Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Remedial) (Scotland) Order 2011 (SSI 2011/45)

Tuesday 1 March 2011 Justice Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 14 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
John Lamont Con The Convener · Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

The first instrument is SSI 2011/45. I draw members’ attention to the cover note, which is paper 2 of the committee papers.The Subordinate Legislation Committee was content with the order under its criteria, but has drawn it to the attention of the Justice Committee on the basis that this committee might wish to explore the power that amends the maximum notification periods. The power can both shorten and extend the maximum notification periods.I invite the cabinet secretary to make a short opening statement; I will then ask members whether they have any questions for him.

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

Thank you, convener.The order was made and laid before Parliament on 27 January, and it came into force on 28 January. It is an urgent order, as provided for under sections 12 and 14 of the Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland) Act 2001. As such, it came into force upon laying. I am here to ask the Scottish Parliament to approve it to ensure that it can remain in force.I will give some background and context. On 25 October 2010, I made the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Remedial) (Scotland) Order 2010 (SSI 2010/370). Again, that order had immediate effect. The 2010 order was the first of its kind in Scotland. It was introduced, as a matter of urgency, to address a United Kingdom Supreme Court judgment that ruled that requiring sex offenders to register indefinitely on the sex offenders register without the opportunity for review was incompatible with the European convention on human rights.The 2001 act procedures provide that, upon making the remedial order, the Scottish ministers must give appropriate public notice of the contents of the order and invite comments, which are to be made in writing within a period of 60 days. That consultation period ended on 23 December 2010. Members should have before them a copy of the consultation report that we published on 8 February, which provides a summary of the comments that were received, together with details of the resulting changes that we have made to the original 2010 order, which are incorporated into the 2011 order.Members should know that public safety has been our absolute priority. In recent years, we have improved the safeguards that have been in place—for example, we have improved the risk assessment of sex offenders and rolled out the successful community disclosure scheme. Our focus must be on enabling the police to manage offenders who pose a continuing risk of sexual harm. Accordingly, the review mechanism that is contained in the remedial order provides a number of significant safeguards and conditions. Those who receive a sentence of 30 months or more will still be put on the sex offenders register for life, and therefore indefinite registration for serious sex offenders will continue.In reviewing the extent to which the value of the notification system would be eroded by the introduction of such review procedures, the Supreme Court noted:“it is open to the legislature to impose an appropriately high threshold for review”.The order sets an appropriately high bar. Adult offenders will have to be on the sex offenders register for 15 years before they are considered for review. For young offenders, the period will be eight years. That will not include time spent in prison for the index offence. No offender will be automatically removed from the register when the review date is reached. The police will carry out a robust assessment of every offender who reaches the review date, and will take into account a comprehensive range of information, including any risk assessments that have been carried out as part of the multi-agency public protection arrangements, or MAPPA, process. A senior police officer will decide whether the offender should remain on the register, and offenders who pose a continuing risk of sexual harm to the public will remain on it. When offenders are kept on the register, the police or, on appeal, the court will set a timescale of up to 15 years for a further review. The offender will be able to appeal the police decision to a sheriff, and the sheriff’s decision to grant or refuse an appeal can be appealed to the sheriff principal, whose decision will be final.Members will no doubt have picked up on the fact that the UK Government also has to comply with the Supreme Court ruling. The Prime Minister, David Cameron, said that he was “appalled” by the ruling. I share his distaste for the measures, but regardless of how objectionable I feel they are, the Scotland Act 1998 places a specific duty on the Scottish ministers and the Scottish Parliament to act in accordance with convention rights. Therefore, I have been compelled to bring forward the order for members’ consideration in order to ensure that our legislation no longer contravenes the ECHR.The UK Government has followed our lead in opting for the 15-year and eight-year review periods and entrusting the decision to the police. The review process sits alongside a range of other measures that we have taken to strengthen the management of sex offenders in our communities. For example, registered sex offenders are already required to provide details of their bank accounts, credit cards and passports, and we will shortly be able to require sex offenders to comply with positive obligations as part of any sexual offences prevention order.I believe that Scotland’s review mechanism, which the police support, will ensure that public protection is the foremost consideration in meeting the requirements that ECHR places on us. We will continue to monitor all aspects of the remedial order and, if necessary, we will bring forward further measures to improve its operation. In that regard, we have also built in powers to amend the 15-year and eight-year review periods that are set out in the order. Such a flexible power is sensible because it will allow us to calibrate the review mechanism to recognise developments in policy, practice and evidence-based knowledge and understanding.I am sure that committee members will have questions and I am happy to answer them.

John Lamont Con The Convener · Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. Are there any questions?

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Cabinet secretary, you will be aware that the Subordinate Legislation Committee has drawn to the attention of the committee new section 88H of the Sexual Offences Act 2003, which allows the Government to vary the maximum notification periods. In your comments, you quoted the Supreme Court saying that it is open to the legislature to set the periods and that they should be set at a suitably high bar. I acknowledge that point, but what is your response to the Subordinate Legislation Committee?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I go back to my opening statement. We recognise that it is difficult to deal with sex offenders and that we have to monitor and review the situation. We have to see the information and analysis that come in, whether from our jurisdiction or elsewhere.It could be argued that the 15-year and eight-year review periods, which have been copied south of the border, are fairly arbitrary. Why are they not 16 years or 14 years, or six years or nine years? The periods were set after discussion with those who monitor and are involved in these matters, so the 15-year and eight-year review periods that are used north and south of the border are based on the best evidence that we have at present. If they do not work, or are too harsh or whatever, we or any other Administration can review them.We need to ensure that we do not fetter the hands of a future Administration or of those who work with a difficult minority of people. We need to give some flexibility so that change can be made if necessary.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

As the cabinet secretary rightly says, this is a difficult area. I am not all that sure about what his objection is to a right of review, particularly for young offenders who are convicted when they are under 18 and therefore before they are mature. What is his objection to a right of review, especially when it is accepted that a review could mean that the person would continue to be on the register?Is there any place for input into the decision-making process by victims?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

There is an on-going debate about the ECHR as it relates to these matters. We took the view that the system was working—fair enough. We accept the decision of the European Court of Human rights on the ECHR; we are obliged to follow it, and we have done so. There is a broader debate to be had about the rights and wrongs of such matters and how they impinge on us.There is no provision for victim input as such—we are not talking about a victim notification scheme such as the one that is used when someone is released or put on parole. However, we are happy to consider the issue. I would have thought that the police would consider the victim at the time of the review, because after 15 years or eight years, they would have to look at the likely danger posed by the individual concerned, whether there has been any on-going misbehaviour, the effect on the community, where the victim is, and so on.It is fair to say that the victim does not have any direct input into the review as such, but it clearly follows that the victim’s interests will be considered—initially by the police during the review and subsequently by sheriffs and sheriff principals in any appeal.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

I accept that the reviews will be dealt with using professional standards and protocols. However, will the cabinet secretary follow up my suggestion a little bit? It is a bit like the rights that have been given to victims in relation to parole hearings. Could the cabinet secretary and his officials consider introducing such rights as a more formal part of the process when they are looking at the exact arrangements that will come out of the remedial order?10:15

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I am more than happy to feed that suggestion back so that those who are working under the MAPPA process—especially the police—take it on board. In many cases, there might not be just one victim; there might be many victims, especially in cases that involve internet paedophile offences, for example, in which victims might be difficult to contact. When we are talking about a horrendous rape or something similar, we need to consider the interests of the victim and the community.Mr Kelly asked why we are seeking to build in a review. The answer is that we are continually working to improve public safety. Many offenders will not reoffend but, tragically, some do so with calamitous consequences. We have to make sure that we learn every day and take appropriate action. I will feed that suggestion back.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Going back to James Kelly’s point, I note that page 10 of the executive note says that section 88H means that the 15-year or eight-year period can be amended by affirmative order. Presumably such an order would come to the Justice Committee. Can the cabinet secretary confirm that? If so, using the same process for the order that we are considering is totally unobjectionable.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I ask you to say a wee bit more about a concern raised by the Law Society of Scotland, which responded to the consultation. The society is concerned about the chief constable doing the initial review. You said that the chief constable or a senior police officer would do that review and that there could be a subsequent appeal. Are you confident that that addresses the issues that the society raised in its response to the consultation? It questioned whether the order is compatible with articles 6 and 8 of the ECHR.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We are confident that the order is compatible with the ECHR. We would not have laid it if it was not compatible. We think that the police are best placed to make an initial decision on public safety because, ultimately, they have to deal with the regular monitoring and with the consequences of a review.The police operate within the broader MAPPA process, which takes on board everything from social work to housing, but the primary protection of the public comes from the police, which is why we think that the additional sift should be done by the police, taking into account information received from other agencies. A right of appeal to the sheriff and ultimately to the sheriff principal is built into the order. That approach covers ECHR challenges.

John Lamont Con The Convener · Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

As there are no further questions for the cabinet secretary, I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the officials to change over.10:18 Meeting suspended.

10:18 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Convener Procedure · 3
  3. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  6. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
  7. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  8. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  9. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
  10. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 55
  11. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  12. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  13. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  14. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  15. 10:00 Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 32

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.