Agenda item 4 is slightly more extensive. Our approach to developing a work programme is an important part of our early thinking and will extend over more than just this meeting. I refer members to the note from the clerk and to the legacy papers from the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee and Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee.Although it is not my intention at this meeting to have a detailed discussion on our forward work programme, it would be helpful if members would flag up ideas for future areas of work. I have a few ideas, which I will raise during the discussion. It will allow the clerks and the Scottish Parliament information centre to prepare further information on those topics for full discussion in the future.It is our job to scrutinise the work of Government in a huge slice of Scottish life: social, economic and environmental aspects. Obviously, the effects of European Union and world issues impinge considerably on our detailed business. Therefore we have an extremely wide remit, which means that we will have to prioritise. However, we should find out what members’ ideas are now, and in due course consider how to prioritise and to devise methods of working.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Rob Gibson only · show everyone- Rob Gibson SNP 20
- Alex Fergusson Con 9
- Simon Watkins Clerk 5
- Elaine Murray Lab 4
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 3
- Jim Hume LD 3
- Aileen McLeod SNP 3
- Mark McDonald SNP 1
- Jenny Marra Lab 1
- Graeme Dey SNP 1
Rob Gibson’s contributions
20 contributionsI offer Mark McDonald a chance to speak because he may have to leave us slightly early.
Indeed. Thank you very much. We have such a wide remit that we will have to spend a little bit of time working out how we should decide what is most urgent. I will take some of what members have said as a start.We have to see the CAP proposals before we can look at them in detail. We cannot second-guess what will happen, but two of our members—Aileen McLeod and Annabelle Ewing—are on the European and External Relations Committee, so we can link up with that committee’s thinking.That leads me to the point about the need to work with others. Jenny Marra mentioned biomass and the environment, and we need to explore how we can work with the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee to discuss those issues. I agree that there should be more collaborative working with other committees whenever we can, especially at this early stage when we do not have legislation to deal with immediately.The CAP will come along a little later in our timetable, but there are proposals on the CFP for July, so we have a timetabling issue with that. Because it is such a wide issue, the committee will want to have formed its view well before December, as Elaine Murray suggested. Other issues have been highlighted by the major campaign on discards. The Rural Affairs and Environment Committee’s legacy paper suggested that the committee should look at the views of fish processors, as opposed to catchers, for a change.There are different ways of dealing with those issues, but I suggest that we think about the possibilities. In a minute or two, I will let members back in to have a bit of a discussion; first, I will reflect on some of the comments that have jumped out at me.I will stick with immediate agricultural issues, because, as I said, the CAP will come up in due course. The issue of food production versus forestry definitely looms in each part of the country. During the election, I was tasked by a lot of tenant farmers in Sutherland to deal with that issue—I suspect that we all heard about it. The sheep tagging question is also pretty urgent. We might want first to dig into the reasons why it has come up as it has, and then look at the implications. It is very much an on-going matter—it is in the press today. With regard to the CFP, the discards issue is quite high profile: there is an excellent article about it in the current issue of Holyrood magazine, and I think that we should examine the matter closely. That again flags up the issue of our EU representation: the Scots members of the European Parliament have often worked together on these matters to try to get the best deal, and we want to be well abreast of the situation.There are also issues relating to inshore fisheries development and the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010, which applies in every part of the country. We can take some more comments from Elaine Murray on that, as she went through the Marine (Scotland) Bill process. We need to get up to speed with how inshore fisheries have been set up and how the regional and area management provisions in the 2010 act are beginning to impinge on each area. There are issues in my part of the world that relate to the need for better management. The area around Loch Torridon and Gairloch is one example, but we might also want to mention other areas such as the Solway Firth.Somebody mentioned land reform; there is a series of such issues in the legacy papers that relate to post-legislative scrutiny. The tenant and landlord situation needs to be examined—the committee must consider how we can tackle such a big subject properly. We also need to examine the very current issue of the Crown Estate Commissioners and that body’s impact on Scotland’s land and seas.As Mark McDonald said, rural development is a much wider issue. Community assets—the way in which we use the land and the potential wealth from energy creation and so on—will, I believe, be the subject of a Government bill, so we may want to examine the issue in more detail.Broadband and mobile coverage is an issue that affects us all and is close to everyone’s heart. Even when I travel through Fife on the train it becomes utterly annoying to go through blank spot after blank spot, but that is nothing in comparison with what happens when one travels further north. That flags up the need for us to know—and to let the public know—exactly where broadband and mobile coverage is. We need to map that and see where the blanks are, and then confront the bodies that are responsible for supposedly providing a service.Climate change is bound to loom regularly in our activities. As a member of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee in the previous session, and from dealing with the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009, I know that proposals and policies are produced annually. There are adaptation strategies, and a land use strategy that relates to the biodiversity provisions in the 2009 act, some of which were amended by members from all sides of the chamber.The 2009 act will throw up pressing issues to do with flooding, coastal erosion and landslips. Such things will affect people more as we experience more extreme climate change, so we need to consider them, especially as a raft of secondary legislation will come through regularly.Crofting and aquaculture are yet further issues—I could go on, but members have raised a series of issues that we need to prioritise and we must work out a way of dealing with those, although we cannot do so today. We have the opportunity to ask questions of the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment and the Minister for Environment and Climate Change at committee next week, if we so choose; I think that the cabinet secretary has to be in Europe the following week. That would be our first chance to raise these matters, and to focus on issues on which we would like answers. We can use the legacy papers to inform some of those questions, and add the issues that we think are important. We should crystallise that information by having SPICe come along beforehand to give us an overview. We have been sent papers, but it is always good to have people speak about these matters, recognising that they will help us to focus. If we are going to do that, we will have to agree that in a little while.We must also consider the potential for having a business planning day, whether we want to hold it externally, what form it might take and so on. Quite a bit of preparation must take place.Do committee members want to come back on any of those issues or on the process?10:30
We had better get used to it.
I will discuss the matter with the clerks and we can come up with some suggestions for the next meeting about a business planning day. There are reasons why we should not meet on the grass outside just because this is a rural committee; we should be out on the wider grass further afield. Such events can include a public-facing part. If we have a large amount of work to do, however, we will need to think about that carefully.On the wider matter of dealing with the European dimension, under the pilot scheme that was started in the previous session—rather too late to be effective—a member of each of the subject committees was identified to deal with the European and External Relations Committee, so that such liaison would take place. It will be interesting to hear what the convener of the European and External Relations Committee says about carrying on that pilot and how the liaison will work with each of the different committees, but it is vital for us to know about that early on. Although I will take the committee’s advice, I suggest that we ask the European and External Relations Committee to give us a briefing on that at an early stage so that we can be involved.
In that case, we have been round the houses for a start and I suspect that we will go round them quite a lot more. In order to make progress, we therefore have to make certain decisions. The committee is asked to agree that we meet on 22 June to take evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment and, I suggest, the Minister for Environment and Climate Change.
Okay, but we can always ask.That is the first proposal. Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.
We would hold a short informal briefing with SPICe before the cabinet secretary gives evidence to the committee, because he can come only at a certain time. I have forgotten what that time is.
The briefing will be at half past 10, and the cabinet secretary will give evidence after that.
Okay, so we can meet at—
That is slightly earlier—I hope that that is not an inconvenience to people.Do we agree to that?Members indicated agreement.
We agreed to hold a business planning day—perhaps an external one. However, bearing in mind what members have said, we will have a look at the matter with the clerks. It will certainly be held in the summer recess; I suggest that it should be held towards the end of August.
We can take that suggestion on board. We need to collaborate with all the different Parliaments and their representatives. The business planning day might be a good place to have an off-the-record discussion about that, since it is an internal meeting. Thank you for that suggestion.I suggest the last Monday in August as a possible date, but we will need to find a date that is suitable for everybody—that is the trouble.
What about the Wednesday?
Wednesday, 31 August.We will have to get a list of when members are available in August. We can do that immediately after the meeting. I ask members to tell the clerks when they are available and we can see whether we can find a suitable date. As far as I am concerned, the later in August, the better.
That is true, but you are making the assumption that we would hold the meeting in the Parliament.Let us see if we can get some dates together. That will probably prove quite difficult, but we can perhaps deal with the matter after the meeting.We also have to discuss and agree a work programme at the business planning day. We will give the clerks time to prepare some ideas for us before then so that we can agree what steps to take when we return in September and take up our duties on a weekly basis. As members can see, it will be necessary for us to meet weekly.Are we agreed on that?Members indicated agreement.
Are there any other matters that need to be decided now?
It is only a proposal.
It is important that we take on as much information and as many ideas as we can so that we can distil them and make decisions, but we are not making decisions now. We are making proposals, but the decisions that we have made are about the process that we will follow to reach decisions later on.
We will stick with the Scottish version of his name. I think that he has agreed to attend committee meetings. If we so choose, we can ask him to brief us as we see fit.As members have no other points, that completes today’s business. The committee’s next meeting will be on 22 June. Thank you for attending.Meeting closed at 10:46.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Jun 2011 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 14
- 10:00 Convener Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 4
- 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 50
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.