Item 5 is external committee research. Members have received a paper from the clerk. As we enter the final year of the first session of our Parliament, members may consider this an appropriate time to take stock of what we have achieved. A useful start to such a process would be to compare ourselves with other audit committees internationally. The proposed research would enable us to do that. After three years of substantial and, I think, very successful work, it is time to take an objective look at our committee's practices and procedures within the UK, European and world auditing context, to ascertain ways in which we can further improve what we do.The aims are clear. We should assess the committee's progress, development and achievements so far. I hope that that will assist our successors in the next session and inform their work. Also, we should place the committee in its international auditing context by making a comparative study of the practices and procedures of equivalent committees in other Parliaments.Such a study would build on the contacts that we have already established with our UK and European counterparts. The proposal is for an external research project examining equivalent committees and legislatures, seeking out best practice and drawing together an overview of the work done by the Audit Committee in its first Parliament. That could be the basis of a seminar or other civic participation event with the wider community.
Official Report · Committee
External Research
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andrew Welsh SNP 5
- Keith Raffan LD 3
- David Davidson Con 1
The record
9 contributionsI am not opposed to the research proposal. However, I am concerned about the time scale. If we ask for research to be completed by the end of 2002, I am not sure how in-depth it will be. I am also concerned about the ambition to hold a seminar prior to dissolution, when many people's minds may be somewhat distracted and focused on other things. I like the idea of holding a seminar—more than a civic participation event—because it could be very useful for the committee. However, we might be trying to do too much too quickly.
I take your point, but I am told that the Scottish Parliament information centre can complete the research. We have to lay down a reasonably strict timetable to ensure that we can do the work. There is no point in starting something that we cannot finish. SPICe assures me that the time scale is reasonable.
Can I make a suggestion? I would prefer to allow the research to be given a little longer and for the seminar to be held in the new Parliament. There will be a time when things are rather thin in the early months of the new Parliament and it would be better to hold the seminar then, rather than rushing it now.
I can understand the desire not to rush the research, but I think that it can be done within the time scale. The expertise is in the committee. I hope that we can put some of our ideas on record. We are passing on information to the new Parliament, to inform and help our successors.
Looking forward, I have concerns that the total remit of the committee should be re-examined. Perhaps that could be dealt with as part of the research. We must consider what limits were put on the scope of various committees in other Parliaments. We do not have the privilege of auditing every penny on which the Parliament votes. It is important that we set in context whether it is feasible to consider alternative arrangements for the Audit Committee and whether its powers should be extended. That should be part of the research into how other Parliaments do things—if they do things differently, we should know why. That will provide something for the new Parliament to discuss.
I take your point. We insist on best value from those who appear before us and we must also insist on that best value from our own conduct. I seek a decision in principle that we consider the research in a more detailed paper, including a timetable, to be considered at our next meeting. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
That would delay the research further. It will be the end of the month before we get it going.
Your point has been taken, Mr Raffan. Festina lente. We shall receive the more detailed paper at the next meeting.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Sep 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Tuesday 3 September 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Items in Private Procedure · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 8
- “Review of the management of waiting lists in Scotland” Committee business · 11
- “Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01” Committee business · 5
- External Research Committee business · 9
- Parliamentary Audit Committees (Visits) Committee business · 5
- National Assembly for Wales (Meeting) Committee business · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.