Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 16 June 2011 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00047)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Immediately after First Minister’s questions I, in conjunction with the Opposition party leaders, will be meeting some of Scotland’s unpaid carers, who are in the Parliament to mark carers week. I am sure that the whole chamber will join me in expressing our thanks to Scotland’s unpaid carers. Today, the carers are visitors to the Parliament, but I hope that they will soon be here on a more formal basis, as we take forward our proposal for a carers parliament to ensure that the views and needs of Scotland’s carers properly inform the work that we undertake in government and in the chamber. [Applause.]

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Yesterday, we saw another attack by the First Minister on one of Scotland’s most senior judges. The political editor of The Times commented on Twitter:

“Going by Salmond attack on Lord Hope, the First Minister has finally lost the plot.”

Well, has he?

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

That of course was one of the milder comments that followed on from the First Minister’s comments in his Holyrood magazine interview. At the very least, the First Minister is in danger, if not of losing the plot, then of losing any argument that he might have by prosecuting it in that way. This morning, Jim Sillars, the former deputy leader of the Scottish National Party, called the First Minister’s remarks “undignified”, “foolish” and “juvenile”. In the remarks that the First Minister aimed at Lord Hope, he said:

“At least I went to the bother of getting elected.”

That is true, but those crass personal attacks demean the office to which he was elected. Will he retract them?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I conducted the interview with Holyrood magazine two weeks ago, when we were engaged in a vigorous debate on these matters. Since then, I have appointed a panel of people of eminence and expertise under Lord McCluskey to advise the Parliament. Their views will then be debated in the Parliament so that we can address the underlying issue. That is how we should proceed, and I look forward to the McCluskey report.

When Iain Gray asked that earlier question, it struck me that there was something about this losing the plot business. Just by happenchance—I had no prior knowledge of Iain Gray’s question—I came across a quote in The Guardian of 15 May 2003 from David Blunkett, the Labour Home Secretary at the time. The report said:

“David Blunkett’s spat with the judges over their sentencing powers plumbed new depths yesterday when he accused a ... high court judge of not living in the real world and the leader of Britain’s barristers of ‘losing the plot’.”

We all have the right of fair comment. I am interested that Iain Gray’s memory of his colleagues in London and the various political ramifications of judicial decisions is not so perfect, if he repeats their language but does not remember the case.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

My view that the remarks were inappropriate is not one that I alone hold. We have seen comments that the First Minister’s statements were crude, ignorant and embarrassing. That is not my judgment; it is the judgment of commentators and the legal establishment. It is no answer for the First Minister of Scotland to say, “This is something I said two weeks ago when I was in a bad mood.” The truth is that the issue has spiralled out of control. It started with the usual constitutional grandstanding and led to gratuitous attacks on judges, courts, lawyers and even newspapers that dared to question the First Minister. That has brought us to an extraordinary joint statement from the Faculty of Advocates and the Law Society of Scotland, which described the situation as

“a challenge not only to the courts but to the rule of law.”

The First Minister is now taking the advice of the editor of The Scotsman to “Calm down, Alex, dear”, but he must also grow up, own up and apologise so that the debate can move on and be conducted in the way that it should have been from the word go. Will he apologise?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

No, I will go forward—as I think the Parliament should go forward—on the basis of looking at the expert views of Lord McCluskey and his panel. There has been a general welcome for that approach. Let the Parliament debate those views and get to the underlying issue. Iain Gray cites in his favour a range of figures, so I will cite figures who have spoken out and said that there is an issue of concern that must be addressed. They include Paul McBride QC, an adviser, at one stage at least, to the Conservative Party; Ian Smart, former president of the Law Society of Scotland and a founder of Scottish Labour Action; and Lord Fraser of Carmyllie, who said that Alex Salmond is “spot-on.” There is also Elish Angiolini, the former Lord Advocate, and the Scottish judiciary in their submission to the Advocate General for Scotland’s review of devolution issues.

There is an issue that requires to be addressed. The interaction of the judiciary and parliamentary comment is of course age old. The independence of the judiciary is guaranteed in the legislation that we passed in the Parliament in 2008. However, it is not just about a right of free speech, which everyone in this debate should have—including Lord Hope, who exercised his. I have made no complaint about that, just as I make no complaint about the right of anyone to exercise their right of free speech. However, when you are First Minister of Scotland, or for that matter an Opposition leader, you have to address matters of key public concern.

The integrity of the criminal law of Scotland is a matter of public concern. It was never meant to be second-guessed in the way that is happening at present. It is an issue of public concern that compensation payments are paid to criminals in Scotland under a liability that does not exist in any other jurisdiction. Those are points of public concern. As well as a right of free speech, we have a duty as parliamentarians to articulate the public concerns and try to bring proper remedy.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

The First Minister cites some important principles that underpin our democracy. The problem is that his public statements to the press and otherwise undercut those principles, and that is what his critics are saying to him.

Let us examine some of those fundamental principles. The First Minister attacked a lawyer for representing people because they are vile. His justice secretary threatened to cut off funding from a court because he did not like its judgments. I do not like some of its judgments either, but vile people having rights is the price that we pay for us all to have those rights. Vile people being properly defended in court is the price that we pay for our right to be defended too. Yes, we make the laws, but the independence of the judiciary is the price that we pay for the freedom to do that. Does the First Minister agree? Will he retract his statements, which undermine those principles of the Parliament?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

It was this Administration that underpinned our commitment to the independence of the judiciary in statute, through the Judiciary and Courts (Scotland) Act 2008.

I am afraid that Iain Gray misrepresents the issue in the Somerville case. The issue was not one of human rights in respect of what the Scottish courts laid down when they said that people had a human right to proper sanitation in the Scottish prison estate. It was that the Somerville judgment extended the liability for that not by one year, which would have been the same as in every jurisdiction in Europe, but back to 1999.

We could take the view that the people responsible for that potential liability were the people who were in office in 2001-02: Lord Wallace, who was the justice secretary in this Parliament, and Iain Gray, who was the deputy justice secretary. We might say that they should have had the foresight to ensure that sanitation was proper. Alternatively, we might say that the issue was not the fact that the Scottish courts directed the correction in that situation, which was done, but whether our liability as citizens should extend back to 1999, which offered a potential legal bill of £50 million or, according to one estimate, £100 million.

That is an issue of huge public concern. It is not, as Iain Gray represents it, about whether everybody should have human rights. It is about whether this Parliament, this jurisdiction and this legal system stand in equality with every other jurisdiction in western Europe. If Iain Gray is going to stand on the argument that, regardless of the bill of liability to honest, decent, law-abiding people, we should respect it back to 1999 and make compensation payments to the vilest members of society on that basis, I think that he will stand in a very lonely position indeed.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Business Motion Business motions · 2
  2. Taking Scotland Forward: Education and Lifelong Learning Debate · 61
  3. Fuel Poverty (Impact of Price Increases) Questions · 4
  4. Commuter Rail Services (Fife) Questions · 6
  5. A77 (Improvements) Questions · 7
  6. Severe Winter Weather (Damage to Roads) Questions · 6
  7. Early Years Framework Questions · 6
  8. Social Housing (Rural Communities) Questions · 6
  9. Asylum Seekers (Education) Questions · 4
  10. Civil Law (Representation) Questions · 4
  11. Social Care and Social Work Improvement Scotland (Budget and Staffing) Questions · 4
  12. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  14. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Oil and Gas Industries First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. Fuel Poverty Budget First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Global Entrepreneurship Monitor First Minister’s Questions · 4
  18. Onshore Wind Farms (Guidelines for Local Authorities) Questions · 6
  19. Living Wage (Public Sector Staff) Questions · 4
  20. Arm’s-length Organisations (Paid Directorships) Questions · 4
  21. Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth Directorates (Accountability and Transparency) Questions · 6
  22. Tourism (Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) Questions · 4
  23. Crichton Campus (Jobs and Economic Benefits) Questions · 8
  24. Living Wage (Local Authority Staff) Questions · 4
  25. Local Government Finance Formula Questions · 8
  26. Planning Regulations (Green Belt Land) Questions · 4
  27. School Building Programme (Costs) Questions · 4
  28. Mass Waste Incinerators Questions · 8
  29. Public Contracts (Small Companies) Questions · 4
  30. Meetings (Skills Development Scotland) Questions · 4
  31. Council Tax Freeze (Charges for Council Services) Questions · 4
  32. Microgeneration (Support) Questions · 6
  33. Scottish Broadcasting and the Scottish Digital Network Debate · 72
  34. Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Motion Debate · 2
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 8
  36. North Sea Taxation Members’ business · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.