The first item is to consider whether we want to take item 7, on proposals for a children's commissioner bill, and item 8 in private. Both items relate to drafting a proposal for a committee bill. Concern about taking matters in private has been expressed in the Procedures Committee, but, given the nature and importance of the items, I believe that it would be fine to discuss them in private.
Official Report · Committee
Items in Private
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 4
- Michael Russell SNP 2
- Brian Monteith Con 2
- Irene McGugan SNP 1
- Ian Jenkins LD 1
The record
11 contributionsI wondered about this question. We have had an open set of hearings about the children's commissioner bill. I do not think that the discussions that we are having today will reflect on anything other than those hearings. There might be a case for discussing our forward timetable in private, simply because we will be discussing details of committee reports. However, I do not think that there is much of a case for having the children's commissioner bill discussions in private, unless people think that it will be particularly acrimonious, which it has not been so far.
I ask Irene McGugan to comment, given that she and Jackie Baillie have been working in detail on the proposed bill.
I doubt that there will be anything acrimonious about the discussions that we are having with the non-Executive bills unit on the policy direction and decisions that we are making to guide the draftsmen. There are issues of resourcing, which are, perhaps, a little more sensitive. We would appreciate the opportunity to update the committee on where we are with that.
I query the idea that because something might be acrimonious, it should be kept private.
That has been the story of the Tory party.
It has been the story of all your articles in The Herald, Mike.If Irene McGugan's view is that issues of resources or advice that officials give us should be protected because the advice might otherwise be compromised, that is a reason for having the discussion in private. However, I can think of nothing healthier than for the public to see that we disagree quite acrimoniously.
Do other members have views on this? I do not know whether we have unanimity.
I agree with the essence of what Brian Monteith said. We should take the discussions in private because of the nature of the advice that we might get, rather than because we might disagree on the details or principles of the children's commissioner's appointment.
I saw Cathy Peattie nodding there. Do we agree to take items 7 and 8 in private, while being conscious of the impact of taking future discussions in private?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Apr 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Tuesday 16 April 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 4
- Items in Private Procedure · 11
- Scottish Qualifications Authority Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 89
- Petition Petitions · 18
- Budget Process 2003-04 Committee business · 26
- Local Government Covenant Committee business · 8
- Scottish Ballet Committee business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.