Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Dairy Farmers (Human Rights) (PE1263)

Tuesday 8 February 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 39 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

PE1263, by Evelyn Mundell, on behalf of Ben Mundell, is on human rights for dairy farmers. Jamie McGrigor MSP is here.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am grateful for the opportunity to make a short statement in support of my constituents Mr and Mrs Mundell. I share their concerns and disappointment that the Scottish Government has failed to answer adequately the questions that the committee has put to it.The Scottish Government at least appears to have moved its position, as it now recognises that human rights issues were involved in the original decision to continue the ring fence in the southern isles. If that is the case, my constituents deserve to see the detail of that consideration.The Scottish Government has also recognised, most notably in the example of the removal of the ring fence for Islay, which is just up the road—or over the sea, so to speak—that the ability to sell quota on the open market realises income that can be used to support existing businesses or diversification into other areas.Why was it considered appropriate to deny the rights that the people in Islay received to Mr and Mrs Mundell and other dairy farmers in the southern isles ring fence? That question has never been answered.My view remains that retaining the southern isles ring fence negatively and disproportionately affects the individuals concerned. It is disproportionate to the extent that it seems to have been considered acceptable for my constituents to bankrupt themselves to support the wider community. I struggle to find other examples of the Government, through its direct actions, forcing individuals or businesses to make serious financial sacrifices for the greater good of an area or sector—at least not in peacetime.I note that the committee has not asked the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment to give oral evidence. Will it consider that option? I hope that the committee will at least keep the petition open as a way of continuing to seek substantive answers from the Government. The saga has caused genuine worry and potential financial ruin for my constituents. In the interests of justice and fairness, the committee should continue to pursue the matter on behalf of my constituents, whom I quote:“As the PPC previously quoted from the Human Rights Commission in one of its previous questions to Government:—‘a fair balance will not have been struck where the individual property owner is made to bear “an individual and excessive burden”.’”

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Jamie McGrigor makes fair points. I am trying to think where we can go from here, given that we have just one meeting left. Could we recommend in our legacy paper that the future committee should invite the cabinet secretary along? I am not sure where we stand on that—perhaps the clerk can help.

Fergus Cochrane
link

If the committee decides to make that suggestion, it can be part of the legacy arrangements for the session 4 committee, which might want to consider inviting the cabinet secretary to give evidence. It would be up to that committee to decide what action—if any—it took on the petition. Procedurally, the committee could leave the petition under the legacy arrangements.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

If we kept the petition open and wanted to invite the cabinet secretary along, the only alternative would be to invite him to our next meeting. Given diary commitments, his attendance might not be feasible.

Fergus Cochrane
link

After today, the committee has three meetings—on 22 February and on 1 and 8 March. If the committee wanted to invite the cabinet secretary to give evidence, we could check his availability and timetable in his evidence.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We have not clarified the human rights issue and whether the Government had advice on that.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I was going to make that point. The additional correspondence that we received today—the communication between Peter Peacock and Mr and Mrs Mundell—asks whether ministers ever received legal advice on the human rights issue. I am sure that I read in the papers that qualified officials were conversant with the matter. I suggest that we clarify whether ministers received such advice and, if so, that we ask them to share it with us. They would be unlikely to share all the information with us, but whether they sought advice would be useful to know before we decide what to do with the petition.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

A question of timing might be involved. Do you suggest that we should obtain a further response before deciding whether to invite the minister, or do you think that the actions are not mutually exclusive?

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

If we invited the minister to give evidence, he would know that we wanted to ask him the legal advice question, so he should be conversant with the issue and have an answer.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I agree with both my colleagues. We can continue the petition by making a suggestion to our successor committee, but we should also have the minister in front of the committee to ask him one or two pertinent questions, if the timetable allows for that. That is only fair.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I notice that we are putting off many things until 8 March. Is it being suggested that we should leave the matter for a legacy paper and also bring in the minister for an evidence session during one of our final two meetings?

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I think that it has been suggested that we should ask the minister to come along to the committee and attempt to clarify some matters. There may or may not be a resolution that the committee can progress; we do not know whether there is. I think that the suggestion is that we should try to clarify whether there is any other information that we can elicit that would help to make the position clear for the petitioners. If we thought that there was nothing further that the committee could do at that stage, I presume that we would have to decide whether to close the petition. The issue might be for the courts rather than the committee—I do not know—but we would have to decide at that juncture whether to close the petition or whether we thought that a future committee would be able to do something further.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Okay, but given that we do not have much time, could we not just write to the minister and get clarification rather than bring him in? With the best will in the world, when we bring people in—particularly politicians—the consideration tends to last much longer than it needs to, as everybody wants to ask them questions and people like to repeat themselves. Would not it be better just to write to the minister and ask for a response before our final meeting?

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I am in the hands of the committee.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Heaven forfend that a politician should be accused of being verbose.We could write to the minister, but we could also have him live in front of us, if we can fit that in. The one good thing about a live questioning session is that other questions suggest themselves as it proceeds. That facility exists in such a session, but not with a letter. If the minister cannot make it along and the timetable does not allow for that, that is the way it goes, but if he can make it along and the timetable allows for it, we can take both approaches.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I agree with most members that we need to pursue the matter further, but I respectfully suggest that, if the petition is to be included in our legacy paper for the committee in the fourth session, rather than asking the minister to give evidence to this committee prior to dissolution, it may be better for the new committee to interrogate the minister on the issues that this committee has identified. We would get one opportunity to interrogate the minister before the Parliament dissolves. A new committee will be formed after 5 May, and I would prefer it to pick up on the work that has been done on the petition and to have the opportunity to interrogate whoever the minister is on the advice that was given to the Government when decisions were made on the issue. If we interrogate the minister, we will get some responses, but the question is how we can then fit things into a legacy paper and allow the new committee to take the petition forward.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I think that the intention was that bringing the minister to the committee might mean that we would not have to include the petition in a legacy paper. It seems to me that the petition is one of those in respect of which there may or may not be a resolution. At the moment, we are trying to get the clarification that we have not yet been able to get, specifically on human rights issues. However, as I have said, I am in the hands of the committee.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I will make two points.First, I am not quite sure how we can bottom out the human rights issues. I am not at all convinced that a minister will be able to come along to a meeting of the committee and say something that decisively answers the question. Obviously, the minister will have had advice, but I do not know whether they would be able to say how good that advice was and whether it was correct; I do not know whether they could say anything other than simply, “Well, that’s the advice we’ve had.”Secondly, I am not sure that I even have some of the basic facts, such as the number of farmers affected. Forgive me if that is a memory lapse. Jamie McGrigor rightly made the point that, in a sense, it depends on how many people have been messed around and whether the approach has been proportionate or appropriate.I am not sure that I have got those numbers in my head; I am not sure that I have even seen them. Whatever policy answer we might get on human rights, it must be underpinned by the numbers. That all has to be put together if we are going to get anywhere near a definitive answer. I just do not think that that will happen within our timescale. I am with those who feel that it might be better to leave the petition in a legacy paper, recognise that it is a real issue and ask our successors to pick it up.12:30

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We have had two specific proposals. One is that we should ask the minister for some answers and the other is that the petition should become part of our legacy paper.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

The problem is the timescale. If we could get appropriate answers during the current committee’s existence, that would be fine. However, we might get a more thorough response if we put the petition in the legacy paper. I am open to suggestions.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

My concern is that if the committee in the next parliamentary session asks the questions, that does not mean that it will necessarily get different answers. I do not know whether there are any other answers to be had. I do not know how many letters have gone back and forth on the petition, but there is a considerable number of them.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I believe that we have three options before us. The first is to leave the petition to our successor committee and make a recommendation in the legacy paper. The second is to write to the minister with questions. The third is to invite the minister to come to the committee for an oral evidence session.We could probably do all three of those things, or we could carry on and see how practicable each one is. If we write to the minister, I think that we will get some answers, so I think that we should do that. I hope that those answers will be informative for our successor committee. However, even if they are informative, I do not think that they will be definitive.We should also stick with the idea of inviting the minister to the committee, if he can fit it into his schedule and if we can fit it into the committee’s timetable. Those suggestions are not mutually exclusive.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

One point to keep in mind is that we do not know who will be the minister during the next parliamentary session.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Yes, but we know who will be the minister at our next meeting. You are quite right to say that we do not know what the electorate is going to decide on the first Thursday in May, but whatever information we can get from the current minister, whether in written form or from an oral evidence session—or both—that will inform the deliberations of our successor committee. That would be useful and helpful to that committee.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

We seem to be presupposing that we will not close the petition before the next parliamentary session if we follow all three of Mr Butler’s suggestions. If we get a written response from the minister, he agrees to come before the committee and we get conclusive answers from him, the petition might not form part of the legacy paper and we could close it on 1 or 8 March. Even if we get a written response, we may have the opportunity to discuss the petition fully if the minister is available to come to the committee. My concern is whether we will have an opportunity to examine the petition fully if we have a ministerial evidence session on 1 or 8 March.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

That is up to the committee. If we think that such an evidence session is sufficiently important, we will make time for it.Where does that leave us? We can contact the minister and ask the questions that we think are outstanding on some of the human rights issues that have been raised and the issues that Jamie McGrigor has raised. We can also say that we would like to have the minister come along to give oral evidence, if possible. We can then take it from there and decide whether the petition should come back to our successor committee.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

There is a fourth issue for the committee to take into account: our timetable and the number of petitions that we are trying to cover on 1 and 8 March. We have set ourselves a timetable to try to clear up as much of the backlog of petitions as possible. Today, we have continued two petitions that had been recommended for closure. We have to consider whether or not we have an opportunity to fully examine—I repeat fully examine—the minister on this matter within the committee’s remaining meetings this session.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

When suggestions are being made about what happens with petitions, it is incumbent on us all to consider seriously whether we will be able to give them adequate time. However, if we take a decision to bring petitions back, the committee has a responsibility to make adequate time to discuss them.

Fergus Cochrane
link

I am having a look at the forward planner that clerks use. The way I saw things happening, petitions coming out of today’s meeting would roll forward to 1 March, and petitions coming out of the next meeting, on 22 February, would roll forward to 8 March if possible. However, that is an extremely tight timetable for getting responses from organisations to any questions that you have. As far as the remaining three meetings are concerned, the one on 22 February is probably coming around too quickly. The one on 1 March would be the easiest meeting in which to timetable a slot with the minister, if that is what members are looking for. That is the lightest in terms of current petitions. There is already an oral evidence session timetabled for that day—with the commissioners, regarding the time for all to be heard petition. I have tried to leave the 8 March meeting as a safety net, although it already has a number of petitions down for it. There are also the annual report and the legacy paper to consider. I was trying to leave 8 March as the day for the committee’s final meeting, with a bit of a safety net.Choosing 1 March gives the minister three weeks’ notice, to get the matter into the diary. If that is the committee’s decision, my suggestion is to aim for the meeting on 1 March. I should clarify that, if you wish the minister to provide written responses to questions, we need to be quite clear about what the questions are.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

There is another petition in relation to which it would be good to hear from the minister. I had decided not to suggest it because of the committee’s timetable and other members might have been thinking the same thing. I now feel a bit more strongly about this other matter, so I possibly will make the suggestion. We need to be aware of how much time we have and of doing justice to particular petitions. John Wilson was asking whether we can do the matter justice. Would the next Public Petitions Committee not be best placed to give it the full attention that it deserves? That is what I had been thinking about the other petition to which I have alluded.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

The committee has to do justice to every single petition that comes before us. We have to treat all of them equally.Fergus Cochrane has suggested that there could be time to ask the minister along to our meeting on 1 March. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

The questions will be on whether human rights issues have been considered—what about other issues that should be asked of the Government?

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Mr McGrigor was making the point about the ring fencing of the quota, and why it applies only in the area concerned.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Yes—there is the issue of the geographical anomaly.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

The point is that many people in this particular area were disadvantaged unfairly. It is a human rights issue. In response to Mr Don, I know that other dairy farmers have contacted the Public Petitions Committee, but at this point in time only 20 per cent of those farmers are supplying milk. I venture to suggest that the idea was not very good in the first place and that, as a result, a lot of people have gone down the tubes.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

So we should write to the Government, asking, first, whether human rights have been breached and what advice it received on the matter and, secondly, about the unfairness of ring fencing.

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 39
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 16
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  22. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.