I would like to comment on SSI 2011/89. Paragraph 2 of the Executive note on the regulations states, under the heading “Policy Objective”:“A reform of the Blue Badge Scheme in Scotland is necessary to reflect the significant social changes that have taken place over the past 40 years”.The document is therefore quite significant, and I find it surprising that there is no equality impact assessment, for example. I would have thought that changing something that has been around for 40 years is a major thing to do.Paragraph 4 of the business and regulatory impact assessment says:“We wish to ensure that all applications”for blue badges“should be assessed in the same way in order that the process is consistent”,and Department for Work and Pensions definitions are referred to. The people involved would be eligible for the higher rate of disability living allowance, for example. The focus is on applicants who are “unable to walk” or are “virtually unable to walk”.Over the page, the note deals with the public consultation, which involved questionnaires. I have a copy of one of the questionnaires with me. Question 2.3 in it says:“Do you agree that we should extend eligibility to those with severe forms of autistic spectrum disorder and very advanced forms of dementia?”I know that some people are concerned about the language there, especially in relation to autism, but that is not my point. My point is that those who responded to the consultation agreed by a majority of two to one that the focus should very much be on eligibility based on “inability to walk” or “virtual inability to walk”. However, questionnaires such as the one to which I referred raise expectations among some people with autistic spectrum disorder who are perfectly able to walk from a physical point of view but may not, for reasons to do with their complex needs, be able to make a consistent transition to other means of transport.17:00
My concern is that the consultation gave rise to the impression that the eligibility criteria may indeed include people who are not physically disabled per se, but have other complex needs. However, paragraph 13 of the Executive note indicates that the majority of responses agreed that the focus should be on “inability to walk” or “virtual inability to walk”, which are the DWP criteria and which I think was the real intention in the first place.I do not think that this was a model consultation. It is too late for me to move a motion to annul, but I know that my comments are now on the record. It is up to colleagues to decide whether the committee should add a rider or whatever to those comments.The consultation was a major piece of work that was, on the face of it, extensive, but there should not just be, in effect, a show of hands for criteria such as those I have described. In this case, that means that by a majority of two to one people with an interest in physical disability have, in effect, outvoted people who responded in good faith to the possibility that some people with autism, for example, might be able to access a blue badge. I think that I have made my point.