Agenda item 4 is to take evidence on the draft Antisocial Behaviour Notices (Houses Used for Holiday Purposes) (Scotland) Order 2011. I welcome the witnesses who are with us this morning. Alex Neil, the Minister for Housing and Communities, is accompanied by Peter Reid, senior policy officer in housing markets and supply in the Scottish Government, and Colin Brown, senior principal legal officer in the Scottish Government. Does the minister want to make opening remarks?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Antisocial Behaviour Notices (Houses Used for Holiday Purposes) (Scotland) Order 2011 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Neil SNP 3
- Duncan McNeil Lab 2
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
- Jim Tolson LD 1
- Sarah Boyack Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsYes please, convener. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to the committee about the draft order.Through the work of Mr Stanley Player in lodging his public petition, and the work of others, the Government has been made well aware of concerns about persistent antisocial behaviour associated with party flats that are let out for events such as stag parties and hen parties. We therefore welcomed the suggestion from Sarah Boyack, Shirley-Anne Somerville, the City of Edinburgh Council and others to clarify and improve the application of antisocial behaviour notices in relation to short-term lets, thereby allowing local authorities to take action against landlords of holiday flats that have a series of antisocial tenants. Officials from the Scottish Government and the City of Edinburgh Council have worked together to improve the legislation so that it can better meet the needs of our communities.The order creates an additional set of criteria under which a local authority can issue an antisocial behaviour notice. The property must have been used for holiday purposes on at least two occasions and antisocial behaviour must have been engaged in by a user or visitor during at least two of those occasions.The antisocial behaviour notice can set out actions that the landlord must take to prevent future antisocial behaviour. Those actions could include: first, limits on the number of people who can be in the property at any one time; secondly, requiring some form of on-site supervision, or at least a person to whom complaints can be directed and who is able effectively to address them; and, thirdly, requiring improvements to the security of the premises.If the landlord fails to comply with the antisocial behaviour notice, various remedies are available to the local authority. First, it may apply to a sheriff for an order so that no rent is payable. Secondly, it may apply to a sheriff for a management control order for the premises. Thirdly, it may take such steps as it considers necessary to deal with antisocial behaviour, with the landlord being liable for any expenses incurred. Finally, failure to comply is an offence, with a fine of up to level 5 on the current scale, which is £5,000. Although we expect that that will allow the local authority to tackle persistent antisocial behaviour from party flats, we do not expect it to impose a burden on the vast majority of reputable owners of tourist accommodation that is not associated with antisocial behaviour.I welcome any questions from the committee and I will move the motion later.
My question may seem like a trivial one, but it still interests me. What is the likely timescale for having this series of actions carried out? The reason I ask is to establish whether such notices can be used to deal with a specific problem or whether we are talking about accommodation that has a record of being a problem, so we cannot deal with a specific case through the measures outlined in the order.11:30
If it was only a one-off case of antisocial behaviour, it would be dealt with under the normal antisocial behaviour laws. The order applies where there is a record of antisocial behaviour emanating from one—or more than one—flat.The problem is that if the antisocial behaviour is committed by a visitor who is in Edinburgh only for a weekend stay, it is often difficult for the police to identify the culprit and take the necessary action to deal with them before they leave the city.The pattern has been that a few flats in certain areas, particularly—although not exclusively—in Edinburgh, are consistently being reported to the police and the local authority because of on-going antisocial behaviour. It takes place almost every weekend in some cases, and sometimes for longer periods, but it is caused by different people who are visiting. Those flats are let out for the specific purpose of partying, which gets a bit excessive.
It sounds like an interesting and—one hopes—worthwhile change in the legislation, but I worry about how we deal with the potential consequences and the excuses that one will hear from some tenants as to why there has been antisocial behaviour.I am thinking in particular of an instance in which an issue is raised with a tenant and they claim that a third party—what you or I, or any other party-goer, might call a gatecrasher—has caused the antisocial behaviour. How do we deal with situations like that, where it is difficult to find out who is responsible? Is it right that we charge the landlord in that case when they have had no control over the third party coming in to their property?
In a sense, the situation will be no different from the general application of antisocial behaviour legislation. The local authority and/or the police always have to investigate to establish who the culprit is, and take appropriate action.Sometimes it is not always clear who the culprit is, and it can therefore be more difficult to take action. That is the case at present, and there will no doubt be instances under this order in which it might be difficult to pin-point exactly who the culprits are. The point is that if the landlord continually allows that to happen, he becomes the culprit under this legislation. He will be dealt with, as it is his responsibility to ensure that his flat is not consistently used for antisocial behaviour.
I thank the convener for letting me contribute to the discussion.I am really pleased that we have got to this point. The current position means that my constituents’ lives are disrupted on a regular basis—as the minister said, such antisocial behaviour is a weekly occurrence for people who have the misfortune to live anywhere near one of these party flats.The current system does not enable effective action to be taken. It has become a football that is passed between the antisocial behaviour team, the noise team and the police, none of whom have the powers to tackle the issue properly. I very strongly welcome the order.The City of Edinburgh Council has made it clear to me that it does not have the power to act. From discussions with the council and the minister, it seems to me that the order potentially fills the gap in legislation. It is proportionate, as it should kick in only where there are demonstrable problems. The threshold of two reported instances is fair—they have to be reported, so action cannot be taken only on someone’s say-so.There are several flats in my constituency alone to which the order could make a real difference for residents in those areas. The landlords rent out their flats and earn a huge amount of money. They spend some money putting a lot of beds in the flats, so we could be talking about 15 or 20 people, who are all drunk and there for three days.That is massively disruptive not only within the flat, but in the vicinity, so I am pleased at the detail in the order in that regard. On-street disturbance is significant, and the vandalism that is caused to people’s cars and stairwells makes it a very expensive problem for local residents who have to clear up the mess afterwards.I also welcome the fact that the powers that are given to the council will give it a choice about how to proceed. It can prevent the flat from being used or it can require supervision, and it can force the landlord to be liable for expenses.The provisions will begin to concentrate the minds of landlords, because there will be a financial consequence. At present, their habit is to charge high deposits, but that only lines their pockets more, because the people who create problems go off and do not get their deposits back.On the internet, you can find a large number of people who have reported unhappiness about the situation. Even this week, several constituents have got in touch with me about party-flat problems. The problem has been going on for several years and is on-going. I hope that, if the order is approved by Parliament, it will send out a strong message to managers of party flats that the days of irresponsible lets are over. That should provide some respite for constituents who have weekly experienced distress, costly repairs and disruption to their lives.The order is proportionate and will target the right people, although I hope that the Scottish Government will keep the operation of the measure under review. The Government has done a good job, in consultation with the City of Edinburgh Council. If the committee agrees to recommend approval of the order, which I hope it will, the challenge will be in implementation.
I am sure that the minister welcomes those remarks, but I did not hear a question in there, so we may have pre-empted the debate. I hope that that will reduce the time that we spend on it.As there are no further questions, we move to agenda item 5, which is consideration of motion S3M-7287.Motion moved,That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the Antisocial Behaviour Notices (Houses Used for Holiday Purposes) (Scotland) Order 2011 be approved.—Alex Neil.Motion agreed to.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Mar 2011 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Local Electoral Administration (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 6
- 10:00 Electoral Management Committee business · 94
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:00 Annual Report Committee business · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.