I thank the committee for inviting me to a meeting at an early point following my appointment as Minister for Local Government and Planning. It is quite different to be sitting on this side of the table.As members know from my written submission, my primary portfolio responsibilities are local government, planning and building standards. Members know that I do not cover regeneration interests—that responsibility lies with the Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure and Capital Investment, Mr Neil. However, it is clear that there are important links between my portfolio and Mr Neil’s portfolio and areas in which they overlap—business rates incentivisation, for example. As members would expect, Mr Neil and I will want to explore those portfolio links further. I am sure that you will speak to him in due course.My ministerial post is new, and it emphasises the importance that we place on the new relationship between the Scottish Government and local government, which was established in 2007. That relationship has transformed the way in which we work with local government in its overt recognition that having a partnership of mutual respect between central Government and local authorities is critical for delivering excellent public services. I want to continue to build on that relationship and believe that, in partnership, we can deliver much more for the people of Scotland, despite the difficult financial situation that public services face.The committee will be aware of the financial and other challenges that we face over the coming months, principally those challenges associated with reduced funding as a consequence of the Westminster Government’s cuts and the spending review process that we are about to embark on. Those cuts make the imperative for public service reform more urgent. That reform process will be informed by the findings and recommendations of the Christie commission, which is due to report later this month. All of that sets a challenging context for local government, but I am sure that the committee shares my commitment to driving up performance and catalysing real improvements in the delivery of public services through a continuing focus on outcomes that matter to the people.The priorities for the local government part of my portfolio reflect those aims. Over the next year, I will focus in particular on further strengthening our relationship with local government through the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and direct engagement with councils; the local government settlement beyond 2011-12 through the spending review process; further embedding the cornerstones of community planning and single outcome agreements as the means of planning and delivering outcomes that matter for people and communities throughout Scotland; ensuring that the preparations for the local government elections in May 2012 are focused and thorough; and driving forward the emerging programme of reform with a culture of continuous improvement for local government.I am pleased that the committee has a wealth of past and present local government experience—indeed, I believe that four members of the committee are elected councillors on Aberdeen City Council, North Lanarkshire Council and Fife Council. I welcome and value your experience. I know that you already have first-hand understanding of the importance of strong relationships between central and local government in Scotland.I was pleased to be able to meet COSLA leaders within days of my appointment and I am committed to openness and honesty in how I engage with local government. I have also welcomed the opportunity to meet a number of elected members and senior executives from councils, to discuss at first hand issues that they face.I have taken away some important messages from those meetings and I have been struck by the extent and depth of innovation in local government. In Fife, I visited a combined social work services contact centre, to see how critical services are being joined up to provide a single point of contact for people. In Renfrewshire, I was impressed by an innovative project to provide healthy school meals and a community project to provide children’s play areas. Yesterday, in Perth, I visited the impressive Almondbank House, which is a multi-agency facility for young children who are unable to engage with mainstream education.I am sure that the committee shares my enthusiasm for such projects—large and small—which make a positive impact on local communities and support the wider community outcomes that matter to local people. Innovation that drives improvement and efficiency in public services really matters, and in my ministerial role I will be considering how and where it is taking place throughout Scotland. The sort of imagination and creativity that I witnessed in Fife, Renfrewshire and Perthshire is exactly what will make things happen and I will encourage and champion it wherever I see it.As the committee knows, responsibility for elections falls within my ministerial portfolio. The next set of elections in the cycle will be the local government elections next May. Those are the only elections for which the Scottish Parliament currently has legislative responsibility and it is vital that we get them right. We are undertaking a number of key activities in preparation for 2012. We require to put in place the legislation that governs the running of the elections and we are progressing the development and testing of the electronic vote-counting system that will be used. Electoral administration is above politics and I hope that we can work together to improve electoral structures in Scotland, continuing the excellent work that the committee’s predecessor committee and Bruce Crawford did over the past four years.We know that improving early years experience in Scotland is key to enabling us to address some of our most entrenched problems of poverty, poor health, poor attainment and antisocial behaviour. We know that investment in the early years repays in economic terms, too. Our bespoke Scottish economic modelling work demonstrates that without effective intervention in the early years the costs for a child with severe needs can be nine times higher. In the previous session of the Parliament, the Finance Committee recognised the strength of those arguments in its report on its inquiry into preventative spending.We will continue to build on the success of our early years framework, which we published in December 2008, by creating an early years taskforce to co-ordinate policy and ensure that early years spending is prioritised by the whole of the public sector. In the context of my portfolio, we will ensure that every council in Scotland reflects that agenda in its single outcome agreement.The Government considers that planning is vital to making our country more successful. Key to that are up-to-date and clear development plans and high-quality individual developments. We need a planning system that not only fosters economic recovery and growth but protects and enhances the places where we work, live and spend our leisure time. That means getting everyone who is engaged in planning to take a proactive and positive approach. I want communities to play an active role in the planning system. The earlier that people are engaged, the better.Much has been done to modernise the planning system and we want to give greater certainty to developers and communities. This is an exciting time in the context of delivery of the new planning system and planning’s ability to make a real contribution to the future of Scotland. The Scottish Government is taking forward a number of broad areas of work in relation to planning. We are ensuring that the planning system is suitably resourced, we are driving a culture of continuous improvement through the development of performance frameworks and support for cultural change, and we are following up on the review of the first 12 months of the modernised planning system.A range of individual projects are under way. For example, there is work to help to address the difficulties around infrastructure provision and the Scottish sustainable communities initiative is continuing. There is also important work to consider how enterprise zones could apply in Scotland and the new Scottish cities strategy.Building standards are about the principle of getting good outcomes and there have been various modernisations in that regard. Our broad areas of priority in building standards relate to verification and energy. As always, we are keen that all areas of the system should be fit for purpose. On energy, for example, the 2010 standards are set at a good level, but we need to explore how much further we can go. There will be a review for 2013, but we must be mindful of capital costs and their effects on the industry.As for legislation, much of the planning legislation that is likely to come before the committee will be in the form of Scottish statutory instruments on permitted development rights, which remove the need to apply for planning permission for certain developments. After the summer recess, we intend to introduce legislative changes to householder permitted development rights, which relate to features such as extensions, dormer windows and outbuildings. We are also reviewing non-domestic permitted development rights, and new legislation on that should be forthcoming in the first half of next year. The initial public consultation on that closes on 1 July.We are working on a number of potential changes to the modernisation legislation that was introduced in 2009, to pick up some of the teething issues with the new system. Further public consultation is needed, with a view to making a statutory instrument in early 2012.Given your predecessors’ involvement in the second national planning framework, members will be interested in the first annual update of NPF 2. The annual update on the national planning framework action programme will be ready shortly and I would be happy to discuss it with the committee in detail, once it has been made available to you.Through all my engagement with local authorities, I have strengthened my view that partnership is important. It is by working in partnership with local government and other public service delivery partners that the improved outcomes for people that we seek will begin to be achieved.It is your job to question, inquire and scrutinise over the next five years. This is my first appearance before you—the first of many—and I am sure that the next time we meet, you will be exercising your challenge and scrutiny role over my portfolio. I look forward to these exchanges and to working with you in a positive and constructive way. I welcome your questions.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Aileen Campbell only · show everyone- Aileen Campbell SNP 25
- Joe FitzPatrick SNP 9
- Kevin Stewart SNP 9
- Jim Mackinnon Scottish Government 9
- Bill Walker SNP 6
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 5
- Mark Griffin Lab 3
- David Torrance SNP 2
- Graham Owenson Scottish Government 1
Aileen Campbell’s contributions
25 contributionsPrimarily, my role involves the relationship with local government. There is clearly a lot of overlap with Mr Neil’s portfolio and regeneration. We intend to work closely and constructively together to deliver the best for regeneration and to ensure that local government has an active voice on that agenda. I intend to proceed along those lines. I know that Mr Neil will work with me in delivering outcomes for regeneration.
I apologise for having responded with regard to Mr Neil.Mr Swinney has an overarching role and he will still be taking an active interest in what I do and in my relationship with local government. However, I have primary responsibility for local government—for all aspects of local government finance, performance and scrutiny, community planning and developing and maintaining the relationship that Mr Swinney established with local government back in 2007.
I have just referred to the groundbreaking relationship that Mr Swinney established with COSLA and local government during the previous session and we intend to work with COSLA to develop and enhance that partnership. Discussions are on-going, but I am happy to share with the committee any information as it pans out.We certainly want to continue with that partnership, which I think has been constructive for both parties over the past four years. I know that COSLA wishes to continue with it and the matter was heavily discussed in my initial meetings with the COSLA leadership within days of my coming into post.
There has been a real shift in opinion because everyone now realises that single outcome agreements have been the way to do business. There is always room for improvement to maintain progress and ensure effective scrutiny of those outcomes. I do not see there being too much difference in the approach; single outcome agreements will remain part of the landscape and they will be enhanced during the next five years of the parliamentary session. They seem to be the only game in town.During my visits to a number of different councils, I have heard that they appreciate the focus on outcomes that has developed during the past four years and we will maintain that and seek to continue with it.
Yes. In the summer months, I intend to get out and about and visit as many local authorities as I possibly can. I have already met Perth and Kinross, Fife and Renfrewshire councils, and seen some of their good practice. I have seen their community planning partnerships working well, effective engagement with stakeholders around the table, and how they are delivering for folk in their communities. It is in my mind to see more evidence of that good practice.Some local authorities and community planning partnerships might need a bit more support and time to bed in. It is a fairly new way of working so it is about creating the space for folk to let me know if they need a bit more support or whatever else they feel that they need from Government to take community planning partnerships forward. I would certainly like to showcase the existing innovation and promote the good practice that is happening in many of our local authorities. The three authorities that I have met so far have the bit between their teeth and want to deliver more for the communities that they serve.
One of the youngest, just about. I think that there are younger members now.
Yes, and that is certainly the message that has come from the three councils that I have visited. All the local authorities recognise that times are tough financially so they need to think imaginatively and innovatively and not have the silo mentality that you have described.In the three councils that I have visited, there was a lot of crossover in how they want to work and deliver the outcomes. They want to deliver more. That is another thing that I would like to showcase during the summer months, to ensure that councils are achieving those things. I want to see how they are working and examples of what they are doing and then consider how I can take that message and share it more widely.There is always work to do and room for improvement, and we keep an eye on all of that. Measures are in place to scrutinise how councils work. I agree that we need to work together, and that already happens. At national Government level, there is crossover in portfolio briefs, so we have to practise what we preach. When we go out to local authorities, we must ensure that they are working together.We do not have huge pots of money to bring about that change in culture, but it is important, especially when times are tough financially. The change fund is an example of a pot of money that has helped local authorities to refocus how they deliver some services. I want to explore those issues further during the summer months. We definitely need to work together and across portfolios. We must realise that councils deliver services to the people and that the people who receive those services are not necessarily concerned about who provides them. People want a good service that they can get when they need it.
I understand and acknowledge the issues that Kevin Stewart raises. We all recognise that there is a scarcity of funds out there. Work is on-going to consider the issue that he describes about a requirement to pay up front because money is tight, which might put off a lot of development. I will bring in Jim Mackinnon to comment further, but I certainly take on board your comments.
Thank you for your kind words. I listened to your maiden speech and I know that child poverty is close to your heart and that you want to tackle it. I also understand that you have a wider interest in cross-party groups on the subject.Local government recognises that it must deliver more. Local authorities are acutely aware that children in their areas need to be cared and catered for, that poverty is a blemish on Scotland and that, if children live in poverty in their areas, they need to deal with those children effectively. Single outcome agreements will reflect that. Local government is acutely aware of the need to deal effectively with the issue, regardless of whether that is done by local authorities or the healthcare service.On education provision and being corporate parents, local authorities understand their role clearly and want to make a difference. I have not met a local authority that has wanted to shy away from its responsibility to ensure that the children in its area can aspire to greatness and come out of the poverty trap. Local authorities are working hard to overturn the statistics.
We have committed to having a task force on the early years, to ensure that the early years and children are a priority in all portfolios. We want that to be reflected in our work with local government.It is clear that the statistics for children who live in poverty are horrible. It is horrible to know that such figures exist in 21st century Scotland—a potentially very rich country. My gut feeling is that we as a country do not have some of the powers that we need to tackle child poverty effectively. We do not control social security and benefits. We do not have all the tools that we need to overturn some of the figures. However, we will work hard with the powers that we have to ensure that progress is made.The feeling across the Government is that we want to examine and improve the child poverty situation. However, we as a Government do not have all the powers that we need to tackle that effectively. With the new powers that are coming to the Scottish Parliament—I hope that we will have more in the next few years—perhaps we will be able to tackle child poverty effectively. Ensuring that children have the best start in life and can continue to aspire and prosper in this country motivates and drives many of us in the Scottish Parliament.
I would like to have more control over benefits, to ensure that people who are working and in poverty have more finances at their disposal, so that they can bring about the aspirational qualities that Scotland’s children need.We need those powers. We do not have the financial tools to bring about the effective change in child poverty that we wish to see. We should all recognise that we have only limited powers in the Scottish Parliament, and we need more so that we can deliver for Scotland and have bespoke, tailored policies to ensure that change happens as quickly as possible.10:30
Work is always on-going to examine legislative changes by the United Kingdom Government at Westminster. I am aware that colleagues in COSLA and local authorities are acutely aware of the pressure that may be placed on them with the changes that the Welfare Reform Bill will bring. I understand that there is frustration among some local authorities about the relationship with the Department for Work and Pensions. We need to find ways to make those relationships better, to ensure that councils’ views and messages are heard at Westminster, and I am willing to do anything that I can to help with that process.
The Scottish Government recognises that there is an issue with equal pay, but it was not involved in the negotiations with COSLA and it is an issue for local authorities. There has been previous engagement between COSLA and the Scottish Government, and if COSLA sees any way for the Scottish Government to intervene to resolve outstanding issues on equal pay, I am sure that we will consider that. Equal pay is a real issue, and we need to ensure that it is resolved quickly. It is the responsibility of local government, and it is up to authorities as autonomous bodies to resolve it. However, I have my eye on it, and if there are any ways in which we can help local authorities, I will be happy to begin the process of engagement.
If COSLA or local authorities come up with a list of ways in which the Scottish Government can helpfully intervene on equal pay, we will need to look at that and find ways to resolve issues and to work together to ensure that things happen quickly. However, as I said, local authorities are autonomous entities, and the issue, rightly, is looked at by them. We hope that they can resolve some of the issues quickly.
Of course, that would be an eminently sensible approach, to ensure that we have a full picture of how local authorities approached the issue. Kevin Stewart rightly says that the negotiations happened in 1999. Where councils have exercised their responsibilities quickly and effectively, it would be sensible to examine what they have done and to question, look at and work with the local authorities that are still involved in negotiations and are still finding ways to resolve the issues, because we need to ensure that the equal pay issue is resolved quickly. If councils have managed to resolve the issue quickly, we need to establish how they have done so and why others have not. That would be sensible.
I will be happy to share the update with you when it comes out and to return to the committee to discuss the issues. The framework is full of projects that are of national importance. I will hand over to Jim Mackinnon to elaborate on that.
As you rightly point out, the manifesto made a commitment that no local authority would receive less than 85 per cent of the Scottish average revenue support. The cost of that will be supported by additional money from central Government. Of course, all of this is tied up in the spending review settlement, which will be announced later this year, and the Government has committed to engaging with all local authorities to ensure that they can know in advance what their funding settlements will be and can put in place their own arrangements to deliver that money as quickly as they can.I will bring in Graham Owenson to elaborate.
Yes.
Folk are concerned about delays or perceived delays in the planning process. The issue of how we speed up the planning process to ensure that developments are not curtailed and investment is not missed has been raised with us. However, we want to ensure that the planning process as a whole is improved, and that entails thinking about not only the speed of the process but ways of ensuring that people come to local authorities with robust planning applications that have all the necessary details and information and do not cause delays.There is a hierarchy of planning applications, and we want to ensure that applications are dealt with at the appropriate level, so that the process does not become burdensome for committees or reporters. Whoever looks at applications must have the time and space to deal with those that it is most appropriate for them to deal with.10:45
You asked about wind turbines and the effect that they have on aeroplanes and radar. We must have a degree of comfort that turbines will not interfere with aeroplanes, airports and all the technologies that go with them, so I would imagine that that is an issue that is looked at continually. If there is a specific concern in your local area that has not been resolved, we could get back to you and liaise with you on that, if you would find that helpful.As far as meaningful engagement with the public in the planning system is concerned, the changes that were made to the planning system were designed to front-load the consultation and engagement process, so that it took place at the very start of the application process. Regardless of the fact that I have been charged with ministerial responsibility for planning, I am acutely aware in my capacity as an MSP that that engagement must be meaningful. I want to look at that closely to ensure that people feel that they have a voice in the planning system and know when they can have a say, and that their voice is heard and taken into account.
We are always willing to learn lessons from small countries in Europe. I am not aware of the particular situation that you mention, but I am certainly not ruling out learning lessons from it.
Mr Stewart raises good points, and I am willing to get back to him with more detail. I reiterate that I am happy to learn lessons from others who are managing effectively the interaction of onshore and offshore wind farms with aviation authorities.
Christie will report at the end of this month. We will look closely at what the commission recommends and any conclusions that it draws from its thorough investigations of public service reform. The Government is yet to present its legislative programme, so I am unable at the moment to give a firm indication of its plans for social care. However, anything that impinges on the issue will come to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee as the lead committee. We will need to look at the outcomes-based approach in the light of the Christie commission’s report, to see whether there is a need to strengthen the general provisions for the role of local authorities and the infrastructure of delivery.Responses to the consultation on the police were published yesterday. There was a clear indication of a willingness to look at how policing is delivered in our communities. COSLA is very much part of that discussion. If there are any firmer developments, I can liaise with the committee to make it aware of changes or differences that are made in light of the consultation responses.
I understand that the committee will probably be working on an away day. If you need any additional support over the summer months, by all means get in contact with me. We will assist in any way that we can, if you would like to take up that offer.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Jun 2011 →- 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 69
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:00 Reporter (European Union) Committee business · 4
- 10:00 Budget Adviser Committee business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.