6. To ask the First Minister what recent discussions the Scottish Government has had with the Secretary of State for Defence regarding the future of Scotland’s airbases, given the potential impact on jobs in the relevant local communities. (S4F-00039)
Official Report · Chamber
Airbases
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 3
- Roderick Campbell SNP 2
- David McLetchie Con 1
The record
6 contributions6. To ask the First Minister what recent discussions the Scottish Government has had with the Secretary of State for Defence regarding the future of Scotland’s airbases, given the potential impact on jobs in the relevant local communities. (S4F-00039)
The Scottish Government has for some months been in discussions with Ministry of Defence officials about the issue. I have also had a number of discussions with the Secretary of State for Defence. The Scottish Government’s role in those discussions has been to protect Scottish interests by making the compelling strategic and economic case for retaining RAF Leuchars and RAF Lossiemouth, and putting the case for relocating the maximum number of personnel currently based in Germany to Scotland.
Those discussions have been treated as confidential because many of the personnel involved are currently on active service in Afghanistan and elsewhere and because no decisions have yet been made by the United Kingdom Government. The Scottish Government is in the process of preparing a further and final submission to the Ministry of Defence, again setting out in detail the case for retaining the two RAF bases and for the transfer of the maximum number of army personnel from Germany. That will be submitted next week, so that it can be taken into account by the Secretary of State for Defence and the UK Government as they reach their final decisions on those matters.
Those discussions have been treated as confidential because many of the personnel involved are currently on active service in Afghanistan and elsewhere and because no decisions have yet been made by the United Kingdom Government. The Scottish Government is in the process of preparing a further and final submission to the Ministry of Defence, again setting out in detail the case for retaining the two RAF bases and for the transfer of the maximum number of army personnel from Germany. That will be submitted next week, so that it can be taken into account by the Secretary of State for Defence and the UK Government as they reach their final decisions on those matters.
I am sure that the First Minister is fully aware of the remarks made this week by Liam Fox, the Secretary of State for Defence, at the Select Committee on Scottish Affairs, where he admitted that over the past decade substantially bigger reductions were made in military personnel in Scotland, proportionally, than in other parts of the UK.
Does the First Minister agree that that supports the case for the UK Government not to close two thirds of Scotland’s airbases?
Does the First Minister agree that that supports the case for the UK Government not to close two thirds of Scotland’s airbases?
Yes, I do. I should point out that the centre of the case that we have been making to the UK Government is on strategic grounds and on the assets and advantages of Lossiemouth and Leuchars as RAF bases. However, we have also made the point that in an estate and defence review, and a base review that is proposing the closure of some 20 per cent of RAF bases throughout the UK, it would seem highly unreasonable to propose the closure of 66 per cent of the Scottish bases.
Since the First Minister aspires for Scotland to be an independent country, responsible for its own defence outwith the framework of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, would he care to tell us exactly what he envisages would be an appropriate size for the Scottish royal air force? How many planes and squadrons would it have and how many airbases would it need?
I can draw David McLetchie’s attention to some good international comparisons. I do so because at one of the meetings that I had with Liam Fox, he had just come back from talking about Nordic defence co-operation, particularly as far as airbases were concerned. Norway has seven airbases and Denmark has three. Norway’s population is slightly smaller than that of Scotland and Denmark’s is roughly equivalent to Scotland’s. None of the countries of that size seem to have only one airbase. I am sure that as Mr McLetchie casts his experienced eye around the canvas of similarly populated states throughout Europe, he will agree with me that two airbases in Scotland would be better than one.
12:29 Meeting suspended.
14:00 On resuming—
12:29 Meeting suspended.
14:00 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 Jun 2011 →- Caring for Scotland’s Older People Debate · 64
- Urban Regeneration Questions · 6
- Public-private Partnership/Private Finance Initiative Schools (North Ayrshire Council) Questions · 4
- Regeneration (Airdrie and Shotts) Questions · 5
- Schools (Capital Investment) Questions · 6
- Disabled People (Support) Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Governance) Questions · 6
- Care Homes (Inspections) Questions · 4
- Bus Services (Rural and Out-of-town Areas) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Corporation Tax First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Unpaid Carers First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Airbases First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Rural Schools Statement · 31
- Scotland Bill: Borrowing Powers and Growing the Economy Bill debate · 87
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Wild Animals in Circuses (Ban) Members’ business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.