Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 30 June 2011 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 11 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00086)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
If I may, Presiding Officer, at this last meeting of the Parliament before the summer recess, I would like to say a few words about Iain Gray. He has served his party with great distinction, as a minister and as leader of the Opposition. His approach on key issues has been constructive. Recently, he has offered support to tackle sectarianism and to deal with the problems that are associated with alcohol in our society. Relevant to today, he has joined us in expressing concern about the United Kingdom’s approach to public sector pensions. His approach has certainly been appreciated and I hope that his successor, whoever that may be, will continue in the same distinguished vein. The Parliament owes Iain Gray a debt of gratitude for his public service. [Applause.]

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
We have not set a date for the election of my successor yet, but nonetheless I take those remarks in the spirit in which they were made.

In the time in which we have faced each other, the First Minister and I have often talked about the national health service. The First Minister and Nicola Sturgeon have told us that they are protecting the NHS, yet this week we found out that, in the past six months, 1,600 NHS jobs have gone. Of those, 700 are nurses and midwives—the very people on the front line of patient care. The Royal College of Nursing called that “unsustainable”. Why is the First Minister not protecting the NHS as he promised he would?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
As Iain Gray knows, we have guaranteed that all consequentials will go to the national health service. That was not a universal view when the issue was debated last autumn. I remember that Iain Gray himself, on “Newsnight Scotland” on 8 September 2010, said:

“We wouldn’t ring fence the health budget.”

The protection of the health budget has meant that, even in these difficult times, health employment in every single category—through medical consultants, general practitioners, dentists and nurses to allied health professionals—is substantially up today on the level that we inherited in 2007.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister needs to examine the statistics that he has given to make sure of their veracity. The fact is that there are fewer nurses and midwives in the NHS now than there were at the end of 2007-08, which was the period of the last budget of the Labour Administration that was in office up to 2007.

It was not just nurses who got big promises that the First Minister would protect them. In March, he announced:

“if the people return me as first minister, then I will secure that prize—of no compulsory redundancies”.

He said specifically that he was talking about local government, schools, colleges and the health service. Fifty staff at Edinburgh’s Telford College are facing compulsory redundancy. The chances are that some of them voted for Alex Salmond on the basis of that promise. He has his job as First Minister, but they are getting P45s. This Tuesday, Michael Russell told a parliamentary committee,

“I have no power to enforce the policy”,—[Official Report, Education and Culture Committee, 28 June 2011; c 26.]

so why did Alex Salmond make the promise?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I want to correct Iain Gray on the health service statistics. The number of consultants, on a full-time equivalent basis, is up by 20 per cent from September 2006.

Members: 2006!

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Well, that is on the basis of the term of the previous Scottish National Party Administration.

The number of general practitioners is up by 7.2 per cent, the number of nursing and midwifery staff is up by 383; the number of dentists is up by 20 per cent and the number of allied health professionals is up by 9 per cent. That is a comprehensive increase. Even under the most difficult and severe Westminster-induced budgetary cutbacks, our decision to pass on the full consequentials and to ring fence the national health service budget shows that we are maintaining and sustaining that level of investment in our staff in the national health service.

As Iain Gray well knows, the no-compulsory-redundancy pledge was made to our 30,000 central Government staff and to the hundreds of thousands of people who work in the national health service in Scotland. That pledge is not available elsewhere in the United Kingdom and nor, incidentally, is that a new phenomenon. I have quotes here from 2006 when Tony Blair, the then Prime Minister, said in answer to a question that it was all right, because there would be only a few hundred compulsory redundancies in the national health service in England. Do not let us believe that compulsory redundancies south of the border started as a Tory-led initiative.

We have applied the policy in the areas that we directly control. As Iain Gray well knows, the colleges, thanks to a statute passed by the Labour Party when it was in government, are independently run in Scotland. The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning gives them advice. I hope that colleges throughout Scotland will take that advice.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Mike Russell was right and the promise was worthless.

As for directly employed employees, what about the 16 Caledonian MacBrayne workers who are redundant today? CalMac is a company that is wholly owned by the Scottish Government. Those workers are employed by a company that is owned by the Scottish Government and they are redundant today.

If promises to nurses and college staff were worthless, what about teachers? Paul Bisland is a newly qualified teacher who, no matter how hard he tries, cannot get a job, and 80 per cent of his colleagues are in the same boat. Mr Russell wrote personally to Paul Bisland in January and promised him that

“there will be a sufficient number of vacancies for all teachers seeking employment in 2011”,

so where are they?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Can I just correct Iain Gray? As a point of fact, there are no compulsory redundancies in Caledonian MacBrayne. I hope that he accepts that. It is not appropriate to come to the chamber and make an announcement that is absolutely not true. There are no compulsory redundancies.

There are areas in which our advice to other public bodies has prevailed. I am thinking of James Watt College, which, after some debate, accepted the policy of no compulsory redundancies. Recently, I even heard the leader of Inverclyde Council on air reversing his policy of compulsory redundancies. Iain Gray should not underrate the ability of exhortation of ministers in this Administration to persuade even the most recalcitrant Labour authority to follow such a policy. Incidentally, among the groups that we have not yet convinced of the value of our policies are some Labour-led councils in Scotland that, as we know from many previous debates, are responsible for the vast majority of the decline in teacher numbers in Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
This is the pattern, is it not? The First Minister makes the promise and then blames someone else when he breaks it.

When the First Minister made his announcement of no compulsory redundancies in March, he said that he would spend every day trying to deliver the policy. Is the problem not that he has spent every day doing something else? I do not deny that he has been busy, what with non-stop constitutional bickering over his referendum, gratuitously insulting Supreme Court judges and, let us not forget, introducing a bill on sectarianism so badly drafted that his own minister could not explain it.

There has been intransigence, intemperance and incompetence, and, all the time, indifference to cuts in the number of nurses, redundancies in colleges and teachers on the scrapheap. All they get are excuses. When is he going to get off his personal agenda and start paying some attention to the promises of jobs and services that he made to the people of Scotland only six weeks ago?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I recognise that rhetoric—it is a throwback to some 50 days ago. It is what Iain Gray was arguing in the election campaign.

Let us reflect on some of the things that have happened since the election campaign. Unemployment fell by 10,000 over the quarter—the seventh consecutive reported fall in Scotland. Official statistics show that, for the fifth successive year, Scotland is in a stronger budgetary position than the United Kingdom as a whole. What about some specific announcements that I know Iain Gray is dying to welcome? Amazon has created 900 jobs in Scotland. State Street has established its European centre of excellence here. Gamesa, one of the great companies in the renewables revolution, has announced the start of its recruitment programme in Scotland. I know that, in his current position, Iain Gray is not able to welcome those signs of positive achievement under the most adverse circumstances, but I also know that when he is in a different position—when he is less committed and is able to take a judicious view of such matters—he will be the very first to welcome the positive achievements of this Administration.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Renewable Energy Statement · 29
  2. Scotland Bill (Supreme Court) Bill debate · 61
  3. Transport Infrastructure (South-east Scotland) Questions · 9
  4. Crown Estate (Freshwater Salmon Fishing Rights) Questions · 8
  5. Tourism (Growth) Questions · 4
  6. Geothermal Energy Questions · 6
  7. Scottish Water (Coastal Pollution) Questions · 6
  8. High-speed Rail Link Questions · 6
  9. Research and Development Investment (South of Scotland) Questions · 4
  10. Antisocial Behaviour Questions · 4
  11. Uncollected Fiscal Fines Questions · 4
  12. Judges (Appointment) Questions · 5
  13. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
  14. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  15. Legal Profession (Cadder Ruling) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Borrowing Powers First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Care Homes (Inspections) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  18. Ambulance and Fire Service Crews (Attacks) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  19. “The Scheme” Members’ business · 6
  20. Social Care and Social Work Improvement Scotland (Capacity) Questions · 12
  21. Measles Outbreak (Mainland Europe) Questions · 7
  22. NHS Dumfries and Galloway (Meetings) Questions · 4
  23. Detect Cancer Early Questions · 6
  24. Health Budget 2011-12 (VAT Increase) Questions · 8
  25. Mesothelioma Cases (Employment History) Questions · 4
  26. Dementia (Care Home Places) Questions · 6
  27. Young Carers Questions · 4
  28. Commonwealth Games 2014 (Multiculturalism) Questions · 9
  29. Sports Development Questions · 4
  30. Preventative Health Messages Questions · 6
  31. Cancer Drugs Questions · 4
  32. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 5
  33. Diabetes Action Plan 2010 Questions · 5
  34. Smokers Questions · 6
  35. NHS Highland (Cowal Hospice) Questions · 4
  36. Rural Connectivity Debate · 35
  37. Finance (No 3) Bill Bill debate · 2
  38. Decision Time Decision time · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.