been identified?
They will be significant. We are moving into a new era of joined-up partnership working. I might be wrong, but it feels as though, for the first time, we are devolving a lot of power and responsibility locally. If local government does not deliver locally, it is accountable to the electorate. Certainly, for the first time I think, there is a mutual trust. Previously, I almost got the feeling that local government was not trusted on matters such as looking after children, education or kinship care. I might be wrong, but I think that, for the first time, we are moving into an exciting era of joined-up thinking and regular meetings with the Scottish ministers. I know that many councillors to whom I have spoken through COSLA are—like me—trying to get their head round the top-down prescriptive approach that we traditionally had whereby we were told from above how to deliver services. In fact, some of us councillors know what is needed locally and we can identify local priorities. It will be good if policy from the Borders, West Lothian or wherever can now start to be fed upwards rather than have everything come from the top down.I know that Mary Mulligan is shaking her head. I am disappointed at that because I know that many politicians locally have seen a difference in the working relationship between MSPs and councillors. I welcome that.
Several members have follow-up questions, but we have a couple of lines of questioning on which we are still to start. I will let Richard Baker and Liz Smith in, but they must be brief.
I have only one question. Councillor Hutton talked about the need to trust local authorities to deliver key services. Of course we trust local authorities to deliver those, but they will not be able to deliver them properly without adequate resources. That is what we are trying to get to the bottom of today. Paragraph 6 of the COSLA submission refers to "A reversal of the trend over recent Spending Reviews which left Local Government with a decreasing share of public expenditure in Scotland."Is it not the case that, of the £385 million growth in the local government settlement, £210 million is specifically for the council tax freeze? Funding for council services will in effect decline, as it will increase by 0.5 per cent per annum, compared to a 1.6 per cent increase in health funding. Can you not understand why some of us are sceptical about how local government will meet the terms of the concordat when funding for services will increase by only 0.5 per cent?
Again, we come back to the fact that this is a tight settlement. What we have negotiated, with the flexibilities that we have been given, is what we think we can deliver. Clearly, we have also built in a monitoring process and a review of progress each year. If decisions on resourcing need to be changed, that is where they will take place. We see the agreement as a more positive way of doing business between the two spheres of government. If there are difficulties, we will need to address them together.
I am delighted that there might be more bottom-up negotiations, as that is a much better way to run education, but that does not take away from the fact that this is a tight settlement from the Scottish Government. Our concern as a committee is that not much proper costing has been done on the commitments for the different regions and that there is not much on the specific priorities that can be addressed. The guidance that is given seems very sketchy indeed.
As I said before, the approach that is taken to non-specific commitments such as the one on class sizes will be very much a local matter. People will need to work within the local circumstances. I was not entirely sure whether you were saying that there should be more guidance on the commitments.
It is extraordinary that, if COSLA believes that the priorities should be more regionally based, it has not sought more information from the different local authorities on what they can and cannot deliver. I find that extraordinary.
Essentially, what can and cannot be delivered will be down to local circumstances. If an authority's school rolls are rising, that might mean that it will not be able to reduce all class sizes to 18. We have agreed the overall national commitments, which are carefully worded. How those are delivered will naturally depend on local circumstances.
I want to find out how you will cope with one of the new developments. The committee has heard from witnesses in the further education sector who feel that their budget allocation will allow them to continue to operate at current levels and no more. The concordat between the Scottish Government and the local authorities includes a policy to give more pupils access to vocational learning, some of which will be delivered by the colleges. To make that proposal workable for further education colleges and to allow them to afford to deliver such courses, they will have to be paid for at full cost.Have local authorities understood that cost pressures in other parts of the education sector might require them to fund additional training for large numbers of pupils at what might be significant—in other words, full—cost, given the need for FE colleges to remain financially sustainable?
I would not want to comment on the FE budget; we negotiated the local authority budget.There are different ways of delivering vocational education across the country. School-college partnerships are one method but, for geographical reasons, they do not work in every local authority area and sometimes they work only in parts of a local authority area. The fact that a college might be quite distant from the school in a rural area means that it might be more appropriate for vocational education to be delivered in the school. With the Government, we have agreed to develop policy that will allow local solutions to delivering vocational education to be developed. That is one of the strands of the positive partnership working that we have embarked on.
You cannot say that the delivery of vocational education will be uniform.
The policy development section of the concordat says that policy will not stand still and that issues will arise. For example, we will work with the Government to develop policy on early years education. As part of the development process, we will negotiate on what resources are available or could be made available. In our view, that is a more positive way of developing policy. In the longer term, that will be one of the most significant benefits of the development of a new relationship between local government and the Scottish Government. We will be involved in the development of policy at ground level and will not be brought in at the consultation stage. We have built into the spending review a yearly review so that we will have an opportunity to rethink how we spend our resources and to rethink our commitments.
You are saying that it should be easier for you to make such policy developments.
Yes. We feel that if we are involved in the process at an early stage and can bring to it our views on what some of the delivery issues and the problems might be with a particular policy, and on how much it might cost, we will be able to influence the way in which the policy is developed. That will avoid our suddenly finding ourselves in a situation in which we are asked to respond to a consultation on a policy that has already broadly been developed. We feel that the new arrangement will give us an opportunity to be in at the start of policy developments. An example of such a policy development is the early years strategy. We have already started having meetings with civil servants on how to progress that.
It is important that we establish that your ability to have a clear perception of the global sums of money involved is new. I do not know whether you would like to comment on the fact that there was an overallocation in the Labour-Liberal Democrat Administration's budget of £220 million. The fact that John Swinney has set out the Government's budget in a much clearer fashion means that people now have a much better idea of what they can spend than they did before.
We negotiated with the current and previous Governments to get an agreed base budget. This particular negotiation has not just developed a base budget in terms of revenue but added a base budget in terms of capital. That is a step forward.
That is a good step forward.Coming back to the FE question, you talk about different areas of the country having different solutions. Nevertheless, if we are to deliver the kind of vocational training that we are talking about, local government might have to pick up the tab for keeping pupils in school longer. Can you see a way in which you can identify the cash for that?
Throughout the country, there are different ways of delivering vocational education. We want to develop policy further. Ministers have talked on the record about access to all, and about parity of esteem between vocational and academic education. With that in mind, we will look to further policy. If that highlights costs, we can raise the issue with the Scottish Government. However, we are at the beginning of a process of partnership working on that.
I have a brief supplementary question. Mr Harris mentioned the early years strategy, particularly in relation to increased entitlement to nursery provision. Did COSLA estimate how much it would cost to increase nursery provision from the new level of 475 hours per annum to 570 hours?
As I said regarding class sizes, all our costings were intended to develop the overall package. We have set out that we will move to the higher figure by 2010. Local authorities were fully funded in the summer for an initial increase, but will move to the higher figure by 2010. Again, all the costings are part of the overall package, as that is how we approached negotiations.
I wonder how you can come to an overall figure when you do not seem to have individual figures to put into that pot.However, I return to my question. Much of the education skills and children's services agenda will be delivered by local authorities. In ensuring that national priorities are met, how can we ensure that the outcome agreements will be effective?
We are negotiating a single outcome agreement around the five strategic priorities supporting outcomes and the national indicators. We are in the process of developing local outcome indicators that relate to that, and developing a template of what a single outcome agreement will look like. You need to understand that the single outcome agreement will be set in the context of continuing statutory responsibilities, so there will be on-going monitoring of that. The focus of the outcome agreements in each area will be to identify those areas—such as health, pupil attainment and safer communities—that require significant improvement. That will be negotiated by the council, the community planning partners and the Scottish Government. The outcome agreements will focus on a relatively small number of priorities, because if you do not focus on the performance improvements that are important for a community, you end up spreading your resources too thinly.We have started that process. We feel that it will make local government and the Scottish Government jointly more accountable, because we will say how we will spend our money, what our priorities will be and what we will achieve by such and such a date. That is positive, because we will be accountable to our communities and the Scottish Government feels that, across the public sector, we will be more accountable to Parliament.
Are indicators such as"Increase the proportion of schools receiving positive inspection reports … Increase the proportion of pre-school centres receiving positive inspection reports"and"Increase the overall proportion of area child protection committees receiving positive inspection reports"appropriate as outcomes?
We were invited to comment on the set of national indicators. There is no indicator for some areas, so one way of getting some initial feelings for performance is to use inspectorate reports. We wanted the national indicators to specify a high level for what we as a nation want to deliver; our local outcome indicators will probably focus more on how we deliver those outcomes. For example, on health, some councils will tackle drug and alcohol abuse, smoking or obesity. That may vary from one council area to another, but it will be part of our overall commitment to improve people's life chances, quality of life and health and to tackle health inequality. However, some national indicators are there as proxies because we do not have outcome measures to measure them.
I agree that outcomes are more appropriate for measuring impact on society than the kind of things that we have listed. However, you have also claimed that delivery on outcomes increases accountability. How can you argue that, given that you seem to assume that some local authorities will not be able to deliver for whatever reason—perhaps population increase? How does that make local authorities or the Scottish Government accountable?
We have signed up to delivering improved pupil attainment as an outcome. That is how we envisage the decisions on class sizes being picked up. Class size reductions are one route to improving attainment outcomes, but there are other routes that might be equally appropriate.
The inputs to deliver those outcomes will vary and the demands within the local authorities will vary, so how can we be sure that the outcomes will be delivered?
All local authorities have looked at the national indicators and have signed up to the strategic priorities and to using the indicators. We know that they are not perfect and that there is work to be done. We felt that improving pupil attainment was probably a better outcome than measuring class sizes, but we regard class size reductions as one route to improving pupil outcomes.
I agree with you on pupil attainment. That would be my priority as well, but I did not promise to ensure that every child in primary 1 to primary 3 would be taught in a class of 18. If that is not achieved, what will the sanction be for not achieving it?
It will be monitored and we will be in negotiations with the Scottish Government on how we respond to it. If there is an issue and we are not delivering a particular commitment, we will consider how we can respond. There may be many reasons for not delivering and we will have to deal with them as they arise.
I like to think that we are working towards partnership working and that, if there are pressures, rather than having prescriptive sanctions, we would take a joint approach to alleviate those pressures and deliver the desired outcome of a reduction in class sizes to 18, year on year, throughout the 32 local authorities.
I do not think that anyone would suggest that local and central Government should not work in partnership.
I am pleased to hear that. Thank you.
No one would suggest that for a minute, just as no one would suggest that the new Government in Edinburgh is the first to sit down around the table with COSLA. That seemed to be the suggestion earlier on.Mr Purvis has some final questions.
On 14 November, in response to a question that I asked, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth said that a substantial amount of the education and lifelong learning budget has been transferred to the local authority block. How much is that?
I was not aware of that. I do not know how the money was reallocated within the Scottish Government. Again, I will come back to you if we can find out the figures. We negotiated an overall block of money as distinct from a block of money that came from different parts of the Scottish Government.Clearly, issues around the transfer of money to local government might arise from changes to the ways in which we handle enterprise, Communities Scotland and so forth. Again, we are negotiating on those one by one.
To clarify, you do not know how much has been transferred from existing budget lines for education and lifelong learning to areas that have been rolled up into the local government block for education and lifelong learning.
You are talking about the funds that were previously ring fenced.
Yes, or indeed other funds from the education and lifelong learning budget, whether they are for skills, workforce development or other functions that have been transferred to local government and which are linked to tertiary education.
We have said repeatedly that we negotiated the whole package, or the whole settlement. Wherever the money comes from in the Scottish Government, it is part of the overall negotiation. No element of the local government settlement was allocated specifically for education or any other policy area. It is a whole settlement, and local authorities will prioritise spending locally as they see fit.
We certainly know which funding streams are no longer ring fenced. We are talking to the Government about whether we will retain the level of funding that was put into those streams previously and whether they will be uprated by inflation. There is a negotiation about that. There is also a negotiation on how we might distribute that money to the 32 councils. That work is continuing. By the time we fix the budgets, we will know precisely what money is available and how much will go to each council.
If I may, convener, I will return to the point about ring fencing, because it is important. However, I ask my question again. On 14 November, I asked the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, with regard to the budget document, why the proportion of funding for education and lifelong learning will fall in the current session of Parliament. His response was:"The member's point about the education and lifelong learning budget is explained by the fact that in a host of areas there will be transfers of resources out of particular budgets into the local authority block. That reflects differences and changes in the budget."—Official Report, 14 November 2007; c 3346. You are saying that you do not know what that figure is.
We are saying that it was part of an overall negotiation to establish the local government settlement. It will be for local government to prioritise how it spends the money locally.
If we are talking about previously ring-fenced funding, we will be able to answer that precisely.
Okay. In that case, I will ask a precise question about ring fencing. What is the value of all the areas that have been wrapped up in the local government settlement that were previously ring fenced?
We are negotiating that. We are taking as a baseline the resources that were there in the previous financial year, and we are assuming that there will be some uplift.
Did you say that you "are assuming"?
We have argued that if the resources are shifted, the opportunity should not be taken unilaterally to cut the amount of money available.
Is it part of the new relationship between local government and the Scottish Government to assume, without asking, that figures will be uplifted in the budget?
We have made that assumption because the money is being transferred into our base budget, which will be uplifted by inflation. We have not yet seen the final figures.
Did you ask?
We have asked.
Before the signing of the concordat?
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Dec 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 5 December 2007 Committee business · 1
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 450
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.