PE1364, by Phyllis M McBain, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review all guidelines relating to Gypsy Traveller encampments.We have been joined by Alex Johnstone, who would like to speak to the petition.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Gypsy/Traveller Encampments (Guidance) (PE1364)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Rhona Brankin Lab 16
- Christine Grahame SNP 5
- Nigel Don SNP 4
- Bill Butler Lab 4
- Nanette Milne Con 3
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 2
- Fergus Cochrane Clerk 2
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
The record
37 contributionsI am grateful for the opportunity to say a few words and give you an update on the situation. I must, as ever, declare that, as a resident of Stonehaven, I have first-hand experience of some of the problems that have led to this petition. Stonehaven traditionally receives visitors from the travelling community—it is not uncommon to find them in the surrounding area in the summer. The visit of the travelling community has begun early this year. Since I last addressed the committee, there has been further agitation between the Traveller community and the settled community. I am disappointed that that has happened, but I should point out that it has not taken place to the serious extent that it might have. Specifically, there was an incident related to the creation of a Facebook site, which led ultimately, as these things do, to members of the public making some threatening remarks towards the Travellers. I am grateful that the Facebook site has now been removed and should not be a problem. In addition, a number of incidents, which I will not list at this stage, have brought about some public protest. 15:15
However, this morning, I attended a meeting of the Kincardine and Mearns area committee of Aberdeenshire Council, simply as a member of the public. I can report that community leaders and those within the community who are able to show leadership took a responsible view and the situation has not become inflamed as a result of some of the exchanges that took place in recent days.The council is looking for a solution, including the identification of a permanent Travellers site, and believes that it may be making progress on that. The Minister for Housing and Communities, Alex Neil, will meet representatives of the council on, I believe, Thursday. However, I am disappointed that it has taken so long to make any progress on the matter and that we are still merely hopeful that success is just around the corner.The Government and the council have worked hard to make what progress they have. It would be of great value if the Parliament were to take the issue on—ideally at committee level at this stage—and join the other agencies that are moving forward and seeking a solution to the problem.My sympathy has always been with council officers and police officers, who find themselves with an obvious problem to deal with and no means to deal with it legitimately. Those people require our support, and we need to ensure that the Parliament maintains a stake in the direction of travel on the issue. That is why I would like the Parliament to take the petition on and deal with the issues that it raises until we have a long-term solution for the travelling community and for the people who find it difficult to live close by them.
I thank Alex Johnstone for his update and his comments about the leadership within the settled community in Stonehaven, which I am delighted to hear. I am not surprised to hear them, but I am delighted, because one of the issues that emerges from the papers that are before us—if I can take us back to the petition, although it directly affects Stonehaven—is the need to establish contact with leadership within the travelling community. That is one of the issues that the Government and, indeed, our society need to address. It is relatively easy to find the leadership within the settled community; it is much more difficult to find leadership among those who travel.In passing, I note that the papers suggest that the Government still thinks that the term “occupational traveller” has a specific meaning. That is very much a side issue, but it is one that we need to address, because other people, including the police, feel that we could do without that term. It needs to be addressed, but it is at the perimeter of the issue.Everybody agrees that we need more authorised sites, because if there are good places for the Travellers to go, they are more likely to go there and the police can legally move them on. That is the nub of the matter. Everybody knows that, so we could argue that the petition has run its course. However, it seems to me and to the petitioner—to whom I am grateful for her comments; I notice that she is with us again today—that there is a community that has not yet been spoken to: the private landowners who could provide us with halting sites. There has not been enough discussion with them in the collective discussion to sort out the matter at a national and local level, although the council will have discussed it with them.We need to hold on to the petition. I am certainly against closing it at this stage. We need to find ways of establishing leadership within the travelling community and we also need to find ways of establishing a dialogue with landowners. That may be difficult for the committee to do—I can see the clerks frowning and thinking, “How do we handle this?” We have to be clever in how we work this through, but it is part of the national exploration of the issue.My only other point, to come back to the petitioner’s comments, is that her suggestion of a charter of conduct may be entirely appropriate. Travelling communities, by definition, travel. That is a very different form of social life and it would be helpful if it were clearly understood how they wanted to live and how others felt that they should live. Some kind of charter about how the settled and travelling communities work together in the modern age might be very useful, but it comes back to needing leadership within those communities.
The Government has established a working group on the issue, but if there is no representation from the travelling community on that group, is it too late for us to ask the Government to bring a member of the travelling community on to it? The Government says that it will bring forward a strategy by March 2011, so maybe we are a bit late to do that.
I will answer that question, because I am on the working group. As a point of fact, there is a representative from the travelling community, but we do not seem to have ready access to representatives of specific travelling clans—if I may I use that term kindly. Part of the problem is dealing with specific groups of Travellers, large and small—families, clans, describe them how you will. That is where our efforts are probably breaking down.
Is the petitioner included on the working group?
No. Perhaps that requires a little bit of explanation. The working group was designed by Alex Neil, the minister, to try to get the people who could make something happen quickly make it happen. It includes only three representatives—two MSPs and one councillor—to ensure that there is a public input. That is the nature of the forum.A forum that involved everybody would be very different, and probably would not achieve much very quickly, whereas the minister was determined to see what he could make happen quickly.
So the committee’s view is that, if we continue the petition and include it in our legacy work, we should at this stage seek responses from the Government to the points raised by the petitioner. In essence, its response will go forward to our successor committee.
We know that a week can be a long time in politics. By the time that Parliament reconvenes in May, I think that those two months will have proven to be a pretty long two months in the context of the issues that are before us. At that point, our successor committee and the Government will be several pages further on in the book and they will be able to reconsider where they have got to.
Is it agreed that the petition will be continued and put forward for legacy work?Members indicated agreement.Political Education (PE1368)
PE1368, by Rowena Carlton MSYP, on behalf of the Scottish Youth Parliament, is on political education for all. I ask for members’ views on how to deal with the petition.
My information—colleagues have the same information before them—is that the note of the meeting between the Scottish Government and the petitioner has only recently been received. The meeting took place on 24 February and I think that we received the note of the meeting in the past 24 hours. I do not think that there has been sufficient time for us properly to consider it, so I suggest that we defer consideration of the petition to the next, and indeed last, meeting of the Public Petitions Committee, on 8 March.
Is the committee happy to defer the petition to our next meeting?Members indicated agreement.Justice for Megrahi (PE1370)
PE1370, by Dr Jim Swire, Professor Robert Black QC, Mr Robert Forrester, Father Patrick Keegans and Mr Iain McKie, is on behalf of Justice for Megrahi. I ask for views and welcome Christine Grahame to the meeting. Christine, would you like to speak briefly to the committee before we take a view on the petition?
I have not seen whether the Government has responded to your letter so, if it is procedurally appropriate, I would like to hear what the committee has to say and see whether I can add to it. I have not had sight of any response from the Government, so I do not know where we are.
There is a response from 3 February, which I think is available on the Parliament’s website.
Forgive me for my incompetence on the website. I had a go at looking for a response but I could not find anything—I am sure that it is lurking somewhere on the website.I am happy to make a few comments.
If you would like to take a minute to look at the response, that would be fine.
Is it okay if I let the committee comment first? It will take me a bit of time to read the response.
I suggest that we take a five-minute comfort break, in all senses of that phrase.
I have my uses.
The always gallant Mr Butler has come to the rescue and suggested a five-minute comfort break. Is that agreed by the rest of the committee?Members indicated agreement.15:25 Meeting suspended.
15:31 On resuming—
In resuming this meeting of the Public Petitions Committee, I welcome a delegation from the German Bundestag. They are here for a short time to observe the committee’s work. We will also see you tomorrow. Welcome to the committee.We are currently considering PE1370, and we are going to hear a submission from Christine Grahame MSP.
Thank you, convener, and thank you for giving me time to read the correspondence. Whether they have the same view as me, everyone accepts that the al-Megrahi issue remains unresolved and to many people the situation is highly unsatisfactory.I have had the opportunity to read the correspondence. I am quite interested in the issue that the Lord Advocate raises. Quite rightly, we get the usual stuff about the position of the Lord Advocate and the Crown with regard to appeals: it is standard stuff. However, the final paragraph says:“The criminal investigation in respect of others responsible for this crime remains open and the position remains as stated to the Scottish Parliament by my predecessor”.However, I was curious to find out how many officers were assigned to continuing the investigation and following a freedom of information request several months ago was told that there is one. The Lord Advocate uses the words“The criminal investigation ... remains open”but when only one police officer is engaged on it, it is more like file management—if I may put it that bluntly—than a serious and funded investigation to find those who were responsible.We should remember that Mr al-Megrahi’s conviction relates to him being involved in placing a device within a suitcase. Even if he is guilty as convicted, there must have been others; that is known. My concern is that although only one police officer is assigned to the case, freedom of information is blocked because lots of information is unavailable if an investigation is on-going, which could be the case for decades. I draw that matter to the committee’s attention.I am also aware that the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has replied on the issue of the extra test under the Criminal Procedure (Legal Assistance, Detention and Appeals) (Scotland) Act 2010 to which I referred the committee, saying that it will be under some kind of review. I am still not satisfied that the Parliament has not somehow put another block in the path of this case and others in which the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission considers that there has been a miscarriage of justice by saying that it is somehow in the interest of justice for the case not to be referred. If there has been a miscarriage of justice, it follows that it is in the interest of justice that something be done about it. However, I note that the SCCRC test is under review.The First Minister also announced that he would, if re-elected, introduce primary legislation to deal with the issue of data from third parties pretty much preventing publication of the SCCRC report—they can refuse that.Given all that and, to some extent—I do not want to overegg the pudding—the flux in international politics with regard to Libya and, indeed, the position of al-Megrahi himself both within Libya and his physical state, I hope to persuade the committee to keep the petition open, allow the review group to report and see whether primary legislation is introduced after the election, if the First Minister is re-elected, or what any other incoming Administration might do. I also ask the committee to consider what happens way beyond these shores with regard to Mr al-Megrahi, Gaddafi and all the evidence. There are now so many conspiracy theories that it is time that we had a clear look at the role of Scottish justice in the case. The issue is not whether Libya or any other country was guilty; it is simply whether Abdelbaset al-Megrahi was rightly convicted, and we have not heard the answer to that yet.
I agree with Christine Grahame. Having read the petitioners’ response and the other responses and having listened to Christine Grahame, I think that there are too many unresolved issues for us simply to close the petition. Given current events, as Christine Grahame says, and with al-Megrahi close to death, it would be wrong of us to close the petition and forget all about it. I know that, because it calls on the Scottish Government to hold an inquiry and the Scottish Government has said no, that is technically the end of the petition. However, the petitioners make a number of suggestions, such as that the committee might hold an evidence session. Clearly, the present Public Petitions Committee cannot do that, but the suggestion could be included in our legacy paper or we could refer it to the Justice Committee, which might be a better option. I do not know whether we can do that at this stage in the session—Bill Butler is shaking his head. If not, I suggest that we include it in our legacy paper. I do not want to close the petition.
I shook my head, but that is simply my view. I do not know whether the convener can give us a formal view on whether the suggestion could be referred to the Justice Committee. Given the fact that dissolution is on 22 March, there will be no chance of the matter being taken up by the present Justice Committee—that is all that I meant. I apologise if I inadvertently shook my head.The two questions that we asked have been answered, although perhaps not satisfactorily. I would not be averse to suggesting in the legacy paper—it can only be a suggestion, as we cannot instruct—that our successor committee might wish to take the matter up. By that time, the review group will have reported. I think that that is all that we can do. There has been a response to the two questions that were suggested by Christine Grahame at our previous meeting, which I echoed.
Our difficulty is that the petition was specifically worded, but what the petitioners are asking for is a much broader look at the issues. Because of the wording of the petition, I am not sure that, under the standing orders, the matter could be taken forward or whether the petition would have to be resubmitted to a new committee with different wording.
Whether members consider that what is being asked falls within the petition’s parameters is very much a judgment call for them. Mr Butler is quite correct to point out that if the committee was minded to flag up the petition in the legacy paper for the session 4 committee it would be for the next committee to consider the action that it wanted to take. One option might be to refer the petition to the next justice committee and invite it to consider holding a specific inquiry on the issues that have been highlighted. As I say, it is a judgment call for members whether the responses that the committee has received adequately address the specific issue raised in the petition or whether they feel that certain issues that fall within its parameters should be pursued.
The petitioners refer to“two occasions on which erroneous information has been supplied to the Scottish Government ... in respect of our petition”and have said that the decision made in response to the petition not to have an inquiry was based on that information. I do not know whether or not it was erroneous but, to me, such comments mean that the petition remains open. The petitioners are asking us to say to the Scottish Government that the information was not correct and to ask it to look at it again, which I think falls within the original petition’s parameters.
The successor committee might well conclude that the present Scottish Government has responded and decide to close the petition on that basis, in which case the petitioners would have to resubmit a petition. On the other hand, as the clerk has suggested, the committee might decide that it would be appropriate to refer the petition to the justice committee. Who knows? We do not. All I and my colleague Anne McLaughlin are suggesting is that we do not bring the shutters down right now and that in our legacy paper we refer the petition to the successor committee, which will then have to decide whether it wishes to close it or whether there is some other avenue that can be explored. On that basis, convener, I suggest that we include it in our legacy paper.
Are other members happy with that suggestion?
Can we make a recommendation to the successor committee?
We can make a suggestion.
We could put that in writing.
Just to be helpful, for most petitions the legacy paper, which will come before the committee next week, will suggest to the successor committee the issues that it might want to pursue.
Do members agree to include the petition in our legacy paper?Members indicated agreement.
I thank Christine Grahame for attending.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Mar 2011 →- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 27
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 32
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 37
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.