PE1379, on green alternatives to incineration, is covered in paper 13. Do members wish to make any comments on the substance of the petition before we talk about the options that are open to us?Members: No.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Incineration (Green Alternatives) (PE1379)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 6
- Kevin Stewart SNP 3
- Sandra White SNP 2
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Bill Walker SNP 1
- Nanette Milne Con 1
The record
14 contributionsOkay. Do members have any views on the three options, which are to continue the petition, to refer it to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, or to close the petition on the basis that the action has already been carried out? We have to give an explanation if we close a petition.
If the action has already been carried out, the petition has done its job, so I recommend that we close it—unless anyone has any other view.
I agree with Sandra White. I do not know what guidance is given to petitioners, but some things in a petition can be nigh on impossible to achieve. If the petition is not correct or cannot be acted on, I cannot see the point of going forward with it. We are told in the papers that it would be impossible, even if we so wished, to close all existing plants within five years, so the petition is null and void, in that regard. I would close the petition. The petitioner might want to resubmit a petition, using other wording; I do not think that we can move forward with the petition, because of its wording.
I suggest that the committee refer the petition to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee. The petitioner has raised a number of issues in relation to the incineration programme in Scotland and the innovative ways in which some developers work—they are coming out with phrases that do not mention the word “incinerator” to describe something that does the same thing. There is a much wider issue for communities throughout Scotland because we will see growth in the number of pyrolysis plants or incinerators—whatever we want to call them—due to the desire of the Government and the European Union both to reduce the amount of waste that is going to landfill and to find alternatives. If we refer the petition to the relevant subject committee, it will be able to conduct a greater examination and to pull together some of the other factors that might be involved.Although Kevin Stewart is right that we may not be able to shut down all plants in five years, I hope that the committee could examine what methods or actions have been taken by plant operators to reduce emissions from incinerators.
I do not disagree that the issue probably needs to be looked at by the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, and I will not enter into a debate about energy from waste, whether that is conventional incineration, pyrolysis or whatever. That is a debate for elsewhere.The point for me is that the petition is very specific. It is clearly impossible to shut all existing plants within five years. Having listened to colleagues and hearing that today we have perhaps referred more petitions to committees than has been done for a long time, I do not think that we can agree to refer a petition when we know that what it wants cannot be enacted.11:45
If the petitioner wanted to submit a modified petition, I am sure that the committee would look at it, but we all know that it will be absolutely impossible to shut all existing waste incineration plants within five years. If that were done, we would have to find many more landfill sites, which I am sure none of us wants. Because we know that what the petitioner wants is impossible, the right thing to do is to close the petition. I do not know whether we are allowed to suggest that the petitioner submit a modified petition.
I agree with much of what Kevin Stewart has just said. The petition calls for the Government to“immediately ban the construction of new waste incinerators”.That seems to be straightforward enough, but what concerns me is that it also calls for a ban on the construction of “large biomass burners”. To me, those are not the same thing. Biomass is a different kettle of fish—that is a terrible metaphor—so, in my view, the petition is not consistent. It would be impossible for the Government to close down such plants within five years, which is what the petition asks for. I just do not think that that is right, especially in the case of biomass.
Just for the record, I point out that I was summarising some of the points in the petition, but the petition goes into a lot more detail.
I agree with Kevin Stewart. People submit petitions to us, which we act on by taking evidence and so on. If one of the issues that the petition deals with were included in a different petition, we could probably act further on it, but there is no way we could call on the Government to shut all existing waste incineration and biomass burning plants. We should not become a sifting committee for other committees. If we were to pass the petition on to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, I think that it would say exactly what we have said—that what the petitioner is asking for just could not be done.
There is a division of opinion on whether to refer the petition to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee or close it. I invite members who have not commented to make clear their views.
I appreciate John Wilson’s argument, but it is clear that the petition raises issues that cannot be acted on—although I do not know that I would say that it is not competent. I would like it to be made plain to the petitioner that it is an interesting petition, which could, with rewording, be resubmitted.
Would that satisfy Kevin Stewart?
Absolutely. I think that I made that suggestion. We cannot deal with a request that we know that we could not action. I think that the petitioner should resubmit a modified petition. I do not know whether the clerks are allowed to do this, but perhaps the petitioner could be given some guidance.
The suggestion is that we close the petition under rule 15.7, on the basis of incompetence, and that the clerks have a discussion about reframing the petition, which we might then see in a modified form in the future—although that would obviously be up to the petitioner. Are members happy for us to go down that route?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jun 2011 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 25
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 70
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 5
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 8
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.