1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2747)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
12 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2747)
Later today I will be taking forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I should say to the chamber that we applied yesterday evening for a derogation on the limits on drivers’ hours, initially in the interests of securing animal feed supplies, although it may be extended today to fuel deliveries. It is not something that we do lightly, but I am sure that members will appreciate that it is a wise move to make in the current circumstances in Scotland.
I should say to the chamber that we applied yesterday evening for a derogation on the limits on drivers’ hours, initially in the interests of securing animal feed supplies, although it may be extended today to fuel deliveries. It is not something that we do lightly, but I am sure that members will appreciate that it is a wise move to make in the current circumstances in Scotland.
Will the First Minister agree that, if his much-promised 1,000 extra bobbies on the beat are actually bobbies stuck in the back room, his promise on police numbers is just a con?
No. We have a record number of police officers in Scotland—1,190 more than when we took office and 1,190 more than we were promised by the Labour Party at the previous election. Despite the extraordinary pressure on Scottish budgets, thanks to our deal with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities—except the Labour Party, unfortunately—we have every opportunity to maintain the record numbers of front-line police officers in Scotland. Everyone should welcome that achievement.
I am all in favour of police officers; I just think that they should be out on the beat, policing. The reality on the ground is as described to me by a civilian custody support worker who contacted me to say that he is to lose his job, but only after he has trained a new police recruit who will replace him. He said:
“When you hear that my force has recruited 100 new officers, 80 or more will then be taken from that and placed within the custody area doing jobs already being done by Custody security officers.”
The First Minister trumpets his 1,000 extra police, but they are being used to fill civilian jobs. Is not that a con?
“When you hear that my force has recruited 100 new officers, 80 or more will then be taken from that and placed within the custody area doing jobs already being done by Custody security officers.”
The First Minister trumpets his 1,000 extra police, but they are being used to fill civilian jobs. Is not that a con?
The only cons that are going down in Scotland is the number of criminals, as we have a 30-year low in recorded crime. The test of front-line policing is in the crime statistics. That is what should convince even Iain Gray that there are 1,190 more police officers on the streets and communities of Scotland than there were in March 2007.
Of course, Iain Gray’s track record in these matters is not very impressive. On 29 August 2008, as a novice leader, he forecast that it would take the Scottish National Party 13 years to keep its promise. Here we are, only three years later and 10 years ahead of Iain Gray’s timetable, with the achievement of 1,190 additional police officers in Scotland.
Of course, Iain Gray’s track record in these matters is not very impressive. On 29 August 2008, as a novice leader, he forecast that it would take the Scottish National Party 13 years to keep its promise. Here we are, only three years later and 10 years ahead of Iain Gray’s timetable, with the achievement of 1,190 additional police officers in Scotland.
The crime statistics are not testament to the First Minister; they are testament to the work of police officers, like—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
The figures are testament to the work of police officers such as Detective Inspector Paul Swinburne from East Kilbride. He has 30 years’ service, and this year he has seen 10 murders solved, 50 house break-ins solved, and eight drug dealers brought to justice. He has received five commendations, a Royal Humane Society award, and two police medals. Surely he is exactly the kind of dedicated police officer we want. No: he is being released. Why? So that he can be replaced by cheaper probationers, so that the SNP can get its 1,000 police officers. Does the First Minister think that the police should be protecting the public or protecting his election pledges?
Yes, of course the drop in the level of recorded crime, which gives us the lowest crime statistics for 30 years in Scotland, is due to the work of front-line police officers. Thankfully, there are 1,190 more of them than there would have been under the Labour Party—and the process goes on. In our negotiations with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, as we negotiated to maintain the number of front-line police officers, every other party in Scotland saw the priority in keeping that number in place except the Labour Party, which does not regard it as a priority. A political party that went into the last election promising zero extra police officers, that then forecast that it would take 13 years for the SNP Government to achieve the target of 1,000 extra police officers and was proved wrong, and that now, in local authorities, is doing its best to scupper the deal that will maintain police numbers can do many things, but it cannot come along to this chamber with a shred of credibility and start weeping crocodile tears for police officers in Scotland.
It is the real experience of real experienced police officers and civilian support staff that I bring, but which the First Minister treats with contempt. When I was a justice minister, we worked to release hundreds of police officers from back-room work in order that they could do their jobs on the streets, and we worked to keep experienced police officers in place. Every time we hear the First Minister talk about 1,000 police officers, we should remember that it is a con. Support staff are being sacked so that they can be replaced by police officers who are taken off the beat, and experienced officers are being forced out. Grampian Police have called it “naive”; Unison has called it “a cosmetic political exercise”.
Last week, the First Minister admitted that he was not telling the whole story on tax powers. Yesterday, he had to admit that he was not telling the whole story on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s loan. Today, will he admit that he is not telling the whole story on police numbers, either?
Last week, the First Minister admitted that he was not telling the whole story on tax powers. Yesterday, he had to admit that he was not telling the whole story on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s loan. Today, will he admit that he is not telling the whole story on police numbers, either?
If I were Iain Gray, I would not remind the people of Scotland of the days when he was a justice minister. When he was a justice minister, the level of crime in Scotland was much higher than it is today.
Iain Gray claims, despite not backing a single extra police officer in Scotland and despite his extraordinary misforecast, that he is the voice of Scottish policing. Why do we not listen to the real voice of Scottish policing—the Scottish Police Federation? It stated:
“Today’s decision to maintain existing levels of front line Police numbers confirms our feeling that the politicians listened to our plea, shared our concerns and have responded accordingly. We now call upon local authorities to step up to the mark and match the Government’s commitment.”
That was on 17 November, two weeks ago.
There is no doubt where the voice of front-line police officers stands. The only doubt is that some local authorities—the Labour ones—may not share the commitment of COSLA and the Government to maintaining the record 1,000 extra police officers in Scotland so that we can continue to force down the level of recorded crime to levels that were unheard of when Iain Gray was a disastrous justice minister.
Iain Gray claims, despite not backing a single extra police officer in Scotland and despite his extraordinary misforecast, that he is the voice of Scottish policing. Why do we not listen to the real voice of Scottish policing—the Scottish Police Federation? It stated:
“Today’s decision to maintain existing levels of front line Police numbers confirms our feeling that the politicians listened to our plea, shared our concerns and have responded accordingly. We now call upon local authorities to step up to the mark and match the Government’s commitment.”
That was on 17 November, two weeks ago.
There is no doubt where the voice of front-line police officers stands. The only doubt is that some local authorities—the Labour ones—may not share the commitment of COSLA and the Government to maintaining the record 1,000 extra police officers in Scotland so that we can continue to force down the level of recorded crime to levels that were unheard of when Iain Gray was a disastrous justice minister.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Dec 2010 →- Economy Debate · 138
- RAF Kinloss (Economic Assistance) Questions · 4
- Strategic Transport Projects Review Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Student Places) Questions · 5
- Transport (Aberdeen and the North-east) Questions · 8
- Education Maintenance Allowance Questions · 8
- Firefighters Questions · 4
- Water and Sewerage Charges (Exemptions) Questions · 4
- Children (Advocacy Services) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Sectarianism First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Physical Education First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Police First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National Health Service Boards Questions · 8
- Nurses (NHS Grampian) Questions · 7
- Private Rented Housing (Scotland) Bill Questions · 5
- Parkinson’s UK Questions · 4
- Homoeopathy Questions · 4
- Mental Health Problems Questions · 7
- Tenants (Security of Tenure) Questions · 7
- Violence Against Women and Children (Funding for Services) Questions · 8
- Air Ambulance (Orkney) Questions · 5
- Older People Care Services (Mansionhouse Unit) Questions · 4
- Bedblocking (Dementia Patients) Questions · 4
- Preventive Treatment (Glasgow City Council) Questions · 10
- Forensic Science Services Modernisation Programme Statement · 29
- Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 24
- Business Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.